This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/wales/8343506.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Bid to stop badger cull rejected | Bid to stop badger cull rejected |
(about 22 hours later) | |
A bid to halt a controversial badger cull in Pembrokeshire has failed. | A bid to halt a controversial badger cull in Pembrokeshire has failed. |
Assembly Members voted in favour of plans to trap and shoot badgers as part of a campaign to get rid of bovine TB. | Assembly Members voted in favour of plans to trap and shoot badgers as part of a campaign to get rid of bovine TB. |
No cull will not happen until a final decision by the rural affairs minister, and not before the end of the closed season, between winter and spring. | |
The vote was tabled by two AMs opposed to the planned cull. Meanwhile, the Badger Trust is seeking a judicial review of the decision to allow a cull. | The vote was tabled by two AMs opposed to the planned cull. Meanwhile, the Badger Trust is seeking a judicial review of the decision to allow a cull. |
The vote on whether to annul a ministerial order underpinning the cull was defeated nine votes to 43. | The vote on whether to annul a ministerial order underpinning the cull was defeated nine votes to 43. |
During an assembly debate, Rural Affairs Minister Elin Jones said 12,000 cows were slaughtered last year because of TB, compared to 7,000 in 1997. | During an assembly debate, Rural Affairs Minister Elin Jones said 12,000 cows were slaughtered last year because of TB, compared to 7,000 in 1997. |
Pembrokeshire will be known as the killing fields... it's not a cull - it's a slaughter Lorraine Barrett AM | |
The bill for compensating Wales' farmers has risen from £1.8m to £24m since 2000. | The bill for compensating Wales' farmers has risen from £1.8m to £24m since 2000. |
Ms Jones said: "Both government-led culling and vaccination of badgers are appropriate strategies to pursue the eradication of bovine TB in Wales, which is why this order confers powers to carry out both. | Ms Jones said: "Both government-led culling and vaccination of badgers are appropriate strategies to pursue the eradication of bovine TB in Wales, which is why this order confers powers to carry out both. |
"Culling removes infection through the removal of infected animals, whiles vaccination protects uninfected animals from becoming infected. | "Culling removes infection through the removal of infected animals, whiles vaccination protects uninfected animals from becoming infected. |
"So each will be necessary to pursue the eradication of bovine TB in Wales." | "So each will be necessary to pursue the eradication of bovine TB in Wales." |
She added that other measures were planned to help rid Wales of the disease, including improvements in moving infected animals from farms. | She added that other measures were planned to help rid Wales of the disease, including improvements in moving infected animals from farms. |
Bad animal husbandry | Bad animal husbandry |
Labour AM Lorraine Barrett, who tabled the vote with Liberal Democrat Peter Black, called on the assembly government to concentrate solely on vaccinating animals. | Labour AM Lorraine Barrett, who tabled the vote with Liberal Democrat Peter Black, called on the assembly government to concentrate solely on vaccinating animals. |
She said: "I have always been a loyal member of my party and this government here in the assembly, but I just couldn't stand by and let this order go through without a last-minute attempt to stop it. | She said: "I have always been a loyal member of my party and this government here in the assembly, but I just couldn't stand by and let this order go through without a last-minute attempt to stop it. |
"I don't believe that killing badgers as a means of tackling this problem is scientifically or morally justified. | "I don't believe that killing badgers as a means of tackling this problem is scientifically or morally justified. |
"Pembrokeshire will be known as the killing fields. It's not a cull - it's a slaughter." | "Pembrokeshire will be known as the killing fields. It's not a cull - it's a slaughter." |
The AM read out letters from opponents of the cull in Pembrokeshire and said there was evidence that intensive faming and bad animal husbandry caused disease. | The AM read out letters from opponents of the cull in Pembrokeshire and said there was evidence that intensive faming and bad animal husbandry caused disease. |
Cattle control measures | Cattle control measures |
Conservative rural affairs spokesman Brynle Williams, speaking in support of the cull, said: "Too many people are very emotive about this and don't realise that TB crosses to people. | Conservative rural affairs spokesman Brynle Williams, speaking in support of the cull, said: "Too many people are very emotive about this and don't realise that TB crosses to people. |
National Farmers' Union Cymru president Dai Davies said: "Today's motion to annul the order would have deprived the assembly government of the scope to pursue, alongside stringent cattle control measures, a badger control strategy. | National Farmers' Union Cymru president Dai Davies said: "Today's motion to annul the order would have deprived the assembly government of the scope to pursue, alongside stringent cattle control measures, a badger control strategy. |
"In the same ways as it would be irresponsible to leave diseased cattle to continue to spread the disease, we have also to contain and eradicate TB in the badger population. | "In the same ways as it would be irresponsible to leave diseased cattle to continue to spread the disease, we have also to contain and eradicate TB in the badger population. |
"Only then will be able to fulfil our aspiration of a cattle and wildlife population free of disease and living in harmony." | "Only then will be able to fulfil our aspiration of a cattle and wildlife population free of disease and living in harmony." |
Previous version
1
Next version