This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/Http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/8550779.stm
The article has changed 13 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Iraq war was 'right', says Brown | Iraq war was 'right', says Brown |
| (10 minutes later) | |
| Prime Minister Gordon Brown has said the 2003 war was "right", as he gives evidence to the UK's Iraq inquiry. | Prime Minister Gordon Brown has said the 2003 war was "right", as he gives evidence to the UK's Iraq inquiry. |
| He insisted he had not been kept in the dark by his predecessor Tony Blair and was fully "in line" with the invasion. | He insisted he had not been kept in the dark by his predecessor Tony Blair and was fully "in line" with the invasion. |
| His own intelligence briefings had convinced him that Iraq was a threat that "had to be dealt with", he said. | His own intelligence briefings had convinced him that Iraq was a threat that "had to be dealt with", he said. |
| But the main issue for him was that Iraq was in breach of UN resolutions - and that "rogue states" could not be allowed to flout international law. | But the main issue for him was that Iraq was in breach of UN resolutions - and that "rogue states" could not be allowed to flout international law. |
| If the international community could not act together over Iraq, Mr Brown said, he feared the "new world order we were trying to create would be put at risk". | If the international community could not act together over Iraq, Mr Brown said, he feared the "new world order we were trying to create would be put at risk". |
| 'Diplomatic route' | 'Diplomatic route' |
| Mr Brown, who was chancellor at the time of the war, is giving evidence weeks ahead of the UK general election, which is expected to be held in early May. | Mr Brown, who was chancellor at the time of the war, is giving evidence weeks ahead of the UK general election, which is expected to be held in early May. |
| THE STORY SO FAR He may have been writing the cheques as chancellor, but Gordon Brown remained largely silent in the run-up to the 2003 Iraq warHe was thought by some to be sceptical about it. Others thought he was hedging his bets ahead of a leadership bidAfter becoming PM, he set up the Iraq inquiry to "learn lessons" from the war, although he originally wanted it held in secret and the timing ensured it would not report until after the electionEx-military leaders have given evidence at the inquiry suggesting Mr Brown kept defence spending tight during his 10 years at the Treasury with some suggesting this had a knock-on effect on forces' kitMr Brown has denied this and will want to counter any impression, as put by David Cameron, that he did not see the military as a priority until he was PM and it became politically convenient LIVE: Video and text commentary Q&A: Iraq war inquiry Iraq inquiry: Day-by-day timeline | THE STORY SO FAR He may have been writing the cheques as chancellor, but Gordon Brown remained largely silent in the run-up to the 2003 Iraq warHe was thought by some to be sceptical about it. Others thought he was hedging his bets ahead of a leadership bidAfter becoming PM, he set up the Iraq inquiry to "learn lessons" from the war, although he originally wanted it held in secret and the timing ensured it would not report until after the electionEx-military leaders have given evidence at the inquiry suggesting Mr Brown kept defence spending tight during his 10 years at the Treasury with some suggesting this had a knock-on effect on forces' kitMr Brown has denied this and will want to counter any impression, as put by David Cameron, that he did not see the military as a priority until he was PM and it became politically convenient LIVE: Video and text commentary Q&A: Iraq war inquiry Iraq inquiry: Day-by-day timeline |
| He began the session by paying tribute to the "sacrifice" made by British servicemen and women, but he added: "I think it was the right decision and made for the right reasons." | He began the session by paying tribute to the "sacrifice" made by British servicemen and women, but he added: "I think it was the right decision and made for the right reasons." |
| Mr Brown acknowledged that there were "important lessons" to be learned from the way Iraq descended into chaos following the invasion. | Mr Brown acknowledged that there were "important lessons" to be learned from the way Iraq descended into chaos following the invasion. |
| "It was one of my regrets that I wasn't able to be more successful in pushing the Americans on this issue - that the planning for reconstruction was essential, just the same as planning for the war," he said. | "It was one of my regrets that I wasn't able to be more successful in pushing the Americans on this issue - that the planning for reconstruction was essential, just the same as planning for the war," he said. |
