This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/mar/13/retired-met-police-sergeant-fails-to-sue-senior-officer-calling-him-numpty
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Tribunal rejects ex-Met officer’s ‘numpty’ discrimination claim | Tribunal rejects ex-Met officer’s ‘numpty’ discrimination claim |
| (32 minutes later) | |
| Sonny Kalar made series of claims including race and disability discrimination – all were dismissed | Sonny Kalar made series of claims including race and disability discrimination – all were dismissed |
| A long-serving Metropolitan police sergeant has failed in his attempt to sue the force for discrimination because a more senior officer called him a “numpty”. | A long-serving Metropolitan police sergeant has failed in his attempt to sue the force for discrimination because a more senior officer called him a “numpty”. |
| Sonny Kalar, who was with the Met for 30 years, said he was offended when Ch Insp Marlise Davies twice called him a “numpty”, an employment tribunal heard. | Sonny Kalar, who was with the Met for 30 years, said he was offended when Ch Insp Marlise Davies twice called him a “numpty”, an employment tribunal heard. |
| But the employment judge Richard Nicolle, sitting at London Central employment tribunal, said Davies used the term in a “lighthearted manner” and it did not amount to discrimination. | |
| Kalar, who joined the Met in June 1993 and retired in June 2023, brought a series of claims including race discrimination and harassment, disability discrimination and harassment, victimisation and whistleblowing detriment. | Kalar, who joined the Met in June 1993 and retired in June 2023, brought a series of claims including race discrimination and harassment, disability discrimination and harassment, victimisation and whistleblowing detriment. |
| He made wide-ranging allegations against senior officers, claiming there was a “collective witch-hunt” against him – all the claims were dismissed. | He made wide-ranging allegations against senior officers, claiming there was a “collective witch-hunt” against him – all the claims were dismissed. |
| One of his allegations was that Davies, a chief inspector in the SO15 counter terrorism command, discriminated against him by calling him a “numpty”. | One of his allegations was that Davies, a chief inspector in the SO15 counter terrorism command, discriminated against him by calling him a “numpty”. |
| The tribunal heard: “CI Davies accepts using the term, once not twice, but said that it was used as an affectionate term as in ‘don’t be so silly’, rather than in a disparaging manner. Nevertheless, she apologised to [Mr Kalar].” | The tribunal heard: “CI Davies accepts using the term, once not twice, but said that it was used as an affectionate term as in ‘don’t be so silly’, rather than in a disparaging manner. Nevertheless, she apologised to [Mr Kalar].” |
| Judge Nicolle said: “We accept CI Davies’ evidence that the comment was made during her call with [Kalar] on 15 July 2022 in a lighthearted manner. | Judge Nicolle said: “We accept CI Davies’ evidence that the comment was made during her call with [Kalar] on 15 July 2022 in a lighthearted manner. |
| “We do not consider that the term ‘numpty’ has any racial or disability connotations and in the context that it was used, in what we considered to be a lighthearted manner, not one which was capable of constituting harassment when looked at objectively.” | “We do not consider that the term ‘numpty’ has any racial or disability connotations and in the context that it was used, in what we considered to be a lighthearted manner, not one which was capable of constituting harassment when looked at objectively.” |
| Sign up to Headlines UK | Sign up to Headlines UK |
| Get the day’s headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning | Get the day’s headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning |
| after newsletter promotion | after newsletter promotion |
| According to research conducted by King’s College London, the origins of the word “numpty” can be traced back to the 18th century. | According to research conducted by King’s College London, the origins of the word “numpty” can be traced back to the 18th century. |
| Evidence found it was first used in a play in 1733, as a “term of mocking endearment for a cuckolded husband”. | Evidence found it was first used in a play in 1733, as a “term of mocking endearment for a cuckolded husband”. |
Previous version
1
Next version