This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/middle-east-live/2012/jun/14/syria-crisis-war-crimes-evidence-live
The article has changed 20 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Syria crisis: new evidence of war crimes - live updates | Syria crisis: new evidence of war crimes - live updates |
| (40 minutes later) | |
| 10.12am: Egypt: The post-Mubarak transition could be doubly derailed today – and we should know in a couple of hours or so. The Supreme Constitutional Court is meeting to consider whether former prime minister Ahmed Shafiq is legally qualified to stand in the presidential election this weekend, and also whether the recent parliamentary election was legally valid. | |
| There are various possible outcomes, which Zeinobia discusses on her Egyptian Chronicles blog, though almost everyone expects the court's decision to be driven more by politics than strict legal niceties. | |
| According to legal expert Ibrahim Yousry, quoted by Ahram Online, "it is unlikely the verdicts will mean halting the elections and reversing the democratic process because that may have serious consequences". More likely, Yousry says, these potential verdicts are being used as negotiating cards with Mohamed Morsi, the Muslim Brotherhood's candidate in the presidential election. | |
| Ahram Online continues: | |
| Political analyst Ibrahim El-Hodeiby believes the most likely scenario is that nothing will be changed, as the Disenfranchisement Law [excluding Shafiq from the presidential election] would be considered unconstitutional and the parliamentary elections constitutional. | |
| "I think Shafiq will become president and the Brotherhood will be offered the government instead. That way the Brotherhood will be made responsible for three difficult issues including the gas cylinders crisis, the shortage of bread and the shortage of gasoline," El-Hodeiby speculated. | |
| "In other words, the deep state [military, secret service and media] will work to make the Brotherhood lose popular support. The Brotherhood will agree to this deal because they do not want to be responsible for the presidency." | |
| 10.00am: Bahrain: AP has the latest on mixed fate of medics accuses of treating protesters in last year's uprising. | |
| A defense lawyer in Bahrain says a court has sentenced nine medical professionals to prison terms ranging from five years to one month in a retrial on charges of aiding the Gulf kingdom's uprising. | |
| Lawyer Jalila al-Sayed says nine other doctors and nurses were cleared of charges Thursday. Fifteen-year sentences against two doctors who fled Bahrain also stood. | |
| The 20-member group had been sentenced to prison terms of between five and 15 years by a now-disbanded security tribunal, which was set up by the Sunni monarchy as part of crackdowns against Shiite-led protests that began 16 months ago. | |
| A retrial in civilian court was ordered earlier this year. Bahrain authorities accused staff at the state-run Salmaniya Hospital of siding with protesters. Medical personnel deny the allegations. | |
| Commenting on the mixed verdicts activist Ala'a Shehabi tweeted: | |
| Medics trial is microcosm of govt's half-measures for PR, perpetuating crisis, avoiding a resolution thru justice & accountability #bahrain | |
| — Dr Ala'a Shehabi (@alaashehabi) June 14, 2012 | |
| Activist Mohammed Ashoor tweeted: | |
| I'm happy for the doctors proved innocent but justice is still not fully done. All of them are innocent. #Bahrain | |
| — Mohammed Ashoor (@MohmdAshoor) June 14, 2012 | |
| 9.49am: "Virtually everyone I met [in Syria] asked one thing and that was 'why is the world not doing anything to help us?'" said Amnesty's senior crisis response adviser Donatella Rovera. | |
| Speaking in a video to accompany Amnesty's new report, she added: "Everyday I saw people being killed and injured." | |
| 9.43am: China has again signalled its backing for Syria. | 9.43am: China has again signalled its backing for Syria. |
| China's foreign ministry said it does not approve of excessive reliance on pressure or sanctions to address the crisis, al-Jazeera reports. | China's foreign ministry said it does not approve of excessive reliance on pressure or sanctions to address the crisis, al-Jazeera reports. |
| Syria | Syria |
| • Amnesty International has documented fresh evidence of crimes against humanity and war crimes being perpetrated as part of state policy, based on the more than 200 interviews with eyewitnesses, victims and their families. Donatella Rovera, who spent several weeks undercover in Syria conducting the research, urged the UN to take decisive action to stop attacks civilians. | • Amnesty International has documented fresh evidence of crimes against humanity and war crimes being perpetrated as part of state policy, based on the more than 200 interviews with eyewitnesses, victims and their families. Donatella Rovera, who spent several weeks undercover in Syria conducting the research, urged the UN to take decisive action to stop attacks civilians. |
| For more than a year the UN Security Council has dithered, while a human rights crisis unfolded in Syria. It must now break the impasse and take concrete action to end to these violations and to hold to account those responsible. | For more than a year the UN Security Council has dithered, while a human rights crisis unfolded in Syria. It must now break the impasse and take concrete action to end to these violations and to hold to account those responsible. |
| The report calls on Russia and China to halt arms sales to Syria and for Assad regime to be referred to the international criminal court. | The report calls on Russia and China to halt arms sales to Syria and for Assad regime to be referred to the international criminal court. |
