This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/health/6568081.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| NHS consultant contract attacked | NHS consultant contract attacked |
| (about 5 hours later) | |
| Patients have not seen any improvement in the care they get under the new consultant contract, a watchdog says. | Patients have not seen any improvement in the care they get under the new consultant contract, a watchdog says. |
| The National Audit Office said despite pay rising by 27% to £110,000, doctors were not providing more flexible care or spending more time with patients. | The National Audit Office said despite pay rising by 27% to £110,000, doctors were not providing more flexible care or spending more time with patients. |
| But the watchdog blamed ministers and health managers for the way the 2003 deal was implemented in England, and said it cost £150m more than expected. | But the watchdog blamed ministers and health managers for the way the 2003 deal was implemented in England, and said it cost £150m more than expected. |
| The government said the contract still had "considerable potential". | The government said the contract still had "considerable potential". |
| Over the first three years of the contract, as well as seeing the jump in pay - which does not take into account private earnings - specialist doctors also saw their hours cut. | Over the first three years of the contract, as well as seeing the jump in pay - which does not take into account private earnings - specialist doctors also saw their hours cut. |
| NHS consultants have led on delivering reductions in waiting times and strive to introduce new treatments and efficiencies for patients Jonathan Fielden,British Medical Association Q&A: Consultant contract | NHS consultants have led on delivering reductions in waiting times and strive to introduce new treatments and efficiencies for patients Jonathan Fielden,British Medical Association Q&A: Consultant contract |
| These changes were expected, as consultants have always argued they were under-paid for the hours they worked. | These changes were expected, as consultants have always argued they were under-paid for the hours they worked. |
| But at the time the government said it was a "something for something" contract and would lead to increased productivity and better patient care. | But at the time the government said it was a "something for something" contract and would lead to increased productivity and better patient care. |
| The contract - the biggest shake-up in the way consultants worked since the NHS was formed - was designed to free them up to spend more time with patients and provide more flexible services, such as evening clinics. | The contract - the biggest shake-up in the way consultants worked since the NHS was formed - was designed to free them up to spend more time with patients and provide more flexible services, such as evening clinics. |
| The National Audit Office (NAO) report said it had failed on both counts. | The National Audit Office (NAO) report said it had failed on both counts. |
| Since the contract started, consultant numbers have risen by 11% to 31,990, but the number of patients seen has only gone up by 4%. | Since the contract started, consultant numbers have risen by 11% to 31,990, but the number of patients seen has only gone up by 4%. |
| Cost | Cost |
| The NAO also said the contract has cost at least £715m. | The NAO also said the contract has cost at least £715m. |
| It added that the government had underestimated the amount of work consultants did, and NHS trust managers had failed to keep within budget. | It added that the government had underestimated the amount of work consultants did, and NHS trust managers had failed to keep within budget. |
| The watchdog said NHS trusts needed to improve job planning to improve access to service, while consultants should become more engaged with managers. | The watchdog said NHS trusts needed to improve job planning to improve access to service, while consultants should become more engaged with managers. |
| Karen Taylor, director of health at the NAO, said: "Patients are not seeing consultants work any differently, but if trusts managed job planning better, there is potential for this to change." | Karen Taylor, director of health at the NAO, said: "Patients are not seeing consultants work any differently, but if trusts managed job planning better, there is potential for this to change." |
| There is considerable potential for the consultant contract to further improve the management of consultant time Lord Hunt, Health Minister | There is considerable potential for the consultant contract to further improve the management of consultant time Lord Hunt, Health Minister |
| Liberal Democrat health spokesman Norman Lamb said: "This is yet further proof of the government's incompetent stewardship of the NHS." | Liberal Democrat health spokesman Norman Lamb said: "This is yet further proof of the government's incompetent stewardship of the NHS." |
| And shadow health secretary Andrew Lansley said there was "no evidence of improved productivity". | And shadow health secretary Andrew Lansley said there was "no evidence of improved productivity". |
| But Jonathan Fielden, chairman of the British Medical Association's consultants committee, said workload remained high and was "intensely demanding and exceedingly complex". | But Jonathan Fielden, chairman of the British Medical Association's consultants committee, said workload remained high and was "intensely demanding and exceedingly complex". |
| "NHS consultants have led on delivering reductions in waiting times and strive to introduce new treatments and efficiencies for patients. | "NHS consultants have led on delivering reductions in waiting times and strive to introduce new treatments and efficiencies for patients. |
| "If trusts are failing to realise the benefits of the contract it is because they have been distracted by the pressure to balance their books and meet political targets." | "If trusts are failing to realise the benefits of the contract it is because they have been distracted by the pressure to balance their books and meet political targets." |
| His colleague Dr Mark Porter told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "The vast majority of consultants are continuing to provide the professional care to their patients that they want as they always have." | |
| But he said there were tensions about how that was reflected in the number of hours trusts recognised they worked. | |
| "A small number of consultants have seen real reductions, but the majority are continuing to do their professional job." | |
| Alastair Henderson, deputy director of NHS Employers, said the new contract did provide a good framework. | |
| But he added: "I think it will continue to work better in the future." | |
| Health Minister Lord Hunt said: "There is considerable potential for the consultant contract to further improve the management of consultant time and deliver full value for money to the NHS." | |
| The criticism of the consultants' contract comes after the government was also attacked for the new contract for GPs which, since it started in 2004, has seen GP pay break through the £100,000 a year barrier. | The criticism of the consultants' contract comes after the government was also attacked for the new contract for GPs which, since it started in 2004, has seen GP pay break through the £100,000 a year barrier. |