| And he added: "There will be other states, rogue states, that need to change and we need to ensure civilian support as well as military support to do what's necessary when a broken state has to be rebuilt." | And he added: "There will be other states, rogue states, that need to change and we need to ensure civilian support as well as military support to do what's necessary when a broken state has to be rebuilt." |
| He also stressed that he had always believed in an international effort to rebuild Iraq and create a "just peace" for its citizens, adding: "I never subscribed to what you might call the neo-Conservative position that somehow, at the barrel of a gun, overnight, liberty and democracy could be conjured up." | He also stressed that he had always believed in an international effort to rebuild Iraq and create a "just peace" for its citizens, adding: "I never subscribed to what you might call the neo-Conservative position that somehow, at the barrel of a gun, overnight, liberty and democracy could be conjured up." |
| Setting out his thinking on the rationale for war for the first time in public, Mr Brown said terrorists and "rogue states" were the "two risks to the post-Cold War world" and had to be tackled. | Setting out his thinking on the rationale for war for the first time in public, Mr Brown said terrorists and "rogue states" were the "two risks to the post-Cold War world" and had to be tackled. |
| FROM BBC RADIO 5 LIVE More from BBC Radio 5 live | FROM BBC RADIO 5 LIVE More from BBC Radio 5 live |
| He said he had met the intelligence service five times during 2002 and early 2003 and was given information "which led me to believe that Iraq was a threat that had to be dealt with by the actions of the international community." | He said he had met the intelligence service five times during 2002 and early 2003 and was given information "which led me to believe that Iraq was a threat that had to be dealt with by the actions of the international community." |
| But he added: "Right up to the last minute, right up to the last weekend, I think many of us were hopeful that the diplomatic route would succeed." | But he added: "Right up to the last minute, right up to the last weekend, I think many of us were hopeful that the diplomatic route would succeed." |
| Equipment | Equipment |
| Mr Brown said he had largely restricted his involvement in the run up to war to financial matters, and he had assured Tony Blair at an early stage that he would not try to block military options "on the grounds of cost". | Mr Brown said he had largely restricted his involvement in the run up to war to financial matters, and he had assured Tony Blair at an early stage that he would not try to block military options "on the grounds of cost". |
| CORRESPONDENT'S VIEW From political editor, Nick Robinson | CORRESPONDENT'S VIEW From political editor, Nick Robinson |
| Heavily prepared. Heavily made-up. Gordon Brown was so eager to make his defence that he strode into the Iraq Inquiry before the committee itself had settled comfortably in their seats. | Heavily prepared. Heavily made-up. Gordon Brown was so eager to make his defence that he strode into the Iraq Inquiry before the committee itself had settled comfortably in their seats. |
| Again and again he spelt out his explanation of his own role, often ignoring questions to the evident frustration of those asking. | Again and again he spelt out his explanation of his own role, often ignoring questions to the evident frustration of those asking. |
| It was like watching a skilful chess player who had a defensive move prepared for every possible attack. Yes, Iraq had been the right decision for the right reasons but of course he had regrets. | It was like watching a skilful chess player who had a defensive move prepared for every possible attack. Yes, Iraq had been the right decision for the right reasons but of course he had regrets. |
| As for those missing weapons of mass destruction he had believed the information he had been given by the intelligence services . | As for those missing weapons of mass destruction he had believed the information he had been given by the intelligence services . |
| Financially, he had given the armed forces everything they could have wanted and whatsmore he wished he had managed to persuade the Americans to take reconstruction more seriously. | Financially, he had given the armed forces everything they could have wanted and whatsmore he wished he had managed to persuade the Americans to take reconstruction more seriously. |
