This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cp3yp3l175do
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 4 | Version 5 |
|---|---|
| Former Labour MSP Neil Findlay quits party over welfare cuts | Former Labour MSP Neil Findlay quits party over welfare cuts |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| Neil Findlay, who ran for the Scottish Labour leadership in 2014, says he is quitting the party for the sake of his own sanity | Neil Findlay, who ran for the Scottish Labour leadership in 2014, says he is quitting the party for the sake of his own sanity |
| Former Scottish Labour MSP Neil Findlay has quit the party over the UK government's plan to cut £5bn a year from the welfare budget. | Former Scottish Labour MSP Neil Findlay has quit the party over the UK government's plan to cut £5bn a year from the welfare budget. |
| It came as members of the party's Holyrood group, including a frontbencher, also voiced criticism of the proposals. | It came as members of the party's Holyrood group, including a frontbencher, also voiced criticism of the proposals. |
| Sir Keir Starmer says the current social security system is "unfair to taxpayers" and lets down claimants. | Sir Keir Starmer says the current social security system is "unfair to taxpayers" and lets down claimants. |
| Mr Findlay - who was an MSP between 2010 and 2021 - said Labour was choosing to "punish and stigmatize the weak, poor and the vulnerable". | Mr Findlay - who was an MSP between 2010 and 2021 - said Labour was choosing to "punish and stigmatize the weak, poor and the vulnerable". |
| His resignation came as Scottish Labour public health spokesperson Carol Mochan called the social security reforms a "mistake". | His resignation came as Scottish Labour public health spokesperson Carol Mochan called the social security reforms a "mistake". |
| Mr Findlay, a left-wing trade union member who ran unsuccessfully for the Scottish Labour leadership in 2014, announced his resignation in a letter to Sir Keir. | Mr Findlay, a left-wing trade union member who ran unsuccessfully for the Scottish Labour leadership in 2014, announced his resignation in a letter to Sir Keir. |
| He accused Labour ministers of having "lied" to the electorate. The former MSP cited the cut to winter fuel payments for pensioners, the decision over compensation for Waspi women, the two-child benefits cap and handling of the closure of the Grangemouth oil refinery. | He accused Labour ministers of having "lied" to the electorate. The former MSP cited the cut to winter fuel payments for pensioners, the decision over compensation for Waspi women, the two-child benefits cap and handling of the closure of the Grangemouth oil refinery. |
| Mr Findlay told BBC Radio Scotland's Lunchtime Live: "The final straw was the attack on some of the weakest and most vulnerable people in society, people who are long-term sick and disabled." | Mr Findlay told BBC Radio Scotland's Lunchtime Live: "The final straw was the attack on some of the weakest and most vulnerable people in society, people who are long-term sick and disabled." |
| He added: "The inference is that these people are skivers and shirkers and they are milking in the system." | He added: "The inference is that these people are skivers and shirkers and they are milking in the system." |
| Mr Findlay cited senior members of the Labour government, including the prime minster, accepting freebies from wealthy donors. He said it was them, not benefits claimants, who were "milking the system". | Mr Findlay cited senior members of the Labour government, including the prime minster, accepting freebies from wealthy donors. He said it was them, not benefits claimants, who were "milking the system". |
| In his letter, the trade unionist predicted Labour "will be lucky to come third" in next year's Scottish election, would lose power in Wales for the first time and "faces being routed" at the next UK general election. | In his letter, the trade unionist predicted Labour "will be lucky to come third" in next year's Scottish election, would lose power in Wales for the first time and "faces being routed" at the next UK general election. |
| "This will be down to your disastrous tenure as leader," Mr Findlay told the prime minister. | "This will be down to your disastrous tenure as leader," Mr Findlay told the prime minister. |
| He added: "In solidarity with the individuals and families who will be affected by these vindictive and brutal policies and for my own sanity, dignity and self respect I can no longer remain a member of the Labour Party." | He added: "In solidarity with the individuals and families who will be affected by these vindictive and brutal policies and for my own sanity, dignity and self respect I can no longer remain a member of the Labour Party." |
| Sir Keir Starmer says the current welfare system is unfair to taxpayers | Sir Keir Starmer says the current welfare system is unfair to taxpayers |
| Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has said the UK government is right to reform the welfare system but added any changes must be "fair". | Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has said the UK government is right to reform the welfare system but added any changes must be "fair". |
