This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/blog/2012/jun/13/jeremy-hunt-commons-vote-pmqs-live

The article has changed 14 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 9 Version 10
Jeremy Hunt Commons vote and PMQs: Politics live blog Jeremy Hunt Commons vote and PMQs: Politics live blog
(40 minutes later)
4.27pm: The Tories have won by 290 votes to 252 - a majority of 38.
4.17pm: This is from Labour's Kevin Brennan.
DUP voting with Tories on Hunt motion - how much will that cost?
— Kevin Brennan (@KevinBrennanMP) June 13, 2012
4.12pm: They are voting now.
We'll get the result in about 15 minutes.
4.06pm: Sir George Young is still speaking.
He says Harriet Harman called for Hunt's resignation only a few minutes after the 163-page document about Adam Smith's links with News Corporation had emerged. She had not had time to study the evidence, he says. That is how justice operates in a "banana republic".
She says that if Harman is so willing to accept the word of the Murdochs, she should say whether she accepts what Rupert Murdoch said about the conversation he had with Gordon Brown which Brown claims did not take place.
And he says that today's motion, calling for an inquiry into Hunt's conduct, suggests Harman has already backed down from her demand for his resignation. It's a humiliating climbdown, he says.
3.59pm: Sir George Young, the leader of the Commons, is winding up for the government. He says the government will respond in due course to the report from the public adminstration committee calling for the independent adviser on ministers' interests to be made fully independent.
He says Chris Bryant's comments about Hunt being a liar were "regrettable". Despite John Bercow's decision to allow this, it did nothing for the reputation of parliament. He says he hopes Bryant will withdraw.
3.56pm: Angela Eagle is still speaking. She says that Sir Alex Allan gets paid £20,000 a year for being the prime minister's independent adviser on ministers' interests. But Allan has very little work to do, she says. This "something for nothing" culture must end, she jokes.
3.49pm: Angela Eagle, the shadow leader of the Commons, is winding up the debate for Labour.
Bernard Jenkin asks her if the Labour party will commit itself to giving the independent adviser on ministers' interests the right to decide for himself whether or not he launches an investigation into an alleged breach of the ministerial code.
Eagle will not make up policy on the hoof. She says that there should be a "fresh look" at this issue. And she says she personally has "an open mind". But she does not explicitly say yes.

