This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/wales/8366323.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Dream killer 'should walk free' | Dream killer 'should walk free' |
(about 22 hours later) | |
A man who strangled his wife while he had a dream about an intruder should be set free whatever the outcome of his murder trial, a court has heard. | A man who strangled his wife while he had a dream about an intruder should be set free whatever the outcome of his murder trial, a court has heard. |
Brian Thomas, 59, of Neath accepts he killed Christine, 57, in their camper van in Aberporth, Ceredigion, but blamed it on a sleep disorder. | Brian Thomas, 59, of Neath accepts he killed Christine, 57, in their camper van in Aberporth, Ceredigion, but blamed it on a sleep disorder. |
Jurors at Swansea Crown Court have to reach a verdict of not guilty or of not guilty by reason of insanity. | Jurors at Swansea Crown Court have to reach a verdict of not guilty or of not guilty by reason of insanity. |
A psychiatrist for the prosecution said she did not think he posed a risk. | A psychiatrist for the prosecution said she did not think he posed a risk. |
Tests commissioned by both the prosecution and the defence were carried out on Mr Thomas as he slept following his claims of a sleep disorder. | Tests commissioned by both the prosecution and the defence were carried out on Mr Thomas as he slept following his claims of a sleep disorder. |
Both sleep experts agreed his behaviour was consistent with automatism, which meant at the time he killed his wife, his mind had no control over what his body was doing. | Both sleep experts agreed his behaviour was consistent with automatism, which meant at the time he killed his wife, his mind had no control over what his body was doing. |
But the jury has been told there are two types of automatism: insane automatism and non-insane automatism, which they will have to decide between for their verdict. | But the jury has been told there are two types of automatism: insane automatism and non-insane automatism, which they will have to decide between for their verdict. |
The court has heard how the couple were disturbed by "boy racers" earlier | |
Dr Caroline Jacob, a member of the Royal College of Psychiatrists who has practised at high security psychiatric hospital Broadmoor, gave evidence for the prosecution. | Dr Caroline Jacob, a member of the Royal College of Psychiatrists who has practised at high security psychiatric hospital Broadmoor, gave evidence for the prosecution. |
She said after looking at the evidence she favoured a verdict of insane automatism but acknowledged that was for the jury to decide. | She said after looking at the evidence she favoured a verdict of insane automatism but acknowledged that was for the jury to decide. |
Defending barrister Elwen Evans QC asked whether Mr Thomas was in need of the sort of psychiatric help a patient in Broadmoor would receive. | Defending barrister Elwen Evans QC asked whether Mr Thomas was in need of the sort of psychiatric help a patient in Broadmoor would receive. |
She replied in her view sending him to a psychiatric unit was not necessary. | She replied in her view sending him to a psychiatric unit was not necessary. |
She said: "Mr Thomas posed no real risk of repeating his behaviour. | She said: "Mr Thomas posed no real risk of repeating his behaviour. |
"It would be impossible to completely exclude it happening again, but the chances of it happening again are very, very rare." | "It would be impossible to completely exclude it happening again, but the chances of it happening again are very, very rare." |
Ms Evans said if found guilty due to insane automatism the only outcome would be to send Mr Thomas to a psychiatric hospital under a restriction order. | Ms Evans said if found guilty due to insane automatism the only outcome would be to send Mr Thomas to a psychiatric hospital under a restriction order. |
Dr Jacob said she did not think that was necessary and favoured "an absolute discharge". | Dr Jacob said she did not think that was necessary and favoured "an absolute discharge". |
She acknowledged a different psychiatrist might take a different view. | She acknowledged a different psychiatrist might take a different view. |
Missed medication | Missed medication |
The court heard that medication that Mr Thomas usually took to control the disorder had been stopped while the couple were on holiday. | The court heard that medication that Mr Thomas usually took to control the disorder had been stopped while the couple were on holiday. |
The couple - childhood sweethearts who were married for 40 years with two daughters - had driven 60 miles to the seaside village of Aberporth in July 2008. | The couple - childhood sweethearts who were married for 40 years with two daughters - had driven 60 miles to the seaside village of Aberporth in July 2008. |
They had originally parked in a car park on the seafront but had been disturbed in the night by young drivers doing wheel spins and handbrake turns. | They had originally parked in a car park on the seafront but had been disturbed in the night by young drivers doing wheel spins and handbrake turns. |
As a result they moved onto a pub car park for the night. | As a result they moved onto a pub car park for the night. |
The jury previously heard a recording of Mr Thomas's emergency call in which he frantically told the operator "I think I've killed my wife. Oh my god." | The jury previously heard a recording of Mr Thomas's emergency call in which he frantically told the operator "I think I've killed my wife. Oh my god." |
Prosecuting barrister Paul Thomas QC, has described the case as "highly unusual". | Prosecuting barrister Paul Thomas QC, has described the case as "highly unusual". |
He said the defendant was charged with the murder of his wife, whose death he accepted causing. | He said the defendant was charged with the murder of his wife, whose death he accepted causing. |
But the barrister said the prosecution did not seek a murder or manslaughter conviction. | But the barrister said the prosecution did not seek a murder or manslaughter conviction. |
Instead, he said the prosecution would be arguing for the "special verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity". | Instead, he said the prosecution would be arguing for the "special verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity". |
The alternative, the jury was told, would be "a simple verdict of not guilty". | The alternative, the jury was told, would be "a simple verdict of not guilty". |
The case continues. | The case continues. |
Previous version
1
Next version