This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/8522734.stm
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
'Death tax' best for social care | |
(about 3 hours later) | |
The government is under pressure to back a compulsory fee to pay for social care in England. | |
The Department of Health is currently hosting a meeting of charities, council chiefs and care providers in a bid to achieve a consensus on reforming care. | |
Representatives told the BBC ahead of the summit they wanted to see the levy brought in. | |
The Tories have refused to take part, dubbing the levy a "death tax" and calling for a voluntary scheme instead. | |
The Liberal Democrats are attending the meeting, held at the Department of Health's London HQ, and have said they are open to the idea of a compulsory charge. | |
Opening the talks, Health Secretary Andy Burnham said the issue was bigger than "any single political party". | |
Rows | |
It comes after a fortnight of rows between the parties over the best way to reform the means-tested service. | |
Government "age champion" Dame Joan Bakewell attacked politicians for "political point scoring" on the issue. | Government "age champion" Dame Joan Bakewell attacked politicians for "political point scoring" on the issue. |
Last year, Labour set out a range of options in a Green Paper on how the system could be overhauled. | |
One of the suggestions was a compulsory fee, possibly up to £20,000, which could be taken from an individual's estate after death. | One of the suggestions was a compulsory fee, possibly up to £20,000, which could be taken from an individual's estate after death. |
It is time for a serious debate. We believe a system that involves everyone is the only way to properly fund care Stephen Burke, of Counsel and Care | It is time for a serious debate. We believe a system that involves everyone is the only way to properly fund care Stephen Burke, of Counsel and Care |
The Conservatives vehemently oppose this idea, claiming it would penalise families who want to look after elderly relatives themselves. They favour a voluntary scheme. | The Conservatives vehemently oppose this idea, claiming it would penalise families who want to look after elderly relatives themselves. They favour a voluntary scheme. |
The issue has proved a major sticking point and caused secret talks between the three main parties to break down. | The issue has proved a major sticking point and caused secret talks between the three main parties to break down. |
Health Secretary Andy Burnham called Friday's conference. | |
But shadow health secretary Andrew Lansley told GMTV that these talks were "a Labour Party political ploy". | |
He added: "I will talk to anybody, anytime, anywhere, but I won't take part in a Labour party political smokescreen that stops people making progress and covers up the fact that they are pursuing the option of a compulsory death tax." | He added: "I will talk to anybody, anytime, anywhere, but I won't take part in a Labour party political smokescreen that stops people making progress and covers up the fact that they are pursuing the option of a compulsory death tax." |
In a letter to those taking part in the conference, Mr Burnham acknowledged that there were "pros and cons" to each funding proposal. | In a letter to those taking part in the conference, Mr Burnham acknowledged that there were "pros and cons" to each funding proposal. |
"A voluntary option gives people more choice and control but will not cover everyone," he wrote. | "A voluntary option gives people more choice and control but will not cover everyone," he wrote. |
"A compulsory option provides peace of mind and care free at the point of use when needed, but restricts choice." | "A compulsory option provides peace of mind and care free at the point of use when needed, but restricts choice." |
Consensus | |
Dame Joan Bakewell, the government-appointed Voice of Older People, said no-one should expect to have a new policy "written in stone within a few weeks". | Dame Joan Bakewell, the government-appointed Voice of Older People, said no-one should expect to have a new policy "written in stone within a few weeks". |
She added: "I think it's a very, very big issue indeed and it's going to take time to arrive at a consensus. | She added: "I think it's a very, very big issue indeed and it's going to take time to arrive at a consensus. |
"And this flurry of political point scoring is just getting in the way of it, because really the politicians need to listen more and do less sparring with each other." | "And this flurry of political point scoring is just getting in the way of it, because really the politicians need to listen more and do less sparring with each other." |
We don't need a political bun fight because then it will be put into the 'too difficult box' Association of Directors of Adult Social Services | We don't need a political bun fight because then it will be put into the 'too difficult box' Association of Directors of Adult Social Services |
Representatives told the BBC they will tell Mr Burnham he needs to be clearer about how a national care service would be funded. | |
David Rogers, of the Local Government Association, said: "We need much greater clarity over this. We don't want to see councils left to pick up the bill." | David Rogers, of the Local Government Association, said: "We need much greater clarity over this. We don't want to see councils left to pick up the bill." |
He said local authorities had already had to start restricting access to services because of a lack of funding to cope with the ageing population - three-quarters of councils now only provide help to the most in need. | He said local authorities had already had to start restricting access to services because of a lack of funding to cope with the ageing population - three-quarters of councils now only provide help to the most in need. |
His concerns were backed by an Audit Commission report this week, which said councils were facing a struggle as the £9bn-a-year bill for older people could double by 2026. | His concerns were backed by an Audit Commission report this week, which said councils were facing a struggle as the £9bn-a-year bill for older people could double by 2026. |
Mr Rogers said the LGA did not have a position on which of the models for reform it preferred - this reflects the fact the group has cross-party membership. | Mr Rogers said the LGA did not have a position on which of the models for reform it preferred - this reflects the fact the group has cross-party membership. |
But others attending the conference said they were backing a compulsory charge. | |
Stephen Burke, of Counsel and Care, a charity for the elderly, said: "It is time for a serious debate. We believe a system that involves everyone is the only way to properly fund care." | Stephen Burke, of Counsel and Care, a charity for the elderly, said: "It is time for a serious debate. We believe a system that involves everyone is the only way to properly fund care." |
The Association of Directors of Adult Social Services also said a compulsory charge was the best way to get the most funding. | |
Its president, Jenny Owen, said: "The problem with a voluntary scheme is that too many people opt out. | Its president, Jenny Owen, said: "The problem with a voluntary scheme is that too many people opt out. |
"We now need to get consensus. We don't need a political bun fight because then it will be put into the 'too difficult box'." | "We now need to get consensus. We don't need a political bun fight because then it will be put into the 'too difficult box'." |
The government is hoping to publish its preferred plan in a White Paper in March. | |
Are you affected by the issues raised in this story? Tell us your experiences using the form below. | Are you affected by the issues raised in this story? Tell us your experiences using the form below. |
A selection of your comments may be published, displaying your name and location unless you state otherwise in the box below. | A selection of your comments may be published, displaying your name and location unless you state otherwise in the box below. |
The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide. Terms & Conditions | The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide. Terms & Conditions |