This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/magazine/6567961.stm
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Just say... what? | Just say... what? |
| (10 minutes later) | |
| By Tom Geoghegan BBC News Magazine More than two decades of anti-drugs campaigns have been largely fruitless in preventing drug use among young people, says a report. With teenage rebellion as it is, are such campaigns doomed to fail? | |
| First it was Zammo, now it's Frank. | First it was Zammo, now it's Frank. |
| Twenty years after the Grange Hill pupil told its young BBC audience to "Just Say No" to drugs, young people are being told to "Talk to Frank", a figurative friend who offers advice and information. | |
| A report to the UK Drugs Policy Commission, which was launched on Wednesday, says there is little evidence such campaigns reduce rates of drug use. | A report to the UK Drugs Policy Commission, which was launched on Wednesday, says there is little evidence such campaigns reduce rates of drug use. |
| Dummy (1985) Talk to Frank (2003) | Dummy (1985) Talk to Frank (2003) |
| Getting a moral message across to young people is notoriously difficult. George Bush's US administration has spent more than $1bn promoting sexual abstinence, but research this week suggested it had had no effect. | Getting a moral message across to young people is notoriously difficult. George Bush's US administration has spent more than $1bn promoting sexual abstinence, but research this week suggested it had had no effect. |
| On the other hand, the famous gravestone Aids adverts were credited with reducing HIV infections in the UK 20 years ago. | On the other hand, the famous gravestone Aids adverts were credited with reducing HIV infections in the UK 20 years ago. |
| So after two decades of trying almost everything, how can any anti-drugs campaigns succeed? | So after two decades of trying almost everything, how can any anti-drugs campaigns succeed? |
| With difficulty, says Neil Hunt, director of KCA - a drug and alcohol service provider. He thinks money is better spent on so-called secondary prevention, targeting vulnerable groups like young offenders and children in care. | With difficulty, says Neil Hunt, director of KCA - a drug and alcohol service provider. He thinks money is better spent on so-called secondary prevention, targeting vulnerable groups like young offenders and children in care. |
| "However much societies would like to have them, campaigns and programmes of this sort, which hope to prevent drug use in the first place, are surrounded by unrealistic expectations and will not deliver this to any significant extent. | "However much societies would like to have them, campaigns and programmes of this sort, which hope to prevent drug use in the first place, are surrounded by unrealistic expectations and will not deliver this to any significant extent. |
| "Patterns of drug consumption are too embedded and youth culture and peer influences have a far greater effect that is just not amenable to central initiatives like these." | "Patterns of drug consumption are too embedded and youth culture and peer influences have a far greater effect that is just not amenable to central initiatives like these." |
| The medium can be as important as the content, says Dan Clays, managing director at digital media specialist BLM Quantum. | The medium can be as important as the content, says Dan Clays, managing director at digital media specialist BLM Quantum. |
| "Distribution on social networking sites and consumer-generated content would have more impact because youth media consumption is so fragmented and traditional channels are dwarfed by digital media. | "Distribution on social networking sites and consumer-generated content would have more impact because youth media consumption is so fragmented and traditional channels are dwarfed by digital media. |
| 'Alarmist' | 'Alarmist' |
| "Today's youth are more enfranchised and have more control than ever over the media and advertising they receive, so where the message is placed must reflect this to have any recognition." | "Today's youth are more enfranchised and have more control than ever over the media and advertising they receive, so where the message is placed must reflect this to have any recognition." |
| The message itself has changed since the first campaign in 1985, a year before Zammo's habit made national headlines. | The message itself has changed since the first campaign in 1985, a year before Zammo's habit made national headlines. |
| The slogan of the series of short films was Heroin Screws You Up, although evidence suggested it led to some glamorisation of addiction and the "heroin chic" fashion style. | The slogan of the series of short films was Heroin Screws You Up, although evidence suggested it led to some glamorisation of addiction and the "heroin chic" fashion style. |
