This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c8e1zd98k9no
The article has changed 10 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Epping hotel asylum seekers to remain at the Bell, court rules | Epping hotel asylum seekers to remain at the Bell, court rules |
| (32 minutes later) | |
| Tensions have been high over the housing of 138 asylum seekers at The Bell Hotel in Epping | Tensions have been high over the housing of 138 asylum seekers at The Bell Hotel in Epping |
| A temporary injunction that blocked asylum seekers being housed at an Essex hotel has been overturned at the Court of Appeal. | A temporary injunction that blocked asylum seekers being housed at an Essex hotel has been overturned at the Court of Appeal. |
| Lawyers for The Bell Hotel in Epping and the government challenged a High Court ruling that would have forced 138 asylum seekers to leave the site by 12 September. | Lawyers for The Bell Hotel in Epping and the government challenged a High Court ruling that would have forced 138 asylum seekers to leave the site by 12 September. |
| Overturning the injunction, Lord Justice Bean said the High Court ruling was "seriously flawed in principle". | Overturning the injunction, Lord Justice Bean said the High Court ruling was "seriously flawed in principle". |
| Epping Forest District Council, which obtained the initial injunction, said "the battle was not over". | Epping Forest District Council, which obtained the initial injunction, said "the battle was not over". |
| The Home Office has braced itself for a wave of legal challenges from other councils over the use of hotels in their areas, fearing Epping's victory would set a precedent. | The Home Office has braced itself for a wave of legal challenges from other councils over the use of hotels in their areas, fearing Epping's victory would set a precedent. |
| But Lord Justice Bean said the High Court ruling by Mr Justice Eyre failed to consider the challenges of relocating the migrants. | But Lord Justice Bean said the High Court ruling by Mr Justice Eyre failed to consider the challenges of relocating the migrants. |
| "The judge's approach ignores the obvious consequence that the closure of one site means capacity needs to be identified elsewhere in the system," he said, reading the ruling made by him and two other Court of Appeal judges. | "The judge's approach ignores the obvious consequence that the closure of one site means capacity needs to be identified elsewhere in the system," he said, reading the ruling made by him and two other Court of Appeal judges. |
| Reacting to the latest ruling, Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said it "puts the rights of illegal immigrants above the rights of the British people". | Reacting to the latest ruling, Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said it "puts the rights of illegal immigrants above the rights of the British people". |
| Protesters started to gather outside the Bell in the hours after the judgement - with several Union Jack and St George's flags being waved. | |
| A BBC reporter observed an asylum seeker being heckled. | |
| A full High Court hearing to decide on a permanent injunction for the Bell is expected in mid-October. | A full High Court hearing to decide on a permanent injunction for the Bell is expected in mid-October. |
| Protests and counter-demonstrations have been staged outside The Bell Hotel during the summer | Protests and counter-demonstrations have been staged outside The Bell Hotel during the summer |
| Thousands of people have attended anti-immigration protests and counter-demonstrations outside The Bell Hotel since July. | Thousands of people have attended anti-immigration protests and counter-demonstrations outside The Bell Hotel since July. |
| It followed an asylum seeker housed there being arrested and subsequently charged with several offences including the sexually assault of a 14-year-old girl. | It followed an asylum seeker housed there being arrested and subsequently charged with several offences including the sexually assault of a 14-year-old girl. |
| Hadush Kebatu, who is from Ethiopia, denies the offences and has been on trial. | Hadush Kebatu, who is from Ethiopia, denies the offences and has been on trial. |
| The protests acted as a trigger for the council to apply for an injunction, its legal team said in court. | The protests acted as a trigger for the council to apply for an injunction, its legal team said in court. |
| Lord Justice Bean said this was "worrying", adding: "If an outbreak of protest enhances a case, this runs the risk of acting as an impetus for further protests - some of which may be disorderly - around asylum accommodation. | Lord Justice Bean said this was "worrying", adding: "If an outbreak of protest enhances a case, this runs the risk of acting as an impetus for further protests - some of which may be disorderly - around asylum accommodation. |