| • A bus bomb has exploded in the capital Damascus, the state news agency Sana reported. Security reinforcement rushed to the area, and heavy gunfire was heard afterwards, an activist in the city said. | • A bus bomb has exploded in the capital Damascus, the state news agency Sana reported. Security reinforcement rushed to the area, and heavy gunfire was heard afterwards, an activist in the city said. |
| • The US has alleged that Russian-made weapons are killing Syrians on "an hourly basis" as the accusations fly between Washington and Moscow over arms supplied to Syria. In the face of a strong denial from the Russian foreign minister, Sergei Lavrov, the US secretary of state, Hillary Clinton, stood by her assertion that Russian attack helicopters are on their way to Syria. | • The US has alleged that Russian-made weapons are killing Syrians on "an hourly basis" as the accusations fly between Washington and Moscow over arms supplied to Syria. In the face of a strong denial from the Russian foreign minister, Sergei Lavrov, the US secretary of state, Hillary Clinton, stood by her assertion that Russian attack helicopters are on their way to Syria. |
| Here's a run-down of the diplomatic ding-dong so far: | Here's a run-down of the diplomatic ding-dong so far: |
| Clinton: "They have, from time to time, said that we shouldn't worry, [that] everything they're shipping is unrelated to [Syria's] actions internally. That's patently untrue, and we are concerned about the latest information we have that there are attack helicopters on the way from Russia to Syria which will escalate the conflict quite dramatically." | Clinton: "They have, from time to time, said that we shouldn't worry, [that] everything they're shipping is unrelated to [Syria's] actions internally. That's patently untrue, and we are concerned about the latest information we have that there are attack helicopters on the way from Russia to Syria which will escalate the conflict quite dramatically." |
| Lavrov: "We are not delivering to Syria, or anywhere else, items that could be used against peaceful demonstrators. In this we differ from the United States, which regularly delivers riot control equipment to the region, including a recent delivery to a Persian Gulf country [Bahrain]. But for some reason the Americans consider this to be fine ... [The US is] providing arms and weapons to the Syrian opposition that can be used in fighting against the Damascus government." | Lavrov: "We are not delivering to Syria, or anywhere else, items that could be used against peaceful demonstrators. In this we differ from the United States, which regularly delivers riot control equipment to the region, including a recent delivery to a Persian Gulf country [Bahrain]. But for some reason the Americans consider this to be fine ... [The US is] providing arms and weapons to the Syrian opposition that can be used in fighting against the Damascus government." |
| Clinton: "We have repeatedly urged the Russian Government to cut these military ties completely and to suspend all further support and deliveries. Obviously, we know [Russia is supplying helicopters], because they confirm that they continue to deliver .. The United States has provided no military support to the Syrian opposition, none. All of our support has been medical and humanitarian to help relieve the suffering of the Syrian people, a total of $52m so far. We have also provided nonlethal support to the opposition, including things like communications gear." | Clinton: "We have repeatedly urged the Russian Government to cut these military ties completely and to suspend all further support and deliveries. Obviously, we know [Russia is supplying helicopters], because they confirm that they continue to deliver .. The United States has provided no military support to the Syrian opposition, none. All of our support has been medical and humanitarian to help relieve the suffering of the Syrian people, a total of $52m so far. We have also provided nonlethal support to the opposition, including things like communications gear." |
| • The helicopters on their way from Russia to Syria maybe not be new, officials and analyst have told the New York Times. | • The helicopters on their way from Russia to Syria maybe not be new, officials and analyst have told the New York Times. |
| What Clinton did not say, however, was whether the aircraft were new shipments or, as administration officials say is more likely, helicopters that Syria had sent to Russia a few months ago for routine repairs and refurbishing, and which were now about to be returned. | What Clinton did not say, however, was whether the aircraft were new shipments or, as administration officials say is more likely, helicopters that Syria had sent to Russia a few months ago for routine repairs and refurbishing, and which were now about to be returned. |
| • The UN has backtracked on the claims by its peacekeeping chief Herve Ladsous that Syria has descended into civil, Foreign Policy reports. It quotes a spokesman for UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon as saying: "it's clear it's not for us to determine or formally characterize the nature of the conflict in Syria." | • The UN has backtracked on the claims by its peacekeeping chief Herve Ladsous that Syria has descended into civil, Foreign Policy reports. It quotes a spokesman for UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon as saying: "it's clear it's not for us to determine or formally characterize the nature of the conflict in Syria." |