In a report in March the public adminstration committee said that the independent adviser should have the power to initiate an inquiry.
3.38pm: There has been very little evidence of Lib Dem/Tory tensions in the debate. Tory MPs have largely avoided saying anything critical about their Lib Dem coalition colleagues and their decision to abstain in the vote.3.38pm: There has been very little evidence of Lib Dem/Tory tensions in the debate. Tory MPs have largely avoided saying anything critical about their Lib Dem coalition colleagues and their decision to abstain in the vote.
But on Twitter the Tory MP Conor Burns has been sounding off.But on Twitter the Tory MP Conor Burns has been sounding off.
Out of my hospital bed and on way to HoC for vote so our coalition partners can polish their consciences. Many of us won't forget thisOut of my hospital bed and on way to HoC for vote so our coalition partners can polish their consciences. Many of us won't forget this
— Conor Burns MP (@Conor_BurnsMP) June 13, 2012— Conor Burns MP (@Conor_BurnsMP) June 13, 2012
3.33pm: Labour's Jim Sheridan says in his speech that the practice of politicians having "cosy dinners" with media executives has to end. He says Labour was just as guilty of this as the Tories.3.33pm: Labour's Jim Sheridan says in his speech that the practice of politicians having "cosy dinners" with media executives has to end. He says Labour was just as guilty of this as the Tories.
He also says Hunt should resign and allow another minister to take charge of the Olympics.He also says Hunt should resign and allow another minister to take charge of the Olympics.
3.27pm: Damian Collins, a Conserative member of the culture committee, says no new evidence has emerged in today's debate.3.27pm: Damian Collins, a Conserative member of the culture committee, says no new evidence has emerged in today's debate.
3.14pm: Therese Coffey, a Conservative member of the Commons culture committee, says in her speech that there is no evidence Hunt has done anything wrong. All MPs should reject the motion.3.14pm: Therese Coffey, a Conservative member of the Commons culture committee, says in her speech that there is no evidence Hunt has done anything wrong. All MPs should reject the motion.
I believe that ever since he was given responsibility for this process, he has done exactly the right thing ... I am concerned that having this heated debate in the terms expressed today, does nothing but continue to drag politics into the mud and that is something that should worry us all.
3.05pm: John Denham, the Labour MP who was shadow business secretary when Vince Cable had responsibility for the bid, is speaking. He says that Gus O'Donnell, the cabinet secretary in December 2010, should have been told about the memo that Hunt had sent to David Cameron expressing support for the News Corporation bid for BSkyB before O'Donnell agreed that Hunt could take over responsibility for it from Cable.3.05pm: John Denham, the Labour MP who was shadow business secretary when Vince Cable had responsibility for the bid, is speaking. He says that Gus O'Donnell, the cabinet secretary in December 2010, should have been told about the memo that Hunt had sent to David Cameron expressing support for the News Corporation bid for BSkyB before O'Donnell agreed that Hunt could take over responsibility for it from Cable.
He invites Hunt to explain why he did not tell the cabinet secretary about this.He invites Hunt to explain why he did not tell the cabinet secretary about this.
Hunt replies: "Because I was not party to any of the discussions between the prime minister and the cabinet secretary [about who should take over responsibility for the bid from Cable]."Hunt replies: "Because I was not party to any of the discussions between the prime minister and the cabinet secretary [about who should take over responsibility for the bid from Cable]."
2.57pm: Here's the extract from Chris Bryant's speech where he accused Hunt explicitly of lying - and Hunt's response.2.57pm: Here's the extract from Chris Bryant's speech where he accused Hunt explicitly of lying - and Hunt's response.
Bryant: The deliberate nature of this misinformation is also evidenced by [Hunt's] response to two backbenchers in his statement of April this year ... When one asked him how many conversations did he have, meaning with News International or News Corporation, the secretary of state said, quite categorically and emphatically, "zero". And when another one asked - this is a Conservative member, it's not coming out of the blue this - whether he recognised the conversations attributed to him by Fred Michel, he said: "I do not. Throughout the whole bid process, when I got responsibility for it, the contact that I had with Fred Michel was only at official meetings that were minuted with other people present. The fact is that there is a whole pile of emails, 54 in total, in which he talks about having contact with me, but that simply did not happen." Neither of these responses were unpremedited responses. They were deliberately placed on the record. Both are deliberate obfuscations and lies.Bryant: The deliberate nature of this misinformation is also evidenced by [Hunt's] response to two backbenchers in his statement of April this year ... When one asked him how many conversations did he have, meaning with News International or News Corporation, the secretary of state said, quite categorically and emphatically, "zero". And when another one asked - this is a Conservative member, it's not coming out of the blue this - whether he recognised the conversations attributed to him by Fred Michel, he said: "I do not. Throughout the whole bid process, when I got responsibility for it, the contact that I had with Fred Michel was only at official meetings that were minuted with other people present. The fact is that there is a whole pile of emails, 54 in total, in which he talks about having contact with me, but that simply did not happen." Neither of these responses were unpremedited responses. They were deliberately placed on the record. Both are deliberate obfuscations and lies.
Hunt: I'm sure that [Bryant] would not wish to misled the House. So let me just tell [Bryant] in both cases the questions I was asked were referring to the 54 emails that Fred Michel wrote talking about conversations with JH. And in both cases I confirmed that no such conversations with me happened.Hunt: I'm sure that [Bryant] would not wish to misled the House. So let me just tell [Bryant] in both cases the questions I was asked were referring to the 54 emails that Fred Michel wrote talking about conversations with JH. And in both cases I confirmed that no such conversations with me happened.
2.51pm: Bernard Jenkin, the Conservative chairman of the public administration committee, is speaking now. He says the independent adviser on ministers' interests should be able to decide whether or not he investigates alleged breaches of the ministerial code.2.51pm: Bernard Jenkin, the Conservative chairman of the public administration committee, is speaking now. He says the independent adviser on ministers' interests should be able to decide whether or not he investigates alleged breaches of the ministerial code.
2.47pm: Bryant says Cameron says these matters have been covered by Leveson. But, because of the Bill of Rights, the inquiry cannot question what occured in parliament. That is why the independent adviser on ministers' interests should hold an inquiry.2.47pm: Bryant says Cameron says these matters have been covered by Leveson. But, because of the Bill of Rights, the inquiry cannot question what occured in parliament. That is why the independent adviser on ministers' interests should hold an inquiry.
Bryant concludes by saying that Matthew Parris, a News International employee and a former Tory MP, has described this as a "shabby business".Bryant concludes by saying that Matthew Parris, a News International employee and a former Tory MP, has described this as a "shabby business".
2.42pm: Bryant says Hunt told parliament on 3 March 2011 that he had published all the exchanges between his department and News Corporation.2.42pm: Bryant says Hunt told parliament on 3 March 2011 that he had published all the exchanges between his department and News Corporation.
Later that year, in a written answer to John Mann, he tried to "backtrack". He said he could not provide a list of all contacts with News Corporation because of the disproportionate cost. But he did not mention his personal contacts with people like James Murdoch. And he did not mention his memo to David Cameron. This meant that he was withholding information from the Commons.Later that year, in a written answer to John Mann, he tried to "backtrack". He said he could not provide a list of all contacts with News Corporation because of the disproportionate cost. But he did not mention his personal contacts with people like James Murdoch. And he did not mention his memo to David Cameron. This meant that he was withholding information from the Commons.
In response to questions from MPs about his contact with Fred Michel, he said there had been no contact. But there had been contact. He was lying.In response to questions from MPs about his contact with Fred Michel, he said there had been no contact. But there had been contact. He was lying.
Hunt intervenes. He says he was responding to questions about the Fred Michel emails, which referred to "JH" when Michel had actually been speaking to Adam Smith.Hunt intervenes. He says he was responding to questions about the Fred Michel emails, which referred to "JH" when Michel had actually been speaking to Adam Smith.
2.37pm: Labour's Chris Bryant is speaking now.2.37pm: Labour's Chris Bryant is speaking now.
He says Hunt is a nice man. He is courteous.He says Hunt is a nice man. He is courteous.
He also says that ministers do from time to time mislead the Commons inadvertently. The issue is whether Hunt did this deliberately.He also says that ministers do from time to time mislead the Commons inadvertently. The issue is whether Hunt did this deliberately.
Bryant says there is prima facie evidence to prove this.Bryant says there is prima facie evidence to prove this.
Fred Michel, the News Corporation lobbyist, was given privileged information before it was announced in the Commons. This may have been against the law.Fred Michel, the News Corporation lobbyist, was given privileged information before it was announced in the Commons. This may have been against the law.
Adam Smith worked very closely with Hunt. Yet Hunt expects MPs to believe that Hunt did not know what Smith was doing.Adam Smith worked very closely with Hunt. Yet Hunt expects MPs to believe that Hunt did not know what Smith was doing.
Jeremy Hunt intervenes. He says it is standard practice to give advance warning of a statement affecting it. And, if Hunt had a grand plan to clear the bid, why did he refer it to independent regulators?Jeremy Hunt intervenes. He says it is standard practice to give advance warning of a statement affecting it. And, if Hunt had a grand plan to clear the bid, why did he refer it to independent regulators?