| "There is a risk of encouraging further lawlessness." | "There is a risk of encouraging further lawlessness." |
| Police say 25 arrests have been made in connection with disorder outside the hotel, with 16 people charged. | Police say 25 arrests have been made in connection with disorder outside the hotel, with 16 people charged. |
| Lord Justice Bean said Mr Justice Eyre "made a number of errors" when imposing the injunction on 19 August. | Lord Justice Bean said Mr Justice Eyre "made a number of errors" when imposing the injunction on 19 August. |
| Criticism was also levelled at the High Court judge's refusal to allow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper's 11th-hour attempt to dismiss the council's case. | Criticism was also levelled at the High Court judge's refusal to allow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper's 11th-hour attempt to dismiss the council's case. |
| That would have given him more insight into the challenge of relocating the asylum seekers, Lord Justice Bean added. | That would have given him more insight into the challenge of relocating the asylum seekers, Lord Justice Bean added. |
| Epping Forest District Council had argued there was "no compelling reason" to overturn the injunction | Epping Forest District Council had argued there was "no compelling reason" to overturn the injunction |
| At the High Court, Epping Forest District Council claimed that the Bell owner Somani Hotels breached planning rules by turning the site into asylum accommodation. | At the High Court, Epping Forest District Council claimed that the Bell owner Somani Hotels breached planning rules by turning the site into asylum accommodation. |
| "The battle is not over and we will continue the fight," a spokesperson said earlier. | "The battle is not over and we will continue the fight," a spokesperson said earlier. |
| "It is nothing less than the people of Epping would expect and deserve." | "It is nothing less than the people of Epping would expect and deserve." |
| Neil Hudson, the Tory MP for Epping Forest, said the judgement was a "dreadful decision". | Neil Hudson, the Tory MP for Epping Forest, said the judgement was a "dreadful decision". |
| Reform UK leader Nigel Farage said on X: "Illegal migrants have more rights than the British people under Starmer." | Reform UK leader Nigel Farage said on X: "Illegal migrants have more rights than the British people under Starmer." |
| But Steve Smith, chief executive of refugee charity Care4Calais, said the ruling "made it clear that violent protest, and in many cases overt racism, is not a fast-track route for the far right to attack the rights of people seeking sanctuary in this country". | But Steve Smith, chief executive of refugee charity Care4Calais, said the ruling "made it clear that violent protest, and in many cases overt racism, is not a fast-track route for the far right to attack the rights of people seeking sanctuary in this country". |
| Liberal Democrat home affairs spokeswoman, Lisa Smart, told the BBC that Labour should be "speeding up asylum processing to bring down the backlog and end hotel use once and for all". | Liberal Democrat home affairs spokeswoman, Lisa Smart, told the BBC that Labour should be "speeding up asylum processing to bring down the backlog and end hotel use once and for all". |
| Border Security and Asylum Minister Dame Angela Eagle said the Home Office launched this appeal so hotels could be "exited in a controlled and orderly way". | Border Security and Asylum Minister Dame Angela Eagle said the Home Office launched this appeal so hotels could be "exited in a controlled and orderly way". |
| The judgement followed evidence being heard on Thursday. | The judgement followed evidence being heard on Thursday. |
| Housing asylum seekers was described as a "lifeline" for the venue, which was only 1% full when it was open to paying customers in August 2022. | Housing asylum seekers was described as a "lifeline" for the venue, which was only 1% full when it was open to paying customers in August 2022. |
| Becca Jones, the Home Office's director of asylum support, added it would have been a blow to lose The Bell Hotel's 152 beds when pressure was "significant and increasing". | Becca Jones, the Home Office's director of asylum support, added it would have been a blow to lose The Bell Hotel's 152 beds when pressure was "significant and increasing". |
| The hearing was told there were 103,684 accommodated asylum-seekers as of 31 March, higher than in 2024. | The hearing was told there were 103,684 accommodated asylum-seekers as of 31 March, higher than in 2024. |
| Philip Coppel KC, acting for the district council, argued there was "no compelling reason" for the appeal bid to be allowed. | Philip Coppel KC, acting for the district council, argued there was "no compelling reason" for the appeal bid to be allowed. |
| Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X. | Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X. |