| It was only when Sir Roderic Lyne, the skilful former diplomat, pushed him on whether he had been told by Tony Blair what the then prime minister had told President Bush did Gordon Brown stumble. | It was only when Sir Roderic Lyne, the skilful former diplomat, pushed him on whether he had been told by Tony Blair what the then prime minister had told President Bush did Gordon Brown stumble. |
| Once again he avoided the question, so blatantly that this time the audience broke into laughter. Yet throughout this morning Gordon Brown will feel he has not made a mistake. | Once again he avoided the question, so blatantly that this time the audience broke into laughter. Yet throughout this morning Gordon Brown will feel he has not made a mistake. |
| The big problem for him may come when the issue turns to money and the decisions around the Ministry of Defence budget which caused problems not so much in Iraq but later in Afghanistan. Read Nick's thoughts in full | The big problem for him may come when the issue turns to money and the decisions around the Ministry of Defence budget which caused problems not so much in Iraq but later in Afghanistan. Read Nick's thoughts in full |
| And he insisted UK forces had been given all the equipment they had asked for - in response to earlier evidence from ex-military leaders who told the inquiry spending had been squeezed. | And he insisted UK forces had been given all the equipment they had asked for - in response to earlier evidence from ex-military leaders who told the inquiry spending had been squeezed. |
| "At any point, commanders were able to ask for equipment that they needed and I know of no occasion when they were turned down," he told the panel. | "At any point, commanders were able to ask for equipment that they needed and I know of no occasion when they were turned down," he told the panel. |
| He said the total cost to the UK of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan had been £18bn, in addition to a "rising" defence budget, which he admitted was a "sizeable sum of money" which had "made my life more difficult" as chancellor. | He said the total cost to the UK of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan had been £18bn, in addition to a "rising" defence budget, which he admitted was a "sizeable sum of money" which had "made my life more difficult" as chancellor. |
| But he said the government had been able to meet the costs from reserves without making cuts elsewhere and it had ultimately been "manageable". | But he said the government had been able to meet the costs from reserves without making cuts elsewhere and it had ultimately been "manageable". |
| Panel member Lawrence Freedman challenged Mr Brown over funding for armed forces equipment - particularly Snatch Land Rovers, an issue he said had been raised by the families of soldiers killed in Iraq. | Panel member Lawrence Freedman challenged Mr Brown over funding for armed forces equipment - particularly Snatch Land Rovers, an issue he said had been raised by the families of soldiers killed in Iraq. |
| Mr Brown said Bulldog and Mastiff vehicles had been supplied to troops at a cost of £90m as soon as their commanders on the ground had asked for them, with the first of them arriving in Iraq "within six months". | Mr Brown said Bulldog and Mastiff vehicles had been supplied to troops at a cost of £90m as soon as their commanders on the ground had asked for them, with the first of them arriving in Iraq "within six months". |
| Mr Brown praised Tony Blair's handling of the diplomatic negotiations: "Everything Mr Blair did he did properly and I was kept fully informed about the information that I needed to make my decisions." | Mr Brown praised Tony Blair's handling of the diplomatic negotiations: "Everything Mr Blair did he did properly and I was kept fully informed about the information that I needed to make my decisions." |
| But he said he had largely restricted his involvement to financial matters, telling the inquiry: "My role in this was not to interfere in what were very important diplomatic negotiations." | But he said he had largely restricted his involvement to financial matters, telling the inquiry: "My role in this was not to interfere in what were very important diplomatic negotiations." |
| He said he had not seen letters sent by Tony Blair to US President George W Bush - and had not been aware that Attorney General Lord Goldsmith had changed his opinion on the legality of the war. | He said he had not seen letters sent by Tony Blair to US President George W Bush - and had not been aware that Attorney General Lord Goldsmith had changed his opinion on the legality of the war. |
