This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/us_and_canada/10254279.stm
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Utah counts down to firing squad execution | Utah counts down to firing squad execution |
| (40 minutes later) | |
| By Kathryn Westcott BBC News | By Kathryn Westcott BBC News |
| Barring a last-minute stay of execution, five anonymous marksmen bearing rifles will take their places late on Thursday in a prison room to carry out the request of death-row inmate Ronnie Lee Gardner: execution by firing squad. | Barring a last-minute stay of execution, five anonymous marksmen bearing rifles will take their places late on Thursday in a prison room to carry out the request of death-row inmate Ronnie Lee Gardner: execution by firing squad. |
| Ronnie Lee Gardner has been on death row since 1985 | Ronnie Lee Gardner has been on death row since 1985 |
| Gardner won't see the law enforcement officers who have volunteered to carry out the death sentence. He will be bathed in light, they will be hidden in darkness some 20 feet away, probably behind a screen containing narrow slots for the guns. | Gardner won't see the law enforcement officers who have volunteered to carry out the death sentence. He will be bathed in light, they will be hidden in darkness some 20 feet away, probably behind a screen containing narrow slots for the guns. |
| A target will be placed over his heart, a hood over his head. And the men, who are likely to have practised together for accuracy, will respond to the command: "Ready, aim..." | A target will be placed over his heart, a hood over his head. And the men, who are likely to have practised together for accuracy, will respond to the command: "Ready, aim..." |
| None, however, will ever be certain whether they fired a lethal shot. One gun will have been loaded with a dummy - probably wax - bullet, which is said to deliver the same recoil as a live round. | None, however, will ever be certain whether they fired a lethal shot. One gun will have been loaded with a dummy - probably wax - bullet, which is said to deliver the same recoil as a live round. |
| Gardner, 49, was sentenced to death in 1985, after fatally shooting lawyer Michael Burdell and severely wounding a bailiff Nick Kirk in an escape attempt from court. At the time, he was facing a murder charge in the case of the shooting of bartender Melvyn Otterstrom. | Gardner, 49, was sentenced to death in 1985, after fatally shooting lawyer Michael Burdell and severely wounding a bailiff Nick Kirk in an escape attempt from court. At the time, he was facing a murder charge in the case of the shooting of bartender Melvyn Otterstrom. |
| Violent prisoner | Violent prisoner |
| Although death by firing squad has been outlawed in Utah since 2004, the law does not apply to those convicted before that date, so Gardner was allowed to choose it as the method of his execution. | Although death by firing squad has been outlawed in Utah since 2004, the law does not apply to those convicted before that date, so Gardner was allowed to choose it as the method of his execution. |
| Gary DeLand, executive director of Utah's corrections agency from 1985 to 1992, knew Gardner during the early years of his imprisonment. He says he was not surprised by this request. | Gary DeLand, executive director of Utah's corrections agency from 1985 to 1992, knew Gardner during the early years of his imprisonment. He says he was not surprised by this request. |
| The execution chair used by John Albert Taylor | The execution chair used by John Albert Taylor |
| "He was a particularly violent man. He was kept away from other inmates. He was the kind of person who would harm others for the sport of it, and enjoyed causing trouble. | "He was a particularly violent man. He was kept away from other inmates. He was the kind of person who would harm others for the sport of it, and enjoyed causing trouble. |
| "We don't know why Gardner chose this method but one prisoner who had chosen the firing squad basically said if he was going to die, he wanted someone to have to clean up the mess." | "We don't know why Gardner chose this method but one prisoner who had chosen the firing squad basically said if he was going to die, he wanted someone to have to clean up the mess." |
| Executions by firing squad are rare in the US - only two people have been put to death this way since 1977. There is no set procedure, but details of those executions hint at what lies ahead for Gardner and those who have volunteered to help deliver the ultimate punishment. | Executions by firing squad are rare in the US - only two people have been put to death this way since 1977. There is no set procedure, but details of those executions hint at what lies ahead for Gardner and those who have volunteered to help deliver the ultimate punishment. |
| Mr DeLand, who oversaw executions by lethal injection and planned one execution by firing squad (which had to be abandoned at the last minute) wrote a prison manual in 1986 setting out a plan. | Mr DeLand, who oversaw executions by lethal injection and planned one execution by firing squad (which had to be abandoned at the last minute) wrote a prison manual in 1986 setting out a plan. |
| "I have been told the manual is still at the Utah prison and has been dusted down," he says. | "I have been told the manual is still at the Utah prison and has been dusted down," he says. |
| Suicide watch | Suicide watch |
| According to Mr DeLand's proposal, Gardner would have been taken to a holding cell 24-48 hours ahead of execution. There a prisoner is watched continually by rotating teams of prison staff, to ensure he doesn't try to take his own life. | According to Mr DeLand's proposal, Gardner would have been taken to a holding cell 24-48 hours ahead of execution. There a prisoner is watched continually by rotating teams of prison staff, to ensure he doesn't try to take his own life. |
| "That's why we called it the 'Death Watch cell'," he says. | "That's why we called it the 'Death Watch cell'," he says. |
| Only a few people will be allowed to enter - lawyers, for example, working until the last minute to secure a stay of execution. | Only a few people will be allowed to enter - lawyers, for example, working until the last minute to secure a stay of execution. |
| The identities of the marksmen - local law enforcement officers who have volunteered their services - will be protected forever. | The identities of the marksmen - local law enforcement officers who have volunteered their services - will be protected forever. |
