This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/8293971.stm
The article has changed 12 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 4 | Version 5 |
---|---|
Dismissed Baby P chief 'suicidal' | Dismissed Baby P chief 'suicidal' |
(about 1 hour later) | |
The former director of children's services who lost her job over the Baby Peter case has been left financially ruined and suicidal, a court has heard. | The former director of children's services who lost her job over the Baby Peter case has been left financially ruined and suicidal, a court has heard. |
Sharon Shoesmith argues she was treated unfairly and illegally when removed from her Haringey Council post on the children's secretary's instructions. | Sharon Shoesmith argues she was treated unfairly and illegally when removed from her Haringey Council post on the children's secretary's instructions. |
A judicial review of her sacking heard she was a victim of a "flagrant breach of the rules of natural justice". | A judicial review of her sacking heard she was a victim of a "flagrant breach of the rules of natural justice". |
Peter Connolly suffered over 50 injuries by the time of his death. | Peter Connolly suffered over 50 injuries by the time of his death. |
The 17-month-old - initially known as Baby P - died in Haringey, north London, in August 2007. | |
His death came while he was under the care of his mother Tracey Connolly, 28, her partner Steven Barker, 33, and Barker's brother Jason Owen, 37, who were all jailed. | |
WHO IS SHARON SHOESMITH? Sharon Shoesmith's name is synonymous with the case of Baby Peter. | WHO IS SHARON SHOESMITH? Sharon Shoesmith's name is synonymous with the case of Baby Peter. |
His death, after months of abuse, caused a national outcry because he was on Haringey Council's at-risk register. | His death, after months of abuse, caused a national outcry because he was on Haringey Council's at-risk register. |
The former head of children's services in the borough was removed on the orders of Schools Secretary Ed Balls. | The former head of children's services in the borough was removed on the orders of Schools Secretary Ed Balls. |
The 56-year-old claims she has been vilified by the press and made a scapegoat. | The 56-year-old claims she has been vilified by the press and made a scapegoat. |
More than one million people signed the Sun newspaper's petition calling for heads to roll. She says the media pressure played a role in her dismissal. | More than one million people signed the Sun newspaper's petition calling for heads to roll. She says the media pressure played a role in her dismissal. |
Ms Shoesmith has also been criticised for defending her department's actions and not apologising after the trial, but she claims she did say sorry. | Ms Shoesmith has also been criticised for defending her department's actions and not apologising after the trial, but she claims she did say sorry. |
However she has had her supporters - more than 60 head teachers wrote a letter calling her "an outstanding public servant". | However she has had her supporters - more than 60 head teachers wrote a letter calling her "an outstanding public servant". |
In an BBC interview, she said the way ministers handled the Baby Peter affair was "breathtakingly reckless". She also said she had contemplated suicide. | In an BBC interview, she said the way ministers handled the Baby Peter affair was "breathtakingly reckless". She also said she had contemplated suicide. |
As the shocking details of Baby Peter's short life were made public along with the missed opportunities to save him, Sharon Shoesmith became a target for public anger. | As the shocking details of Baby Peter's short life were made public along with the missed opportunities to save him, Sharon Shoesmith became a target for public anger. |
The toddler had been on Haringey's child protection register at the time of his death. | The toddler had been on Haringey's child protection register at the time of his death. |
The Serious Case Review Ms Shoesmith chaired into the case found lessons needed to be learned but that none of her staff deserved to lose their jobs. | The Serious Case Review Ms Shoesmith chaired into the case found lessons needed to be learned but that none of her staff deserved to lose their jobs. |
But in December 2008, following a damning report into Shoesmith's department by Ofsted inspectors, children's secretary Ed Balls removed her from her post. | But in December 2008, following a damning report into Shoesmith's department by Ofsted inspectors, children's secretary Ed Balls removed her from her post. |
A week later she was dismissed by a panel of Haringey councillors without compensation. | A week later she was dismissed by a panel of Haringey councillors without compensation. |
She attempted to overturn the decision to sack her but a panel of councillors rejected her appeal. | She attempted to overturn the decision to sack her but a panel of councillors rejected her appeal. |
It has prompted her to launch the judicial review of her dismissal at the High Court, arguing Haringey Council, Ofsted and Mr Balls treated her unfairly and illegally. | |
James Maurici, appearing for Ms Shoesmith, described how she was still recovering from post traumatic shock. | James Maurici, appearing for Ms Shoesmith, described how she was still recovering from post traumatic shock. |
He said her dismissal left her shocked, ruined her career and led her to thoughts of suicide. | |
He told Mr Justice Foskett: "As matters stand the simple fact is the claimant will never work again. | He told Mr Justice Foskett: "As matters stand the simple fact is the claimant will never work again. |
"She has been financially ruined and her health has been very seriously affected." | "She has been financially ruined and her health has been very seriously affected." |
Mr Maurici accused Mr Balls of "convicting the claimant with no opportunity whatever to be heard". | Mr Maurici accused Mr Balls of "convicting the claimant with no opportunity whatever to be heard". |
Mr Balls had said in press conferences on several occasions he judged Ms Shoesmith "not to be fit to hold office". | |
Prejudicial comments | |
It was "extraordinary" how the Secretary of State had convicted the claimant with no opportunity whatever to be heard - "there is no doubt that is the case", said Mr Maurici. | |
Nor was Ms Shoesmith given an opportunity to see the Ofsted report or details of the oral presentation given by Ofsted inspectors, on which Mr Balls had acted. | |
She also had no chance to challenge "a number of highly prejudicial comments made by Ofsted inspectors to the Secretary of State in the course of that meeting". | |
The report Ofsted produced was itself the result of an inspection, which was not carried out in accordance with Ofsted's arrangements for such inspections, said Mr Maurici. | |
Connolly, Barker and Owen received minimum prison terms of five, 12 and three years respectively for causing or allowing Peter's death. All three have appealed against their sentences. | Connolly, Barker and Owen received minimum prison terms of five, 12 and three years respectively for causing or allowing Peter's death. All three have appealed against their sentences. |