This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/business/8376906.stm
The article has changed 21 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 13 | Version 14 |
|---|---|
| Banks win on overdraft fees case | Banks win on overdraft fees case |
| (10 minutes later) | |
| Millions of bank customers hoping to be refunded overdraft charges have been dealt a major blow by a Supreme Court judgement. | Millions of bank customers hoping to be refunded overdraft charges have been dealt a major blow by a Supreme Court judgement. |
| The court has overturned earlier court rulings that allowed the Office of Fair Trading to investigate the fairness of charges for unauthorised overdrafts. | The court has overturned earlier court rulings that allowed the Office of Fair Trading to investigate the fairness of charges for unauthorised overdrafts. |
| At stake in the case, which has run for over two years, is an estimated £2.6bn of annual income for the banks. | At stake in the case, which has run for over two years, is an estimated £2.6bn of annual income for the banks. |
| Campaigners said they were shocked and disappointed with the decision. | Campaigners said they were shocked and disappointed with the decision. |
| Banks welcomed the ruling, said there had been major changes to current account packages recently, and pointed out that these unplanned overdraft fees could be avoided. | Banks welcomed the ruling, said there had been major changes to current account packages recently, and pointed out that these unplanned overdraft fees could be avoided. |
| Seven banks and one building society wanted the court to overturn two previous rulings that said the OFT had the power to investigate unauthorised overdraft fees. | Seven banks and one building society wanted the court to overturn two previous rulings that said the OFT had the power to investigate unauthorised overdraft fees. |
| ANALYSIS By Ian Pollock, personal finance reporter, at the Supreme Court | ANALYSIS By Ian Pollock, personal finance reporter, at the Supreme Court |
| It took Lord Phillips just a couple of minutes to deliver a profoundly important ruling for UK banks and their customers. | It took Lord Phillips just a couple of minutes to deliver a profoundly important ruling for UK banks and their customers. |
| The Supreme Court has decided that for the past two and a half years the OFT has been barking up the wrong legal tree. | The Supreme Court has decided that for the past two and a half years the OFT has been barking up the wrong legal tree. |
| The result is that banks can continue charging high fees for customers who go overdrawn without authority to subsidise the cost of providing current accounts to other customers who stay in the black. | The result is that banks can continue charging high fees for customers who go overdrawn without authority to subsidise the cost of providing current accounts to other customers who stay in the black. |
| In a three-day appeal in the House of Lords in June, the banks argued they would receive a "deluge of litigation" if the decision was made against them. | In a three-day appeal in the House of Lords in June, the banks argued they would receive a "deluge of litigation" if the decision was made against them. |
| Historic claims | Historic claims |
| Those who received payments from banks before the test case started will keep their money, because these pay-outs were made as "goodwill gestures". | Those who received payments from banks before the test case started will keep their money, because these pay-outs were made as "goodwill gestures". |
| All new claims against banks were effectively suspended in July 2007 when the OFT and the banks agreed to stage the test case to see if the overdraft charges were legal or not. | All new claims against banks were effectively suspended in July 2007 when the OFT and the banks agreed to stage the test case to see if the overdraft charges were legal or not. |
| The OFT has previously said that even if it lost, it would still try to use other powers, perhaps by instigating a full Competition Commission enquiry, to attack overdraft fees. | The OFT has previously said that even if it lost, it would still try to use other powers, perhaps by instigating a full Competition Commission enquiry, to attack overdraft fees. |
| In explaining his ruling, the Supreme Court's president Lord Phillips said that bank customers agreed to pay overdraft charges as part of the price of having a current account, so they fell outside the scope of the appropriate regulations. | In explaining his ruling, the Supreme Court's president Lord Phillips said that bank customers agreed to pay overdraft charges as part of the price of having a current account, so they fell outside the scope of the appropriate regulations. |
| HAVE YOUR SAYFees are agreed by customers when they open their accounts. If they break those terms & conditions by having insufficient funds then they should pay the price.Bob, Wokingham Send us your comments | HAVE YOUR SAYFees are agreed by customers when they open their accounts. If they break those terms & conditions by having insufficient funds then they should pay the price.Bob, Wokingham Send us your comments |
| But Lord Phillips added that this was not the end of the matter as the OFT could still try to scrutinise bank charges under other parts of the regulations. | But Lord Phillips added that this was not the end of the matter as the OFT could still try to scrutinise bank charges under other parts of the regulations. |
| "This will not close the door on the OFT's investigations and may well not resolve the myriad cases that are currently stayed [put on hold] in which customers have challenged the relevant charges," he told the court. | "This will not close the door on the OFT's investigations and may well not resolve the myriad cases that are currently stayed [put on hold] in which customers have challenged the relevant charges," he told the court. |
| The Supreme Court ruling will come as a bitter blow to the consumer organisations who have campaigned against what they considered to be unfair overdraft charges. | The Supreme Court ruling will come as a bitter blow to the consumer organisations who have campaigned against what they considered to be unfair overdraft charges. |
| The Court said it would not allow an appeal by the OFT to the European Court of Justice. | The Court said it would not allow an appeal by the OFT to the European Court of Justice. |
| The judge did not give any explicit guidance as to how the judicial authorities should deal with the frozen cases. | The judge did not give any explicit guidance as to how the judicial authorities should deal with the frozen cases. |