| "They will probably have practised for some time in the chamber to ensure they fire in unison. We want to hear one single noise - not, bang, bang, bang, bang, bang," says Mr DeLand. There is likely to be a standby executioner in case one loses his nerve. | "They will probably have practised for some time in the chamber to ensure they fire in unison. We want to hear one single noise - not, bang, bang, bang, bang, bang," says Mr DeLand. There is likely to be a standby executioner in case one loses his nerve. |
| The marksmen, along with members of staff who contributed to the planning of the execution, will be given a commemorative Gardner coin. | The marksmen, along with members of staff who contributed to the planning of the execution, will be given a commemorative Gardner coin. |
| It was Mr DeLand who introduced the tradition of handing out commemorative badges for "service beyond their ordinary daily duties". Apparently, this time, staff preferred something "a bit more modern". | It was Mr DeLand who introduced the tradition of handing out commemorative badges for "service beyond their ordinary daily duties". Apparently, this time, staff preferred something "a bit more modern". |
| Throwback to earlier time | Throwback to earlier time |
| His case has attracted much national and international interest because the method has been vilified by many as an anachronistic form of Wild West-style justice. | His case has attracted much national and international interest because the method has been vilified by many as an anachronistic form of Wild West-style justice. |
| According to the Death Pentalty Information Centre, the Supreme Court gave Utah permission to use the firing squad as a method of execution in 1879. | According to the Death Pentalty Information Centre, the Supreme Court gave Utah permission to use the firing squad as a method of execution in 1879. |
| "This is clearly a throwback to an earlier time, and people wonder, how can we still be doing that?" Richard Dieter, executive director of the centre, told CBS news recently. | "This is clearly a throwback to an earlier time, and people wonder, how can we still be doing that?" Richard Dieter, executive director of the centre, told CBS news recently. |
| The last person to have been executed by firing squad was John Albert Taylor in 1996, who said he chose the method to embarrass the state. | The last person to have been executed by firing squad was John Albert Taylor in 1996, who said he chose the method to embarrass the state. |
| But Gary DeLand says he doesn't know why execution by firing squad generates so much interest. "An execution is an execution," he said. "I guess it's just morbid curiosity." | But Gary DeLand says he doesn't know why execution by firing squad generates so much interest. "An execution is an execution," he said. "I guess it's just morbid curiosity." |
| Michael Burdell's family say he would not have wanted the death penalty | |
| The families of Gardner's victims are divided over the execution. | The families of Gardner's victims are divided over the execution. |
| Nick Kirk's widow VelDean has said the execution will come as a relief, and plans to be a witness on Thursday. | |
| Family and friends of Michael Burdell have been quoted as saying that the execution would simply be a victory for the violence that the lawyer sought to curb. Donna Nu, his fiance at the time, told the BBC World Service in April that we should have "gone past eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth". | |
| Asked about Gardner's method of execution, she said he may have chosen it, "partially to make the point how barbaric it is. Firing squad makes it more real what's happening than lethal injection does." | Asked about Gardner's method of execution, she said he may have chosen it, "partially to make the point how barbaric it is. Firing squad makes it more real what's happening than lethal injection does." |
| Historians say the method stems from 19th Century doctrine of the state's predominant Mormon religion. | Historians say the method stems from 19th Century doctrine of the state's predominant Mormon religion. |
| In a recent article in the Salt Lake Tribune, journalist Peggy Fletcher Stack traces the history of the firing squad in the state and reports that according to some people in Utah, one reason why the execution technique remained an option was because of the notion of "blood atonement." | In a recent article in the Salt Lake Tribune, journalist Peggy Fletcher Stack traces the history of the firing squad in the state and reports that according to some people in Utah, one reason why the execution technique remained an option was because of the notion of "blood atonement." |
| She explains that the term refers to an "arcane LDS (Mormon Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) belief that a murderer must shed his own blood - literally - to be forgiven by God." | She explains that the term refers to an "arcane LDS (Mormon Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) belief that a murderer must shed his own blood - literally - to be forgiven by God." |
| The Church now offers no opinion on the use of the firing squad. | |
| Prison officials have said that counsellors will be on hand to talk to members of staff, should they need it, after Gardner's execution. Few will have experienced what those five men will go through. | |
| But unnamed officers who took part in the last execution by firing squad this week described their experiences to the Salt Lake Tribune. | But unnamed officers who took part in the last execution by firing squad this week described their experiences to the Salt Lake Tribune. |
| One described it as an "assignment, nothing more than getting an order to do something like kicking in a door to serve a warrant". | |
| Another likened John Albert Taylor's execution to "returning a defective product to the manufacturer". And one said he "had issues about shooting a guy strapped in a seat, helpless. But the state had ordered us to do this and we had a job to do. I don't regret doing it, but I would never do it again." | Another likened John Albert Taylor's execution to "returning a defective product to the manufacturer". And one said he "had issues about shooting a guy strapped in a seat, helpless. But the state had ordered us to do this and we had a job to do. I don't regret doing it, but I would never do it again." |