This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/blog/2012/jun/27/pmqs-lords-reform-cameron-miliband-live

The article has changed 11 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 7 Version 8
PMQs and Lords reform bill published: Politics live blog PMQs and Lords reform bill published: Politics live blog
(39 minutes later)
3.27pm: Here's an afternoon reading list. Actually, it's more of a viewing list, because of the two wonderful YouTube collections. Don't click on them if you are hoping to do some work this afternoon ...
• Damian McBride on his blog reflects on the day Gordon Brown became prime minister - and what went wrong afterwards.
There's a popular post-hoc view that we lost our raison d'etre; that Gordon had sought power for its own sake and didn't know what to do once he had it. There's another post-hoc argument that we lost control; that Gordon's previous reliance on set-piece moments and drawn-out decision-making was fundamentally unsuited to the fast-paced and usually random nature of events in No10. For me, what we lost that day was something more fundamental, as apparent during the first months of the 'Brown Bounce' as in the doldrums that followed. We lost the Treasury. By which I mean that, in the Treasury, Gordon had officials in every key position who knew how he worked and what he wanted; who knew when to refer issues to him and when to take decisions themselves. These were relationships built up over 10 years of long days and late nights working on Budgets, Spending Reviews, Mansion House speeches and Euro papers. Gordon knew them, and trusted them.
• Tim Shipman on his blog posts clips from what could be the 20 worst car crash interviews in history.

• James Randerson at the Guardian posts clips from some of Jeremy Paxman's greatest TV moments.

• Jonathan Freedland at the Guardian explains what Chloe Smith should have said to the tricky questions she received from Paxman.

• Michael White at the Guardian thinks Smith handled her Paxman interview pretty well.
2.56pm: The British Humanist Association has criticised Nick Clegg's decision to retain bishops in the House of Lords. This is from Andrew Copson, the BHA chief executive.2.56pm: The British Humanist Association has criticised Nick Clegg's decision to retain bishops in the House of Lords. This is from Andrew Copson, the BHA chief executive.
This is deeply disappointing ... Not only do arguments to retain bishops possess no intellectual credibility, they are also unpopular with the public, with polls indicating 74% of the population –including 70% of Christians – believe it is wrong that Church of England Bishops are given automatic places.This is deeply disappointing ... Not only do arguments to retain bishops possess no intellectual credibility, they are also unpopular with the public, with polls indicating 74% of the population –including 70% of Christians – believe it is wrong that Church of England Bishops are given automatic places.
Representatives of the Church of England will retain the right to sit in the House of Lords by virtue of their faith, denomination, gender and vocation. In a Britain which is not only religiously plural, but also increasingly non-religious, there is absolutely no justification for maintaining the Church of England preferred status. It is an affront to the principles of democracy and equal citizenship.Representatives of the Church of England will retain the right to sit in the House of Lords by virtue of their faith, denomination, gender and vocation. In a Britain which is not only religiously plural, but also increasingly non-religious, there is absolutely no justification for maintaining the Church of England preferred status. It is an affront to the principles of democracy and equal citizenship.
2.53pm: Here's the Guardian audio of PMQS.2.53pm: Here's the Guardian audio of PMQS.
It lasts the full half an hour.It lasts the full half an hour.
2.40pm: David Miliband (pictured) was on Sky's Boulton & Co at lunchtime. According to PoliticsHome, he said he was baffled by the Lib Dem suggestion (see 10.24am) that Labour were blocking Lords reform.2.40pm: David Miliband (pictured) was on Sky's Boulton & Co at lunchtime. According to PoliticsHome, he said he was baffled by the Lib Dem suggestion (see 10.24am) that Labour were blocking Lords reform.
I don't understand that at all, actually, because I heard Ed [Miliband] yesterday - actually I read his thing that came out - we are completely committed to supporting it. I'm voting for it. They've given it nine days, so Labour wants more time to talk about it ...I don't understand that at all, actually, because I heard Ed [Miliband] yesterday - actually I read his thing that came out - we are completely committed to supporting it. I'm voting for it. They've given it nine days, so Labour wants more time to talk about it ...
We don't want to send it to the House of Lords in a position where – we had experience with this, remember - if you're not careful the House of Lords say, 'one of the reasons to be against this is the Commons hasn't given it proper scrutiny because it hasn't looked at the following clauses'. There are 60 clauses in this bill and it doesn't seem to me unreasonable to say five clauses a day is pretty speedy going. Let's do it properly and let's send it with a very strong democratic message to the Lords that we want them to pass it.We don't want to send it to the House of Lords in a position where – we had experience with this, remember - if you're not careful the House of Lords say, 'one of the reasons to be against this is the Commons hasn't given it proper scrutiny because it hasn't looked at the following clauses'. There are 60 clauses in this bill and it doesn't seem to me unreasonable to say five clauses a day is pretty speedy going. Let's do it properly and let's send it with a very strong democratic message to the Lords that we want them to pass it.
2.15pm: Here's a lunchtime summary. I'm afraid I had some technical problems earlier, which is why it's later than usual.2.15pm: Here's a lunchtime summary. I'm afraid I had some technical problems earlier, which is why it's later than usual.
• David Cameron has challenged Labour to support the House of Lords reform bill published today. Speaking at PMQs, he said that if MPs in favour of Lords reform supported the bill, it would go through.• David Cameron has challenged Labour to support the House of Lords reform bill published today. Speaking at PMQs, he said that if MPs in favour of Lords reform supported the bill, it would go through.

We have been discussing this issue for 100 years and it really is time to make progress. There are opponents of Lords reform in every party. But there is a majority in this House for a mainly-elected House of Lords and I believe there's a majority for that in the country. If those who support Lords reform don't get out there and back it, it won't happen. That is the crucial point.
We have been discussing this issue for 100 years and it really is time to make progress. There are opponents of Lords reform in every party. But there is a majority in this House for a mainly-elected House of Lords and I believe there's a majority for that in the country. If those who support Lords reform don't get out there and back it, it won't happen. That is the crucial point.
But Tory MPs have renewed their attack on the plans. Conor Burns said he would be willing to resign as a ministerial aide over the matter, while Jesse Norman told the World at One that the bill was "a constituional monstrosity".But Tory MPs have renewed their attack on the plans. Conor Burns said he would be willing to resign as a ministerial aide over the matter, while Jesse Norman told the World at One that the bill was "a constituional monstrosity".
• Cameron has rejected claims that the government peformed a U-turn on fuel duty. Ed Miliband said the decision was "another case of panic at the pumps". He also described it as a U-turn. But Cameron rejected this.• Cameron has rejected claims that the government peformed a U-turn on fuel duty. Ed Miliband said the decision was "another case of panic at the pumps". He also described it as a U-turn. But Cameron rejected this.
The fuel duty increase was a Labour tax rise. It cannot be a U-turn to get rid of a Labour tax increase. They put in place 12 increases on fuel duty in government. They left behind six increases in fuel duty and I'm proud of the fact we are dealing with them.The fuel duty increase was a Labour tax rise. It cannot be a U-turn to get rid of a Labour tax increase. They put in place 12 increases on fuel duty in government. They left behind six increases in fuel duty and I'm proud of the fact we are dealing with them.
Cameron also denied that George Osborne "hid" yesterday when he should have been defending the decision. And Downing Street has confirmed that other cabinet ministers were not told about the move until it was announced Osborne in the Commons.Cameron also denied that George Osborne "hid" yesterday when he should have been defending the decision. And Downing Street has confirmed that other cabinet ministers were not told about the move until it was announced Osborne in the Commons.
• Cameron has said that the government wants a new version of the GCSE exam to be a "gold standard". This is what he told MPs at PMQs.• Cameron has said that the government wants a new version of the GCSE exam to be a "gold standard". This is what he told MPs at PMQs.

