This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/int/news/-/news/health-12634111

The article has changed 12 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 4 Version 5
'We don't need so many hospitals' 'We don't need so many hospitals'
(about 3 hours later)
VIEWPOINT By Dr Greg Parston Chair of the Public Management FoundationVIEWPOINT By Dr Greg Parston Chair of the Public Management Foundation
In this week's 'Scrubbing Up', Dr Greg Parston of the Public Management Foundation, argues that closing hospitals or reducing what they do can be in the best interests of an effective and efficient health service.In this week's 'Scrubbing Up', Dr Greg Parston of the Public Management Foundation, argues that closing hospitals or reducing what they do can be in the best interests of an effective and efficient health service.
The coalition government's reforms to the NHS are attracting heat.The coalition government's reforms to the NHS are attracting heat.
Some experts, including the respected King's Fund, provide evidence that claims of poor health outcomes as a justification for change are factually wrong. Opponents warn that the reforms will fuel privatisation, cost jobs and harm patients.Some experts, including the respected King's Fund, provide evidence that claims of poor health outcomes as a justification for change are factually wrong. Opponents warn that the reforms will fuel privatisation, cost jobs and harm patients.
And others wonder about the timing, with the Health Select Committee expressing reservations about the viability of radical change at a time of unprecedented efficiency savings.And others wonder about the timing, with the Health Select Committee expressing reservations about the viability of radical change at a time of unprecedented efficiency savings.
The reforms are huge and the opposition is vocal, but these arguments are about the wrong things.The reforms are huge and the opposition is vocal, but these arguments are about the wrong things.
The NHS does need change, but not these changes.The NHS does need change, but not these changes.
That glaring point is being ignored by government and by much of opposition, to the danger not only of the NHS but also to the health of the nation.That glaring point is being ignored by government and by much of opposition, to the danger not only of the NHS but also to the health of the nation.
The government reforms will alter only the NHS's superstructure -patterns of money flow, responsibilities for service procurement and levels of accountability.The government reforms will alter only the NHS's superstructure -patterns of money flow, responsibilities for service procurement and levels of accountability.
They ignore the country's health imperatives and undermine our ability to improve the NHS where it really needs to be improved.They ignore the country's health imperatives and undermine our ability to improve the NHS where it really needs to be improved.
Status quoStatus quo
The real need for change is to the NHS's infrastructure - to the provision of care.The real need for change is to the NHS's infrastructure - to the provision of care.
The NHS needs to radically realign service configuration to effect massive investments in non-acute care.The NHS needs to radically realign service configuration to effect massive investments in non-acute care.
It needs to close unneeded hospitals and transfer resources out of expensive inappropriate facilities in order to meet the rapidly changing patterns of need.It needs to close unneeded hospitals and transfer resources out of expensive inappropriate facilities in order to meet the rapidly changing patterns of need.
Neither the reforms nor the status quo will achieve that.Neither the reforms nor the status quo will achieve that.
Of course we need hospitals, but not nearly as many as we have currently.Of course we need hospitals, but not nearly as many as we have currently.
Some experts estimate that as much as 60% of the NHS clinical budget over the next 10 years will be spent on the chronic conditions of older people, who can be cared for in facilities other than hospitals - care facilities, hostels, and even in their own homes.Some experts estimate that as much as 60% of the NHS clinical budget over the next 10 years will be spent on the chronic conditions of older people, who can be cared for in facilities other than hospitals - care facilities, hostels, and even in their own homes.
They suggest that in London alone we could close a half dozen hospitals, which would easily fund high quality "close-to-home" services that allow for greater independence and self-respect.They suggest that in London alone we could close a half dozen hospitals, which would easily fund high quality "close-to-home" services that allow for greater independence and self-respect.
Currently, we do not have enough low-level chronic facilities or home care professionals because today's NHS is so dominated by acute hospital and medical professionals.Currently, we do not have enough low-level chronic facilities or home care professionals because today's NHS is so dominated by acute hospital and medical professionals.
Some primary care trusts were beginning to come to grips with this, exercising commissioning decisions (of considerable volume and money) in a manner that sought to change patterns of care.Some primary care trusts were beginning to come to grips with this, exercising commissioning decisions (of considerable volume and money) in a manner that sought to change patterns of care.
In Torbay, for example, partly influenced by US Kaiser Permanente's "Home is the Hub" strategy, the integration of health and social care is driven by a powerful combination of NHS and local authority commissioners.In Torbay, for example, partly influenced by US Kaiser Permanente's "Home is the Hub" strategy, the integration of health and social care is driven by a powerful combination of NHS and local authority commissioners.
The results include dramatically decreased hospital admissions for the elderly and a 30% reduction in occupied hospital beds since 1999.The results include dramatically decreased hospital admissions for the elderly and a 30% reduction in occupied hospital beds since 1999.
Dilution of powerDilution of power
But this is not just about the elderly.But this is not just about the elderly.
While average lengths of stay for acute condition in the UK hover at seven days, in systems as diverse as the US, Sweden, France and Australia, the same figure is well below six days.While average lengths of stay for acute condition in the UK hover at seven days, in systems as diverse as the US, Sweden, France and Australia, the same figure is well below six days.
With over 1,000,000 admissions per month, even half a day adds up to a lot of money that could be spent on alternative, cheaper and more appropriate services.With over 1,000,000 admissions per month, even half a day adds up to a lot of money that could be spent on alternative, cheaper and more appropriate services.
We simply keep on using hospitals instead of more appropriate alternatives.We simply keep on using hospitals instead of more appropriate alternatives.
By ignoring these facts, the current reforms undermine the possibility of needed service transformation and entrench power in existing institutions.By ignoring these facts, the current reforms undermine the possibility of needed service transformation and entrench power in existing institutions.
By diluting the power of commissioning amongst hundreds of GP groups, with little experience in commissioning or inclination to real service revolution, the reforms protect many un-needed hospitals.By diluting the power of commissioning amongst hundreds of GP groups, with little experience in commissioning or inclination to real service revolution, the reforms protect many un-needed hospitals.
The effects of hundreds of individual service procurements will not re-shape the NHS. Only large-scale commissioning decisions are capable of doing that.The effects of hundreds of individual service procurements will not re-shape the NHS. Only large-scale commissioning decisions are capable of doing that.
Commissioning health care is not simply about procuring services locally, as the reforms' advocates will have us believe; it is also about managing and reshaping the overall provision of care.Commissioning health care is not simply about procuring services locally, as the reforms' advocates will have us believe; it is also about managing and reshaping the overall provision of care.
In this regard, perversely, the coalition's reforms only protect the status quo.In this regard, perversely, the coalition's reforms only protect the status quo.


