This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/norfolk/8394040.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Banker's killers make appeal bid | |
(about 18 hours later) | |
Two brothers who admitted the manslaughter of a senior banking executive in Norfolk have appealed against their jail terms. | Two brothers who admitted the manslaughter of a senior banking executive in Norfolk have appealed against their jail terms. |
Ben Cowles, 21, and Tom Cowles, 22, beat Frank McGarahan, 45, during a night out in Norwich in September 2008. | Ben Cowles, 21, and Tom Cowles, 22, beat Frank McGarahan, 45, during a night out in Norwich in September 2008. |
Mr McGarahan, of Hertfordshire, never regained consciousness. | Mr McGarahan, of Hertfordshire, never regained consciousness. |
Court of Appeal judges, who reserved judgement to a later date, heard the sentences of seven and seven and a half years were "manifestly excessive". | Court of Appeal judges, who reserved judgement to a later date, heard the sentences of seven and seven and a half years were "manifestly excessive". |
The brothers, both of Beaumont Road, Costessey, near Norwich, had got into a fight with a Lithuanian man, Robertas Sinkevicius, at the entrance to Dove Street in the early hours of 28 September. | The brothers, both of Beaumont Road, Costessey, near Norwich, had got into a fight with a Lithuanian man, Robertas Sinkevicius, at the entrance to Dove Street in the early hours of 28 September. |
Punched repeatedly | Punched repeatedly |
Father-of-two Mr McGarahan, of Much Hadham, near Bishop's Stortford, was in the city for a family christening. | Father-of-two Mr McGarahan, of Much Hadham, near Bishop's Stortford, was in the city for a family christening. |
He and his party appeared and the brothers were branded "cowards" for their part in the previous altercation. | He and his party appeared and the brothers were branded "cowards" for their part in the previous altercation. |
Frank McGarahan worked at Barclays Wealth | Frank McGarahan worked at Barclays Wealth |
A new fight then started, during which Mr McGarahan was put in a headlock and punched repeatedly. He died in hospital. | A new fight then started, during which Mr McGarahan was put in a headlock and punched repeatedly. He died in hospital. |
Ben Cowles was jailed for seven-and-a-half years and his brother for seven years after they admitted manslaughter. | Ben Cowles was jailed for seven-and-a-half years and his brother for seven years after they admitted manslaughter. |
Following the brothers' sentencing in June, Mr McGarahan's family described the prison terms as "disgraceful" and called for a review of the law to allow higher sentences. | Following the brothers' sentencing in June, Mr McGarahan's family described the prison terms as "disgraceful" and called for a review of the law to allow higher sentences. |
Lawyers for the brothers told the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Judge, sitting with four senior colleagues, that they had not been treated leniently and had received sentences which were "much too long". | Lawyers for the brothers told the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Judge, sitting with four senior colleagues, that they had not been treated leniently and had received sentences which were "much too long". |
'More mitigating factors' | 'More mitigating factors' |
Michael Hubbard QC said: "It was not a sustained attack, it was not premeditated, the application of force was on the moderate side. | |
"There were no facial injuries found, no fractures. | "There were no facial injuries found, no fractures. |
"I have to accept that there was a degree of punching, coincidental with the headlock, but thereafter, nothing." | "I have to accept that there was a degree of punching, coincidental with the headlock, but thereafter, nothing." |
He added: "These are two good lads from good homes, and they have done splendidly well. | He added: "These are two good lads from good homes, and they have done splendidly well. |
"They are the sort of lads who spend their quiet hours fishing, at home with mum and dad, with a job and have, as much as they can, redeemed themselves while in custody. | "They are the sort of lads who spend their quiet hours fishing, at home with mum and dad, with a job and have, as much as they can, redeemed themselves while in custody. |
"We suggest there were infinitely more mitigating factors than there were aggravating factors." | "We suggest there were infinitely more mitigating factors than there were aggravating factors." |
Previous version
1
Next version