| ARE YOUNGSTERS SAYING 'NO'? 11-15 years: In 12 months to September 2005, drug use fell from 19% to 11%. 16-24 years: Between 1998 and 2005, drug use fell from 32% to 26% Sources: Stats on Young People and Drugs Misuse 2006, British Crime Survey 2005-06 | ARE YOUNGSTERS SAYING 'NO'? 11-15 years: In 12 months to September 2005, drug use fell from 19% to 11%. 16-24 years: Between 1998 and 2005, drug use fell from 32% to 26% Sources: Stats on Young People and Drugs Misuse 2006, British Crime Survey 2005-06 |
| A similar tone was used throughout the 80s and 90s, which was a time of rocketing drug use among young people. | A similar tone was used throughout the 80s and 90s, which was a time of rocketing drug use among young people. |
| Ecstasy was linked to the death in 1995 of Leah Betts, who collapsed at her 18th birthday party and the image of her on a life-support machine was used in a subsequent poster campaign entitled Sorted. | Ecstasy was linked to the death in 1995 of Leah Betts, who collapsed at her 18th birthday party and the image of her on a life-support machine was used in a subsequent poster campaign entitled Sorted. |
| But the Talk to Frank campaigns launched in 2003 marked a significant change in emphasis. A narrator, speaking in a conversational way, directs viewers to a website and telephone line - an information and advice service called Frank. | But the Talk to Frank campaigns launched in 2003 marked a significant change in emphasis. A narrator, speaking in a conversational way, directs viewers to a website and telephone line - an information and advice service called Frank. |
| Moving story | Moving story |
| While the potential risks of drugs like crystal meth and cannabis are spelled out, there is acknowledgement that some drugs can have a benign effect, like ecstasy making people hug each other. Appearing on television, online and even in a Hollyoaks storyline, the cost so far is £24m. | While the potential risks of drugs like crystal meth and cannabis are spelled out, there is acknowledgement that some drugs can have a benign effect, like ecstasy making people hug each other. Appearing on television, online and even in a Hollyoaks storyline, the cost so far is £24m. |
| Explaining the shift in strategy, a Home Office spokesman says: "We moved on from 'Just Say No' to empowering people with information - for example, if you take crystal meth, this is what happens to your teeth - so they can make informed and educated choices. | Explaining the shift in strategy, a Home Office spokesman says: "We moved on from 'Just Say No' to empowering people with information - for example, if you take crystal meth, this is what happens to your teeth - so they can make informed and educated choices. |
| It's not as if we're spending all this money on glitzy adverts and nothing else Home Office spokesman "The good news is that drug use has fallen by a fifth among 16 to 24-year-olds over the last 10 years. | It's not as if we're spending all this money on glitzy adverts and nothing else Home Office spokesman "The good news is that drug use has fallen by a fifth among 16 to 24-year-olds over the last 10 years. |
| "There are also record numbers of people undergoing treatment so it's not as if we're spending all this money on glitzy adverts and nothing else. We've spent £7.5bn on drugs policy since 1998." | "There are also record numbers of people undergoing treatment so it's not as if we're spending all this money on glitzy adverts and nothing else. We've spent £7.5bn on drugs policy since 1998." |
| It's difficult to judge the impact of Frank, says Martin Barnes, chief executive of DrugScope, but he thinks giving people credible information was a welcome change in direction. | It's difficult to judge the impact of Frank, says Martin Barnes, chief executive of DrugScope, but he thinks giving people credible information was a welcome change in direction. |
| 'Anguish' | 'Anguish' |
| "Teenage drug use increased so much in the 90s and 80s that alarmist campaigns like Just Say No lost credibility because young people knew drug users who were not coming to harm. So rather than look at the risks, they thought 'what I'm being told is nonsense because one smoke of cannabis doesn't kill you.'" | "Teenage drug use increased so much in the 90s and 80s that alarmist campaigns like Just Say No lost credibility because young people knew drug users who were not coming to harm. So rather than look at the risks, they thought 'what I'm being told is nonsense because one smoke of cannabis doesn't kill you.'" |
| Success should not be judged solely on rates of use - which have fallen - but on making people aware of the risks and reducing harm, he says. And the distinction between casual drug users and problematic ones needs to be made. | Success should not be judged solely on rates of use - which have fallen - but on making people aware of the risks and reducing harm, he says. And the distinction between casual drug users and problematic ones needs to be made. |