Comments



Comments

You are not currently signed in. or register.You are not currently signed in. or register.
 
  • id="comment_106971708">
 
  • id="comment_106977925">
This comment is awaiting moderation. Explain.
Report this comment
Link to this
    • Not registered with the GMC. Is it responsible to use the title Doctor when writing an article about reorganisation within the NHS, this may give the erroneous impression that you have some experience of delivering clinical care to patients rather than basing your view on spreadsheets and vacuous questionnaires.Not registered with the GMC. Is it responsible to use the title Doctor when writing an article about reorganisation within the NHS, this may give the erroneous impression that you have some experience of delivering clinical care to patients rather than basing your view on spreadsheets and vacuous questionnaires.
    Report this comment Report this comment
    Link to thisLink to this
    		•
    • Of course the NHS will save money if they can transfer patients to establishments labelled 'care homes'. Either local authorities will pay or, and even better from the exchequer's point of view, the patient will pay. The fact that the patient may have to be transferred long distances in case of emergency is purely incidental.Of course the NHS will save money if they can transfer patients to establishments labelled 'care homes'. Either local authorities will pay or, and even better from the exchequer's point of view, the patient will pay. The fact that the patient may have to be transferred long distances in case of emergency is purely incidental.
    Report this comment Report this comment
    Link to thisLink to this
           
    Add your commentAdd your comment
    You are not currently signed in. or register.You are not currently signed in. or register.