Bryant says he does not accept this. He thinks Hunt achieved precisely the outcome he wanted.Bryant says he does not accept this. He thinks Hunt achieved precisely the outcome he wanted.
On the point about News Corporation having advance notice, he says that should not have happened before the markets opened. And News Corporation was given infromation not available to the other side.On the point about News Corporation having advance notice, he says that should not have happened before the markets opened. And News Corporation was given infromation not available to the other side.
2.35pm: Don Foster is still speaking.2.35pm: Don Foster is still speaking.
He says Labour's conduct in relation to this affair has been "appalling".He says Labour's conduct in relation to this affair has been "appalling".
The ministerial code says ministers should not delay announcements under the ends of the parliamentary sessions.The ministerial code says ministers should not delay announcements under the ends of the parliamentary sessions.
But, on the last day of one session when Labour was in power, it made 30 written ministerial announcements. Ten of them were from the prime minister.But, on the last day of one session when Labour was in power, it made 30 written ministerial announcements. Ten of them were from the prime minister.
2.29pm: Don Foster, a Lib Dem backbencher and a party spokesman on culture, is speaking now.2.29pm: Don Foster, a Lib Dem backbencher and a party spokesman on culture, is speaking now.
He says Hunt handled the News Corporation bid "by the book". He took decisions (in relation to Sky News being made independent) that would have reduced the influence of News Corp.He says Hunt handled the News Corporation bid "by the book". He took decisions (in relation to Sky News being made independent) that would have reduced the influence of News Corp.
A Labour MP asks why, in that case, the Lib Dems are not supporting Hunt in the lobbies tonight.A Labour MP asks why, in that case, the Lib Dems are not supporting Hunt in the lobbies tonight.
Foster says that the decision not to refer Hunt to the independent adviser on minister's interests was taken by David Cameron alone. The Lib Dems were not involved. That is why they cannot endorse it, he says.Foster says that the decision not to refer Hunt to the independent adviser on minister's interests was taken by David Cameron alone. The Lib Dems were not involved. That is why they cannot endorse it, he says.
There was not a collective decision on this, it is not part of the coalition agreement, it was a decision taken solely by the prime minister and in no way will our vote, or absence of votes, tonight in any way preclude us from continuing to work with out coalition partners in relation to those issues we've agreed in the coalition agreement and sorting out the economic mess that the previous government have left us.
2.28pm: Guido Fawkes has got hold of the list of planted questions from the whips for use by Tory MP during the debate.2.28pm: Guido Fawkes has got hold of the list of planted questions from the whips for use by Tory MP during the debate.
2.21pm: Labour's Paul Flynn is speaking now. He says the independent adviser on ministers' interests should be allowed to initiate his own inquiries. What happens if there is a complaint about the prime minister himself breaking the ministerial code? The prime minister will not order an inquiry into himself, he says.2.21pm: Labour's Paul Flynn is speaking now. He says the independent adviser on ministers' interests should be allowed to initiate his own inquiries. What happens if there is a complaint about the prime minister himself breaking the ministerial code? The prime minister will not order an inquiry into himself, he says.
If we are going to raise respect for us in society, we have to subject every honourable minister to the examination by someone who is genuinely independent. If the prime minister breaks the code, we need an independent investigator to decide of his own volition whether to investigate. Now we have a poodle instructed by the Prime Minister.
A resignation delayed is a disgrace multiplied. I believe Mr Hunt will regret the fact he didn't go, he didn't submit his own case to the independent adviser. He should go.
He says that some MPs suffered has a result of the expenses scandal. Some innocent members suffered "collateral damage". He says he has just finished a biography of an MP (David Taylor) who was a victim of this. Flynn says he thinks the expenses controvery contributed to Taylor's death.He says that some MPs suffered has a result of the expenses scandal. Some innocent members suffered "collateral damage". He says he has just finished a biography of an MP (David Taylor) who was a victim of this. Flynn says he thinks the expenses controvery contributed to Taylor's death.
2.15pm: John Whittingdale says that there is a case for allowing the independent adviser on ministers' interests to be allowed to launch his own inquiries, without having to wait to be asked to by the prime minister. He says the public administration committee is looking at this and that perhaps this is a reform that will emerge from this affair. 2.15pm: John Whittingdale says that there is a case for allowing the independent adviser on ministers' interests to be allowed to launch his own inquiries, without having to wait to be asked to by the prime minister. He says that the public administration committee has been looking at this and that perhaps this is a reform that will emerge from this affair.
He says Harman wrote to him asking the culture committee to look into this affair. Hunt will be giving evidence to the committee soon about the work of his department, and committee members can question him about this matter then, he says.He says Harman wrote to him asking the culture committee to look into this affair. Hunt will be giving evidence to the committee soon about the work of his department, and committee members can question him about this matter then, he says.
2.12pm: John Whittingdale says he will be "disappointed" if Lib Dem MPs do not vote with the Conservatives. He hopes that, having heard Hunt, they will decide to do so.2.12pm: John Whittingdale says he will be "disappointed" if Lib Dem MPs do not vote with the Conservatives. He hopes that, having heard Hunt, they will decide to do so.
Whittingdale says he was a special adviser in the department for trade in the 1980s. At that time he was not allowed to get involved in competition issues, because it was felt that there should be no party political imput into those decisions. But since then the role of special advisers has changed, he says.Whittingdale says he was a special adviser in the department for trade in the 1980s. At that time he was not allowed to get involved in competition issues, because it was felt that there should be no party political imput into those decisions. But since then the role of special advisers has changed, he says.
2.09pm: John Whittingdale, the Conservative chairman of the Commons culture committee, is speaking now.2.09pm: John Whittingdale, the Conservative chairman of the Commons culture committee, is speaking now.
He says that Hunt should have had dealings with media companies. He was culture secretary.
/>Some seem to have suggested Mr Hunt should not have had a view about the bid by News Corp to acquire all of BSkyB. As secretary of state, one of his first responsibilities is he is the minister for the media industry of this country. It would have been extraordinary if the secretary of state had not had a view. BSkyB is one of the most important media companies in this country, it plays a vital part in the future of the media - of course he was going to have a view about it.
And many people will have had a view on whether the News Corporation bid for BSkyB should do ahead. As it happens, not only do I think he was entitled to have a view, I think he held the correct view.
But the important point is that Hunt set it aside, he says. This was such an important matter almost anybody who was given the responsibility was bound to have had a view.
The important thing was having been given the responsibility, he then put aside his view and judged it clearly and solely on the advice he received. That is precisely what he did.
2.05pm: Ian Lucas is still speaking. He says David Cameron used Sir Alex Allan for political advantage.2.05pm: Ian Lucas is still speaking. He says David Cameron used Sir Alex Allan for political advantage.
2.01pm: Labour's Ian Lucas is speaking now. He says Hunt will not be trusted to act impartially in the future. If Hunt has any dignity, he will accept that he should not be in post, Lucas says.2.01pm: Labour's Ian Lucas is speaking now. He says Hunt will not be trusted to act impartially in the future. If Hunt has any dignity, he will accept that he should not be in post, Lucas says.
1.56pm: Winding up, Hunt says that in taking the decisions he did about the News Corporation bid for BSkyB, he followed the procedure set out in the Enterprise Act passed by Labour.1.56pm: Winding up, Hunt says that in taking the decisions he did about the News Corporation bid for BSkyB, he followed the procedure set out in the Enterprise Act passed by Labour.
Some may say she has proved herself to be little better than the newspapers that she has so criticised.Some may say she has proved herself to be little better than the newspapers that she has so criticised.
I have spent six weeks being accountable for my actions and being proved right. she has spent six weeks cooking up allegations and being proved wrong.I have spent six weeks being accountable for my actions and being proved right. she has spent six weeks cooking up allegations and being proved wrong.
(I've taken this quote, and some others in the debate, from PoliticsHome.)(I've taken this quote, and some others in the debate, from PoliticsHome.)
1.54pm: Apparently John Bercow allowed Chris Byrant to accuse Jeremy Hunt of lying because, if MPs are debating a motion accusing a minister of providing inaccurate information to parliament, the normal rule about the term "liar" being banned does not apply.1.54pm: Apparently John Bercow allowed Chris Byrant to accuse Jeremy Hunt of lying because, if MPs are debating a motion accusing a minister of providing inaccurate information to parliament, the normal rule about the term "liar" being banned does not apply.
1.51pm: A Labour MP tells Adam Smith told Leveson that Hunt had told him that he had not done anything wrong.1.51pm: A Labour MP tells Adam Smith told Leveson that Hunt had told him that he had not done anything wrong.
Hunt says that some of Smith's actions were "inappropriate".Hunt says that some of Smith's actions were "inappropriate".
1.47pm: Hunt accuses Harman of double standards. She says that Tory ministers are responsible for the actions of their special advisers. But she never said that Labour ministers were guilty of a breach of the code when their special advisers misbehaved, he says.1.47pm: Hunt accuses Harman of double standards. She says that Tory ministers are responsible for the actions of their special advisers. But she never said that Labour ministers were guilty of a breach of the code when their special advisers misbehaved, he says.