What the education secretary explained in great detail yesterday is that what we want to have is an absolute gold standard of exams in our country that are about rigour and high standards. The tragedy is that what we inherited from the last government was a system that was being progressively dumbed down, where Britain was falling down the league tables and GCSE questions included things like 'How do you see the moon, is it through a telescope or a microscope?'. We think we need a rigorous system and that is what we are going to put in place.
What the education secretary explained in great detail yesterday is that what we want to have is an absolute gold standard of exams in our country that are about rigour and high standards. The tragedy is that what we inherited from the last government was a system that was being progressively dumbed down, where Britain was falling down the league tables and GCSE questions included things like 'How do you see the moon, is it through a telescope or a microscope?'. We think we need a rigorous system and that is what we are going to put in place.
• Tony Blair has said that he would like to be prime minister again, although he accepts that this is unlikely to happen. In an interview to mark the fifth anniversary of his departure from office, he also praised Ed Miliband for keeping Labour in the centre ground.• Tony Blair has said that he would like to be prime minister again, although he accepts that this is unlikely to happen. In an interview to mark the fifth anniversary of his departure from office, he also praised Ed Miliband for keeping Labour in the centre ground.

Ed Miliband has made a conscious decision that he is going to keep the Labour party in the centre, and that is sensible ...
Ed Miliband has made a conscious decision that he is going to keep the Labour party in the centre, and that is sensible ...
My view is that you still, in order to win from the Labour perspective, have to have a strong alliance with business as well as the unions. You have got to be very much in the centre ground on things like public sector reform.My view is that you still, in order to win from the Labour perspective, have to have a strong alliance with business as well as the unions. You have got to be very much in the centre ground on things like public sector reform.
Today the level of uncertainty is such that it calls upon political leaders to take very big decisions and there are two types of politician: there are reality creators and reality managers. And for much of the postwar period those who have managed reality have been absolutely adequate. I think we are embarking on a period both in the economy and foreign policy where we are going to have to create reality.Today the level of uncertainty is such that it calls upon political leaders to take very big decisions and there are two types of politician: there are reality creators and reality managers. And for much of the postwar period those who have managed reality have been absolutely adequate. I think we are embarking on a period both in the economy and foreign policy where we are going to have to create reality.
• The Commons home affairs select committee has cleared the way for the controversial appointment of Tom Winsor to the post of chief inspector of constabulary, the first not to come from a policing background in the job's 156-year history.• The Commons home affairs select committee has cleared the way for the controversial appointment of Tom Winsor to the post of chief inspector of constabulary, the first not to come from a policing background in the job's 156-year history.
• Nick Clegg has said the government will extend a scheme providing subsidies to firms that employ young workers in areas of high youth unemployment. As the Press Assocation reports, he said in a speech to a CBI conference that instead of coming in at nine months, the subsidy of £2,275 per person will start at six months. The subsidy, equivalent to half the minimum wage, is part of the government's £1 billion Youth Contract launched last autumn.• Nick Clegg has said the government will extend a scheme providing subsidies to firms that employ young workers in areas of high youth unemployment. As the Press Assocation reports, he said in a speech to a CBI conference that instead of coming in at nine months, the subsidy of £2,275 per person will start at six months. The subsidy, equivalent to half the minimum wage, is part of the government's £1 billion Youth Contract launched last autumn.
• The Welsh assembly has decided to hold a debate on lowering the voting age to 16.

• Norman Baker, the transport minister, has announced investment plans worth £266m in sustainable transport schemes.		• The Welsh assembly has decided to hold a debate on lowering the voting age to 16.

• Norman Baker, the transport minister, has announced investment plans worth £266m in sustainable transport schemes.
1.02pm: The Cabinet Office has just published the House of Lords reform bill. Here's the text of the bill itself. Here are the explanatory notes to the bill (which explain in English what the legislation actually means). And this document - the government's response to the report from the joint committee on the draft bill (pdf) - explains how the government has changed its plans since it published the bill in draft form.1.02pm: The Cabinet Office has just published the House of Lords reform bill. Here's the text of the bill itself. Here are the explanatory notes to the bill (which explain in English what the legislation actually means). And this document - the government's response to the report from the joint committee on the draft bill (pdf) - explains how the government has changed its plans since it published the bill in draft form.
Here's an extract from the Cabinet Office news release explaining what the bill would do.Here's an extract from the Cabinet Office news release explaining what the bill would do.