| Asked whether he knew what Mr Blair had said to Mr Bush at a private meeting at the US president's Texas ranch in 2002, at which some inquiry witnesses have suggested Mr Blair committed Britain to war, he said: "I didn't know the exact conversation and you wouldn't expect me to." | Asked whether he knew what Mr Blair had said to Mr Bush at a private meeting at the US president's Texas ranch in 2002, at which some inquiry witnesses have suggested Mr Blair committed Britain to war, he said: "I didn't know the exact conversation and you wouldn't expect me to." |
| But he said the "decision making structures" at the top of the British government in the run up to war had been too informal and both he and Tony Blair had since taken steps to rectify this. | But he said the "decision making structures" at the top of the British government in the run up to war had been too informal and both he and Tony Blair had since taken steps to rectify this. |
| LAURA KUENSSBERG ON TWITTER | LAURA KUENSSBERG ON TWITTER |
| Twitter: @LauraK | Twitter: @LauraK |
| BBC Brown looks rather relieved on his way out after a long closing tribute to British troops - has already left the inquiry 20 minutes agoBBC Brown ends with tribute to armed forces and admission that decision to go to war was difficult and divisive, but right in his view 25 minutes agoBBC Life in Iraq better now but the loss of life, particularly after Saddam was toppled in initial phase, 'makes me very very sad' says Brown 26 minutes agoBBC Last two questions to Brown now - Chilcot wants to know if UK has yet learnt how to help create proper police forces in places like Iraq 32 minutes agoBBC Brown says effort in Iraq did not suffer because of increasing commitments in Afghanistan but fighting 2 wars, 'particularly stretching' 53 minutes ago | |
| Former Liberal Democrat leader Sir Menzies Campbell said it was clear from Mr Brown's evidence that he had had been kept in the dark by Mr Blair about key aspects of the build up to war. | Former Liberal Democrat leader Sir Menzies Campbell said it was clear from Mr Brown's evidence that he had had been kept in the dark by Mr Blair about key aspects of the build up to war. |
| He told the BBC News channel that as "the most senior member of the cabinet" after Mr Blair, Mr Brown should have asked more questions about the wider political implications of the conflict. | He told the BBC News channel that as "the most senior member of the cabinet" after Mr Blair, Mr Brown should have asked more questions about the wider political implications of the conflict. |
| Unlike Tony Blair when he appeared in January, Mr Brown entered the Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre, where the inquiry is being held, by the front entrance. | Unlike Tony Blair when he appeared in January, Mr Brown entered the Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre, where the inquiry is being held, by the front entrance. |
| Only a small knot of protesters had gathered to mark his arrival. | Only a small knot of protesters had gathered to mark his arrival. |
| Mr Brown is expected to have a private meeting with family members of some of those killed in the conflict at some point during the day. | Mr Brown is expected to have a private meeting with family members of some of those killed in the conflict at some point during the day. |
| Only one family who lost a relative in Iraq has applied for seats at Mr Brown's hearing - 40 seats were reserved for families over the course of Mr Blair's day-long session. | Only one family who lost a relative in Iraq has applied for seats at Mr Brown's hearing - 40 seats were reserved for families over the course of Mr Blair's day-long session. |
| Mr Blair gave evidence to the inquiry in January. | Mr Blair gave evidence to the inquiry in January. |
| He said he had "no regrets" about removing Saddam Hussein from power and insisted the Iraq war had made the world a safer place. | He said he had "no regrets" about removing Saddam Hussein from power and insisted the Iraq war had made the world a safer place. |
| The inquiry is examining events from 2001 to 2009, including the decision to go to war, whether troops were properly prepared, the conflict and what planning there was for its aftermath. | The inquiry is examining events from 2001 to 2009, including the decision to go to war, whether troops were properly prepared, the conflict and what planning there was for its aftermath. |
| Are you watching the inquiry? What is your reaction? | Are you watching the inquiry? What is your reaction? |
| Send your comments using the post form below. | Send your comments using the post form below. |
| A selection of your comments may be published, displaying your name and location unless you state otherwise in the box below. | A selection of your comments may be published, displaying your name and location unless you state otherwise in the box below. |
| The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide. Terms & Conditions | The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide. Terms & Conditions |