1.46pm: A Labour MP asks how Hunt's request for a meeting with David Cameron was not an attempt to influence the decision.1.46pm: A Labour MP asks how Hunt's request for a meeting with David Cameron was not an attempt to influence the decision.
Hunt says his memo to Cameron explicitly said that the proper process had to be followed.Hunt says his memo to Cameron explicitly said that the proper process had to be followed.
1.45pm: Hunt turns to the issue of whether he was responsible for the actions of his special adviser.1.45pm: Hunt turns to the issue of whether he was responsible for the actions of his special adviser.
He says Adam Smith, his adviser, was a man of great integrity.He says Adam Smith, his adviser, was a man of great integrity.
1.44pm: Hunt resumes his speech.1.44pm: Hunt resumes his speech.
He says he made no intervention intended to influence Vince Cable's decision.He says he made no intervention intended to influence Vince Cable's decision.
1.36pm: Jeremy Hunt is responding now. He starts by addressing directly the claim that he misled parliament.1.36pm: Jeremy Hunt is responding now. He starts by addressing directly the claim that he misled parliament.
After his March 2011 statement about his exchanges with News Corporation, he subsquently answered another written question, in response to a question from Labour's John Mann, setting out in more detail his contacts with News Corporation. That answer explained what was and what was not being covered by the answer.After his March 2011 statement about his exchanges with News Corporation, he subsquently answered another written question, in response to a question from Labour's John Mann, setting out in more detail his contacts with News Corporation. That answer explained what was and what was not being covered by the answer.
Hunt says that Harman herself has experience of having to correct the record. He reads out a list of date on which Harman has had to do that.Hunt says that Harman herself has experience of having to correct the record. He reads out a list of date on which Harman has had to do that.
Labour's Chris Bryant says that Hunt could have told MPs about his contacts with News Corporation. He says Hunt lied to parliament.Labour's Chris Bryant says that Hunt could have told MPs about his contacts with News Corporation. He says Hunt lied to parliament.
John Bercow, the Speaker, appeals for calm. But he does not ask Bryant to withdraw.John Bercow, the Speaker, appeals for calm. But he does not ask Bryant to withdraw.
Sir George Young, the leader of the Commons, makes a point of order. He says accusing another member of lying is unparliamentary. He says Bercow should insist that Bryant withdraws the remark.Sir George Young, the leader of the Commons, makes a point of order. He says accusing another member of lying is unparliamentary. He says Bercow should insist that Bryant withdraws the remark.
Bercow says he has taken advice. He does not ask Bryant to withdraw. He says he thinks Bryant should use moderate language. He says he thinks Bryant will not use the term again.Bercow says he has taken advice. He does not ask Bryant to withdraw. He says he thinks Bryant should use moderate language. He says he thinks Bryant will not use the term again.
Hunt says he thinks Bercow should insist on Bryant withdrawing the remark. He invites Bryant to withdraw it.Hunt says he thinks Bercow should insist on Bryant withdrawing the remark. He invites Bryant to withdraw it.
Bryant says he hopes to make a speech later. He will set out why he thinks Hunt lied to MPs.Bryant says he hopes to make a speech later. He will set out why he thinks Hunt lied to MPs.
1.35pm: Harman has concluded. It was a fairly lacklustre speech, and certainly not one of her best.1.35pm: Harman has concluded. It was a fairly lacklustre speech, and certainly not one of her best.
1.34pm: Harman says the Commons cannot let breaches of the code be swept under the carpet.1.34pm: Harman says the Commons cannot let breaches of the code be swept under the carpet.
That's why MPs should vote in favour of the motion, she says.That's why MPs should vote in favour of the motion, she says.
1.32pm: Harman is now onto another alleged breach of the ministerial code - Hunt's failure to take responsibility for the work of his special adviser, Adam Smith.1.32pm: Harman is now onto another alleged breach of the ministerial code - Hunt's failure to take responsibility for the work of his special adviser, Adam Smith.
Either Hunt did not know what he was doing when Smith over-stepped the mark. That would have been a breach of the code. Or, "as people think more likely", Hunt did know what Smith was up to. That would also have been a breach of the code, Harman says. At the very least there is prima facie evidence that you failed to take responsibility for the management and conduct of your special adviser. Either you didn't know what he was doing when the special adviser was overstepping the mark and that was a breach of the code or, as people think more likely, you did know what he was doing when Adam Smith was overstepping the mark and that too would have been a breach of the code. Whichever way you look at it, there has been a clear breach of the ministerial code.
1.29pm: Harriet Harman is still speaking.1.29pm: Harriet Harman is still speaking.
On 19 November 2010 Hunt sent a memo to David Cameron setting out his views on the News Corp bid for BSkyB and asking for a meeting.On 19 November 2010 Hunt sent a memo to David Cameron setting out his views on the News Corp bid for BSkyB and asking for a meeting.
Hunt told parliament that he had not intervened when Vince Cable was in charge of the bid. But, by any definition, a letter to the PM is an intervention, Harman says.Hunt told parliament that he had not intervened when Vince Cable was in charge of the bid. But, by any definition, a letter to the PM is an intervention, Harman says.
1.21pm: Harriet Harman is speaking for Labour.1.21pm: Harriet Harman is speaking for Labour.
She says there should be an inquiry so that Sir Alex Allan can establish whether the facts show that the ministerial code has been broken.She says there should be an inquiry so that Sir Alex Allan can establish whether the facts show that the ministerial code has been broken.
Invited to criticise Sir Alex Allan for not being sufficiently independent, Harman says the exchange of letters is "nothing more than an attempt to distract and create a smokescreen".Invited to criticise Sir Alex Allan for not being sufficiently independent, Harman says the exchange of letters is "nothing more than an attempt to distract and create a smokescreen".
She says ministers are under an obligation to tell the truth to the Commons. They should correct an error at the earliest opportunity.She says ministers are under an obligation to tell the truth to the Commons. They should correct an error at the earliest opportunity.
Ministers who knowingly mislead parliament should resign, the ministerial code says. This is not just "some old-fashioned relic of pomposity". It matters, she says.Ministers who knowingly mislead parliament should resign, the ministerial code says. This is not just "some old-fashioned relic of pomposity". It matters, she says.
Jacob Rees-Mogg, a Conservative, says there is no suggestion that Hunt "knowingly" misled the Commons.Jacob Rees-Mogg, a Conservative, says there is no suggestion that Hunt "knowingly" misled the Commons.
Harman says the code says an error should be corrected at the earliest opportunity.Harman says the code says an error should be corrected at the earliest opportunity.
There is prima facie evidence Hunt failed to give accurate information to MPs, he says.There is prima facie evidence Hunt failed to give accurate information to MPs, he says.
On 3 March 2011 Hunt said he had published all the exchanges between his department and News Corporation.On 3 March 2011 Hunt said he had published all the exchanges between his department and News Corporation.
But when the Murdochs gave evidence to Leveson, it emerged that there had been "hundreds" of exchanges between his department and News Corporation that had not been published.But when the Murdochs gave evidence to Leveson, it emerged that there had been "hundreds" of exchanges between his department and News Corporation that had not been published.
Harriet has two piles of documents with her: the orginal ones disclosed by Hunt, and the ones setting out the full extent of the exchanges as revealed by the Leveson inquiry.Harriet has two piles of documents with her: the orginal ones disclosed by Hunt, and the ones setting out the full extent of the exchanges as revealed by the Leveson inquiry.
1.17pm:The Jeremy Hunt debate is starting now. MPs are debating a Labour motion. Here's the text.1.17pm:The Jeremy Hunt debate is starting now. MPs are debating a Labour motion. Here's the text.
That this House believes that the Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics, Media and Sport should be referred to the Independent Adviser on Ministers' Interests to investigate whether he breached paragraph 1.2c (giving accurate and truthful information to Parliament) and paragraph 3.3 (responsibility for his special adviser) of the Ministerial Code.That this House believes that the Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics, Media and Sport should be referred to the Independent Adviser on Ministers' Interests to investigate whether he breached paragraph 1.2c (giving accurate and truthful information to Parliament) and paragraph 3.3 (responsibility for his special adviser) of the Ministerial Code.
It has been tabled by Labour, but it has also been signed by Mark Durkan and Margaret Ritchie, the SDLP MPs, Elfyn Llwyd, the Plaid Cymru MP, Caroline Lucas, the Green MP, and Angus Robertson, the SNP MP.It has been tabled by Labour, but it has also been signed by Mark Durkan and Margaret Ritchie, the SDLP MPs, Elfyn Llwyd, the Plaid Cymru MP, Caroline Lucas, the Green MP, and Angus Robertson, the SNP MP.
And here's a debate reading list.And here's a debate reading list.
• Paul Waugh at PoliticsHome says David Cameron and Nick Clegg raised their voices when they discussed Jeremy Hunt's future in private.• Paul Waugh at PoliticsHome says David Cameron and Nick Clegg raised their voices when they discussed Jeremy Hunt's future in private.
Rather unusually, Clegg and Cameron raised their voices with each other when discussing the Hunt issue in private, I hear. The DPM was furious he was not consulted when the PM decided to give Hunt a swift endorsement after his Leveson appearance. The PM's decision to refer Baroness Warsi to Alex Allan makes the Government look inconsistent, the Libs mutter.Rather unusually, Clegg and Cameron raised their voices with each other when discussing the Hunt issue in private, I hear. The DPM was furious he was not consulted when the PM decided to give Hunt a swift endorsement after his Leveson appearance. The PM's decision to refer Baroness Warsi to Alex Allan makes the Government look inconsistent, the Libs mutter.