| Mr Barnes believes the Leah Betts campaign backfired because young people who experimented with ecstasy knew a tablet was very unlikely to kill them. | Mr Barnes believes the Leah Betts campaign backfired because young people who experimented with ecstasy knew a tablet was very unlikely to kill them. |
| Rachel's video told her tragic story | Rachel's video told her tragic story |
| But the parents of another teenager believe sharing their tragic story has made a difference. | But the parents of another teenager believe sharing their tragic story has made a difference. |
| A video showing the transformation of Rachel Whitear from a bright teenager to a 21-year-old slumped in a rented room in Exmouth was circulated to schools three years after her death from a heroin overdose. It is still watched by Year 7 pupils today. | A video showing the transformation of Rachel Whitear from a bright teenager to a 21-year-old slumped in a rented room in Exmouth was circulated to schools three years after her death from a heroin overdose. It is still watched by Year 7 pupils today. |
| Her parents, Mick and Pauline Holcroft, featured in the 22-minute video and accompanied viewings of it. | Her parents, Mick and Pauline Holcroft, featured in the 22-minute video and accompanied viewings of it. |
| Mrs Holcroft says although it's impossible to quantify the impact, the young audiences she saw watching it were moved. | Mrs Holcroft says although it's impossible to quantify the impact, the young audiences she saw watching it were moved. |
| "Several of them came to us and said 'I'm never going to do that.' That made all the effort and pain and anguish worthwhile." | "Several of them came to us and said 'I'm never going to do that.' That made all the effort and pain and anguish worthwhile." |
Add your comments on this story, using the form below. | Add your comments on this story, using the form below. |
| Anyone who has experienced FRANK knows that the key difference is that this campaign does not "tell" young audiences what to do or even use the phrase "don't take drugs". It encourages healthy, honest and open conversation and allows teenagers to make up their own mind. It respects the fact that people will always make their own choices in life based on the information they have access to regardless of whether it is from their friends, parents, the media or the government.Lucy Jane, London | |
| Every teenager has experience of recreational drugs, either themselves or a close friend and one has their head in the sand if they think otherwise. Drugs campaigns are completely ineffective in stopping or slowing usage as most users are indulging in what they see as a lifestyle choice. By the time users are onto heroin, physical/medical intervention is required. The ONLY thing that will have a definitive impact is to reduce the supply - simple, but the truth.Neil Lawrence, UK | |
| Personally i think adverts could have an effect if they were of the same standard as the speeding or drink-driving adverts. They are graphic and hard-hitting and really get the message across. I recently passed my driving test and would never even consider drink-driving, partly thanks to the adverts. Drugs need to be pictured in the same light.Hannah, Leicester | |
| I have to disagree with the sentiment that anti-drugs campaigns have been ineffective.We may not be able to see a fall in the numbers of people using and abusing drugs, but what people seem to fail to realise is that these campaigns have probably done a lot to slow down the increase in drug use. So yes, drug abuse may be a problem which is still on the increase, but I think without these campaigns we would see things getting worse much faster.Richard Mason, Lincoln, UK | I have to disagree with the sentiment that anti-drugs campaigns have been ineffective.We may not be able to see a fall in the numbers of people using and abusing drugs, but what people seem to fail to realise is that these campaigns have probably done a lot to slow down the increase in drug use. So yes, drug abuse may be a problem which is still on the increase, but I think without these campaigns we would see things getting worse much faster.Richard Mason, Lincoln, UK |
| Frank. Well, not much use talking to 'him'. A friend of mine phoned them almost 2 years ago after one of their group was vomiting blood after smoking marajuana. They were told to 'put him to bed'. Sounds like Frank doesn't have a clue! Thankfully, the friends were a little more sensible and dialled 999 which was the best move they made that night!Tony Kenny, | Frank. Well, not much use talking to 'him'. A friend of mine phoned them almost 2 years ago after one of their group was vomiting blood after smoking marajuana. They were told to 'put him to bed'. Sounds like Frank doesn't have a clue! Thankfully, the friends were a little more sensible and dialled 999 which was the best move they made that night!Tony Kenny, |