The deputy prime minister today published the House of Lords Reform Bill which would lead to 80 per cent of House of Lords members being elected by the public and the number of members being reduced by nearly half from 826 to 450.
The deputy prime minister today published the House of Lords Reform Bill which would lead to 80 per cent of House of Lords members being elected by the public and the number of members being reduced by nearly half from 826 to 450.
Voters would be able to elect members of the reformed House of Lords for the first time in May 2015. One third of the elected members would be chosen at the general election in 2015, another third in 2020 and the final third in 2025 – 120 members in each election. Existing Peers would be 'phased' out as elected members are brought in.Voters would be able to elect members of the reformed House of Lords for the first time in May 2015. One third of the elected members would be chosen at the general election in 2015, another third in 2020 and the final third in 2025 – 120 members in each election. Existing Peers would be 'phased' out as elected members are brought in.
In total, 80 per cent (360 members) of the total of 450 members would be elected. The remaining 20 per cent (90 members) would be appointed by a statutory appointments commission on a non-party basis. There would also be 12 Church of England bishops, a reduction from the current 26 church representatives, reflecting the smaller overall size of the chamber.In total, 80 per cent (360 members) of the total of 450 members would be elected. The remaining 20 per cent (90 members) would be appointed by a statutory appointments commission on a non-party basis. There would also be 12 Church of England bishops, a reduction from the current 26 church representatives, reflecting the smaller overall size of the chamber.
Under the bill, members of the reformed House would serve for 15-year terms of office, and they would only be allowed to serve for one term. Elected members would be picked using a semi-open List electoral system, giving voters the choice of voting for a party or for an individual in their region.Under the bill, members of the reformed House would serve for 15-year terms of office, and they would only be allowed to serve for one term. Elected members would be picked using a semi-open List electoral system, giving voters the choice of voting for a party or for an individual in their region.
The government is committed to ensuring that the cost of running parliament does not rise significantly. The salary, staffing and administration costs of the new look House are not forecast to rise substantially and are expected to be offset by savings from reducing the size of the House of Commons. There will be a net saving between 2015 and 2025; once the reforms are completed the real terms cost of Parliament is anticipated to be broadly the same as it is now.The government is committed to ensuring that the cost of running parliament does not rise significantly. The salary, staffing and administration costs of the new look House are not forecast to rise substantially and are expected to be offset by savings from reducing the size of the House of Commons. There will be a net saving between 2015 and 2025; once the reforms are completed the real terms cost of Parliament is anticipated to be broadly the same as it is now.
The reformed House of Lords would not challenge the historical primacy of the House of Commons. The new bill specifically states that the parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949, which define the relationship between the Houses, remain in force. The government listened to recommendations on this issue from the joint committee on the draft House of Lords Reform Bill and made changes to the draft legislation published last year. The government's response to the joint committee's report is also published today.The reformed House of Lords would not challenge the historical primacy of the House of Commons. The new bill specifically states that the parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949, which define the relationship between the Houses, remain in force. The government listened to recommendations on this issue from the joint committee on the draft House of Lords Reform Bill and made changes to the draft legislation published last year. The government's response to the joint committee's report is also published today.
12.42pm: PMQs Verdict: This was Ed Miliband's best PMQs for ages. His first question, the one quoting David Cameron saying that he would defend every line of the budget, was perfect and the line he used in his final line about comedians in the cabinet allowed him to finish with a flourish. His questions were a bit more woolly in the middle, but he still clearly had the upper hand because Cameron did so little to engage with the questions about the budget he was being asked. Instead he was flinging responses at Miliband with little or no relevance to the matter in hand (such as Ken Livingstone's election to the NEC), as well as spouting the usual insults. On some days bluster and aggression can work for Cameron at PMQs. But today he just looked evasive.12.42pm: PMQs Verdict: This was Ed Miliband's best PMQs for ages. His first question, the one quoting David Cameron saying that he would defend every line of the budget, was perfect and the line he used in his final line about comedians in the cabinet allowed him to finish with a flourish. His questions were a bit more woolly in the middle, but he still clearly had the upper hand because Cameron did so little to engage with the questions about the budget he was being asked. Instead he was flinging responses at Miliband with little or no relevance to the matter in hand (such as Ken Livingstone's election to the NEC), as well as spouting the usual insults. On some days bluster and aggression can work for Cameron at PMQs. But today he just looked evasive.
12.38pm: Lindsay Hoyle, the deputy speaker, moves on to the formal presentation of bills. He reads out the title of the House of Lords reform bill. This means it has had its first reading.12.38pm: Lindsay Hoyle, the deputy speaker, moves on to the formal presentation of bills. He reads out the title of the House of Lords reform bill. This means it has had its first reading.
It also means that the Cabinet Office will be publishing it very shortly.It also means that the Cabinet Office will be publishing it very shortly.
12.35pm: After PMQs Jacob Rees-Mogg, the Tory MP, raised to make a point of order. He says that earlier editions of Erskine May, the parliamentary rulebook, say bills affecting the Lords should be presented in the Lords first, "as a courtesy". So why isn't today's bill starting in the Lords?12.35pm: After PMQs Jacob Rees-Mogg, the Tory MP, raised to make a point of order. He says that earlier editions of Erskine May, the parliamentary rulebook, say bills affecting the Lords should be presented in the Lords first, "as a courtesy". So why isn't today's bill starting in the Lords?
The deputy speaker, Lindsay Hoyle, says Rees-Mogg is talking about "old" editions of Erskine May. The rules have changed, he says.The deputy speaker, Lindsay Hoyle, says Rees-Mogg is talking about "old" editions of Erskine May. The rules have changed, he says.
12.31pm: Peter Bone, a Conservative, asks Cameron to congratulate Andrew Mitchell for ensuring that a British flag is shown on British overseas aid.

Cameron welcomes the initiative.		12.31pm: Peter Bone, a Conservative, asks Cameron to congratulate Andrew Mitchell for ensuring that a British flag is shown on British overseas aid.

