This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/int/news/-/news/health-12481423
The article has changed 23 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 18 | Version 19 |
|---|---|
| Residential areas 'must have mandatory 20mph limit' | Residential areas 'must have mandatory 20mph limit' |
| (about 4 hours later) | |
| VIEWPOINT By Dominic Harrison Director of Public Health, Blackburn with Darwen | VIEWPOINT By Dominic Harrison Director of Public Health, Blackburn with Darwen |
| Most residential areas have speed limits, set by local councils, of 30mph. But in this week's Scrubbing Up Dominic Harrison, the director of Public Health for Blackburn with Darwen argues a nationwide 20mph speed limit would prevent road accidents and so save thousands of lives. | Most residential areas have speed limits, set by local councils, of 30mph. But in this week's Scrubbing Up Dominic Harrison, the director of Public Health for Blackburn with Darwen argues a nationwide 20mph speed limit would prevent road accidents and so save thousands of lives. |
| Road death as been described by the campaign group as "the greatest avoidable public health epidemic", in my view justifiably so. | Road death as been described by the campaign group as "the greatest avoidable public health epidemic", in my view justifiably so. |
| We need governments, both national and local, to act to reduce this preventable risk to children by introducing mandatory 20mph limits on all residential streets in the UK. | We need governments, both national and local, to act to reduce this preventable risk to children by introducing mandatory 20mph limits on all residential streets in the UK. |
| If the speed limits in all of the residential areas were changed from 30mph to 20mph we could save thousands of children's lives. | If the speed limits in all of the residential areas were changed from 30mph to 20mph we could save thousands of children's lives. |
| The evidence for this is now very strong. | The evidence for this is now very strong. |
| It is very hard to understand why we are not scandalised by our collective inaction. | It is very hard to understand why we are not scandalised by our collective inaction. |
| Saving lives | Saving lives |
| A recent report by the North West Public Health Observatory concluded that 140 killed or seriously injured child casualties could have been prevented each year between 2004-8 if 20mph traffic speed zones had been introduced in residential areas (other than main roads) across the North West. | A recent report by the North West Public Health Observatory concluded that 140 killed or seriously injured child casualties could have been prevented each year between 2004-8 if 20mph traffic speed zones had been introduced in residential areas (other than main roads) across the North West. |
| A 2008 World Health Organization report on preventing child injuries also recommended 20mph limits in residential areas. | A 2008 World Health Organization report on preventing child injuries also recommended 20mph limits in residential areas. |
| "Limits" are cheaper than 20mph "zones", which feature traffic-calming measures, and could be in place across the country within 12 months. | "Limits" are cheaper than 20mph "zones", which feature traffic-calming measures, and could be in place across the country within 12 months. |
| Coupled with a strong social marketing campaign they could make a massive difference to the lives of children and adults alike. | Coupled with a strong social marketing campaign they could make a massive difference to the lives of children and adults alike. |
| No driver really wants to drive at 20mph when it looks safe to drive at 30. | No driver really wants to drive at 20mph when it looks safe to drive at 30. |
| But most children will live and recover if hit by a vehicle travelling at 20mph whereas most risk a lifetime of disability or death if hit at 30mph. | But most children will live and recover if hit by a vehicle travelling at 20mph whereas most risk a lifetime of disability or death if hit at 30mph. |
| The risk each driver creates and the risk to each child of having the current 30mph limit is small - but at a population level over time it becomes very significant. | The risk each driver creates and the risk to each child of having the current 30mph limit is small - but at a population level over time it becomes very significant. |
| System failure | System failure |
| We have had this evidence since 2003 when the English Health Development Agency produced a report saying there was "good evidence for 20mph zones and injury reduction". | We have had this evidence since 2003 when the English Health Development Agency produced a report saying there was "good evidence for 20mph zones and injury reduction". |
| Little action was taken then because there was no one solely responsible for taking the evidence to a Local Authority Transport Committee to decide whether to act, no government minister had to say yes or no to a universal 20mph limit in all residential areas of England, no professional could be found in 'dereliction of duty' for not acting on the evidence and hounded by the media for their culpable failure. | Little action was taken then because there was no one solely responsible for taking the evidence to a Local Authority Transport Committee to decide whether to act, no government minister had to say yes or no to a universal 20mph limit in all residential areas of England, no professional could be found in 'dereliction of duty' for not acting on the evidence and hounded by the media for their culpable failure. |
| This death and injury to children is a 'whole system failure'. | This death and injury to children is a 'whole system failure'. |
| With few exceptions, that failure is still unresolved now, in 2011 and our children are paying the price with their lives. | With few exceptions, that failure is still unresolved now, in 2011 and our children are paying the price with their lives. |
| Several towns have implemented a default 20 mph limit for all residential roads, including Portsmouth, Oxford and Warrington. | Several towns have implemented a default 20 mph limit for all residential roads, including Portsmouth, Oxford and Warrington. |
