This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c20x5xxe4wzo

The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Five takeaways from Canada party leaders' big TV debate Five takeaways from Canada party leaders' big TV debate
(32 minutes later)
Pierre Poilievre and Mark Carney are the frontrunners in national polls Watch: Key moments from Canada's general election debate
The leaders of Canada's four major federal parties squared off in their second and final debate ahead of this month's general election, but someone off stage stole most of the spotlight: US President Donald Trump. The leaders of Canada's four major federal parties have squared off in their second and final debate ahead of this month's general election, but someone off stage stole most of the spotlight: US President Donald Trump.
A big question heading into the debate was whether Liberal leader Mark Carney, who has been leading comfortably in the polls, would stumble. A big question heading into the debate was whether Liberal leader Mark Carney, who has been leading in the polls, would stumble.
Carney had managed to survive Wednesday's French debate despite his shaky French language skills. Carney, the former governor of the Bank of England, managed to survive Wednesday's French debate despite being less proficient in the country's second language.
On Thursday, he was put on the spot numerous times by his three opponents: Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre, New Democratic Party leader Jagmeet Singh and Bloc Quebecois leader Yves-Francois Blanchet. On Thursday, he found himself placed on the spot repeatedly by his three opponents: Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre, New Democratic Party leader Jagmeet Singh and Bloc Québécois leader Yves-Francois Blanchet.
How to respond to Canada's ongoing trade war with the US was a recurring theme, but the debate also featured spirited discussions on other issues facing Canada, like affordability, crime and the environment. How to respond to Canada's ongoing trade war with the US was a theme, but the debate also featured spirited discussions on other issues facing Canada, such as affordability, crime and the environment.
Here are five big takeaways from Thursday's face off: Here are five big takeaways from Thursday's face-off:
The ghost of Justin Trudeau haunts Carney Justin Trudeau's ghost haunts Carney
As Carney leads in the polls, his opponents honed in on the mistakes of his unpopular predecessor, former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. Carney's opponents were quick to hone in on the mistakes of his unpopular predecessor, former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
Conservative leader Poilievre made references to the "lost Liberal decade", referencing the last 10 years in which the Liberal party has been in power. He used issues like housing affordability and the high cost of living to drive this point home. Conservative leader Poilievre made references to the "lost Liberal decade", referencing the last 10 years in which the Liberal party has been in power. He cited issues like housing affordability and the high cost of living to drive his point home.
"How can we possibly believe that you are any different?" Poilievre asked Carney directly. "How can we possibly believe that you are any different?" Poilievre asked Carney.
Blanchet also threw down the gauntlet to Carney. "You claim you are different - you need to prove you are better."Blanchet also threw down the gauntlet to Carney. "You claim you are different - you need to prove you are better."
Carney was forced to defend himself multiple times, noting that he has only been in the prime minister's chair for one month despite sharing the same party banner as Trudeau.Carney was forced to defend himself multiple times, noting that he has only been in the prime minister's chair for one month despite sharing the same party banner as Trudeau.
"I am a very different person than Justin Trudeau," Carney said. At times, he appeared to criticise his predecessor's governance, saying that a Liberal party under his leadership will be more focused on delivering results. "I am a very different person than Justin Trudeau," Carney said.
GUIDE: What you should know about this electionGUIDE: What you should know about this election
CANDIDATES: Who could become the new Prime Minister?CANDIDATES: Who could become the new Prime Minister?
VIDEO: How Canada will chose its new leader VIDEO: How Canada will choose its new leader
FRENCH DEBATE: What happened in the first debate?FRENCH DEBATE: What happened in the first debate?
A softer approach to Donald Trump's tariffsA softer approach to Donald Trump's tariffs
At the top of the hour, the leaders were asked about how they would negotiate with President Trump and respond to his tariffs on Canada. The leaders were asked about how they would negotiate with Trump and respond to his tariffs on Canada.
Trump has implemented blanket 25% tariffs on goods from Canada, with an exemption on products covered by the USMCA - a North American free trade deal. Canada is also hit with global US tariffs on steel and aluminium and cars.Trump has implemented blanket 25% tariffs on goods from Canada, with an exemption on products covered by the USMCA - a North American free trade deal. Canada is also hit with global US tariffs on steel and aluminium and cars.