• Paul Goodman at ConservativeHome says today's Lib Dem abstention has set a new precedent for coalition whipping arrangments.

• Paul Goodman at ConservativeHome says today's Lib Dem abstention has set a new precedent for coalition whipping arrangments.
• James Forsyth at Coffee House says the Lib Dem decision shows that coalition ties are weakening.• James Forsyth at Coffee House says the Lib Dem decision shows that coalition ties are weakening.
The next time Hunt sits down at the Cabinet table, he'll know that several of those present don't think he should be there. That has got to affect the workings of government.The next time Hunt sits down at the Cabinet table, he'll know that several of those present don't think he should be there. That has got to affect the workings of government.


• Stephen Tall, the Lib Dem blogger, says it would be a mistake for the Lib Dems to vote with Labour.

• Stephen Tall, the Lib Dem blogger, says it would be a mistake for the Lib Dems to vote with Labour.

In any case, let's just imagine the Lib Dems did vote with Labour today. What would happen? Nothing. David Cameron would still not refer Jeremy Hunt to Sir Alex Allan. I don't see the point of the Lib Dems spending political capital best saved for the policy fights to come on trying to do the Tories a good turn by saving them from themselves.
In any case, let's just imagine the Lib Dems did vote with Labour today. What would happen? Nothing. David Cameron would still not refer Jeremy Hunt to Sir Alex Allan. I don't see the point of the Lib Dems spending political capital best saved for the policy fights to come on trying to do the Tories a good turn by saving them from themselves.
And if by some miracle Jeremy Hunt was forced to resign as a result of the Lib Dems voting with Labour — well, Mr Hunt would enjoy martyred status among his colleagues ('the Tory brought down by Lib Dem opportunism'), and he'd simply be replaced by another Conservative. Sorry if I fail to get overly excited by that prospect.And if by some miracle Jeremy Hunt was forced to resign as a result of the Lib Dems voting with Labour — well, Mr Hunt would enjoy martyred status among his colleagues ('the Tory brought down by Lib Dem opportunism'), and he'd simply be replaced by another Conservative. Sorry if I fail to get overly excited by that prospect.


• Eoin Clarke at Green Benches lists 10 reasons why he thinks Hunt should resign.

• Eoin Clarke at Green Benches lists 10 reasons why he thinks Hunt should resign.
1.15pm: The Falkland Islands statement is about to end. Harriet Harman, Labour's deputy leader and the shadow culture secretary, will then open the debate on Jeremy Hunt for Labour.1.15pm: The Falkland Islands statement is about to end. Harriet Harman, Labour's deputy leader and the shadow culture secretary, will then open the debate on Jeremy Hunt for Labour.
But, as a result of the Alex Allan letter, she will start at a huge disadvantage. Hunt (who will respond) will be able to say that Labour want to refer the case to an independent adviser who has already said there is no need for him to be involved.But, as a result of the Alex Allan letter, she will start at a huge disadvantage. Hunt (who will respond) will be able to say that Labour want to refer the case to an independent adviser who has already said there is no need for him to be involved.
This is the key sentence in the letter.This is the key sentence in the letter.

The fact that there is an on-going judicial Inquiry probing and taking evidence under oath means that I do not believe that I could usefully add to the facts in this case though I remain available should circumstances change or new evidence emerge.
The fact that there is an on-going judicial Inquiry probing and taking evidence under oath means that I do not believe that I could usefully add to the facts in this case though I remain available should circumstances change or new evidence emerge.

But Labour will be able to say that Sir Alex Allan does not really need to examine the facts. Most of them are known. An inquiry would allow Allan to make a judgment about whether those facts amount to a breach of the ministerial code.
But Labour will be able to say that Sir Alex Allan does not really need to examine the facts. Most of them are known. An inquiry would allow Allan to make a judgment about whether those facts amount to a breach of the ministerial code.
1.02pm: Here's some Twitter comment on the PMQs exchanges.1.02pm: Here's some Twitter comment on the PMQs exchanges.
From Labour MP Chris BryantFrom Labour MP Chris Bryant
A) the Alex Allan letter doesn't quite read as the pm represented it B) it's a bit suspicious that the pm wrote today and got a reply todayA) the Alex Allan letter doesn't quite read as the pm represented it B) it's a bit suspicious that the pm wrote today and got a reply today
— Chris Bryant (@ChrisBryantMP) June 13, 2012— Chris Bryant (@ChrisBryantMP) June 13, 2012
From the Conservative MP Matthew HancockFrom the Conservative MP Matthew Hancock
I think @Ed_Miliband asked only about #leveson because only topic on which he feels comfortable. PMQs today shows he has nothing to sayI think @Ed_Miliband asked only about #leveson because only topic on which he feels comfortable. PMQs today shows he has nothing to say
— Matthew Hancock (@matthancockmp) June 13, 2012— Matthew Hancock (@matthancockmp) June 13, 2012
From the Daily Mail's Tim ShipmanFrom the Daily Mail's Tim Shipman
Labour source says Alex Allan letter is a 'smokescreen'. 'We know what the facts are. The questions are about the PM's judgment'.Labour source says Alex Allan letter is a 'smokescreen'. 'We know what the facts are. The questions are about the PM's judgment'.
— Tim Shipman (Mail) (@ShippersUnbound) June 13, 2012— Tim Shipman (Mail) (@ShippersUnbound) June 13, 2012
From the Observer's Toby HelmFrom the Observer's Toby Helm
Osborne pats cameron on back as he leaves chamber as if to say "one more heave and we're through." I wonder.Osborne pats cameron on back as he leaves chamber as if to say "one more heave and we're through." I wonder.
— Toby Helm (@tobyhelm) June 13, 2012— Toby Helm (@tobyhelm) June 13, 2012
From ITN's Tom BradbyFrom ITN's Tom Bradby
Is it me, or is it simply staggering that there has been only one fleeting reference to the eurozone crisis and not one question on Syria?Is it me, or is it simply staggering that there has been only one fleeting reference to the eurozone crisis and not one question on Syria?
— tom bradby (@tombradby) June 13, 2012— tom bradby (@tombradby) June 13, 2012
12.44pm: PMQs Verdict: So far, Jeremy Hunt survived unscathed. Ed Miliband devoted all six of his questions to the Hunt affair, focusing on the glaring inconsistency (explained superbly in Andrew Rawnsley Observer column this weekend) between Cameron's decision to refer Lady Warsi to the independent adviser on minister's interests but not Jeremy Hunt. But Cameron had a surprise weapon up his sleeve and the quote from Sir Alex Allan saying he does not believe he could "usefully add to the facts in this case" blunted what was otherwise a good performance from Miliband. (Although, as I explained at 12.41pm, the full text of the letter is not quite as exculpatory as Cameron implied.)12.44pm: PMQs Verdict: So far, Jeremy Hunt survived unscathed. Ed Miliband devoted all six of his questions to the Hunt affair, focusing on the glaring inconsistency (explained superbly in Andrew Rawnsley Observer column this weekend) between Cameron's decision to refer Lady Warsi to the independent adviser on minister's interests but not Jeremy Hunt. But Cameron had a surprise weapon up his sleeve and the quote from Sir Alex Allan saying he does not believe he could "usefully add to the facts in this case" blunted what was otherwise a good performance from Miliband. (Although, as I explained at 12.41pm, the full text of the letter is not quite as exculpatory as Cameron implied.)
Cameron was also affecting at addressing the "coalition split" question. At PMQs it is generally best to tell the truth and Cameron's reply when asked why Nick Clegg was not supporting him - "it's politics" - was a perfect example. Slyly, Cameron also managed to make the point that the Lib Dems could afford to take a different stance because they never had a relationship with the Murdochs.Cameron was also affecting at addressing the "coalition split" question. At PMQs it is generally best to tell the truth and Cameron's reply when asked why Nick Clegg was not supporting him - "it's politics" - was a perfect example. Slyly, Cameron also managed to make the point that the Lib Dems could afford to take a different stance because they never had a relationship with the Murdochs.
To be fair to the Liberal Democrats, they didn't have that relationship [with News International} and their abstention tonight is to make that point and I understand that, it's politics.To be fair to the Liberal Democrats, they didn't have that relationship [with News International} and their abstention tonight is to make that point and I understand that, it's politics.
Cameron did not say that the Lib Dems did not have a relationship with News International because News International considered them irrelevant. But, of course, he didn't need to.Cameron did not say that the Lib Dems did not have a relationship with News International because News International considered them irrelevant. But, of course, he didn't need to.
And while we're on the subject of telling the truth, did you notice that Cameron implicitly accused Gordon Brown of lying to the Leveson inquiry. He disguised it as a joke, but the implication was very clear. It would be good to hear Robert Jay probe Cameron on this tomorrow.And while we're on the subject of telling the truth, did you notice that Cameron implicitly accused Gordon Brown of lying to the Leveson inquiry. He disguised it as a joke, but the implication was very clear. It would be good to hear Robert Jay probe Cameron on this tomorrow.
12.41pm: At the Leveson inquiry this morning Nick Clegg backed Jeremy Hunt, saying he has given a "full, good and convincing account" of News Corp's BSkyB bid. He said he accepted Lord O'Donnell's assurances that Hunt would act "objectively" in handling the bid.12.41pm: At the Leveson inquiry this morning Nick Clegg backed Jeremy Hunt, saying he has given a "full, good and convincing account" of News Corp's BSkyB bid. He said he accepted Lord O'Donnell's assurances that Hunt would act "objectively" in handling the bid.
There are more details on our Leveson live blog.There are more details on our Leveson live blog.
12.39pm: David Lidington, the Foreign Office minister, is now making a statement about the Falkland Islands. That means the Hunt debate won't start until around 1pm.12.39pm: David Lidington, the Foreign Office minister, is now making a statement about the Falkland Islands. That means the Hunt debate won't start until around 1pm.
12.34pm: Here is the full text of the letter that David Cameron send to Sir Alex Allan about Jeremy Hunt.12.34pm: Here is the full text of the letter that David Cameron send to Sir Alex Allan about Jeremy Hunt.
Dear Sir Alex AllanDear Sir Alex Allan
You will be aware that I will this week be giving evidence to the Leveson Inquiry. As you know, I have decided not to refer Jeremy Hunt to you as I am satisfied that the relevant information about this issue has been established and I am content that he did not break the ministerial code.You will be aware that I will this week be giving evidence to the Leveson Inquiry. As you know, I have decided not to refer Jeremy Hunt to you as I am satisfied that the relevant information about this issue has been established and I am content that he did not break the ministerial code.
Separately, I will be outlining to Leveson some of the initiatives this Government has taken to strengthen accountability and transparency as well as some areas where I am proposing future changes to the current guidance. These include the conduct of special advisers and the handling of quasi-judicial decisions and I would welcome your comments.Separately, I will be outlining to Leveson some of the initiatives this Government has taken to strengthen accountability and transparency as well as some areas where I am proposing future changes to the current guidance. These include the conduct of special advisers and the handling of quasi-judicial decisions and I would welcome your comments.
Yours sincerelyYours sincerely
David Cameron MPDavid Cameron MP
And here is the full text of Allan's reply.And here is the full text of Allan's reply.