| "What is not clear yet is what happens to the refund claims that have been on hold since July 2007," said BBC personal finance reporter Ian Pollock, who was in court. | "What is not clear yet is what happens to the refund claims that have been on hold since July 2007," said BBC personal finance reporter Ian Pollock, who was in court. |
| "They may stay that way if the OFT attacks bank charges another way, perhaps by triggering a full Competition Commission inquiry. Alternatively, the judicial authorities may simply invite local judges to dismiss the claims that have stacked up before them." | "They may stay that way if the OFT attacks bank charges another way, perhaps by triggering a full Competition Commission inquiry. Alternatively, the judicial authorities may simply invite local judges to dismiss the claims that have stacked up before them." |
| 'Shock' | 'Shock' |
| The OFT said that it was "disappointed" with the judgement. | The OFT said that it was "disappointed" with the judgement. |
| Karen King: "I'm finding it really hard" | Karen King: "I'm finding it really hard" |
| "The OFT will now consider the detail of this judgment before it makes a decision on whether or not to continue its investigation into unarranged overdraft charging terms," it said in a statement. | "The OFT will now consider the detail of this judgment before it makes a decision on whether or not to continue its investigation into unarranged overdraft charging terms," it said in a statement. |
| "It will also explore with others the implications for consumers and for existing and future legislation and regulation." | "It will also explore with others the implications for consumers and for existing and future legislation and regulation." |
| It said it would make another announcement in December. | It said it would make another announcement in December. |
| Research by the OFT published last year found banks earned around a third of their retail revenues from unarranged overdraft charges that were "difficult to understand, not transparent, and not subject to effective consumer control". | Research by the OFT published last year found banks earned around a third of their retail revenues from unarranged overdraft charges that were "difficult to understand, not transparent, and not subject to effective consumer control". |
| Marc Gander, of the Consumer Action Group, said that he was "shocked" about the Supreme Court ruling. | Marc Gander, of the Consumer Action Group, said that he was "shocked" about the Supreme Court ruling. |
| "This is completely unexpected. It is a devastating blow," he said. | "This is completely unexpected. It is a devastating blow," he said. |
| Phil Jones, from the consumers' association Which?, said that he was "utterly outraged" by the ruling. | Phil Jones, from the consumers' association Which?, said that he was "utterly outraged" by the ruling. |
| But Martin Lewis, of Moneysavingexpert.com, said: "This may be a setback for reclaiming but it is not the end. The likelihood is the money is not coming back for anyone who has got claims on hold. There is still hope here, but we have got to do a lot of reading and a lot of legal work." | But Martin Lewis, of Moneysavingexpert.com, said: "This may be a setback for reclaiming but it is not the end. The likelihood is the money is not coming back for anyone who has got claims on hold. There is still hope here, but we have got to do a lot of reading and a lot of legal work." |
| Some of these campaigners said that the OFT could explore other avenues to tackle the banks about charges, but this would require another round of litigation. | Some of these campaigners said that the OFT could explore other avenues to tackle the banks about charges, but this would require another round of litigation. |
| Banks' response | Banks' response |
| The British Bankers Association, which represents the banks, said it considered the decision as a "clarification of the law" rather than a "victory". | The British Bankers Association, which represents the banks, said it considered the decision as a "clarification of the law" rather than a "victory". |
| Individuals can avoid any charge by putting their overdraft arrangements in place first Angela Knight, BBA | Individuals can avoid any charge by putting their overdraft arrangements in place first Angela Knight, BBA |
| "We recognise this issue has been of real concern to a large number of our customers and we are pleased that this decision now brings clarity for all parties," it said. | "We recognise this issue has been of real concern to a large number of our customers and we are pleased that this decision now brings clarity for all parties," it said. |
| "The banks will work with the regulators to ensure that the outstanding customer complaints are brought to a swift conclusion." | "The banks will work with the regulators to ensure that the outstanding customer complaints are brought to a swift conclusion." |
| Angela Knight, from the BBA, was asked whether they would continue to make unauthorised overdraft charges. | Angela Knight, from the BBA, was asked whether they would continue to make unauthorised overdraft charges. |
| "The banks are mindful of their customers, they know the concerns of those who have paid the unauthorised overdraft fees and those who have not," she said. | "The banks are mindful of their customers, they know the concerns of those who have paid the unauthorised overdraft fees and those who have not," she said. |
| "Individuals can avoid any charge by putting their overdraft arrangements in place first." | "Individuals can avoid any charge by putting their overdraft arrangements in place first." |
| Asked about the case at Prime Minister's Questions, Gordon Brown said that it was correct to examine the fairness of charges. | |
| He said government-supported banks - Northern Rock, HBOS and RBS - had recently been asked to review their overdraft charges so that they were fairer to customers. | |
| Sarah McCarthy Fry, Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury, said the government was "determined" to make sure the system was made fairer in future. | Sarah McCarthy Fry, Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury, said the government was "determined" to make sure the system was made fairer in future. |
| "Consumers, who have been waiting a number of years, will be extremely disappointed with this outcome. | "Consumers, who have been waiting a number of years, will be extremely disappointed with this outcome. |
| "It is clear that in the past, banks were not thinking enough about their customers. That needs to change for the future. | "It is clear that in the past, banks were not thinking enough about their customers. That needs to change for the future. |
| "The government will work with the OFT and Financial Services Authority to reach a new framework for fairer bank charges going forward." | "The government will work with the OFT and Financial Services Authority to reach a new framework for fairer bank charges going forward." |