The president has also publicly mused about Canada becoming the 51st US state. The president has also publicly spoken about Canada becoming the 51st US state.
Canada's government had previously said that its position is to implement "dollar-for-dollar" tariffs in retaliation to Trump, with the aim of inflicting maximum pain on the US economy. Canada's government has previously said its position is to implement "dollar-for-dollar" tariffs with the aim of inflicting maximum pain on the US economy.
But during the debate, the leaders appeared to contend with the fact that Canada's economy is dwarfed by that of the US, and that it is ultimately not an equal fight. But during the debate, the leaders appeared to contend that it is ultimately not an equal fight.
"We've moved on from dollar-for-dollar tariffs," Carney said, acknowledging that the US economy is more than 10 times larger than Canada's. "We've moved on from dollar-for-dollar tariffs," Carney said, acknowledging that the US economy is more than 10 times the size of Canada's.
Instead, he said that if elected, his government would focus on incentivising businesses to stay in Canada in order to protect jobs in the country. That doesn't mean retaliatory tariffs are off the table. Rather, the Liberal leader said the focus would shift to targeted tariffs that would maximise pain on the US and hurt Canada as little as possible. The Liberal leader said the focus would shift to targeted tariffs designed to maximise pain on the US and hurt Canada as little as possible.
Trump appears to have softened his language on Canada in recent weeks. After a phone call with the US president in late March, Carney said Trump "respected Canada's sovereignty" and said their conversation was "constructive". Trump appears to have softened his language on Canada in recent weeks. After a phone call with the US president in late March, Carney said Trump "respected Canada's sovereignty" and that their conversation was "constructive".
"We had a very good conversation," Trump said afterwards, noting that Canada is in the middle of an election and that he would meet with the winner afterwards. Canada and the US are expected to start talks on trade and security after the 28 April election.
The devil is in the (policy) details Watch: The BBC’s Lyse Doucet unpacks how debate will impact Canadian election
For Canadians deeply tuned into the issues facing the country beyond Trump and his tariffs, the debate offered substantive policy discussions on an array of topics, from housing to crime to immigration. Devil in the (policy) details
The leaders were often passionate about the specifics of their plans, as well as the ideologies that inspire them. And it was clear that Canadians have starkly different choices before them. For Canadians tuned in to issues facing the country beyond Trump and his tariffs, the debate offered substantive policy discussions on topics from housing to crime to immigration.
It was clear that Canadians have starkly different choices before them.
Poilievre frequently championed his vision of a small government that would keep taxes low to drive up economic growth and affordability for Canadians, and that would be tough on crime.Poilievre frequently championed his vision of a small government that would keep taxes low to drive up economic growth and affordability for Canadians, and that would be tough on crime.
Singh, meanwhile, took several opportunities to push for stronger social programmes in Canada, including expanding the country's national dental care and pharmacare programmes and bolstering spending on healthcare. Singh, meanwhile, pushed for stronger social programmes in Canada, including expanding the country's national dental care and pharmacare programmes and bolstering healthcare spending.
Carney stuck close to the centrist point of view of his party, and took the time to list his proposals on how Canada could restore housing affordability, fight off Trump and strengthen its economy. "Government can play a role, but its role has to be catalytic," he said during a debate segment on strong leadership in a crisis. Carney stuck close to the centrist point of view of his party.
Blanchet, leader of the Bloc Quebecois, unsurprisingly used his airtime to advocate for Quebec's distinct place in Canada and for the protection of its French identity. "Government can play a role, but its role has to be catalytic," he said during a debate segment on strong leadership in a crisis.
"I don't want to be the leader of Canada," he noted transparently. The party supports the eventual separation of Quebec from Canada, and carries no seats outside the province. But if it wins a number of seats, it can become a powerful voting block in parliament. Blanchet, leader of the Bloc, used his airtime to advocate for Quebec's distinct place in Canada and for the protection of its unique identity.
