This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cd023eel919o
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Chris Mason: Gender debate has changed but it's not over yet | Chris Mason: Gender debate has changed but it's not over yet |
(about 4 hours later) | |
Kemi Badenoch delivers a statement in parliament addressing the Supreme Court's ruling that the term "woman" means "biological woman" | Kemi Badenoch delivers a statement in parliament addressing the Supreme Court's ruling that the term "woman" means "biological woman" |
In nearly 25 years in daily journalism, I have never known another issue quite like it. | In nearly 25 years in daily journalism, I have never known another issue quite like it. |
The arguments over sex and gender, trans and women's rights have a passion, an anger and often a toxicity on both sides greater in their intensity than those over the Iraq war two decades ago, or Brexit in more recent years. | The arguments over sex and gender, trans and women's rights have a passion, an anger and often a toxicity on both sides greater in their intensity than those over the Iraq war two decades ago, or Brexit in more recent years. |
The abuse and vitriol that fly into my inbox every time I report on it are really quite something. | The abuse and vitriol that fly into my inbox every time I report on it are really quite something. |
Last week's decision by the Supreme Court was a landmark moment in this debate, providing the prism through which arguments will now be conducted. | Last week's decision by the Supreme Court was a landmark moment in this debate, providing the prism through which arguments will now be conducted. |
But it won't mark an end to those arguments, as a debate in the Commons on Tuesday evening proved. | But it won't mark an end to those arguments, as a debate in the Commons on Tuesday evening proved. |
The Conservative benches were packed and the Tory leader, Kemi Badenoch, took the unusual decision to answer for her party herself, something she would normally do in response to a statement from the prime minister rather than any other minister. | The Conservative benches were packed and the Tory leader, Kemi Badenoch, took the unusual decision to answer for her party herself, something she would normally do in response to a statement from the prime minister rather than any other minister. |
It was clear why she wanted to do so, displaying a greater confidence and sense of self-assurance than at any point since she became Conservative leader last autumn. | It was clear why she wanted to do so, displaying a greater confidence and sense of self-assurance than at any point since she became Conservative leader last autumn. |
Some of her own MPs have grumbled privately that she has lacked oomph and cut-through in her opening months in the job. | Some of her own MPs have grumbled privately that she has lacked oomph and cut-through in her opening months in the job. |
She wasn't lacking oomph this time, arguing the Supreme Court had vindicated what she had long argued, and pretty much saying "I told you so" to the Labour Party. | She wasn't lacking oomph this time, arguing the Supreme Court had vindicated what she had long argued, and pretty much saying "I told you so" to the Labour Party. |
And yes, Labour in recent years, from Sir Keir Starmer down, have been in something of a bind on this issue, frequently tangled in anguish when confronted by questions such as "Can a woman have a penis?" | And yes, Labour in recent years, from Sir Keir Starmer down, have been in something of a bind on this issue, frequently tangled in anguish when confronted by questions such as "Can a woman have a penis?" |
Many senior Labour figures regarded such questions as reductive and trivialising and wanted to be openly thoughtful about the rights of trans people. | Many senior Labour figures regarded such questions as reductive and trivialising and wanted to be openly thoughtful about the rights of trans people. |
They maintain, as do the Conservatives, that they still are, but it is also true that the Labour leadership's position is the opposite of what it was. | They maintain, as do the Conservatives, that they still are, but it is also true that the Labour leadership's position is the opposite of what it was. |
The Supreme Court's decision prompts lots of questions about the practicalities of what it concluded – for organisations large and small, public and private, trans people and others. | The Supreme Court's decision prompts lots of questions about the practicalities of what it concluded – for organisations large and small, public and private, trans people and others. |
It is far from the end of those debates, but they will look and feel different, in politics and in wider society, after that landmark moment just before Easter. | It is far from the end of those debates, but they will look and feel different, in politics and in wider society, after that landmark moment just before Easter. |
Sign up for our Politics Essential newsletter to keep up with the inner workings of Westminster and beyond. |
Previous version
1
Next version