This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2025/apr/16/albanese-accuses-dutton-of-verballing-indonesias-president-over-reported-russian-military-encroachment
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Albanese accuses Dutton of ‘verballing’ Indonesia’s president over reported Russian military encroachment | Albanese accuses Dutton of ‘verballing’ Indonesia’s president over reported Russian military encroachment |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| Foreign affairs minister says opposition leader ‘fabricated’ statement while treasurer claims comments are ‘disqualifying moment’ for upcoming Australian election | |
| Anthony Albanese has accused Peter Dutton of “verballing” Indonesia’s president around questions over Russian military encroachment in the region, condemning the Liberal leader for “extraordinary overreach” before the facts were clear. | |
| Senior ministers also came out swinging against the opposition leader on Wednesday for “reckless” comments, with the foreign affairs minister, Penny Wong, saying Dutton had “fabricated” a statement from the Indonesian president, Prabowo Subianto. | Senior ministers also came out swinging against the opposition leader on Wednesday for “reckless” comments, with the foreign affairs minister, Penny Wong, saying Dutton had “fabricated” a statement from the Indonesian president, Prabowo Subianto. |
| The respected defence publication journal Janes reported on Tuesday that Russia had filed an official request with Jakarta to base Russian aerospace forces aircraft on Manuhua Air Force base in Biak island in Indonesia’s easternmost Papua region – about 1,400km from Darwin. | |
| It did not report that any such request had been granted. | It did not report that any such request had been granted. |
| The Australian prime minister claimed at a press conference on Wednesday there had been “no basis for assuming” the report from Janes was correct. | The Australian prime minister claimed at a press conference on Wednesday there had been “no basis for assuming” the report from Janes was correct. |
| Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter | Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter |
| Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter | Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter |
| Dutton, in a Tuesday press conference shortly after the report was noted in Australian media, had asked: “Did the prime minister know about this before it was publicly announced by the president of Indonesia?” | Dutton, in a Tuesday press conference shortly after the report was noted in Australian media, had asked: “Did the prime minister know about this before it was publicly announced by the president of Indonesia?” |
| He told the ABC on Tuesday that he had “seen commentary” about discussions between Russia and Indonesia, and that it would be a “catastrophic failure” if the government had not known in advance about the request. | He told the ABC on Tuesday that he had “seen commentary” about discussions between Russia and Indonesia, and that it would be a “catastrophic failure” if the government had not known in advance about the request. |
| “That’s obviously come from the administration,” Dutton said. When asked if he had seen Prabowo confirm the discussions, Dutton said there was “comment that’s come out of the administration, out of the Prabowo administration”. | “That’s obviously come from the administration,” Dutton said. When asked if he had seen Prabowo confirm the discussions, Dutton said there was “comment that’s come out of the administration, out of the Prabowo administration”. |
| Prabowo had not made any such public announcement. | Prabowo had not made any such public announcement. |
| Dutton later claimed he was referring to a statement from Indonesia’s government that was reported in Janes. | Dutton later claimed he was referring to a statement from Indonesia’s government that was reported in Janes. |
| Richard Marles, Australia’s defence minister and deputy prime minister, said in a statement on Tuesday night that he had spoken to his Indonesian counterpart, Sjafrie Sjamsoeddin, about the reports. | Richard Marles, Australia’s defence minister and deputy prime minister, said in a statement on Tuesday night that he had spoken to his Indonesian counterpart, Sjafrie Sjamsoeddin, about the reports. |
| “[He] said to me in the clearest possible terms, reports of the prospect of Russian aircraft operating from Indonesia are simply not true,” Marles said. | |
| Indonesian media reported on Wednesday that Sjafrie said no official request had been made by Russia. | Indonesian media reported on Wednesday that Sjafrie said no official request had been made by Russia. |
| “This is absolutely untrue,” he said in a statement, according to the News of Indonesia website. | “This is absolutely untrue,” he said in a statement, according to the News of Indonesia website. |
| “Indonesia adheres to the principle of an independent and active foreign policy. We do not allow foreign military bases on our soil.” | “Indonesia adheres to the principle of an independent and active foreign policy. We do not allow foreign military bases on our soil.” |
| Albanese said on Wednesday he would not provide a “running commentary” as to what Australia knew, and when. | Albanese said on Wednesday he would not provide a “running commentary” as to what Australia knew, and when. |
