This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2012/aug/28/heathrow-third-runway-not-solution
The article has changed 8 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Heathrow third runway 'not a long-term solution', says Greening | |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| The transport secretary has insisted that cross-party consensus means a third runway at Heathrow will not be considered, as a senior Conservative stepped up the pressure for airport expansion by saying David Cameron must decide whether he is a "man or a mouse". | The transport secretary has insisted that cross-party consensus means a third runway at Heathrow will not be considered, as a senior Conservative stepped up the pressure for airport expansion by saying David Cameron must decide whether he is a "man or a mouse". |
| The former environment minister Tim Yeo, a known convert to Heathrow's cause, said the prime minister would be presiding over "a slide towards insignificance". In an article in the Daily Telegraph on Tuesday he claimed that environmental objections to a third runway were disappearing. | The former environment minister Tim Yeo, a known convert to Heathrow's cause, said the prime minister would be presiding over "a slide towards insignificance". In an article in the Daily Telegraph on Tuesday he claimed that environmental objections to a third runway were disappearing. |
| However, Justine Greening, the transport secretary, said it was "not a long-term solution". | However, Justine Greening, the transport secretary, said it was "not a long-term solution". |
| "We do need to look long term. One of the problems of the third runway – aside from noise, air pollution and surface access – is that it's not a full-length runway, it can't take the major new planes. The question then is, where would the fourth one go? | "We do need to look long term. One of the problems of the third runway – aside from noise, air pollution and surface access – is that it's not a full-length runway, it can't take the major new planes. The question then is, where would the fourth one go? |
| "It's time to move away from the piecemeal approach to aviation capacity. We need to look long term, start to be more bold, and think what our country needs in 30, 40, 50 years' time." | "It's time to move away from the piecemeal approach to aviation capacity. We need to look long term, start to be more bold, and think what our country needs in 30, 40, 50 years' time." |
| There has been speculation that Greening may be moved from her post in a forthcoming reshuffle. | There has been speculation that Greening may be moved from her post in a forthcoming reshuffle. |
| Pressed on the BBC Today programme whether she would sit in a cabinet that approved a third runway, she admitted it would be difficult but said: "I don't think the question arises." | Pressed on the BBC Today programme whether she would sit in a cabinet that approved a third runway, she admitted it would be difficult but said: "I don't think the question arises." |
| Yeo wrote: "The prime minister must ask himself whether he is a man or mouse. Does he want to be another Harold Macmillan, presiding over a dignified slide towards insignificance? | Yeo wrote: "The prime minister must ask himself whether he is a man or mouse. Does he want to be another Harold Macmillan, presiding over a dignified slide towards insignificance? |
| "Or is there somewhere inside his heart – an organ that still remains impenetrable to most Britons – a trace of Thatcher, determined to reverse the direction of our ship. | "Or is there somewhere inside his heart – an organ that still remains impenetrable to most Britons – a trace of Thatcher, determined to reverse the direction of our ship. |
| "An immediate go-ahead for a third runway will symbolise the start of a new era, the moment a Cameron government found its sense of mission. Let's go for it." | "An immediate go-ahead for a third runway will symbolise the start of a new era, the moment a Cameron government found its sense of mission. Let's go for it." |
| Greening said she would publish a long-awaited consultation on airport capacity as soon as parliament returns in September. This would consist of a "call for evidence on hub capacity" – namely, airports large enough to cater for connecting flights, which Heathrow's owners, BAA, claim is imperative to make more routes feasible. | Greening said she would publish a long-awaited consultation on airport capacity as soon as parliament returns in September. This would consist of a "call for evidence on hub capacity" – namely, airports large enough to cater for connecting flights, which Heathrow's owners, BAA, claim is imperative to make more routes feasible. |
| For many in aviation this consultation is the crucial marker of government plans, and its postponement this summer meant a framework policy paper published by Greening with plans for more stringent regulation on aircraft noise, the biggest objection to Heathrow expansion from residents in south-west London, was largely ignored. | For many in aviation this consultation is the crucial marker of government plans, and its postponement this summer meant a framework policy paper published by Greening with plans for more stringent regulation on aircraft noise, the biggest objection to Heathrow expansion from residents in south-west London, was largely ignored. |
| Greening said the call for evidence would allow arguments for expanding Heathrow, and BAA could "make their case", but she insisted: "I don't think any of the facts have changed around the third runway." | Greening said the call for evidence would allow arguments for expanding Heathrow, and BAA could "make their case", but she insisted: "I don't think any of the facts have changed around the third runway." |
| The coalition agreement opposes any expansion of airports in the south-east. The Conservatives have continued officially to rule out a third Heathrow runway, which they cancelled on taking office, but the chancellor, George Osborne, is believed to be a closet supporter of expansion. | The coalition agreement opposes any expansion of airports in the south-east. The Conservatives have continued officially to rule out a third Heathrow runway, which they cancelled on taking office, but the chancellor, George Osborne, is believed to be a closet supporter of expansion. |
| Many Tory backbenchers have lent support to the Heathrow cause. Recently the housing minister, Grant Shapps – tipped by some as a possible successor to Greening if she were to move – warned that a third runway was needed to ensure the UK remained a "great trading nation". | Many Tory backbenchers have lent support to the Heathrow cause. Recently the housing minister, Grant Shapps – tipped by some as a possible successor to Greening if she were to move – warned that a third runway was needed to ensure the UK remained a "great trading nation". |
| Boris Johnson accused Cameron of "pussyfooting around" the issue of expansion. The London mayor's idea of a Thames estuary airport looks set to be considered, although birdstrike, lack of infrastructure, airspace constraints and other issues make it appear a problematic solution. | Boris Johnson accused Cameron of "pussyfooting around" the issue of expansion. The London mayor's idea of a Thames estuary airport looks set to be considered, although birdstrike, lack of infrastructure, airspace constraints and other issues make it appear a problematic solution. |
| Yeo, who chairs the Commons energy committee, was previously a high-profile opponent of expansion but now argues that European Union carbon emissions caps will force airlines to use more environmentally friendly planes if they want to use new capacity at Heathrow. | Yeo, who chairs the Commons energy committee, was previously a high-profile opponent of expansion but now argues that European Union carbon emissions caps will force airlines to use more environmentally friendly planes if they want to use new capacity at Heathrow. |
| Labour has called for immediate cross-party talks on airport capacity. The shadow transport secretary, Maria Eagle, said: "While ministers fight amongst themselves, the paralysis at the heart of government on aviation is now adding to the paralysis in our economy." | Labour has called for immediate cross-party talks on airport capacity. The shadow transport secretary, Maria Eagle, said: "While ministers fight amongst themselves, the paralysis at the heart of government on aviation is now adding to the paralysis in our economy." |