Cameron welcomes the initiative.
12.30pm: Caroline Lucas, the Green MP, asks what has happened to the government's plan to review the extradition deal with the US.12.30pm: Caroline Lucas, the Green MP, asks what has happened to the government's plan to review the extradition deal with the US.
Cameron says the government is still looking at this. But it is not a simple issue.Cameron says the government is still looking at this. But it is not a simple issue.
12.30pm: Cameron says he is in favour of flatter, fairer taxes.12.30pm: Cameron says he is in favour of flatter, fairer taxes.
12.28pm: Clive Efford, a Labour MP, says Andrew Lansley is wrong to say PFI is entirely to blame for the defict in the South London Healthcare Trust.12.28pm: Clive Efford, a Labour MP, says Andrew Lansley is wrong to say PFI is entirely to blame for the defict in the South London Healthcare Trust.
Cameron says the PFI is largely to blame. Under PFI contracts, hospitals have to pay £466 to change a light fitting.Cameron says the PFI is largely to blame. Under PFI contracts, hospitals have to pay £466 to change a light fitting.
12.26pm: Jesse Norman, a Conservative MP, asks Cameron to support a campaign for an SAS soldier to get a postumous VC for his role in the battle of Mirbat in Oman 40 years ago.
12.26pm: Jesse Norman, a Conservative MP, asks Cameron to support a campaign for an SAS soldier to get a postumous VC for his role in the battle of Mirbat in Oman 40 years ago.
Cameron says these decisions should not be taken by politicians. But he says Norman is right to highlight the role played by the SAS.Cameron says these decisions should not be taken by politicians. But he says Norman is right to highlight the role played by the SAS.
12.24pm: Labour's Frank Roy asks Cameron to apologise for the Conservative party's role in the demise of the steel industry in his constituency.12.24pm: Labour's Frank Roy asks Cameron to apologise for the Conservative party's role in the demise of the steel industry in his constituency.
Cameron says he is sorry about any jobs being lost. But the government is encouraging manufacturing.Cameron says he is sorry about any jobs being lost. But the government is encouraging manufacturing.
12.24pm: Craig Whittaker, a Conservative, asks about the flooding in Calder Valley.12.24pm: Craig Whittaker, a Conservative, asks about the flooding in Calder Valley.
Cameron says more than 500 properties in Whittaker's constituency were affected. He praises the resilience of the community.Cameron says more than 500 properties in Whittaker's constituency were affected. He praises the resilience of the community.
12.22pm: Labour's Debbie Abrahams applauds the emergency services who attended the Oldham explosion yesterday.12.22pm: Labour's Debbie Abrahams applauds the emergency services who attended the Oldham explosion yesterday.
Cameron agrees. He says people are thinking of the family of the two-year-old who was killed.Cameron agrees. He says people are thinking of the family of the two-year-old who was killed.
12.21pm: Nick de Bois, a Conservative, asks Cameron to support an anti-knife crime initiative.12.21pm: Nick de Bois, a Conservative, asks Cameron to support an anti-knife crime initiative.
Cameron says he supports this. A culture change needs to take place. He salutes the bravery of those relatives of people killed by knife crime who are willing to go into schools to talk about it.Cameron says he supports this. A culture change needs to take place. He salutes the bravery of those relatives of people killed by knife crime who are willing to go into schools to talk about it.
12.20pm: Labour's Iain McKenzie asks why Labour is borrowing £3.9bn more this year than last year.12.20pm: Labour's Iain McKenzie asks why Labour is borrowing £3.9bn more this year than last year.
Cameron says the deficit is down by a quarter.Cameron says the deficit is down by a quarter.
12.20pm: Cameron praises the work down by the emergency services after the recent floods.12.20pm: Cameron praises the work down by the emergency services after the recent floods.
12.19pm: Labour's Chris Bryant asks Cameron to ensure that bullets are included in the arms trade treaty being negotiated in New York.12.19pm: Labour's Chris Bryant asks Cameron to ensure that bullets are included in the arms trade treaty being negotiated in New York.
Cameron says the UK supports the arms trade treaty. On the issue of bullets, he will write to Bryant.Cameron says the UK supports the arms trade treaty. On the issue of bullets, he will write to Bryant.
12.16pm: Labour's John Woodcock asks Cameron if he thinks Lord Ashcroft's tax arrangement are morally wrong.12.16pm: Labour's John Woodcock asks Cameron if he thinks Lord Ashcroft's tax arrangement are morally wrong.
Cameron says peers are no longer allowed to be non-doms. Woodcock might like to look at the tax affairs of the new Labour fund-raiser, Andrew Rosenfeld. Which marginal seat did Rosenfeld use to live in? Zurich, Cameron says.Cameron says peers are no longer allowed to be non-doms. Woodcock might like to look at the tax affairs of the new Labour fund-raiser, Andrew Rosenfeld. Which marginal seat did Rosenfeld use to live in? Zurich, Cameron says.
12.15pm: Sarah Woolaston, a Conservative MP, says community hospitals benefit from Gift Aid. Will Cameron ensure that equipment funded by Gift Aid remains for the use of local people?12.15pm: Sarah Woolaston, a Conservative MP, says community hospitals benefit from Gift Aid. Will Cameron ensure that equipment funded by Gift Aid remains for the use of local people?
Cameron says the League of Friends does a great job raising money for hospitals.Cameron says the League of Friends does a great job raising money for hospitals.
12.14pm: Michael Meacher, the Labour MP, asks when the government will introduce a Commons business committee.12.14pm: Michael Meacher, the Labour MP, asks when the government will introduce a Commons business committee.
Cameron says the government is looking at this.Cameron says the government is looking at this.
12.13pm: Mary MacLeod, a Conservative, says unemployment has fallen by 5.7% in her constituency in the last year. What will the government do to nurture entrepeneurs?12.13pm: Mary MacLeod, a Conservative, says unemployment has fallen by 5.7% in her constituency in the last year. What will the government do to nurture entrepeneurs?
Cameron says the economy is rebalancing. The government is encouraging that.Cameron says the economy is rebalancing. The government is encouraging that.
12.12pm: Labour's Grahame Morris asks Cameron to legislate for a general anti-tax avoidance rule.12.12pm: Labour's Grahame Morris asks Cameron to legislate for a general anti-tax avoidance rule.
Cameron says this is what the government is doing.Cameron says this is what the government is doing.
12.11pm: Sharon Hodgson, a Labour MP, asks Cameron about the moral difference between a celebrity avoiding tax and cabinet ministers passing a budget that helps themselves.12.11pm: Sharon Hodgson, a Labour MP, asks Cameron about the moral difference between a celebrity avoiding tax and cabinet ministers passing a budget that helps themselves.
Cameron says he thought Labour was in favour of a crackdown on tax avoidance.Cameron says he thought Labour was in favour of a crackdown on tax avoidance.
12.10pm: PMQs Snap Verdict: Resounding win for Ed Miliband. More later ....12.10pm: PMQs Snap Verdict: Resounding win for Ed Miliband. More later ....
12.07pm: Miliband says Osborne would not defend his move yesterday. He quotes what Nadine Dorries said about Osborne sending Chloe Smith onto Newsnight. (See 11.08am.)12.07pm: Miliband says Osborne would not defend his move yesterday. He quotes what Nadine Dorries said about Osborne sending Chloe Smith onto Newsnight. (See 11.08am.)
Cameron says Osborne announced the tax cut from the dispatch box. And Osborne wrongfooted the shadow chancellor. Miliband is arguing about process, on the Lords and the deficit. "Absolutely hopeless."Cameron says Osborne announced the tax cut from the dispatch box. And Osborne wrongfooted the shadow chancellor. Miliband is arguing about process, on the Lords and the deficit. "Absolutely hopeless."
Miliband says Cameron talks about Jimmy Carr's tax affairs. But he is giving a tax cut to millionaires worth £40,000, including some in the cabinet. There is one rule for the comedians on stage, and another rule for the comedians in the cabinet.Miliband says Cameron talks about Jimmy Carr's tax affairs. But he is giving a tax cut to millionaires worth £40,000, including some in the cabinet. There is one rule for the comedians on stage, and another rule for the comedians in the cabinet.
