This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/americas/8396803.stm
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Dylan song adopted for Copenhagen | Dylan song adopted for Copenhagen |
| (1 day later) | |
| By Barbara Plett BBC UN correspondent, New York Bob Dylan - now 68 - first performed the song in 1962 | By Barbara Plett BBC UN correspondent, New York Bob Dylan - now 68 - first performed the song in 1962 |
| Bob Dylan has star billing at the climate change summit in CopenhagenÂ… or at least, his music does. | Bob Dylan has star billing at the climate change summit in CopenhagenÂ… or at least, his music does. |
| The United Nations has adopted one of his songs, A Hard Rain's A Gonna Fall, as its unofficial anthem for the talks. | The United Nations has adopted one of his songs, A Hard Rain's A Gonna Fall, as its unofficial anthem for the talks. |
| This is a song best known for channelling the fears of a generation living under the threat of nuclear war. | This is a song best known for channelling the fears of a generation living under the threat of nuclear war. |
| Dylan performed it for the first time in 1962 at the height of the Cold War, shortly before a plan by Moscow to station atomic missiles in Cuba set off a crisis between the United States and the Soviet Union. | Dylan performed it for the first time in 1962 at the height of the Cold War, shortly before a plan by Moscow to station atomic missiles in Cuba set off a crisis between the United States and the Soviet Union. |
| But Hard Rain has weathered well, and is now being invoked to highlight this generation's fear of environmental calamity. | But Hard Rain has weathered well, and is now being invoked to highlight this generation's fear of environmental calamity. |
| That is testimony to the enduring and universal power of its lyrics, says David Fricke, a senior editor at the Rolling Stone music magazine in New York. | That is testimony to the enduring and universal power of its lyrics, says David Fricke, a senior editor at the Rolling Stone music magazine in New York. |
| "Let me just quote some lines and see if any sound familiar," he says. | "Let me just quote some lines and see if any sound familiar," he says. |
| "'I've stepped in the middle of seven sad forests; I've been out in front of a dozen dead oceans; I heard the roar of a wave that could drown the whole world.' | "'I've stepped in the middle of seven sad forests; I've been out in front of a dozen dead oceans; I heard the roar of a wave that could drown the whole world.' |
| "What about this don't we recognise? All of those images and the pictures those words conjure, they're as familiar as a cable news report four minutes ago!" | "What about this don't we recognise? All of those images and the pictures those words conjure, they're as familiar as a cable news report four minutes ago!" |
| The song has inspired numerous covers by various musicians. It also inspired a UN environmental photographer, Mark Edwards. | The song has inspired numerous covers by various musicians. It also inspired a UN environmental photographer, Mark Edwards. |
| His Hard Rain odyssey began in 1969, when he was rescued by Tuareg nomads after getting lost in the Sahara Desert. | His Hard Rain odyssey began in 1969, when he was rescued by Tuareg nomads after getting lost in the Sahara Desert. |
| "My rescuer rubbed two sticks together," recalls Mr Edwards. | "My rescuer rubbed two sticks together," recalls Mr Edwards. |
| "He made a fire and we had a nice cup of tea. Then he turned his battered old cassette player on, and Bob Dylan sang 'A Hard Rain's A Gonna Fall.' | "He made a fire and we had a nice cup of tea. Then he turned his battered old cassette player on, and Bob Dylan sang 'A Hard Rain's A Gonna Fall.' |
| "I was fascinated by the lyrics, and I decided to illustrate each line of the song. In the years that followed I added pictures as I saw them." | "I was fascinated by the lyrics, and I decided to illustrate each line of the song. In the years that followed I added pictures as I saw them." |
| Scepticism | Scepticism |
| The UN is exhibiting his work at the climate change conference, accompanied by the release of a rare live recording of Bob Dylan performing the song, which the UN is using as an unofficial soundtrack to the summit. | The UN is exhibiting his work at the climate change conference, accompanied by the release of a rare live recording of Bob Dylan performing the song, which the UN is using as an unofficial soundtrack to the summit. |
| "What the exhibition does, and what Dylan's lyrics allow us to do, is to illustrate all of our global problems," explains Mr Edwards. | "What the exhibition does, and what Dylan's lyrics allow us to do, is to illustrate all of our global problems," explains Mr Edwards. |
| The idea that the UN is now taking a Bob Dylan tune and putting it up to be the anthem for Copenhagen seems to me kind of silly Max SchulzManhattan Institute class="" href="/2/hi/americas/8397283.stm">Read your views and alternative suggestions | |
| "Poverty, population expansion, conventional pollution. If we want to solve climate change, if we really want to deal with this huge issue, we've got to see the whole of it, we've got to respond to this problem in totality." | "Poverty, population expansion, conventional pollution. If we want to solve climate change, if we really want to deal with this huge issue, we've got to see the whole of it, we've got to respond to this problem in totality." |
| Others are less enthusiastic, including Max Schulz, an energy expert at the Manhattan Institute think tank. | Others are less enthusiastic, including Max Schulz, an energy expert at the Manhattan Institute think tank. |
| He is sceptical about doomsday climate change predictions, and he is also a Bob Dylan fan who thinks the UN is exploiting a great song for its own narrow purposes. | He is sceptical about doomsday climate change predictions, and he is also a Bob Dylan fan who thinks the UN is exploiting a great song for its own narrow purposes. |
| "The idea that the UN is now taking a Bob Dylan tune and putting it up to be the anthem for Copenhagen seems to me kind of silly," he says. | "The idea that the UN is now taking a Bob Dylan tune and putting it up to be the anthem for Copenhagen seems to me kind of silly," he says. |
| "And trying to play on the environmental alarmism of the song seems doubly silly. | "And trying to play on the environmental alarmism of the song seems doubly silly. |
| "It is not clear from anything that we know about the song that it has anything to do with environmental harm or destruction: it's a bizarre song, it's an inscrutable one." | "It is not clear from anything that we know about the song that it has anything to do with environmental harm or destruction: it's a bizarre song, it's an inscrutable one." |
| But regardless of what Bob Dylan did or did not mean, A Hard Rain's A Gonna Fall clearly remains an indictment, says David Fricke, and a stark warning to today's leaders. | But regardless of what Bob Dylan did or did not mean, A Hard Rain's A Gonna Fall clearly remains an indictment, says David Fricke, and a stark warning to today's leaders. |
| "It really shows that if we don't address things, the hard rain is not only 'gonna' fall," he says, "but it's been falling already, and we've haven't been paying attention." | "It really shows that if we don't address things, the hard rain is not only 'gonna' fall," he says, "but it's been falling already, and we've haven't been paying attention." |