| The first county to take this approach is Lancashire County Council, which announced on the 25th January 2011 that it would make all residential areas 20mph by 2013 at a predicted cost of £9m. | The first county to take this approach is Lancashire County Council, which announced on the 25th January 2011 that it would make all residential areas 20mph by 2013 at a predicted cost of £9m. |
| At a time of efficiencies and cuts this was a brave and honourable decision. | At a time of efficiencies and cuts this was a brave and honourable decision. |
| Collective responsibility | Collective responsibility |
| Although we will never know just who was saved we will know how many lives (and lifetime disabilities) were prevented. | Although we will never know just who was saved we will know how many lives (and lifetime disabilities) were prevented. |
| The Department for Transport estimates the cost of each road traffic death (police and hospital costs, lost taxes etc) at over £1.5m. | The Department for Transport estimates the cost of each road traffic death (police and hospital costs, lost taxes etc) at over £1.5m. |
| A 20mph Lancashire speed limit will pay for itself - even in monetary teams (far less important than human life) many times over. | A 20mph Lancashire speed limit will pay for itself - even in monetary teams (far less important than human life) many times over. |
| We need to ask what "cultural disease" has allowed us to tolerate this preventable risk to our children for so long without action. | We need to ask what "cultural disease" has allowed us to tolerate this preventable risk to our children for so long without action. |
| Perhaps also, we all need to extend our moral imaginations. | Perhaps also, we all need to extend our moral imaginations. |
| We need to take collective responsibility for our part in predictable and preventable events that affect the lives of others. | We need to take collective responsibility for our part in predictable and preventable events that affect the lives of others. |
| We are in collective denial of one of the biggest safeguarding risks to children. | We are in collective denial of one of the biggest safeguarding risks to children. |
| It is both predictable and preventable and it is time to do something about it. | It is both predictable and preventable and it is time to do something about it. |
Comments | Comments |
| This entry is now closed for comments | |
|
|
| I do agree with the proposal to limit vehicle speed to 20 mph especially in the Morningside area of Edinburgh where I reside. I do not believe that a lower speed limit would be effectively enforced by increased use of speed bumps. It would be very useful if pedestrians would refrain from wandering about in the middle of the road when there are no fewer than 5 pedestrian crossings in Morningside! | |
| Report this comment | |
| Link to this | |
| | |
| My area had a 20mph speed limit and speed bumps introduced several years ago. First I discovered that riding in a vehicle going over the bumps agravated my chronic shoulder injury, secondly I have noticed that the many vehicles travelling closer to 40mph are far less affected by the 'bumps'.I beleive that a 20mph limit will only be effective if enforced effectively and consistently. | My area had a 20mph speed limit and speed bumps introduced several years ago. First I discovered that riding in a vehicle going over the bumps agravated my chronic shoulder injury, secondly I have noticed that the many vehicles travelling closer to 40mph are far less affected by the 'bumps'.I beleive that a 20mph limit will only be effective if enforced effectively and consistently. |
| Report this comment | Report this comment |
| Link to this | Link to this |
| | |
| My narrow, 20mph, street is a school rat run- kids and cars travelling to the same schools. Do the cars do 20mph? No! They mostly go 30mph+ even though they travel literally within inches of the walkers + bikes. A little wobble, a playful push and the kid would be blood+broken bones.Yes, silly kids need more sense, but the ultimate responsibility is on the driver and should always be. | My narrow, 20mph, street is a school rat run- kids and cars travelling to the same schools. Do the cars do 20mph? No! They mostly go 30mph+ even though they travel literally within inches of the walkers + bikes. A little wobble, a playful push and the kid would be blood+broken bones.Yes, silly kids need more sense, but the ultimate responsibility is on the driver and should always be. |
| Report this comment | Report this comment |
| Link to this | Link to this |
| | |
| On the estate I live on although the estate is only about 5 years old the roads are dangerous for everyone. The paths force unsafe crossing. The roads are an accident waiting to happen but don't look like it until you try to drive on them. Even at 10mph you have near misses as bad junctions and corners are also combined with not being able to see cars coming. The speed limit is 30mph- too high. | On the estate I live on although the estate is only about 5 years old the roads are dangerous for everyone. The paths force unsafe crossing. The roads are an accident waiting to happen but don't look like it until you try to drive on them. Even at 10mph you have near misses as bad junctions and corners are also combined with not being able to see cars coming. The speed limit is 30mph- too high. |
| Report this comment | Report this comment |
| Link to this | Link to this |
| | |
| The problem is parked cars on both sides of the road preventing children from seeing driven cars without stepping out between the parked ones. Children should be free to play outside but they are not always going to be thinking.A lack of passing places means some drive faster to prempt on-coming traffic. One way systems help but lead people driving faster because there is no on-coming traffic. | The problem is parked cars on both sides of the road preventing children from seeing driven cars without stepping out between the parked ones. Children should be free to play outside but they are not always going to be thinking.A lack of passing places means some drive faster to prempt on-coming traffic. One way systems help but lead people driving faster because there is no on-coming traffic. |
| Report this comment | Report this comment |
| Link to this | Link to this |
| Comments 5 of 30 | |
| |
| Add your comment | Add your comment |
| You are not currently signed in. Sign in or register. | You are not currently signed in. Sign in or register. |