This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/int/news/-/news/uk-16112772
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Lawrence trial: Defence claims contamination risks | Lawrence trial: Defence claims contamination risks |
(40 minutes later) | |
Contamination of forensic evidence in the Stephen Lawrence murder case could have occured in nine possible ways, the Old Bailey has been told. | Contamination of forensic evidence in the Stephen Lawrence murder case could have occured in nine possible ways, the Old Bailey has been told. |
Tim Roberts, lawyer for Gary Dobson, said blood flakes could have escaped from Mr Lawrence's clothes and found their way onto the suspect's garments. | Tim Roberts, lawyer for Gary Dobson, said blood flakes could have escaped from Mr Lawrence's clothes and found their way onto the suspect's garments. |
On Thursday, forensic scientist Rosalyn Hammond said there was no realistic possibility of contamination. | On Thursday, forensic scientist Rosalyn Hammond said there was no realistic possibility of contamination. |
Mr Dobson, 36 and David Norris, 35, deny murdering the 18-year-old in 1993. | Mr Dobson, 36 and David Norris, 35, deny murdering the 18-year-old in 1993. |
The prosecution alleges they were part of a group of white youths that shouted a racist remark before forcing Mr Lawrence to the ground and stabbing him twice in Eltham, south-east London. | The prosecution alleges they were part of a group of white youths that shouted a racist remark before forcing Mr Lawrence to the ground and stabbing him twice in Eltham, south-east London. |
Mr Roberts was questioning Ms Hammond, a scientist from LGC Forensics, who has considered the risks of contamination for the prosecution. | Mr Roberts was questioning Ms Hammond, a scientist from LGC Forensics, who has considered the risks of contamination for the prosecution. |
The presence of Mr Lawrence's heavily-bloodstained clothing - "bundled together" by hospital staff and subsequently dried out - meant there was a risk blood flakes could escape and find their way onto the suspect's clothes, Mr Roberts said. | The presence of Mr Lawrence's heavily-bloodstained clothing - "bundled together" by hospital staff and subsequently dried out - meant there was a risk blood flakes could escape and find their way onto the suspect's clothes, Mr Roberts said. |
He said the risk was heightened by the way some clothes had been cut from Mr Lawrence's body, producing large numbers of material fibres. | He said the risk was heightened by the way some clothes had been cut from Mr Lawrence's body, producing large numbers of material fibres. |
Ms Hammond said the way these items had been handled did not heighten the risk of evidence contamination. | Ms Hammond said the way these items had been handled did not heighten the risk of evidence contamination. |
But she said it could have led to fragments of evidence being transferred between the five items of clothing Mr Lawrence had been wearing that night. | But she said it could have led to fragments of evidence being transferred between the five items of clothing Mr Lawrence had been wearing that night. |
Mr Roberts said the fact that packages of clothing had been frequently moved also increased the risk. | Mr Roberts said the fact that packages of clothing had been frequently moved also increased the risk. |
"All that travelling and movements" heightens the risk of contamination, he said. | "All that travelling and movements" heightens the risk of contamination, he said. |
Ms Hammond responded that the "manipulation" of the packaging might be a risk factor, but not necessarily the way they were taken in cars between police stations and laboratories. | Ms Hammond responded that the "manipulation" of the packaging might be a risk factor, but not necessarily the way they were taken in cars between police stations and laboratories. |
Fifteen years | Fifteen years |
Mr Roberts cited as another factor the length of the case - 15 years by the time the evidence was reviewed by LGC Forensics. | Mr Roberts cited as another factor the length of the case - 15 years by the time the evidence was reviewed by LGC Forensics. |
Ms Hammond said that was not in itself important, arguing that it depended how the exhibits had been handled. | Ms Hammond said that was not in itself important, arguing that it depended how the exhibits had been handled. |
But she acknowledged an increased risk because anti-contamination procedures were not as stringent as today; also because sellotape seals on bags had come undone. | But she acknowledged an increased risk because anti-contamination procedures were not as stringent as today; also because sellotape seals on bags had come undone. |
Earlier Ms Hammond was questioned closely about her reliance on a "paper trail" when considering the risks of contamination, rather than extensive examination of the exhibits. | Earlier Ms Hammond was questioned closely about her reliance on a "paper trail" when considering the risks of contamination, rather than extensive examination of the exhibits. |
She felt she generally had all the information she needed, she responded. | She felt she generally had all the information she needed, she responded. |
She accepted she was not an expert in the science which might lead particles of evidence to move between items of clothing in the lab. But she said as a scientist she did "observe how things behave in a lab environment". | She accepted she was not an expert in the science which might lead particles of evidence to move between items of clothing in the lab. But she said as a scientist she did "observe how things behave in a lab environment". |
Ms Hammond also told the Old Bailey that exhibits in the case were not tampered with even though one officer had deliberately sabotaged his own records. | |
It would be clear if any packages had been opened without permission, she said. | |
The jury has already been told that Det Con Paul Steed - who had been in charge of exhibits in the murder investigation - altered his own records after being thrown off the case following a conviction for assault. | |
The defence claims forensic evidence, found in 2008 in a cold case review and allegedly linking Mr Dobson and Mr Norris to the killing of the black teenager, resulted from contamination. | The defence claims forensic evidence, found in 2008 in a cold case review and allegedly linking Mr Dobson and Mr Norris to the killing of the black teenager, resulted from contamination. |
The prosecution says tiny amounts of blood, fibres, and hair found on clothes taken from the men's homes prove their guilt. | The prosecution says tiny amounts of blood, fibres, and hair found on clothes taken from the men's homes prove their guilt. |
The trial continues. | The trial continues. |