This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/scotland/6480631.stm

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Prisoner demands 'right to vote' Prisoner demands 'right to vote'
(about 16 hours later)
A prisoner has urged a court to allow him to cast a vote in the Scottish elections on 3 May.A prisoner has urged a court to allow him to cast a vote in the Scottish elections on 3 May.
Lawyers for Donald Birrell claimed his human rights were being breached by legislation which barrs those in prison from voting. Lawyers for Donald Birrell claimed his human rights were being breached by legislation which bans those in prison from voting.
Birrell is one of three Scots prisoners bringing legal action ahead of the parliamentary and council elections.Birrell is one of three Scots prisoners bringing legal action ahead of the parliamentary and council elections.
Earlier this week, Scotland Office Minister David Cairns vowed that the elections would go ahead.Earlier this week, Scotland Office Minister David Cairns vowed that the elections would go ahead.
He added that any effort to cancel them would be challenged.He added that any effort to cancel them would be challenged.
Separate cases are being brought by the other two inmates, Derek Traynor and James Fisher.Separate cases are being brought by the other two inmates, Derek Traynor and James Fisher.
They hope to halt the elections altogether if they are successful.They hope to halt the elections altogether if they are successful.
The moves follow a ruling in January by Court of Session judges that a blanket ban on prisoners voting was not compliant with the European Convention on Human Rights.The moves follow a ruling in January by Court of Session judges that a blanket ban on prisoners voting was not compliant with the European Convention on Human Rights.
This is not a try-on or some kind of clever lawyers' attempt to get somebody out of jail free Aidan O'Neill QCThis is not a try-on or some kind of clever lawyers' attempt to get somebody out of jail free Aidan O'Neill QC
The Court of Session in Edinburgh has now heard that Birrell was let out on licence in May last year but is now back in jail after the licence was revoked last month.The Court of Session in Edinburgh has now heard that Birrell was let out on licence in May last year but is now back in jail after the licence was revoked last month.
His lawyers said some prisoners on remand awaiting trial do have the right to a postal vote and this would have been the case for their client if he had still been out on licence.His lawyers said some prisoners on remand awaiting trial do have the right to a postal vote and this would have been the case for their client if he had still been out on licence.
They are asking for the recall to be quashed so that Birrell has the right to vote.They are asking for the recall to be quashed so that Birrell has the right to vote.
UK legislation prevents convicted prisoners from voting, but in 2005 the European Court of Human Rights ruled that such a blanket ban was a breach of human rights. UK legislation prevents convicted prisoners from voting, but in 2005 the European Court on Human Rights ruled that such a blanket ban was a breach of human rights.
Aidan O'Neill QC, representing Birrell, criticised the authorities for failing to act in time to prevent such a situation arising.Aidan O'Neill QC, representing Birrell, criticised the authorities for failing to act in time to prevent such a situation arising.
"This is not a try-on or some kind of clever lawyers' attempt to get somebody out of jail free," he said."This is not a try-on or some kind of clever lawyers' attempt to get somebody out of jail free," he said.
"This is bringing to the court the legal consequences of a political decision to go ahead with an election which unlawfully stops prisoners from voting.""This is bringing to the court the legal consequences of a political decision to go ahead with an election which unlawfully stops prisoners from voting."
Birrell, who was not present in court for the hearing, is also seeking £1,000 damages if the election goes ahead and he is not allowed to go to the polls.Birrell, who was not present in court for the hearing, is also seeking £1,000 damages if the election goes ahead and he is not allowed to go to the polls.
Judge Lord Clarke will issue his decision on Friday.Judge Lord Clarke will issue his decision on Friday.