Cameron says Miliband is touchy about tax avoidance, because Ken Livingstone came top in Labour's NEC elections.Cameron says Miliband is touchy about tax avoidance, because Ken Livingstone came top in Labour's NEC elections.
12.04pm: Miliband says borrowing is going up. No wonder the governement wants to change the exam system. The chancellor can't add up. This is the result of the double-dip recession made in Downing Street.12.04pm: Miliband says borrowing is going up. No wonder the governement wants to change the exam system. The chancellor can't add up. This is the result of the double-dip recession made in Downing Street.
Cameron says Miliband is in favour of the fuel duty cut and against it.Cameron says Miliband is in favour of the fuel duty cut and against it.
Miliband says the government is incompetent and unfair. There have been six budget U-turns. But he has not U-turned on the tax cut for millionaires. What feedback has Cameron had from voters.Miliband says the government is incompetent and unfair. There have been six budget U-turns. But he has not U-turned on the tax cut for millionaires. What feedback has Cameron had from voters.
Cameron says it is wrong to have a top rate of tax higher than France and Italy. But under Labour the top rate was 40p, not 45p.Cameron says it is wrong to have a top rate of tax higher than France and Italy. But under Labour the top rate was 40p, not 45p.
12.02pm: Ed Miliband says on 11 April Cameron said he would defend every part of the budget and that he worked on it line by line. What went wrong?12.02pm: Ed Miliband says on 11 April Cameron said he would defend every part of the budget and that he worked on it line by line. What went wrong?
Cameron says the fuel duty increase was a Labour increase.Cameron says the fuel duty increase was a Labour increase.
Miliband says: "So it was all part of a seamless political strategy." But the government forgot to tell the transport secretary, the cabinet and Tory backbenchers. It was "panic at the pumps". Every time Labour proposed getting money into the economy, it was denounced as irresponsible. Plan A has failed.Miliband says: "So it was all part of a seamless political strategy." But the government forgot to tell the transport secretary, the cabinet and Tory backbenchers. It was "panic at the pumps". Every time Labour proposed getting money into the economy, it was denounced as irresponsible. Plan A has failed.
Cameron asks Miliband if he supports the fuel duty move. Miliband indicates he does. So Labour should support it, Cameron says.Cameron asks Miliband if he supports the fuel duty move. Miliband indicates he does. So Labour should support it, Cameron says.
12.00pm: Helen Grant, a Conservative MP, asks Cameron if he agrees that it is stupid for Labour to vote for Lords reform, but against the timetable motion.12.00pm: Helen Grant, a Conservative MP, asks Cameron if he agrees that it is stupid for Labour to vote for Lords reform, but against the timetable motion.
Cameron says this is an important point.Cameron says this is an important point.
We have been discussing this issue for 100 years. It really is time to make progress.We have been discussing this issue for 100 years. It really is time to make progress.
There is a majority for reform in the Commons, he says. But if those who support it don't back it, it won't happen. It is hopeless in life to do what Ed Miliband is doing.There is a majority for reform in the Commons, he says. But if those who support it don't back it, it won't happen. It is hopeless in life to do what Ed Miliband is doing.
11.56am: PMQs will be starting soon. If Ed Miliband needs some tricky questions, he could do a lot worse than use the ones Jeremy Paxman deployed to floor Chloe Smith. (See 11.08am.)11.56am: PMQs will be starting soon. If Ed Miliband needs some tricky questions, he could do a lot worse than use the ones Jeremy Paxman deployed to floor Chloe Smith. (See 11.08am.)
11.50am: Peter Kellner at YouGov has been looking at the polling on Lords reform. Even though the public is notionally in favour of having a largely elected Lords, Kellner thinks that if there is a referendum, people will vote against. Here's an extract.11.50am: Peter Kellner at YouGov has been looking at the polling on Lords reform. Even though the public is notionally in favour of having a largely elected Lords, Kellner thinks that if there is a referendum, people will vote against. Here's an extract.
As things stand, it seems likely that one of two things will now happen. Either the bill to reform the Lords will be still-born, or the price that will be paid for keeping it alive will be a commitment to hold a referendum, after the bill becomes law but before any of our current peers are pensioned off.As things stand, it seems likely that one of two things will now happen. Either the bill to reform the Lords will be still-born, or the price that will be paid for keeping it alive will be a commitment to hold a referendum, after the bill becomes law but before any of our current peers are pensioned off.
If the bill is withdrawn, then we can all forget about reform for a few more years.If the bill is withdrawn, then we can all forget about reform for a few more years.
But if there is to be a referendum, who will win?But if there is to be a referendum, who will win?
On the face of it, there seems to be a big majority for reform. However, if any reader is rash enough to bet on the outcome, my advice would be to put their money on victory for the status quo. As I have argued before, referendums on contentious topics tend to make voters increasingly nervous as polling day approaches. The vague grass-is-greener enthusiasm for change when the decision is some months away tends to be trumped by a keep-a-hold-of-nurse caution when change is imminent.On the face of it, there seems to be a big majority for reform. However, if any reader is rash enough to bet on the outcome, my advice would be to put their money on victory for the status quo. As I have argued before, referendums on contentious topics tend to make voters increasingly nervous as polling day approaches. The vague grass-is-greener enthusiasm for change when the decision is some months away tends to be trumped by a keep-a-hold-of-nurse caution when change is imminent.
11.36am: Lord Reid (pictured), the former Labour cabinet minister, told BBC News that he was opposed to having a democratically elected Lords because it would challenge the Commons.11.36am: Lord Reid (pictured), the former Labour cabinet minister, told BBC News that he was opposed to having a democratically elected Lords because it would challenge the Commons.
If anyone thinks that we will create a new class of 450 senators, with a term three times as long as MPs, with constitutencies 10 times as big, with no constitutuency business to do, because they are voted in by proportional representation, and call them senators and that will not become the primary house, they are deluding themselves. That will not only rival the House of Commons. It will supersede it, just as the Senate in the United States is now a far more superior body to the other house in Congress.If anyone thinks that we will create a new class of 450 senators, with a term three times as long as MPs, with constitutencies 10 times as big, with no constitutuency business to do, because they are voted in by proportional representation, and call them senators and that will not become the primary house, they are deluding themselves. That will not only rival the House of Commons. It will supersede it, just as the Senate in the United States is now a far more superior body to the other house in Congress.
And, incidentally, you will not retain [the primacy of the Commons] by writing in one line or two lines or a paragraph into the law saying, even though they have got longer terms, bigger constitutencies, they are senior members - they are senators - we'll just write a line in saying that they will be the inferior body. That won't work. You can write a line into a bill saying the moon is made of cream cheese. It won't make it the reality.And, incidentally, you will not retain [the primacy of the Commons] by writing in one line or two lines or a paragraph into the law saying, even though they have got longer terms, bigger constitutencies, they are senior members - they are senators - we'll just write a line in saying that they will be the inferior body. That won't work. You can write a line into a bill saying the moon is made of cream cheese. It won't make it the reality.