| • France insists the crisis is a civil war and that all means, including force, should be used under international supervision to help restore peace, the Wall Street Journal reports. French foreign minister Laurent Fabius said he would propose that the UN security council vote on a resolution giving UN members a mandate to intervene in Syria, possibly as part of a military operation. | • France insists the crisis is a civil war and that all means, including force, should be used under international supervision to help restore peace, the Wall Street Journal reports. French foreign minister Laurent Fabius said he would propose that the UN security council vote on a resolution giving UN members a mandate to intervene in Syria, possibly as part of a military operation. |
| • Russia's position on Syria is "shocking, mendacious and indefensible," but Moscow will have to bargained with to find a solution to the crisis, according to Timothy Garton Ash. | • Russia's position on Syria is "shocking, mendacious and indefensible," but Moscow will have to bargained with to find a solution to the crisis, according to Timothy Garton Ash. |
| Have they no other national interests, which might eventually outweigh this one? Now that's a question worth asking. If we are really serious about our commitment to stopping the slaughter in Syria, we in the west have to consider if there are any larger carrots and sticks we can still show Russia, even at some cost to ourselves, so as to achieve a shift in its position. | Have they no other national interests, which might eventually outweigh this one? Now that's a question worth asking. If we are really serious about our commitment to stopping the slaughter in Syria, we in the west have to consider if there are any larger carrots and sticks we can still show Russia, even at some cost to ourselves, so as to achieve a shift in its position. |
| Egypt | Egypt |
| • The future of Egypt's political transition hangs in the balance as the country awaits a court verdict on the constitutionality of both the new parliament and the presidential election, Ahram online reports. The High Constitutional Court is due to rule on two cases. The first could dissolve the new parliament on the grounds that the way MPs were elected was unconstitutional. The second could disqualify former prime Ahmed Shafiq as a candidate in the this weekend's president runoff on the grounds that as a member of the former regime he is prohibited from standing. | • The future of Egypt's political transition hangs in the balance as the country awaits a court verdict on the constitutionality of both the new parliament and the presidential election, Ahram online reports. The High Constitutional Court is due to rule on two cases. The first could dissolve the new parliament on the grounds that the way MPs were elected was unconstitutional. The second could disqualify former prime Ahmed Shafiq as a candidate in the this weekend's president runoff on the grounds that as a member of the former regime he is prohibited from standing. |
| Tunisia | Tunisia |
| • A military court has sentenced former president Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali to life in prison in connection with the killing of 23 demonstrators by police during the revolt that sparked the Arab spring. The mixed panel of military and civilian judges pronounced Ben Ali guilty of complicity in murder and attempted murder. Prosecuting lawyers had sought to prove there were high-level orders to kill protesters. However, lawyers on both sides said they were disappointed that investigating magistrates had failed to reconstruct the exact sequence of events in the hours leading up to the deaths. | • A military court has sentenced former president Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali to life in prison in connection with the killing of 23 demonstrators by police during the revolt that sparked the Arab spring. The mixed panel of military and civilian judges pronounced Ben Ali guilty of complicity in murder and attempted murder. Prosecuting lawyers had sought to prove there were high-level orders to kill protesters. However, lawyers on both sides said they were disappointed that investigating magistrates had failed to reconstruct the exact sequence of events in the hours leading up to the deaths. |
| Libya | Libya |
| • The Libyan leadership said it was powerless to release four officials from the international criminal court who are being detained after visiting Muammar Gaddafi's imprisoned son, Saif al-Islam, writes Julian Borger. | • The Libyan leadership said it was powerless to release four officials from the international criminal court who are being detained after visiting Muammar Gaddafi's imprisoned son, Saif al-Islam, writes Julian Borger. |
| The Libyan attorney general's office said that the ICC detainees, who were organising Saif's legal defence, would be held for 45 days during the investigation, deepening the crisis in relations between Libya and the international community over the incident. The four appear to have been caught in a three-way tussle between the Tripoli government, the Zintan militia holding Saif, and the ICC over where Saif should be put on trial for alleged crimes against humanity committed during the Libyan insurrection last year. | The Libyan attorney general's office said that the ICC detainees, who were organising Saif's legal defence, would be held for 45 days during the investigation, deepening the crisis in relations between Libya and the international community over the incident. The four appear to have been caught in a three-way tussle between the Tripoli government, the Zintan militia holding Saif, and the ICC over where Saif should be put on trial for alleged crimes against humanity committed during the Libyan insurrection last year. |