| He also denied that Labour ministers were imposing austerity. | He also denied that Labour ministers were imposing austerity. |
| Mochan, a member of his Holyrood leadership team, contradicted him when responding to the UK government's announcement. | Mochan, a member of his Holyrood leadership team, contradicted him when responding to the UK government's announcement. |
| She posted on X: "Austerity has never been a sustainable path to growth. We cannot balance the books on the backs of people who require benefits just to have a passable standard of living. | She posted on X: "Austerity has never been a sustainable path to growth. We cannot balance the books on the backs of people who require benefits just to have a passable standard of living. |
| "These reforms are a mistake and should not go ahead." | "These reforms are a mistake and should not go ahead." |
| Labour MSP Monica Lennon, another former leadership contender, said she was "extremely sorry" Mr Findlay had left the party. | Labour MSP Monica Lennon, another former leadership contender, said she was "extremely sorry" Mr Findlay had left the party. |
| She posted on X: "The UK government is going in the wrong direction on welfare. For the sake of my constituents, I urge ministers to stop the cuts to disabled people." | She posted on X: "The UK government is going in the wrong direction on welfare. For the sake of my constituents, I urge ministers to stop the cuts to disabled people." |
| Questioned if Mochan should be sacked by the leadership, UK Energy Minister Michael Shanks said he would not be "drawn on what individuals are going to do in the Scottish Parliament". | Questioned if Mochan should be sacked by the leadership, UK Energy Minister Michael Shanks said he would not be "drawn on what individuals are going to do in the Scottish Parliament". |
| He added that the welfare reforms would protect the most vulnerable people in society while making the social security system "sustainable for the long term". | He added that the welfare reforms would protect the most vulnerable people in society while making the social security system "sustainable for the long term". |
| Incapacity benefits | Incapacity benefits |
| Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall said the government's proposed welfare reforms would save £5bn a year from 2030. | Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall said the government's proposed welfare reforms would save £5bn a year from 2030. |
| She announced on Tuesday that ministers would tighten the eligibility criteria for Personal Independence Payments (PIP) from November 2026 and freeze incapacity benefits under Universal Credit, with payments for new claimants to be reduced. | She announced on Tuesday that ministers would tighten the eligibility criteria for Personal Independence Payments (PIP) from November 2026 and freeze incapacity benefits under Universal Credit, with payments for new claimants to be reduced. |
| Although the benefit is being phased out in Scotland and replaced by the devolved Adult Disability Payment, any reduction on spending on PIP will have a knock-on effect on the Scottish government's budget. | Although the benefit is being phased out in Scotland and replaced by the devolved Adult Disability Payment, any reduction on spending on PIP will have a knock-on effect on the Scottish government's budget. |
| The Fraser of Allander Institute, which is an economic research unit at the University of Strathclyde, forecasts that for every £1bn cut from spending on PIP, the Scottish government would lose between £90m and £115m in Treasury funding. | The Fraser of Allander Institute, which is an economic research unit at the University of Strathclyde, forecasts that for every £1bn cut from spending on PIP, the Scottish government would lose between £90m and £115m in Treasury funding. |
| First Minister John Swinney said he was not yet "certain" what the welfare cuts would mean for Holyrood's finances. | |
| John Swinney says the social security reforms will be "damaging" for the Scottish government's budget | |
| "What I do know is that if there's a £5bn cut to welfare expenditure in the UK by a Labour government, that's picking up on austerity where the Tories left off that's likely to have a damaging effect on the Scottish government's budget," he said. | |
| "We'll consider all those issues in due course." | |
| The UK government cuts come with extra investment in employability services in the hope of bringing more people back into the workforce. | The UK government cuts come with extra investment in employability services in the hope of bringing more people back into the workforce. |
| Sir Keir said the social security system was "actively incentivising" people away from work and represented an "affront to the values of our country". | Sir Keir said the social security system was "actively incentivising" people away from work and represented an "affront to the values of our country". |
| "This is not just unfair to taxpayers, it is also a bad long-term outcome for many of those people," he said. | "This is not just unfair to taxpayers, it is also a bad long-term outcome for many of those people," he said. |
| A Scottish Labour spokesman said: "Mr Findlay is a private citizen, he is entitled to his views." | A Scottish Labour spokesman said: "Mr Findlay is a private citizen, he is entitled to his views." |