11.26am: You can read all today's Guardian politics stories here. And all the politics stories filed yesterday, including some in today's paper, are here.11.26am: You can read all today's Guardian politics stories here. And all the politics stories filed yesterday, including some in today's paper, are here.
As for the rest of the papers, here are a couple of articles that caught my eye.As for the rest of the papers, here are a couple of articles that caught my eye.
• Sam Coates and Roland Watson in the Times (paywall) say City figures have been urging David Cameron to block a proposed EU cap on bank bonuses.• Sam Coates and Roland Watson in the Times (paywall) say City figures have been urging David Cameron to block a proposed EU cap on bank bonuses.
Senior City figures are pleading with David Cameron for help in opposing new Brussels regulations that would impose a limit on bankers' bonuses ...Senior City figures are pleading with David Cameron for help in opposing new Brussels regulations that would impose a limit on bankers' bonuses ...
The Prime Minister will arrive in Brussels tomorrow lunchtime, when he will make clear that reforms to integrate Europe's banking system should apply only to the single currency and Britain will not take part. Mr Cameron has been seeing leading City figures to seek their advice about the eurozone crisis before the meeting.The Prime Minister will arrive in Brussels tomorrow lunchtime, when he will make clear that reforms to integrate Europe's banking system should apply only to the single currency and Britain will not take part. Mr Cameron has been seeing leading City figures to seek their advice about the eurozone crisis before the meeting.
Peter Sands, the chief executive of Standard Chartered Bank, warned the Prime Minister that a new cap on bonuses proposed by the European Parliament could drive the financial sector to New York and Hong Kong.Peter Sands, the chief executive of Standard Chartered Bank, warned the Prime Minister that a new cap on bonuses proposed by the European Parliament could drive the financial sector to New York and Hong Kong.
The change is part of a much wider reform package known as Capital Requirements Directive 4, which forces banks to hold bigger capital buffers.The change is part of a much wider reform package known as Capital Requirements Directive 4, which forces banks to hold bigger capital buffers.
• Nick Clegg in the Financial Times (subscription) says the UK must be engaged in the eurozone plans to create a banking union.• Nick Clegg in the Financial Times (subscription) says the UK must be engaged in the eurozone plans to create a banking union.
Economic marginalisation of the UK would bolster calls for a complete exit from the EU. I want to see the UK standing tall in Europe, not forced to the sidelines or, worse, out the door, for reasons of clout and also for jobs. This government is rightly devoting energy to fostering ties with the emerging powers driving global growth, but I am not convinced their leaders will take us seriously unless we play a leading role in our neighbourhood.Economic marginalisation of the UK would bolster calls for a complete exit from the EU. I want to see the UK standing tall in Europe, not forced to the sidelines or, worse, out the door, for reasons of clout and also for jobs. This government is rightly devoting energy to fostering ties with the emerging powers driving global growth, but I am not convinced their leaders will take us seriously unless we play a leading role in our neighbourhood.
11.08am: One of the big talking points in Westminser today - and BTL here - has been Jeremy Paxman's interview with Chloe Smith, the young Treasury minister, on Newsnight last night. She was pulverised. Given that Paxo was on top form, asking her questions that she could not or would not answer, I thought she held up reasonably well under the circumstances. But it was still excruciating to watch.11.08am: One of the big talking points in Westminser today - and BTL here - has been Jeremy Paxman's interview with Chloe Smith, the young Treasury minister, on Newsnight last night. She was pulverised. Given that Paxo was on top form, asking her questions that she could not or would not answer, I thought she held up reasonably well under the circumstances. But it was still excruciating to watch.
Opinion seems to be divided as to whether to blame Smith for being useless or George Osborne for sending her out to do the interview in the first place. The Conservative MP Nadine Dorries is in the latter camp.Opinion seems to be divided as to whether to blame Smith for being useless or George Osborne for sending her out to do the interview in the first place. The Conservative MP Nadine Dorries is in the latter camp.
I was at a dinner last night so didn't see Newsnight, however, if Osborne sent Chloe on re scrapping 3p he is a coward as well as arrogant.I was at a dinner last night so didn't see Newsnight, however, if Osborne sent Chloe on re scrapping 3p he is a coward as well as arrogant.
— Nadine Dorries MP (@NadineDorriesMP) June 27, 2012— Nadine Dorries MP (@NadineDorriesMP) June 27, 2012
On his blog, Alastair Campbell has advanced the same argument, in a rather more sophisticated form. Here's an extract.On his blog, Alastair Campbell has advanced the same argument, in a rather more sophisticated form. Here's an extract.
It was car crash territory. Like a scene from The Thick Of It. Ms Smith, who had not impinged on my consciousness until last night, will be feeling sore today. But it is Osborne who should be feeling responsible.It was car crash territory. Like a scene from The Thick Of It. Ms Smith, who had not impinged on my consciousness until last night, will be feeling sore today. But it is Osborne who should be feeling responsible.
There is an old cliche/'rule' re Budgets that if they go down well on the day, they unravel. If they go down badly, then tend to work out well. Osborne has made history – his went down badly on the day and has been unravelling ever since.There is an old cliche/'rule' re Budgets that if they go down well on the day, they unravel. If they go down badly, then tend to work out well. Osborne has made history – his went down badly on the day and has been unravelling ever since.
The reason Chloe Smith's interviews were so bad was not because she can't communicate, but because the answers to the questions she was being asked were too embarrassing. When did she know about the decision to freeze fuel duty? Clearly 'about five minutes before he announced it.' Where was the money coming to pay for it? 'We'll make that bit up as we go along as well.' How does a tax cut like this square with reducing the deficit being the main economic objective? 'It doesn't.' Do you ever think you are incompetent? 'No, but clearly the Prime Minister and the Chancellor are.'The reason Chloe Smith's interviews were so bad was not because she can't communicate, but because the answers to the questions she was being asked were too embarrassing. When did she know about the decision to freeze fuel duty? Clearly 'about five minutes before he announced it.' Where was the money coming to pay for it? 'We'll make that bit up as we go along as well.' How does a tax cut like this square with reducing the deficit being the main economic objective? 'It doesn't.' Do you ever think you are incompetent? 'No, but clearly the Prime Minister and the Chancellor are.'
Part of the job of politics is making difficult decisions. And part of the art of leadership is getting your head above the parapet to explain them. As the post-Budget omnishambles has unfolded, Osborne has done the bare minimum of explanation, no doubt because the focus groups are telling his Party that votes go south (or hopefully west towards Labour) every time he appears on the box.Part of the job of politics is making difficult decisions. And part of the art of leadership is getting your head above the parapet to explain them. As the post-Budget omnishambles has unfolded, Osborne has done the bare minimum of explanation, no doubt because the focus groups are telling his Party that votes go south (or hopefully west towards Labour) every time he appears on the box.
11.02am: For the record, here are the latest YouGov GB polling figures.