"I don't want to be the leader of Canada," he noted. The party supports the eventual separation of Quebec from Canada, and carries no seats outside the province. But if it wins a number of seats, it can become a powerful voting bloc in parliament.
Smaller parties fight for air time – and survivalSmaller parties fight for air time – and survival
Canada's political system, similar to that of the UK, features multiple political parties: the centre-left Liberals, the right-leaning Conservatives, the left-leaning New Democrats, and the Bloc Quebecois which only runs candidates in the French-speaking province of Quebec. There is also the Green Party, which was disqualified at the last minute from the debate for not running enough candidates. Canada's political system, similar to that of the UK, features multiple political parties: the centrist Liberals, the right-leaning Conservatives, the left-leaning New Democrats, and the Bloc, which only runs candidates in Quebec. There is also the Green Party, which was disqualified at the last minute from the debate for not running enough candidates.
This means that Canadians have ample choice as they head to the voting booth. This means that Canadians have distinct choices as they head to the voting booth.
But polls show this election might be more polarised than ever. The bulk of Canadians are opting to support either the Conservative party or the Liberal party, with the election turning largely into a contest between the two. But polls show this election the bulk of Canadians are opting to support either the Conservatives or the Liberals.
This has left the remaining parties fighting for survival. National polls have Singh's New Democrats polling at 8.5% - which would roughly translate into just five seats out of 343, a major loss from their current 24 seats. This has left the third-place parties fighting for survival. National polls have Singh's New Democrats polling at 8.5% - which could roughly translate to just five seats out of 343, a major loss from their current 24 seats.
That fight was apparent during the debate for Singh, who visibly pushed to make his voice heard and interrupted both Poilievre and Carney multiple times in an attempt to set his party apart as the choice for progressive voters in Canada. Singh visibly pushed to make his voice heard and interrupted both Poilievre and Carney multiple times in an attempt to set his party apart as the choice for left-wing voters.
Meanwhile, Bloc Quebecois leader Blanchet inserted issues relevant to the French-speaking province at every opportunity. "You can't entrust all the power to Mr Carney," Singh remarked.
Meanwhile, Bloc leader Blanchet inserted issues relevant to the French-speaking province at every opportunity.
His party, too, stands to lose at least a dozen seats in Quebec, according to current polling, with many opting to vote for the Liberals instead as they believe the party is better equipped to deal with Trump and his threats.His party, too, stands to lose at least a dozen seats in Quebec, according to current polling, with many opting to vote for the Liberals instead as they believe the party is better equipped to deal with Trump and his threats.
Both Singh and Blanchet made the case that they need to be a check on any governing party. "You can't entrust all the power to Mr Carney," Singh remarked. Canadian civility on display
Canadian politeness on display
There were interruptions, spirited discussions and even the occasional lines of attack. But overall, the tone from the four federal leaders was rather cordial.There were interruptions, spirited discussions and even the occasional lines of attack. But overall, the tone from the four federal leaders was rather cordial.
That effort to keep the conversation measured was apparent at one point as the leaders were discussing the housing crisis in Canada. In a rebuttal to Poilievre, Carney appeared to stop himself before laying into his opponent. That effort to keep the conversation measured was apparent at one point as the leaders were discussing the housing crisis. In a rebuttal to Poilievre, Carney appeared to stop himself before laying into his opponent.
"A misunderstanding —" Carney said as he paused mid sentence, adding: "I'll be polite." "A misunderstanding. . . ," Carney said as he paused mid-sentence, adding: "I'll be polite."
Even after some heated exchanges between the two leaders, Carney and Poilievre were filmed shaking hands and exchanging a couple of laughs afterwards. Even after some heated exchanges, Carney and Poilievre were filmed shaking hands and exchanging a couple of laughs afterwards.
Overall, it was a strikingly different scene to those who have watched recent presidential debates in the US. It was even friendlier than some past Canadian federal debates, which featured different Liberal and Conservative candidates. Overall, it was a strikingly different tone to those who have watched recent presidential debate cycles in the US.
It was friendlier than some past Canadian federal debates, which featured different Liberal and Conservative candidates.