This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/aug/29/navy-seal-bin-laden-raid
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Navy Seal account of Bin Laden raid contradicts White House claims | Navy Seal account of Bin Laden raid contradicts White House claims |
| (8 days later) | |
| A first-hand account of the US Navy Seal raid that killed Osama bin Laden contradicts previous accounts by administration officials, raising questions over whether he presented a clear threat when he was first fired upon. | A first-hand account of the US Navy Seal raid that killed Osama bin Laden contradicts previous accounts by administration officials, raising questions over whether he presented a clear threat when he was first fired upon. |
| Bin Laden apparently was hit in the head when he looked out of his bedroom door into the top-floor hallway of his compound as Seals rushed up a narrow stairwell in his direction, according to a former Navy Seal writing under the pseudonym Mark Owen in No Easy Day. The book is to be published next week by Penguin's Dutton imprint. | Bin Laden apparently was hit in the head when he looked out of his bedroom door into the top-floor hallway of his compound as Seals rushed up a narrow stairwell in his direction, according to a former Navy Seal writing under the pseudonym Mark Owen in No Easy Day. The book is to be published next week by Penguin's Dutton imprint. |
| The Seal says he was directly behind a "point man" going up the stairs. "Less than five steps" from the top of the stairs, he heard "suppressed" gunfire: "Bop. Bop." The point man had seen a "man peeking out of the door" on the right side of the hallway. | The Seal says he was directly behind a "point man" going up the stairs. "Less than five steps" from the top of the stairs, he heard "suppressed" gunfire: "Bop. Bop." The point man had seen a "man peeking out of the door" on the right side of the hallway. |
| Owen writes that Bin Laden ducked back into his bedroom and the Seals followed, only to find the terrorist crumpled on the floor in a pool of blood with a hole visible on the right side of his head and two women wailing over his body. | Owen writes that Bin Laden ducked back into his bedroom and the Seals followed, only to find the terrorist crumpled on the floor in a pool of blood with a hole visible on the right side of his head and two women wailing over his body. |
| He says the point man pulled the two women out of the way and shoved them into a corner, and he and the other Seals trained their guns' laser sites on Bin Laden's still-twitching body, shooting him several times until he lay motionless. The Seals later found two weapons stored by the doorway, untouched, the author said. | He says the point man pulled the two women out of the way and shoved them into a corner, and he and the other Seals trained their guns' laser sites on Bin Laden's still-twitching body, shooting him several times until he lay motionless. The Seals later found two weapons stored by the doorway, untouched, the author said. |
| In the account related by administration officials after the raid in Pakistan, the Seals shot Bin Laden only after he ducked back into the bedroom because they assumed he might be reaching for a weapon. | In the account related by administration officials after the raid in Pakistan, the Seals shot Bin Laden only after he ducked back into the bedroom because they assumed he might be reaching for a weapon. |
| White House spokesman Tommy Vietor would not comment on the apparent contradiction late Tuesday. But he said in an email: "As President Obama said on the night that justice was brought to Osama bin Laden, 'We give thanks for the men who carried out this operation, for they exemplify the professionalism, patriotism and unparalleled courage of those who serve our country.'" | White House spokesman Tommy Vietor would not comment on the apparent contradiction late Tuesday. But he said in an email: "As President Obama said on the night that justice was brought to Osama bin Laden, 'We give thanks for the men who carried out this operation, for they exemplify the professionalism, patriotism and unparalleled courage of those who serve our country.'" |
| No Easy Day was due out on 11 September, but Dutton announced the book would be available a week early on 4 September because of a surge of orders due to advance publicity that drove the book to the top of the Amazon and Barnes and Noble best-seller lists. | No Easy Day was due out on 11 September, but Dutton announced the book would be available a week early on 4 September because of a surge of orders due to advance publicity that drove the book to the top of the Amazon and Barnes and Noble best-seller lists. |
| The Associated Press purchased a copy of the book Tuesday. | The Associated Press purchased a copy of the book Tuesday. |
| The account is sure to again raise questions as to whether the raid was intended to capture or simply to kill Bin Laden. Owen writes that during a pre-raid briefing, a lawyer from "either" the White House or department of defense told them that they were not on an assassination mission. | The account is sure to again raise questions as to whether the raid was intended to capture or simply to kill Bin Laden. Owen writes that during a pre-raid briefing, a lawyer from "either" the White House or department of defense told them that they were not on an assassination mission. |
| According to Owen, the lawyer said that if bin Laden was "naked with his hands up," they should not "engage" him. If bin Laden did not pose a threat, they should "detain him." | According to Owen, the lawyer said that if bin Laden was "naked with his hands up," they should not "engage" him. If bin Laden did not pose a threat, they should "detain him." |
| In another possibly uncomfortable revelation for US officials who say Bin Laden's body was treated with dignity before being given a full Muslim burial at sea, the author reveals that in the cramped helicopter flight out of the compound, one of the Seals called Walt – one of the pseudonyms the author used for his fellow Seals – was sitting on Bin Laden's chest as the body lay at the author's feet in the middle of the cabin. | In another possibly uncomfortable revelation for US officials who say Bin Laden's body was treated with dignity before being given a full Muslim burial at sea, the author reveals that in the cramped helicopter flight out of the compound, one of the Seals called Walt – one of the pseudonyms the author used for his fellow Seals – was sitting on Bin Laden's chest as the body lay at the author's feet in the middle of the cabin. |
| This is common practice, as troops sometimes must sit on their own war dead in packed helicopters. Space was cramped because one helicopter had crashed in the initial assault, leaving little space for the roughly two dozen commandos in the two aircraft that remained. When the commandos reached the third aircraft, bin Laden's body was moved to it. | This is common practice, as troops sometimes must sit on their own war dead in packed helicopters. Space was cramped because one helicopter had crashed in the initial assault, leaving little space for the roughly two dozen commandos in the two aircraft that remained. When the commandos reached the third aircraft, bin Laden's body was moved to it. |
| Owen also writes disparagingly that none of the Seals were fans of President Barack Obama and knew that his administration would take credit for ordering the May 2011 raid. One of the Seals said after the mission that they had just gotten Obama re-elected by carrying out the raid. | Owen also writes disparagingly that none of the Seals were fans of President Barack Obama and knew that his administration would take credit for ordering the May 2011 raid. One of the Seals said after the mission that they had just gotten Obama re-elected by carrying out the raid. |
| But he says they respected him as commander in chief and for giving the operation the go-ahead. | But he says they respected him as commander in chief and for giving the operation the go-ahead. |
| US officials fear the book may include classified information, as it did not undergo the formal review required by the Pentagon for works published by former or current Defense Department employees. | US officials fear the book may include classified information, as it did not undergo the formal review required by the Pentagon for works published by former or current Defense Department employees. |
| Officials from the Pentagon and the CIA, which commanded the mission, are examining the manuscript for possible disclosure of classified information and could take legal action against the author. | Officials from the Pentagon and the CIA, which commanded the mission, are examining the manuscript for possible disclosure of classified information and could take legal action against the author. |
| In a statement provided to the Associated Press, the author says he did "not disclose confidential or sensitive information that would compromise national security in any way." | In a statement provided to the Associated Press, the author says he did "not disclose confidential or sensitive information that would compromise national security in any way." |
| Jihadists on al-Qaida websites have posted purported photos of the author, whose name has been disclosed by some media outlets, calling for his murder. | Jihadists on al-Qaida websites have posted purported photos of the author, whose name has been disclosed by some media outlets, calling for his murder. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. | Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. Enter your email address to subscribe. | Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. Enter your email address to subscribe. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox every weekday. |