Labour: 42% (down 1 point from YouGov on Monday night)
Conservatives: 34% (up 2)
Lib Dems: 11% (no change)
Ukip: 7% (no change)		11.02am: For the record, here are the latest YouGov GB polling figures.

Labour: 42% (down 1 point from YouGov on Monday night)
Conservatives: 34% (up 2)
Lib Dems: 11% (no change)
Ukip: 7% (no change)
Labour lead: 8 pointsLabour lead: 8 points
Government approval: -36 (no change)Government approval: -36 (no change)
10.41am: Unlock Democracy, the pro-democracy campaign, has said that the government should keep the Commons sitting through the summer if Labour and the Tory rebels vote against the Lords timetable motion. This is from Peter Facey, the Unlock Democracy director.10.41am: Unlock Democracy, the pro-democracy campaign, has said that the government should keep the Commons sitting through the summer if Labour and the Tory rebels vote against the Lords timetable motion. This is from Peter Facey, the Unlock Democracy director.
Labour must also face up to the consequences of its actions. By blocking the programme motion if they are genuine about supporting the bill, they face weeks having to whip their MPs through endless procedural divisions. It isn't clear what all this extra time for debate will actually achieve on a topic which has been discussed to death for well over a century.Labour must also face up to the consequences of its actions. By blocking the programme motion if they are genuine about supporting the bill, they face weeks having to whip their MPs through endless procedural divisions. It isn't clear what all this extra time for debate will actually achieve on a topic which has been discussed to death for well over a century.
It is no doubt too late to persuade Ed Miliband to change his mind and vote in favour of the programme motion, but he might not want to whip his MPs too hard on the day of the vote. Failing that, he must spell out how much time it does need.It is no doubt too late to persuade Ed Miliband to change his mind and vote in favour of the programme motion, but he might not want to whip his MPs too hard on the day of the vote. Failing that, he must spell out how much time it does need.
If the programme motion does fall, the government must be prepared to keep the Commons in session throughout the summer; after all, there is no reason this legislation should eat into the time reserved for other bills. It is worth remembering that the 1911 Parliament Act reached it final stage in Parliament in August.If the programme motion does fall, the government must be prepared to keep the Commons in session throughout the summer; after all, there is no reason this legislation should eat into the time reserved for other bills. It is worth remembering that the 1911 Parliament Act reached it final stage in Parliament in August.
10.24am: And the Today programme also had an interview with the Lib Dem Foreign Office minister Jeremy Browne this morning about Lords reform. Browne used it to launch a scathing attack on Labour for not fully supporting the government's plans.10.24am: And the Today programme also had an interview with the Lib Dem Foreign Office minister Jeremy Browne this morning about Lords reform. Browne used it to launch a scathing attack on Labour for not fully supporting the government's plans.
Well, I think Labour's stance is probably the most depressing of any party, because what they are doing is playing games, and anybody who thinks that Labour are a progressive, enlightened, reformist party have now found out that they are nothing of the sort.Well, I think Labour's stance is probably the most depressing of any party, because what they are doing is playing games, and anybody who thinks that Labour are a progressive, enlightened, reformist party have now found out that they are nothing of the sort.
A lot of people listening to this would think if Labour stood for anything, it would surely be egalitarian will of the people. Actually, what we are finding out now is that the Labour leadership is so cynical, so blinded by hatred for Nick Clegg and the Lib Dems that they are not even willing to go along with what you would you would regard as the core principles of their party if those core principles are espoused by the Liberal Democrats and Nick Clegg.A lot of people listening to this would think if Labour stood for anything, it would surely be egalitarian will of the people. Actually, what we are finding out now is that the Labour leadership is so cynical, so blinded by hatred for Nick Clegg and the Lib Dems that they are not even willing to go along with what you would you would regard as the core principles of their party if those core principles are espoused by the Liberal Democrats and Nick Clegg.
It's an extraordinary situation Labour now find themselves in. They are the most vocal champions of elitism and privilege in our public life.It's an extraordinary situation Labour now find themselves in. They are the most vocal champions of elitism and privilege in our public life.
10.14am: Eleanor Laing, the Conservative MP, has also been speaking out against Lords reform today. This is what she told the Today programme this morning.10.14am: Eleanor Laing, the Conservative MP, has also been speaking out against Lords reform today. This is what she told the Today programme this morning.
The government is bound to do this because it's in the coalition agreement. That is fair enough. But there are large numbers of Conservatives, both in government and on the backbenches, who know that this is simply about giving the Liberal Democrats a permanent balance of power under PR in a second chamber. That's why we want a referendum; that's why we want a proper discussion in the House of Commons.The government is bound to do this because it's in the coalition agreement. That is fair enough. But there are large numbers of Conservatives, both in government and on the backbenches, who know that this is simply about giving the Liberal Democrats a permanent balance of power under PR in a second chamber. That's why we want a referendum; that's why we want a proper discussion in the House of Commons.
It is not for me to speak for the prime minister but I can speak for very large numbers of Conservative members of parliament and let me put it this way: there is no reasonable question to which 450 extra elected politicians is the answer.It is not for me to speak for the prime minister but I can speak for very large numbers of Conservative members of parliament and let me put it this way: there is no reasonable question to which 450 extra elected politicians is the answer.
9.50am: Sir George Young (pictured), the leader of the Commons, has just given an interview to BBC News about the Lords reform bill. Here are the key points.9.50am: Sir George Young (pictured), the leader of the Commons, has just given an interview to BBC News about the Lords reform bill. Here are the key points.
• Young said that "normal sanctions" would apply to Tory MPs who rebelled against the government. I suppose that means that ministers and ministerial aides would be sacked if they did not resign, and backbenchers would forfeit their chances of an early promotion. (There is a reshuffle planned for later this year.) You would expect Young to say this. On his Telegraph blog yesterday, Benedict Brogan said that Tory MPs have been told that rebelling over Lords reform actually won't damage their career prospects.