| Drug use in my school was wiped out overnight in 1976. How? One of the 6th formers (popular, good looking, involved in most of the sports teams) died from an overdose that (we all knew)he had been taking regularly. Arranging for a death each year is not an option, but it's the only anti-drugs message that is guaranteed to be effective amongst the young.David Gold, Elstree Herts | Drug use in my school was wiped out overnight in 1976. How? One of the 6th formers (popular, good looking, involved in most of the sports teams) died from an overdose that (we all knew)he had been taking regularly. Arranging for a death each year is not an option, but it's the only anti-drugs message that is guaranteed to be effective amongst the young.David Gold, Elstree Herts |
| If you told young men that smoking cannabis drops their testosterone levels and can make them grow breasts, I guarantee cannabis use will drop like a stone. Sadly because of the demonisation of softer drugs in the past, people assume that its all hype and that there are no side-effects...which is not the case.Andy, London UK | If you told young men that smoking cannabis drops their testosterone levels and can make them grow breasts, I guarantee cannabis use will drop like a stone. Sadly because of the demonisation of softer drugs in the past, people assume that its all hype and that there are no side-effects...which is not the case.Andy, London UK |
| People ignore drug campaigns because of misinformation and lies, Leah Betts wasn't even killed by ecstasy - she drowned through drinking too much. Even medical professionals and social workers I have seen personally are misinformed about the dangers of cannabis (and anyone, like me, who uses it recreationally and in moderation is so very aware how less harmful it is than alcohol). Things like the ridiculous claims about super-skunk (the Guardian did an excellent debunking) just mean people will trust their own experiences and the views of their peers significantly more than what some campaign claims.Ruth, Birmingham, UK | People ignore drug campaigns because of misinformation and lies, Leah Betts wasn't even killed by ecstasy - she drowned through drinking too much. Even medical professionals and social workers I have seen personally are misinformed about the dangers of cannabis (and anyone, like me, who uses it recreationally and in moderation is so very aware how less harmful it is than alcohol). Things like the ridiculous claims about super-skunk (the Guardian did an excellent debunking) just mean people will trust their own experiences and the views of their peers significantly more than what some campaign claims.Ruth, Birmingham, UK |
| Drug awareness campaigns have gained credibility in the move from ridiculous black and white morality (Just Say No) to accurate information (eg Frank); but they will never be completely credible until the law changes to reflect the fact that many drugs are no more harmful than cigarettes and alcohol. Chris Johns, Bristol, UK | Drug awareness campaigns have gained credibility in the move from ridiculous black and white morality (Just Say No) to accurate information (eg Frank); but they will never be completely credible until the law changes to reflect the fact that many drugs are no more harmful than cigarettes and alcohol. Chris Johns, Bristol, UK |
| It's miserable being a teenager, and drugs and alcohol help them feel happy and in control. And they're still young enough to have no conception of their own mortality, so warning them 'drugs kill' just slides right over them. And of course, most campaigns are run by adults, who would do ANYTHING to stop kids having fun (or so teenagers think, as any parent can tell you) so of course, those campaigns are ignored as 'adult propaganda'MB, London | It's miserable being a teenager, and drugs and alcohol help them feel happy and in control. And they're still young enough to have no conception of their own mortality, so warning them 'drugs kill' just slides right over them. And of course, most campaigns are run by adults, who would do ANYTHING to stop kids having fun (or so teenagers think, as any parent can tell you) so of course, those campaigns are ignored as 'adult propaganda'MB, London |
| A friend of mine who teaches (among other things) Health and Social Education in a high school says she thinks the best ever anti-drugs advert was the film Trainspotting.Gordon JC Pearce, Glasgow | A friend of mine who teaches (among other things) Health and Social Education in a high school says she thinks the best ever anti-drugs advert was the film Trainspotting.Gordon JC Pearce, Glasgow |