This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/int/news/-/news/uk-scotland-17039899
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
RBS 'last bank in town' adverts were 'misleading' | RBS 'last bank in town' adverts were 'misleading' |
(40 minutes later) | |
The advertising watchdog has upheld complaints against The Royal Bank of Scotland for making "misleading" promises to be the "last bank in town". | The advertising watchdog has upheld complaints against The Royal Bank of Scotland for making "misleading" promises to be the "last bank in town". |
RBS, which is 83% owned by the taxpayer, made the claims in two TV commercials. | RBS, which is 83% owned by the taxpayer, made the claims in two TV commercials. |
Viewers from Farsley in West Yorkshire said the last bank in their area, the RBS-owned NatWest, was closed. | Viewers from Farsley in West Yorkshire said the last bank in their area, the RBS-owned NatWest, was closed. |
After a second RBS advert, viewers in the Highlands said their bank premises had been replaced by a mobile bank. | |
The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) was contacted after receiving a number of complaints about the adverts which were screened in June. They have now been banned. | The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) was contacted after receiving a number of complaints about the adverts which were screened in June. They have now been banned. |
'Last bank' | 'Last bank' |
The first showed staff outside a branch on a deserted coastal road and claimed that NatWest would "continue to provide banking services wherever we're the last bank in town". | The first showed staff outside a branch on a deserted coastal road and claimed that NatWest would "continue to provide banking services wherever we're the last bank in town". |
However viewers from Farsley in West Yorkshire, where a branch had closed despite being the last in the area, complained to the watchdog. | However viewers from Farsley in West Yorkshire, where a branch had closed despite being the last in the area, complained to the watchdog. |
The second commercial, for RBS, featured different characters and settings with a similar script. | The second commercial, for RBS, featured different characters and settings with a similar script. |
The ASA later established that RBS had also pulled out of premises it used in Bettyhill, Sutherland, replacing them with a stop on its mobile bank route. | The ASA later established that RBS had also pulled out of premises it used in Bettyhill, Sutherland, replacing them with a stop on its mobile bank route. |
A spokesman for the ASA said of the first advert: "Because (the advertisement) stated that NatWest would continue to provide banking services if it was the last in town and because we understood that there was a town in which they had not done so, we concluded that the claim was misleading." | A spokesman for the ASA said of the first advert: "Because (the advertisement) stated that NatWest would continue to provide banking services if it was the last in town and because we understood that there was a town in which they had not done so, we concluded that the claim was misleading." |
It came to a similar conclusion in relation to the second claim. | It came to a similar conclusion in relation to the second claim. |
"We considered that the claim, and especially the setting and the reference to the "last bank" in the ad, would be interpreted by viewers as a claim that RBS would not close a branch in circumstances when it was the last bank in town," the spokesman said. | "We considered that the claim, and especially the setting and the reference to the "last bank" in the ad, would be interpreted by viewers as a claim that RBS would not close a branch in circumstances when it was the last bank in town," the spokesman said. |
"Because we considered that the ad implied that they would retain bricks-and-mortar branches when, in Bettyhill, they had not done so, we concluded that claim, as it featured in (the advert) was misleading." | "Because we considered that the ad implied that they would retain bricks-and-mortar branches when, in Bettyhill, they had not done so, we concluded that claim, as it featured in (the advert) was misleading." |
'Two desks' | 'Two desks' |
An RBS spokesman said the bank disagreed with the watchdog's decision. | An RBS spokesman said the bank disagreed with the watchdog's decision. |
In a response to the ASA, RBS defended the closure of the Farsley premises and insisted it had never promised to keep all branches open. | In a response to the ASA, RBS defended the closure of the Farsley premises and insisted it had never promised to keep all branches open. |
And it claimed to have improved services in Bettyhill, where it replaced "two desks in a community centre" with the mobile bank. | And it claimed to have improved services in Bettyhill, where it replaced "two desks in a community centre" with the mobile bank. |
"While we disagree with the ASA's decision, we welcome their offer to work more closely with them in future," a spokesman said. | "While we disagree with the ASA's decision, we welcome their offer to work more closely with them in future," a spokesman said. |
RBS, which is being propped up with billions of pounds of public money, has repeatedly come under the spotlight since its collapse in 2008. | RBS, which is being propped up with billions of pounds of public money, has repeatedly come under the spotlight since its collapse in 2008. |
The latest incident follows a torrid few weeks for the bank in which boss Stephen Hester was forced to give up a £963,000 share bonus amid huge political pressure and his predecessor, Fred Goodwin, was stripped of his knighthood for his role in leading the bank to the brink of collapse. | The latest incident follows a torrid few weeks for the bank in which boss Stephen Hester was forced to give up a £963,000 share bonus amid huge political pressure and his predecessor, Fred Goodwin, was stripped of his knighthood for his role in leading the bank to the brink of collapse. |