Prime Minister,

Thank you for your letter of 13 June. I note your decision in relation to Jeremy Hunt's adherence to the Ministerial Code which is of course a matter for you. The fact that there is an on-going judicial Inquiry probing and taking evidence under oath means that I do not believe that I could usefully add to the facts in this case though I remain available should circumstances change or new evidence emerge.
Prime Minister,

Thank you for your letter of 13 June. I note your decision in relation to Jeremy Hunt's adherence to the Ministerial Code which is of course a matter for you. The fact that there is an on-going judicial Inquiry probing and taking evidence under oath means that I do not believe that I could usefully add to the facts in this case though I remain available should circumstances change or new evidence emerge.
On the broader issues I would welcome the opportunity to comment in more detail before the new guidance is finalised.On the broader issues I would welcome the opportunity to comment in more detail before the new guidance is finalised.
Yours sincerelyYours sincerely
Sir Alex AllanSir Alex Allan
At PMQs Cameron read out the line about Allan not being able to "add to the facts in this case", implying that Allan did not want to be involved.At PMQs Cameron read out the line about Allan not being able to "add to the facts in this case", implying that Allan did not want to be involved.
But the full sentence suggests that Allan would be willing to investigate Hunt's case at a later stage.But the full sentence suggests that Allan would be willing to investigate Hunt's case at a later stage.
Cabinet OfficeCabinet Office
70 Whitehall70 Whitehall
12.32pm: Mark Durkan, the SDLP MP, asks for a meeting with the Treasury to discuss the way HM Revenue & Customs imposes duty on alcohol products produced for export. Cameron says that he understands there is an issue here, and that he will be happy to arrange a meeting.12.32pm: Mark Durkan, the SDLP MP, asks for a meeting with the Treasury to discuss the way HM Revenue & Customs imposes duty on alcohol products produced for export. Cameron says that he understands there is an issue here, and that he will be happy to arrange a meeting.
12.31pm: David Burrowes, a Conservative, asks Cameron to block the extradition of Gary McKinnon. Cameron says the home secretary is still considering medical evidence that has been submitted.12.31pm: David Burrowes, a Conservative, asks Cameron to block the extradition of Gary McKinnon. Cameron says the home secretary is still considering medical evidence that has been submitted.
12.29pm: Labour's Steve Rotheram asks Cameron if he has run out of steam, or if the job is too big for him.12.29pm: Labour's Steve Rotheram asks Cameron if he has run out of steam, or if the job is too big for him.
Cameron says he is glad Michael Gove has introduced poetry learning in schools. Perhaps they could start with Rotheram.Cameron says he is glad Michael Gove has introduced poetry learning in schools. Perhaps they could start with Rotheram.
Labour MPs shout about Cameron being rude.Labour MPs shout about Cameron being rude.
12.28pm: Cameron says the government has saved money by not contributing to Eurozone bailouts.12.28pm: Cameron says the government has saved money by not contributing to Eurozone bailouts.
12.26pm: Labour's Alison Seabeck says coalition benefit changes have led to the number of people using food banks in Plymouth going up from 790 last year to more than 4,000 this year.12.26pm: Labour's Alison Seabeck says coalition benefit changes have led to the number of people using food banks in Plymouth going up from 790 last year to more than 4,000 this year.
Cameron praises the people who run food banks. But it was right to put a cap on benefit payments, he says.Cameron praises the people who run food banks. But it was right to put a cap on benefit payments, he says.
12.25pm: Cameron says the King's Fund report about the decline in satisfaction with the NHS said there was no evidence that performance had declined. The NHS is performing extremely well, he says.12.25pm: Cameron says the King's Fund report about the decline in satisfaction with the NHS said there was no evidence that performance had declined. The NHS is performing extremely well, he says.
12.23pm: Labour's Tristram Hunt says Cameron gave a speech before the election attacking "crony capitalism". It described the Conservatives' relationship with the Murdoch's perfectly.12.23pm: Labour's Tristram Hunt says Cameron gave a speech before the election attacking "crony capitalism". It described the Conservatives' relationship with the Murdoch's perfectly.
Cameron says that Tristram Hunt would earn a place in the Olympic team for hypocrisy because of Labour's own dealings with the Murdochs.Cameron says that Tristram Hunt would earn a place in the Olympic team for hypocrisy because of Labour's own dealings with the Murdochs.
12.22pm: Kris Hopkins, a Conservative, asks if the government will start HS2 in north Yorkshire.12.22pm: Kris Hopkins, a Conservative, asks if the government will start HS2 in north Yorkshire.
Cameron says he is very keen to press ahead with the policy.Cameron says he is very keen to press ahead with the policy.
12.21pm: Cameron says the government is putting record sums into the health service. But he won't criticise volunteers who raise funds for the NHS.12.21pm: Cameron says the government is putting record sums into the health service. But he won't criticise volunteers who raise funds for the NHS.
A survey of people who use the NHS found that 92% of people rated it as good, very good or excellent.A survey of people who use the NHS found that 92% of people rated it as good, very good or excellent.
12.20pm: Fiona Bruce, a Conservative, asks about a waste incinerator in her constituency.12.20pm: Fiona Bruce, a Conservative, asks about a waste incinerator in her constituency.
Cameron says there is an appeals process for this decision.Cameron says there is an appeals process for this decision.
12.19pm: Elfyn Llwyd, the Plaid Cymru MP, asks why ministers are being briefed and coached by lawyers before giving evidence to Leveson.12.19pm: Elfyn Llwyd, the Plaid Cymru MP, asks why ministers are being briefed and coached by lawyers before giving evidence to Leveson.
Cameron says ministers have to familiarise themselves with a huge amount of material.Cameron says ministers have to familiarise themselves with a huge amount of material.
12.16pm: In response to a closed question, Cameron says the cabinet sometimes meets outside London.12.16pm: In response to a closed question, Cameron says the cabinet sometimes meets outside London.
Philip Hollobone, a Conservative, says that if it were to come to Kettering, it would be able to congratulate the local Conservative council.Philip Hollobone, a Conservative, says that if it were to come to Kettering, it would be able to congratulate the local Conservative council.
12.15pm: Cameron welcomes the fact that there will be a memorial to Bomber Command. He will consider whether it should receive government funding.12.15pm: Cameron welcomes the fact that there will be a memorial to Bomber Command. He will consider whether it should receive government funding.
12.14pm: PMQs snap verdict: A vintage bust-up, without any clear winner, but with strong performances from both Miliband and Cameron.12.14pm: PMQs snap verdict: A vintage bust-up, without any clear winner, but with strong performances from both Miliband and Cameron.
12.10pm: Miliband says Cameron has reached a new state of delusion. He just wants to talk about the past. He was the future once (a line Cameron famously used against Tony Blair when Cameron first became Tory leader). He says Cameron is not referring Hunt to Sir Alex Allan because he is "scared he won't be cleared".12.10pm: Miliband says Cameron has reached a new state of delusion. He just wants to talk about the past. He was the future once (a line Cameron famously used against Tony Blair when Cameron first became Tory leader). He says Cameron is not referring Hunt to Sir Alex Allan because he is "scared he won't be cleared".
Cameron says imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. This inquiry is about the past, he says. Gordon Brown told Leveson that no one in his position would have instructed an aide to brief against a senior minister. He invites the victims to put their hands up. "I don't need Sir Alex Allan to adjudicate on that one," he says.Cameron says imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. This inquiry is about the past, he says. Gordon Brown told Leveson that no one in his position would have instructed an aide to brief against a senior minister. He invites the victims to put their hands up. "I don't need Sir Alex Allan to adjudicate on that one," he says.
Miliband says this is not about the culture secretary's judgment; it's about Cameron's judgment.Miliband says this is not about the culture secretary's judgment; it's about Cameron's judgment.
Cameron says he hopes the England football team are better at putting the ball in the back of the neck. Hunt should be allowed to get on with the Olympics. If there was an Olympic medal for double standards and hypocrisy, Labour would win it.Cameron says he hopes the England football team are better at putting the ball in the back of the neck. Hunt should be allowed to get on with the Olympics. If there was an Olympic medal for double standards and hypocrisy, Labour would win it.
12.05pm: Miliband says Leveson himself said he would not be looking into the ministerial code. Referring to the heckling, he quotes from a leaked email from Desmond Swayne, Cameron's PPS, about the need to heckle Miliband. He asks Cameron to confirm that Hunt misled the Commons when he said he had not intervened when Vince Cable was handling the News Corporation bid for BSkyB.12.05pm: Miliband says Leveson himself said he would not be looking into the ministerial code. Referring to the heckling, he quotes from a leaked email from Desmond Swayne, Cameron's PPS, about the need to heckle Miliband. He asks Cameron to confirm that Hunt misled the Commons when he said he had not intervened when Vince Cable was handling the News Corporation bid for BSkyB.
Cameron says Sir Alex Allan himself has said he could not usefully add to what the Leveson inquiry had done to establish the facts. In Hunt's note to Cameron in November 2010, Hunt said it would be wrong not to follow the proper procedures in relation to the bid.Cameron says Sir Alex Allan himself has said he could not usefully add to what the Leveson inquiry had done to establish the facts. In Hunt's note to Cameron in November 2010, Hunt said it would be wrong not to follow the proper procedures in relation to the bid.
Miliband says Hunt told the Commons he made no interventions. Is Cameron saying a memo to the PM is of no significance? If Cameron's case is so strong, why is Nick Clegg not supporting him?Miliband says Hunt told the Commons he made no interventions. Is Cameron saying a memo to the PM is of no significance? If Cameron's case is so strong, why is Nick Clegg not supporting him?
Cameron quotes from the November 2010 memo where Hunt said the proper procedure had to be followed. MPs are discussing the takeover because Labour changed the law to allow a foreign company to hold a broadcasting licence. On the subject of the Lib Dems, he says they did not have a relationship with the Murdoch empire. They are abstaining to make that point. Cameron says he understands that; that's politics.Cameron quotes from the November 2010 memo where Hunt said the proper procedure had to be followed. MPs are discussing the takeover because Labour changed the law to allow a foreign company to hold a broadcasting licence. On the subject of the Lib Dems, he says they did not have a relationship with the Murdoch empire. They are abstaining to make that point. Cameron says he understands that; that's politics.
12.02pm: Ed Milband asks why Lady Warsi was referred to the independent adviser on minster's interests but not Jeremy Hunt.12.02pm: Ed Milband asks why Lady Warsi was referred to the independent adviser on minster's interests but not Jeremy Hunt.
Camerons says there is a key difference. Lady Warsi's case has not been examined by a judge-led inquiry. Cameron says he is happy with the explanation given by Warsi. She has admitted breaking the ministerial code.Camerons says there is a key difference. Lady Warsi's case has not been examined by a judge-led inquiry. Cameron says he is happy with the explanation given by Warsi. She has admitted breaking the ministerial code.
Miliband says Leveson did not ask Hunt about whether he misled the Commons.Miliband says Leveson did not ask Hunt about whether he misled the Commons.
Cameron says he has consulted Sir Alex Allan, the independent adviser, about the need for guidelines on handling quasi-judicial decision. He quotes from Allan's reply to him. Allan said he accepted that it was up to Cameron to decide whether there should be an investigation and he said he could not usefully add to the work of the Leveson inquiry.Cameron says he has consulted Sir Alex Allan, the independent adviser, about the need for guidelines on handling quasi-judicial decision. He quotes from Allan's reply to him. Allan said he accepted that it was up to Cameron to decide whether there should be an investigation and he said he could not usefully add to the work of the Leveson inquiry.
12.01pm: Zac Goldsmith, a Conservative, asks for an assurance that the government will not back a third runway at Heathrow.12.01pm: Zac Goldsmith, a Conservative, asks for an assurance that the government will not back a third runway at Heathrow.
Cameron says the coalition position (against) has not changed. But the government must look at how to expand airport capacity generally.Cameron says the coalition position (against) has not changed. But the government must look at how to expand airport capacity generally.
12.00pm: David Cameron starts with a tribute to three soldiers killed in Afghanistan since the last PMQs.12.00pm: David Cameron starts with a tribute to three soldiers killed in Afghanistan since the last PMQs.
11.55am: PMQs is about to start. At the weekend John Bercow, the Speaker, accused MPs how behave badly at PMQs of "juvenile delinquency".11.55am: PMQs is about to start. At the weekend John Bercow, the Speaker, accused MPs how behave badly at PMQs of "juvenile delinquency".

It's a kind of juvenile delinquency, but when it manifests itself in people in their 40s, 50s and even 60s it's a bit sad.
It's a kind of juvenile delinquency, but when it manifests itself in people in their 40s, 50s and even 60s it's a bit sad.
Will the chamber sound any quieter today as a result? Almost certainly, no.Will the chamber sound any quieter today as a result? Almost certainly, no.
11.19am: You can read all today's Guardian politics stories here. And all the politics stories filed yesterday, including some in today's paper, are here.11.19am: You can read all today's Guardian politics stories here. And all the politics stories filed yesterday, including some in today's paper, are here.
As for the rest of the of the papers, here are some stories and articles that are particularly interesting.As for the rest of the of the papers, here are some stories and articles that are particularly interesting.
• Roland Watson and Sam Fleming in the Times (paywall) say George Osborne wants business leaders to campaign more aggressively for lower taxes.• Roland Watson and Sam Fleming in the Times (paywall) say George Osborne wants business leaders to campaign more aggressively for lower taxes.
Business must shout louder for the merits of lower taxes or the Government will be unable to cut the top rate of income tax to 40p, George Osborne warned yesterday.Business must shout louder for the merits of lower taxes or the Government will be unable to cut the top rate of income tax to 40p, George Osborne warned yesterday.
The Chancellor said that Britain was vulnerable to a return to the "politics of envy" and that anti-business sentiment was on the rise.The Chancellor said that Britain was vulnerable to a return to the "politics of envy" and that anti-business sentiment was on the rise.
Mr Osborne accepted that the Budget had caused "lots of bad headlines", but he chastised bosses for the "near silence" with which they had greeted his politically tough decision to lower the top rate of tax from 50p to 45p. And he urged business leaders to be much more vocal in helping the Conservatives to make the case for a low tax economy and a smaller State. Without such support Chancellors would find it hard to "put their necks on the line" for cuts in the top rate of tax.Mr Osborne accepted that the Budget had caused "lots of bad headlines", but he chastised bosses for the "near silence" with which they had greeted his politically tough decision to lower the top rate of tax from 50p to 45p. And he urged business leaders to be much more vocal in helping the Conservatives to make the case for a low tax economy and a smaller State. Without such support Chancellors would find it hard to "put their necks on the line" for cuts in the top rate of tax.
Mr Osborne told The Times CEO Summit: "If your voice is not heard then elected politicians are going to find it very difficult to put together pro-business packages because you leave the space open to everyone else."Mr Osborne told The Times CEO Summit: "If your voice is not heard then elected politicians are going to find it very difficult to put together pro-business packages because you leave the space open to everyone else."
• Benedict Brogan in the Daily Telegraph says that, if the euro breaks up, George Osborne may introduced emergency unfunded tax cuts.• Benedict Brogan in the Daily Telegraph says that, if the euro breaks up, George Osborne may introduced emergency unfunded tax cuts.
If things get worse – certainly if the euro breaks up – then all bets are off and Mr Osborne will be freed of the constraints of the Coalition. He will have permission to do things that he does not currently contemplate, including unfunded tax cuts and a radical paring-down of employment regulations. Privately, he recognises this may become necessary. Tory MPs speak of an emergency Budget acting as a defibrillator on a moribund economy, with tax cuts and a programme to pump credit straight to businesses, possibly through the state-owned RBS.If things get worse – certainly if the euro breaks up – then all bets are off and Mr Osborne will be freed of the constraints of the Coalition. He will have permission to do things that he does not currently contemplate, including unfunded tax cuts and a radical paring-down of employment regulations. Privately, he recognises this may become necessary. Tory MPs speak of an emergency Budget acting as a defibrillator on a moribund economy, with tax cuts and a programme to pump credit straight to businesses, possibly through the state-owned RBS.
• Daniel Finkelstein in the Times (paywall) says that a referendum on Britain's membership of the EU is now inevitable.• Daniel Finkelstein in the Times (paywall) says that a referendum on Britain's membership of the EU is now inevitable.