| “What we saw from Peter Dutton yesterday was an extraordinary overreach. He verballed the president of Indonesia,” he told the press conference. | “What we saw from Peter Dutton yesterday was an extraordinary overreach. He verballed the president of Indonesia,” he told the press conference. |
| “Verballing” is a term for the misattribution of a statement to another person. | “Verballing” is a term for the misattribution of a statement to another person. |
| The treasurer, Jim Chalmers, joining Albanese, went even further and claimed Dutton’s comments were a “disqualifying moment” for his bid to win government. | The treasurer, Jim Chalmers, joining Albanese, went even further and claimed Dutton’s comments were a “disqualifying moment” for his bid to win government. |
| “He is temperamentally unfit to manage our relationships in the world and to manage our economy here at home,” Chalmers said. | “He is temperamentally unfit to manage our relationships in the world and to manage our economy here at home,” Chalmers said. |
| Sign up to Afternoon Update: Election 2025 | Sign up to Afternoon Update: Election 2025 |
| Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key election campaign stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters | Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key election campaign stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters |
| after newsletter promotion | after newsletter promotion |
| Chalmers also claimed Dutton “lies in ways that are bordering on the pathological about the Australian economy”. | |
| Also on Wednesday morning, Albanese told ABC Melbourne that Dutton “always dials things up to 11”. | Also on Wednesday morning, Albanese told ABC Melbourne that Dutton “always dials things up to 11”. |
| “He always shoots from the hip. And when you are either the prime minister or the alternative prime minister of this country, what you need to do is to have a considered approach to our international relations. | “He always shoots from the hip. And when you are either the prime minister or the alternative prime minister of this country, what you need to do is to have a considered approach to our international relations. |
| “I have had to spend this term repairing relations with friends like France, friends in Asean, in the Pacific. And what Peter Dutton has reminded people … is just how reckless he can be.” | “I have had to spend this term repairing relations with friends like France, friends in Asean, in the Pacific. And what Peter Dutton has reminded people … is just how reckless he can be.” |
| Wong told the ABC that Dutton had “fabricated a statement” by Prabowo, and that the government had engaged with Indonesia through “the appropriate channels” to confirm that Indonesia would not allow Russia to base planes there. | Wong told the ABC that Dutton had “fabricated a statement” by Prabowo, and that the government had engaged with Indonesia through “the appropriate channels” to confirm that Indonesia would not allow Russia to base planes there. |
| “Peter Dutton fabricated a statement by the Indonesian president,” Wong said. | “Peter Dutton fabricated a statement by the Indonesian president,” Wong said. |
| “Now, this is an extraordinary thing for a man who wants to be the prime minister to do – to actually try and verbal the president of Indonesia in order to make a domestic political point. | “Now, this is an extraordinary thing for a man who wants to be the prime minister to do – to actually try and verbal the president of Indonesia in order to make a domestic political point. |
| “He is simply too reckless and too aggro.” | “He is simply too reckless and too aggro.” |
| The shadow finance minister, Jane Hume, was asked later about Wong’s accusations on ABC News Breakfast and said the comment was “bizarre” and “very defensive”. | The shadow finance minister, Jane Hume, was asked later about Wong’s accusations on ABC News Breakfast and said the comment was “bizarre” and “very defensive”. |
| “Clearly she was blindsided by this report and has been on the back foot since,” she said. | “Clearly she was blindsided by this report and has been on the back foot since,” she said. |
| Asked about his comments at a Wednesday press conference, Dutton said: “The reference I made is to a credible military website and that talked about government sources and the Prabowo government sources.” | Asked about his comments at a Wednesday press conference, Dutton said: “The reference I made is to a credible military website and that talked about government sources and the Prabowo government sources.” |
| He avoided further requests from journalists to clarify whether he thought this had been a mistake. | He avoided further requests from journalists to clarify whether he thought this had been a mistake. |
| Matthew Sussex, a strategic and defence studies centre fellow at the Australian National University, wrote in the Conversation that Indonesia and Russia have been deepening military ties since Prabowo came to power in October. | |
| Moscow has tried “on numerous occasions to pivot to Asia to give itself more economic heft and leverage in the region”, he wrote. | |
| “The Kremlin is also cognisant that Europe won’t be a friend for the foreseeable future. As such, it’s even more pressing for Russia to establish itself as a player in the Indo-Pacific region – and with that comes a military and security presence.” | “The Kremlin is also cognisant that Europe won’t be a friend for the foreseeable future. As such, it’s even more pressing for Russia to establish itself as a player in the Indo-Pacific region – and with that comes a military and security presence.” |