• Young said he thought the Lords reform bill would get onto the statute book. "I don't think it will fail," he said.		• Young said that "normal sanctions" would apply to Tory MPs who rebelled against the government. I suppose that means that ministers and ministerial aides would be sacked if they did not resign, and backbenchers would forfeit their chances of an early promotion. (There is a reshuffle planned for later this year.) You would expect Young to say this. On his Telegraph blog yesterday, Benedict Brogan said that Tory MPs have been told that rebelling over Lords reform actually won't damage their career prospects.

• Young said he thought the Lords reform bill would get onto the statute book. "I don't think it will fail," he said.
• He said that he was determined to provide "adequate time" for MPs to debate the bill.• He said that he was determined to provide "adequate time" for MPs to debate the bill.
• He said there was no need for a referendum. Labour did not hold a referendum when it carried out the first stage of Lords reform, the removal of most hereditary peers, he said.• He said there was no need for a referendum. Labour did not hold a referendum when it carried out the first stage of Lords reform, the removal of most hereditary peers, he said.
9.45am: Nick Clegg is not holding a press conference or making a Commons statement to mark the publication of the Lords reform bill. But he is giving TV interviews. This is what he told BBC News this morning.9.45am: Nick Clegg is not holding a press conference or making a Commons statement to mark the publication of the Lords reform bill. But he is giving TV interviews. This is what he told BBC News this morning.
There's a very simple principle at stake that I think most people would agree with, which is that people who make the laws of the land should be elected by people who have to obey the laws of the land. It's as simple as that. I think we should just now get on with it. I hope people won't tie themselves up in knots in Westminster. It's something the country expects us to do. We should now do it.There's a very simple principle at stake that I think most people would agree with, which is that people who make the laws of the land should be elected by people who have to obey the laws of the land. It's as simple as that. I think we should just now get on with it. I hope people won't tie themselves up in knots in Westminster. It's something the country expects us to do. We should now do it.
9.22am: Here's some more comment on the Lords reform bill from MPs who have been giving interviews this morning. I've taken the quotes from PoliticsHome.9.22am: Here's some more comment on the Lords reform bill from MPs who have been giving interviews this morning. I've taken the quotes from PoliticsHome.
David Blunkett, the Labour former cabinet minister, said he was opposed to the bill.David Blunkett, the Labour former cabinet minister, said he was opposed to the bill.
I'm opposed to taking a major constitutional change outside a thorough review of the constitutional changes that we've already had and those that are in train like the potential vote in Scotland for separation, the European Union and the eurozone changes, the bill of rights that's supposed to be a written code – all of these things need to be seen in context ...I'm opposed to taking a major constitutional change outside a thorough review of the constitutional changes that we've already had and those that are in train like the potential vote in Scotland for separation, the European Union and the eurozone changes, the bill of rights that's supposed to be a written code – all of these things need to be seen in context ...
We're rushing into this as a legacy for Nick Clegg ... There's a lot of Lib Dems worried about their seats at the next general election. And behold! They're going to pop up on a regional list system with PR trying to get re-elected to the second chamber. Hallelujah!We're rushing into this as a legacy for Nick Clegg ... There's a lot of Lib Dems worried about their seats at the next general election. And behold! They're going to pop up on a regional list system with PR trying to get re-elected to the second chamber. Hallelujah!
Sadiq Khan, the shadow justice secretary, said Labour was not voting against the timetable motion because it wanted to wreck the bill.Sadiq Khan, the shadow justice secretary, said Labour was not voting against the timetable motion because it wanted to wreck the bill.

The problem the government has is that this is a double whammy of bad legislation process. On the one hand they're denying the public their say by way of a referendum. On the other hand, they're denying those who represent the public a proper opportunity to scrutinise and improve the legislation by proper debate in the House of Commons and the floor of the house ...
The problem the government has is that this is a double whammy of bad legislation process. On the one hand they're denying the public their say by way of a referendum. On the other hand, they're denying those who represent the public a proper opportunity to scrutinise and improve the legislation by proper debate in the House of Commons and the floor of the house ...
We want there to be reform, what I am not going to do is say that we are going to help those Tory backbenchers who want to have this bill go down in flames at second reading. We will give this bill a second reading, we want it to be debated and we want to improve it.We want there to be reform, what I am not going to do is say that we are going to help those Tory backbenchers who want to have this bill go down in flames at second reading. We will give this bill a second reading, we want it to be debated and we want to improve it.
Simon Hughes, the Lib Dem deputy leader, said the chances of the bill passing were more than 50%.Simon Hughes, the Lib Dem deputy leader, said the chances of the bill passing were more than 50%.

I think they're better than 50%. They're better than 50% because all three major parties at the last election were committed to having a democratic second chamber, or principally democratic second chamber, and because the two government parties are united in the bill that's now being presented to parliament.
I think they're better than 50%. They're better than 50% because all three major parties at the last election were committed to having a democratic second chamber, or principally democratic second chamber, and because the two government parties are united in the bill that's now being presented to parliament.
9.15am: If you're interested in Lords reform, you'll love today. It's "game on", as Nick Clegg has been telling colleagues. He is publishing his Lords reform bill and starting what is set to be a momentous parliamentary battle to get it onto the statute book. And if you're not interested in Lords reform, well, I'm afraid it's probably best to leave the country now. With Labour refusing to back the timetable motion, it looks as though MPs could be debating little else for the next six months.9.15am: If you're interested in Lords reform, you'll love today. It's "game on", as Nick Clegg has been telling colleagues. He is publishing his Lords reform bill and starting what is set to be a momentous parliamentary battle to get it onto the statute book. And if you're not interested in Lords reform, well, I'm afraid it's probably best to leave the country now. With Labour refusing to back the timetable motion, it looks as though MPs could be debating little else for the next six months.
Today we've already had Conor Burns, a Conservative MP and ministerial aide to Owen Paterson, the Northern Ireland secretary, threaten to resign because he wants to vote against the bill's timetable motion.Today we've already had Conor Burns, a Conservative MP and ministerial aide to Owen Paterson, the Northern Ireland secretary, threaten to resign because he wants to vote against the bill's timetable motion.
This is major constitutional change. Major constitutional change is not usually guillotined in debate. If we are going to have this debate, we need to have it at length and in full and we should have it in committee on the floor of the House of Commons and we should take as much time as is necessary to do that. If I lose my job for something that was a mainstream view within the Conservative party in the last parliament, which serving cabinet ministers held as their view, so be it.This is major constitutional change. Major constitutional change is not usually guillotined in debate. If we are going to have this debate, we need to have it at length and in full and we should have it in committee on the floor of the House of Commons and we should take as much time as is necessary to do that. If I lose my job for something that was a mainstream view within the Conservative party in the last parliament, which serving cabinet ministers held as their view, so be it.

Burns is not the only MP speaking out against the bill. As the day goes on, I'll be reporting on other rebels, as well as covering all the other reaction.
Burns is not the only MP speaking out against the bill. As the day goes on, I'll be reporting on other rebels, as well as covering all the other reaction.
Here's the full agenda for the day.Here's the full agenda for the day.
9am: Nick Clegg speaks at a CBI jobs summit.9am: Nick Clegg speaks at a CBI jobs summit.
9.30am: Nick Gibb, the schools minister, gives evidence to the Commons education committee on behaviour in schools.

11am: Michael Gove, the education secretary, speaks at a Business in the Community conference.		9.30am: Nick Gibb, the schools minister, gives evidence to the Commons education committee on behaviour in schools.

11am: Michael Gove, the education secretary, speaks at a Business in the Community conference.
12pm: David Cameron and Ed Miliband clash at PMQs.12pm: David Cameron and Ed Miliband clash at PMQs.
12pm: David Miliband speaks at the CBI jobs summit.12pm: David Miliband speaks at the CBI jobs summit.
Around 12.30pm: The Lords reform bill is published.Around 12.30pm: The Lords reform bill is published.
As usual, I'll be covering all the breaking political news, as well as looking at the papers and bringing you the best politics from the web. I'll post a lunchtime summary at around 1pm and another in the afternoon.As usual, I'll be covering all the breaking political news, as well as looking at the papers and bringing you the best politics from the web. I'll post a lunchtime summary at around 1pm and another in the afternoon.
If you want to follow me on Twitter, I'm on @AndrewSparrow.If you want to follow me on Twitter, I'm on @AndrewSparrow.
And if you're a hardcore fan, you can follow @gdnpoliticslive. It's an automated feed that tweets the start of every new post that I put on the blog.And if you're a hardcore fan, you can follow @gdnpoliticslive. It's an automated feed that tweets the start of every new post that I put on the blog.