This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/africa/8497021.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Bennett in e-mail evidence blow | Bennett in e-mail evidence blow |
(2 days later) | |
Lawyers for politician Roy Bennett have failed to stop e-mail evidence they say is bogus from being used against him at his terror trial in Zimbabwe. | Lawyers for politician Roy Bennett have failed to stop e-mail evidence they say is bogus from being used against him at his terror trial in Zimbabwe. |
Prosecutors say the messages prove Mr Bennett had contact with an arms dealer and support their view that he plotted to overthrow President Robert Mugabe. | Prosecutors say the messages prove Mr Bennett had contact with an arms dealer and support their view that he plotted to overthrow President Robert Mugabe. |
Mr Bennett's lawyers say they were not allowed to challenge the messages to show how easy they were to concoct. | Mr Bennett's lawyers say they were not allowed to challenge the messages to show how easy they were to concoct. |
Mr Bennett denies insurgency, banditry, terrorism and several other charges. | Mr Bennett denies insurgency, banditry, terrorism and several other charges. |
He could face the death penalty if convicted. | He could face the death penalty if convicted. |
Mr Bennett is an ally of Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, whose Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) says the trial is politically motivated. | Mr Bennett is an ally of Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, whose Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) says the trial is politically motivated. |
The case has threatened to split the unity government. | The case has threatened to split the unity government. |
Basis of case | Basis of case |
The e-mails are alleged to show contact between Mr Bennett and Peter Hitschmann, a convicted arms dealer. | The e-mails are alleged to show contact between Mr Bennett and Peter Hitschmann, a convicted arms dealer. |
Hitschmann was called as a prosecution witness after implicating Mr Bennett in earlier testimony, but on the stand he said his evidence had been extracted under torture. | Hitschmann was called as a prosecution witness after implicating Mr Bennett in earlier testimony, but on the stand he said his evidence had been extracted under torture. |
ROY BENNETT 2000: Elected MP2004: Jailed after pushing minister in parliament2006: Accused of plot to kill President Mugabe2006: Fled to South Africa2009: Nominated as deputy agriculture minister; arrested Profile: Zimbabwe's political farmer | ROY BENNETT 2000: Elected MP2004: Jailed after pushing minister in parliament2006: Accused of plot to kill President Mugabe2006: Fled to South Africa2009: Nominated as deputy agriculture minister; arrested Profile: Zimbabwe's political farmer |
He denied having any contact with Mr Bennett and said the e-mails were fake. | |
Judge Chinembiri Bhunu said testimony obtained by torture was inadmissible, in a major blow for the prosecution case. | Judge Chinembiri Bhunu said testimony obtained by torture was inadmissible, in a major blow for the prosecution case. |
But on Wednesday the judge ruled that the e-mails could be considered as evidence. | But on Wednesday the judge ruled that the e-mails could be considered as evidence. |
"The e-mails cannot be tainted by the alleged abuse suffered by Hitschmann," Judge Bhunu said. | "The e-mails cannot be tainted by the alleged abuse suffered by Hitschmann," Judge Bhunu said. |
"They are relevant and vital to the fair resolution of the case and are hereby admitted as evidence." | "They are relevant and vital to the fair resolution of the case and are hereby admitted as evidence." |
Attorney General Johannes Tomana said he was happy with the judge's decision. | Attorney General Johannes Tomana said he was happy with the judge's decision. |
"Our link between Hitschmann and the accused person is in the communication between the two of them," he said outside court. | "Our link between Hitschmann and the accused person is in the communication between the two of them," he said outside court. |
"Those e-mails are the basis upon which the state founds the connection between Hitschmann and Bennett." | "Those e-mails are the basis upon which the state founds the connection between Hitschmann and Bennett." |
In challenging the messages, defence lawyer Beatrice Mtetwa produced e-mails she said she had sent in the name of the attorney-general to show how easy they were to fake. | |
Local journalist Brian Hungwe says Mr Tomana then made unspecified threats against Ms Mtetwa. | Local journalist Brian Hungwe says Mr Tomana then made unspecified threats against Ms Mtetwa. |
Outside court, she argued she had been prevented from properly challenging the e-mails. | Outside court, she argued she had been prevented from properly challenging the e-mails. |
"The state is trying to stop us from showing that e-mails can be fake," she said. | "The state is trying to stop us from showing that e-mails can be fake," she said. |
Mr Bennett, treasurer for the MDC, was due to be installed as a deputy minister when he was arrested a year ago. | Mr Bennett, treasurer for the MDC, was due to be installed as a deputy minister when he was arrested a year ago. |
Previous version
1
Next version