The common lesson of thin ends is that you make decisions much earlier than you think you do. At a stage when you may not even know where you are going, you choose a path. So it is proving with the European Union.
The common lesson of thin ends is that you make decisions much earlier than you think you do. At a stage when you may not even know where you are going, you choose a path. So it is proving with the European Union.
The question of whether there will be, or should be, a referendum on our continued membership and the terms of that membership is the hottest topic in politics. Too late. We've already made that decision. There will be one. It's just that only now are we realising it.The question of whether there will be, or should be, a referendum on our continued membership and the terms of that membership is the hottest topic in politics. Too late. We've already made that decision. There will be one. It's just that only now are we realising it.
Two decisions already taken, one long ago, have put us on the path to a national vote that it is virtually impossible to avoid. The first is the creation of the euro and our refusal to join it. The second is the passing of the Referendum Act by this Government.Two decisions already taken, one long ago, have put us on the path to a national vote that it is virtually impossible to avoid. The first is the creation of the euro and our refusal to join it. The second is the passing of the Referendum Act by this Government.
11.03am: The GMB union has published research today showing that 248 of the 1,000 people on the Sunday Times rich list have given money to the Conservative party. They have donated £83m. The GMB press release about it is here and here's the report with the full details (pdf). Paul Kenny (pictured), the GMB general secretary, says this shows the Conservatives are the party of the rich.11.03am: The GMB union has published research today showing that 248 of the 1,000 people on the Sunday Times rich list have given money to the Conservative party. They have donated £83m. The GMB press release about it is here and here's the report with the full details (pdf). Paul Kenny (pictured), the GMB general secretary, says this shows the Conservatives are the party of the rich.

It is clear that the wealthy look to the Tory Party to protect their interests and they have been repaid with policies like the change in income tax, down from 50p to 45p. This is not philanthropy. It is an investment by an elite in an elite to look after their interests. These revelations that the Tory party is funded to such an extent by the rich and elite of our country is a shocking indictment of the real allegiance of the Tory party.
It is clear that the wealthy look to the Tory Party to protect their interests and they have been repaid with policies like the change in income tax, down from 50p to 45p. This is not philanthropy. It is an investment by an elite in an elite to look after their interests. These revelations that the Tory party is funded to such an extent by the rich and elite of our country is a shocking indictment of the real allegiance of the Tory party.
10.49am: David Blunkett, the Labour former education secretary, is campaigning for teenagers from poor families who attend a sixth-form college to be allowed free school meals. In an article for epolitix, he says that it is unfair that if they attend a school with a sixth form they can get free school meals but that if they attend a sixth-form college they can't.10.49am: David Blunkett, the Labour former education secretary, is campaigning for teenagers from poor families who attend a sixth-form college to be allowed free school meals. In an article for epolitix, he says that it is unfair that if they attend a school with a sixth form they can get free school meals but that if they attend a sixth-form college they can't.
There are times when politicians can have a genuine argument about what constitutes 'fairness'.There are times when politicians can have a genuine argument about what constitutes 'fairness'.
When, however, over 100,000 young people are denied provision which is available to the rest, and those 100,00 plus are some of the most disadvantaged young people in the country, any argument that the system is fair doesn't stand up to scrutiny for a single moment.When, however, over 100,000 young people are denied provision which is available to the rest, and those 100,00 plus are some of the most disadvantaged young people in the country, any argument that the system is fair doesn't stand up to scrutiny for a single moment.
That is the situation with young people across England who attend sixth form colleges and 16-18 courses in further education.That is the situation with young people across England who attend sixth form colleges and 16-18 courses in further education.
10.23am: Here's some more Twitter comment on the Hunt vote.10.23am: Here's some more Twitter comment on the Hunt vote.
From the BBC's Norman SmithFrom the BBC's Norman Smith
Jeremy Hunt to defend himself/ answer for Govt in key Commons debatethis afternoon on whether there shd be inquiry into his conduct.Jeremy Hunt to defend himself/ answer for Govt in key Commons debatethis afternoon on whether there shd be inquiry into his conduct.
— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012
Smoke signals indicate Clegg will not be in chamber for Hunt debate (or PMQs cos Leveson). But will PM stay to hear Hunt ??? #levesonSmoke signals indicate Clegg will not be in chamber for Hunt debate (or PMQs cos Leveson). But will PM stay to hear Hunt ??? #leveson
— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012
From the Tory MP Conor BurnsFrom the Tory MP Conor Burns
Why doesn't someone ask Clegg the obvious: 'isn't it the case that Murdoch didn't court you because you and the LibDems are irrelevant?Why doesn't someone ask Clegg the obvious: 'isn't it the case that Murdoch didn't court you because you and the LibDems are irrelevant?
— Conor Burns MP (@Conor_BurnsMP) June 13, 2012— Conor Burns MP (@Conor_BurnsMP) June 13, 2012
10.12am: Paul Flynn, the Labour MP who sits on the public administration committee, told BBC News that today's vote was not just about Jeremy Hunt; it was about the status of the independent adviser on ministers' interests. Labour created the independent adviser post, but the adviser (currently Sir Alex Allan) can only carry out an investigation if the prime minister calls for one. Flynn said the adviser should be able to initiate his own inquiries.10.12am: Paul Flynn, the Labour MP who sits on the public administration committee, told BBC News that today's vote was not just about Jeremy Hunt; it was about the status of the independent adviser on ministers' interests. Labour created the independent adviser post, but the adviser (currently Sir Alex Allan) can only carry out an investigation if the prime minister calls for one. Flynn said the adviser should be able to initiate his own inquiries.
The committee is going to have a look at this reform of the ministerial code that was introduce five years ago, and it was a splendid reform that was meant to get some controls and independent surveillance o the conduct of ministers. It was used once under the Labour government, it should have been used at least three times under the present government, but they dodged it. And I'm afraid that what the Tories have done, having come in saying 'we're going to clean up the old sleaze, we're going to be the most transparent government ever', and they've now created new sleaze.The committee is going to have a look at this reform of the ministerial code that was introduce five years ago, and it was a splendid reform that was meant to get some controls and independent surveillance o the conduct of ministers. It was used once under the Labour government, it should have been used at least three times under the present government, but they dodged it. And I'm afraid that what the Tories have done, having come in saying 'we're going to clean up the old sleaze, we're going to be the most transparent government ever', and they've now created new sleaze.
I've taken the quotes from PoliticsHome.I've taken the quotes from PoliticsHome.
10.04am: Nick Clegg has now started his evidence to the Leveson inquiry.10.04am: Nick Clegg has now started his evidence to the Leveson inquiry.
You can follow the proceedings on our Leveson live blog.You can follow the proceedings on our Leveson live blog.
9.50am: Jo Swinson (pictured), the Lib Dem MP and Nick Clegg's parliamentary private secretary, has been giving interviews about this afternoon vote. Like Don Foster (see 9.15am), she's been playing down the significance of the Lib Dem decision to abstain. I've taken the quote from PoliticsHome.9.50am: Jo Swinson (pictured), the Lib Dem MP and Nick Clegg's parliamentary private secretary, has been giving interviews about this afternoon vote. Like Don Foster (see 9.15am), she's been playing down the significance of the Lib Dem decision to abstain. I've taken the quote from PoliticsHome.

No doubt there will be some tensions, but it's inevitable that when you have two different parties that are coming together in the national interest to sort out an economic mess, there will nonetheless be some issues where there is still disagreement. We are after all two independent parties, and so from time to time there will be some disagreements. That's something that we have to deal with. It doesn't stop ministers getting on and working in the national interest in department across Whitehall today and in the future as well.
No doubt there will be some tensions, but it's inevitable that when you have two different parties that are coming together in the national interest to sort out an economic mess, there will nonetheless be some issues where there is still disagreement. We are after all two independent parties, and so from time to time there will be some disagreements. That's something that we have to deal with. It doesn't stop ministers getting on and working in the national interest in department across Whitehall today and in the future as well.

