This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/beds/bucks/herts/8452616.stm
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Five men guilty of parade threats | Five men guilty of parade threats |
| (20 minutes later) | |
| Five Muslim men who protested at a home-coming parade in Luton where soldiers were called murderers have been found guilty of making threats. | Five Muslim men who protested at a home-coming parade in Luton where soldiers were called murderers have been found guilty of making threats. |
| The charges related to a march by The Royal Anglian Regiment through the town in March 2009. | The charges related to a march by The Royal Anglian Regiment through the town in March 2009. |
| The five men, all from Luton, were convicted of using threatening, abusive or insulting words and behaviour likely to cause harassment and distress. | The five men, all from Luton, were convicted of using threatening, abusive or insulting words and behaviour likely to cause harassment and distress. |
| Two men were cleared of all charges at Luton Magistrates' Court. | Two men were cleared of all charges at Luton Magistrates' Court. |
| Jalal Ahmed, 21, Yousaf Bashir, 29, Ziaur Rahman, 32, Shajjadar Choudhury, 31, Munim Abdul, 28, were found guilty. | Jalal Ahmed, 21, Yousaf Bashir, 29, Ziaur Rahman, 32, Shajjadar Choudhury, 31, Munim Abdul, 28, were found guilty. |
| 'Abuse and insults' | 'Abuse and insults' |
| Ibrahim Anderson, 32, and Jubair Ahmed, 19, who are also from Luton, were found not guilty. All had denied the charges. | Ibrahim Anderson, 32, and Jubair Ahmed, 19, who are also from Luton, were found not guilty. All had denied the charges. |
| District Judge Carolyn Mellanby said: "I have no doubt it is abusive and insulting to tell soldiers to 'Go to hell' - to call soldiers murderers, rapists and baby killers. | District Judge Carolyn Mellanby said: "I have no doubt it is abusive and insulting to tell soldiers to 'Go to hell' - to call soldiers murderers, rapists and baby killers. |
| "It is not just insulting to the soldiers but to the citizens of Luton who were out on the streets that day to honour and welcome soldiers home. | "It is not just insulting to the soldiers but to the citizens of Luton who were out on the streets that day to honour and welcome soldiers home. |
| The fact that they say they did not intend their remarks to be insulting does not amount to defence in law District Judge Carolyn Mellanby | The fact that they say they did not intend their remarks to be insulting does not amount to defence in law District Judge Carolyn Mellanby |
| "Citizens of Luton are entitled to demonstrate their support for the troops without experiencing insults and abuse." | "Citizens of Luton are entitled to demonstrate their support for the troops without experiencing insults and abuse." |
| She went on: "The fact that they say they did not intend their remarks to be insulting does not amount to defence in law. | She went on: "The fact that they say they did not intend their remarks to be insulting does not amount to defence in law. |
| "They were fully aware that shocking phrases in such circumstances would inevitably cause distress." | "They were fully aware that shocking phrases in such circumstances would inevitably cause distress." |
| Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) lawyer Paul Harrison said: "It is always a difficult job to balance the rights of those wishing to express their views on political issues against the need to protect the public from distress and alarm. | Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) lawyer Paul Harrison said: "It is always a difficult job to balance the rights of those wishing to express their views on political issues against the need to protect the public from distress and alarm. |
| "We welcome District Judge Mellany's finding that their conduct was threatening and did in fact cause alarm and distress to others present at the parade. | "We welcome District Judge Mellany's finding that their conduct was threatening and did in fact cause alarm and distress to others present at the parade. |
| "She also agreed with the CPS that the defendants' behaviour, in this instance, went beyond what is reasonable when taking part in a lawful demonstration." | "She also agreed with the CPS that the defendants' behaviour, in this instance, went beyond what is reasonable when taking part in a lawful demonstration." |
| Freedom of speech | Freedom of speech |
| Defence lawyers had argued the right to freedom of speech was at stake and Jubair Ahmed's lawyer Sonal Dashani had referred to the French philosopher Voltaire. | |
| He said: "Voltaire said 'I disagree with what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it.' | |
| "That was in the 18th Century. Things have moved on since then, though perhaps not as quickly as one might have liked. | "That was in the 18th Century. Things have moved on since then, though perhaps not as quickly as one might have liked. |
| "If you believe in freedom of speech you have to accept that some things will be said that you will like and some things will be said that you will not like." | "If you believe in freedom of speech you have to accept that some things will be said that you will like and some things will be said that you will not like." |
| Angry scenes broke out during the parade for the 2nd Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment, known as The Poachers. | Angry scenes broke out during the parade for the 2nd Battalion The Royal Anglian Regiment, known as The Poachers. |
| Lawyers defending the men said their clients discussed their plans to protest with police beforehand, had agreed to a time and a place to do so with them, had complied with police throughout and officers had not objected at the time to their slogans. | Lawyers defending the men said their clients discussed their plans to protest with police beforehand, had agreed to a time and a place to do so with them, had complied with police throughout and officers had not objected at the time to their slogans. |