This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/8467915.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| 'Mercy killing' not part of law | 'Mercy killing' not part of law |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| The judge trying a mother accused of murdering her brain-damaged son has said no-one has the "unfettered right" to take the law into their own hands. | The judge trying a mother accused of murdering her brain-damaged son has said no-one has the "unfettered right" to take the law into their own hands. |
| Frances Inglis, 57, of Dagenham, Essex, denies murdering Thomas Inglis, 22, on 21 November 2008 and an earlier attempt to kill him on 4 September 2007. | Frances Inglis, 57, of Dagenham, Essex, denies murdering Thomas Inglis, 22, on 21 November 2008 and an earlier attempt to kill him on 4 September 2007. |
| Mr Inglis was fatally injected with heroin at his Hertfordshire care home. | Mr Inglis was fatally injected with heroin at his Hertfordshire care home. |
| Judge Brian Barker told the Old Bailey jury "there is no concept in law of mercy killing" and it is still killing. | Judge Brian Barker told the Old Bailey jury "there is no concept in law of mercy killing" and it is still killing. |
| He said the jury must "put all emotion aside" when considering the case of Ms Inglis, who gave her son a lethal heroin injection. | He said the jury must "put all emotion aside" when considering the case of Ms Inglis, who gave her son a lethal heroin injection. |
| "People hold strong views all across the spectrum but we are not debating it here. We are not here to send a message," he said. | "People hold strong views all across the spectrum but we are not debating it here. We are not here to send a message," he said. |
| "Our laws are designed to protect us all within society and particularly to protect the weak." | "Our laws are designed to protect us all within society and particularly to protect the weak." |
| Frances Inglis said she wanted her son to have a painless death | Frances Inglis said she wanted her son to have a painless death |
| He added: "We must make it clear that there is no concept in law of mercy killing. It is still a killing no matter how kind the intention." | He added: "We must make it clear that there is no concept in law of mercy killing. It is still a killing no matter how kind the intention." |
| Judge Barker, the Common Serjeant of London, said there was no doubt Ms Inglis had tried to take her son's life in September 2007 and succeeded using an "identical" method 14 months later. | Judge Barker, the Common Serjeant of London, said there was no doubt Ms Inglis had tried to take her son's life in September 2007 and succeeded using an "identical" method 14 months later. |
| He said it was for the jury to decide whether she had "criminal responsibility for her actions on both occasions". | He said it was for the jury to decide whether she had "criminal responsibility for her actions on both occasions". |
| Mr Inglis suffered severe head injuries when he fell out of an ambulance in July 2007. | Mr Inglis suffered severe head injuries when he fell out of an ambulance in July 2007. |
| Summing up the case, the judge said the background of "tragedy and grief" will have struck a chord with all who had heard it. | Summing up the case, the judge said the background of "tragedy and grief" will have struck a chord with all who had heard it. |
| He said: "It would be extraordinary if we didn't feel empathy with the family and what Mrs Inglis had to face." | He said: "It would be extraordinary if we didn't feel empathy with the family and what Mrs Inglis had to face." |
| After the summing up, the jury was sent out to start their deliberations. |