She also claimed that the Lib Dem decision to abstain was not an attack on Jeremy Hunt.
She also claimed that the Lib Dem decision to abstain was not an attack on Jeremy Hunt.
I think it's worth pointing out that this is not a judgement on Jeremy Hunt. We're saying that we think there were questions remaining to be answered after Leveson, and in fact those were particularly around the ministerial code, not actually around the process of how he undertook the bid, because I think that has been properly explained at Leveson.I think it's worth pointing out that this is not a judgement on Jeremy Hunt. We're saying that we think there were questions remaining to be answered after Leveson, and in fact those were particularly around the ministerial code, not actually around the process of how he undertook the bid, because I think that has been properly explained at Leveson.
9.19am: Here's some Twitter comment on today's vote.9.19am: Here's some Twitter comment on today's vote.
From Tory MP Gavin BarwellFrom Tory MP Gavin Barwell
Lib Dem MPs should think about precedent they're setting today. What happens if Con MPs abstain next time Labour target a Lib Dem Minister?Lib Dem MPs should think about precedent they're setting today. What happens if Con MPs abstain next time Labour target a Lib Dem Minister?
— Gavin Barwell MP (@GavinBarwellMP) June 13, 2012— Gavin Barwell MP (@GavinBarwellMP) June 13, 2012
From the Guardian's Patrick WintourFrom the Guardian's Patrick Wintour
Lib Dems say they cannot vote with Labour because they lied about the Iraq war but Labour is led by a leader that says he opposed the war.Lib Dems say they cannot vote with Labour because they lied about the Iraq war but Labour is led by a leader that says he opposed the war.
— Patrick Wintour (@patrickwintour) June 13, 2012— Patrick Wintour (@patrickwintour) June 13, 2012
Lib Dems justify abstention saying the vote will make no difference to PM's decision and precedent is to abstain when coalition disagrees.Lib Dems justify abstention saying the vote will make no difference to PM's decision and precedent is to abstain when coalition disagrees.
— Patrick Wintour (@patrickwintour) June 13, 2012— Patrick Wintour (@patrickwintour) June 13, 2012
Lib Dems not confirming BBC report that Cameron told Clegg why are you bothering with Leveson, no one cares.Lib Dems not confirming BBC report that Cameron told Clegg why are you bothering with Leveson, no one cares.
— Patrick Wintour (@patrickwintour) June 13, 2012— Patrick Wintour (@patrickwintour) June 13, 2012
From the BBC's Norman SmithFrom the BBC's Norman Smith
Tory MPs warning of "pay back" forwhat they say is Clegg treachery over Hunt by scuppering Lords reformTory MPs warning of "pay back" forwhat they say is Clegg treachery over Hunt by scuppering Lords reform
— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012
Tory MPs urging Cameron to take a stand against Clegg..."show who's boss"Tory MPs urging Cameron to take a stand against Clegg..."show who's boss"
— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012
Revenge for Hunt ?? Tory MPssay there could be a vote on Lords reform before recess (programme motion) which cd scupper billRevenge for Hunt ?? Tory MPssay there could be a vote on Lords reform before recess (programme motion) which cd scupper bill
— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012— norman smith (@BBCNormanS) June 13, 2012
From PoliticsHome's Paul WaughFrom PoliticsHome's Paul Waugh
The Tory MP (@JTomlinsonMP) who's been hauled back frm honeymoon for Hunt vote, has a sense of humour. Just tweeted link to his wedding pix.The Tory MP (@JTomlinsonMP) who's been hauled back frm honeymoon for Hunt vote, has a sense of humour. Just tweeted link to his wedding pix.
— Paul Waugh (@paulwaugh) June 13, 2012— Paul Waugh (@paulwaugh) June 13, 2012
Tory @GlynDaviesMP is also missing a funeral cos of Hunt vote. As he Tweeted: "I utterly dislike the Lib Dems.." (via @colinko)Tory @GlynDaviesMP is also missing a funeral cos of Hunt vote. As he Tweeted: "I utterly dislike the Lib Dems.." (via @colinko)
— Paul Waugh (@paulwaugh) June 13, 2012— Paul Waugh (@paulwaugh) June 13, 2012
From Alex Belardinelli, an aide to Ed BallsFrom Alex Belardinelli, an aide to Ed Balls
We think it should happen, but we're not going to vote for it - Jo Swinson explains how Lib Dems do their politicsWe think it should happen, but we're not going to vote for it - Jo Swinson explains how Lib Dems do their politics
— Alex Belardinelli (@abelardinelli) June 13, 2012— Alex Belardinelli (@abelardinelli) June 13, 2012
9.15am: Stress testing is normally associated with banks, but today the coalition is going to experience some stress testing of its own when the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats split in a vote on whether there should be an investigation into whether Jeremy Hunt broke the ministerial code. As Patrick Wintour reports in the Guardian, today's debate will mark one of the most serious breaches of coalition unity since 2010. There's no chance that the Labour motion, calling for Hunt to be investigated by the prime minister's independent adviser on ministers' interests, will get passed. But, at this stage, it is not clear quite how much damage the Lib Dems will do to coalition unity by refusing to vote to defend Hunt? Will it be seen as a polite "agreement to differ"? Or will it be remembered as an act of treachery that will hasten the moment when the coaliton collapses?9.15am: Stress testing is normally associated with banks, but today the coalition is going to experience some stress testing of its own when the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats split in a vote on whether there should be an investigation into whether Jeremy Hunt broke the ministerial code. As Patrick Wintour reports in the Guardian, today's debate will mark one of the most serious breaches of coalition unity since 2010. There's no chance that the Labour motion, calling for Hunt to be investigated by the prime minister's independent adviser on ministers' interests, will get passed. But, at this stage, it is not clear quite how much damage the Lib Dems will do to coalition unity by refusing to vote to defend Hunt? Will it be seen as a polite "agreement to differ"? Or will it be remembered as an act of treachery that will hasten the moment when the coaliton collapses?
In public comments this morning both sides have been seeking to play down the significance of the split. Grant Shapps, the Conservative housing minister, told the Today programme that the Lib Dem position was just a "reminder that we have different perspectives on things".In public comments this morning both sides have been seeking to play down the significance of the split. Grant Shapps, the Conservative housing minister, told the Today programme that the Lib Dem position was just a "reminder that we have different perspectives on things".
It's a reminder that this is two parties that have come together in the national interest to sort out these huge debt problems ... The important thing is that we continue to focus on the big picture, on avoiding getting into the situation of Spain or Greece.It's a reminder that this is two parties that have come together in the national interest to sort out these huge debt problems ... The important thing is that we continue to focus on the big picture, on avoiding getting into the situation of Spain or Greece.
And Don Foster, a Lib Dem backbencher, told the same programme that the debate did not matter much anyway because David Cameron had decided not to have an inquiry into Hunt.And Don Foster, a Lib Dem backbencher, told the same programme that the debate did not matter much anyway because David Cameron had decided not to have an inquiry into Hunt.

It's not going to make a blind bit of difference, the prime minister's already made his mind up on the issue ... The best way Nick Clegg can make clear what he believes about this is to do what he has already done. He doesn't endorse the position the prime minister's made not to refer this to the independent adviser, it's as simple as that.
It's not going to make a blind bit of difference, the prime minister's already made his mind up on the issue ... The best way Nick Clegg can make clear what he believes about this is to do what he has already done. He doesn't endorse the position the prime minister's made not to refer this to the independent adviser, it's as simple as that.
But is it really as good tempered as this? I'll be covering the debate in detail, and I'll be particularly interested in what Tory MPs have to say about the stance of their Lib Dem colleagues.But is it really as good tempered as this? I'll be covering the debate in detail, and I'll be particularly interested in what Tory MPs have to say about the stance of their Lib Dem colleagues.
Here's the full agenda for the day.Here's the full agenda for the day.
9.30am: Tim Loughton, the children's minister, unveils plans to enshrine in law the rights of both divorced fathers and mothers to see their children.9.30am: Tim Loughton, the children's minister, unveils plans to enshrine in law the rights of both divorced fathers and mothers to see their children.
10am: Nick Clegg gives evidence to the Leveson inquiry. In the afternoon Alex Salmond will give evidence.10am: Nick Clegg gives evidence to the Leveson inquiry. In the afternoon Alex Salmond will give evidence.
12pm: David Cameron and Ed Miliband clash at PMQs.12pm: David Cameron and Ed Miliband clash at PMQs.
12.30pm: The Jeremy Hunt debate begins. It should go on until about 4pm.12.30pm: The Jeremy Hunt debate begins. It should go on until about 4pm.
As usual, I'll be covering all the breaking political news, as well as looking at the papers and bringing you the best politics from the web. I'll post a summary before PMQs and another in the afternoon.As usual, I'll be covering all the breaking political news, as well as looking at the papers and bringing you the best politics from the web. I'll post a summary before PMQs and another in the afternoon.
If you want to follow me on Twitter, I'm on @AndrewSparrow.If you want to follow me on Twitter, I'm on @AndrewSparrow.
And if you're a hardcore fan, you can follow @gdnpoliticslive. It's an automated feed that tweets the start of every new post that I put on the blog.And if you're a hardcore fan, you can follow @gdnpoliticslive. It's an automated feed that tweets the start of every new post that I put on the blog.