This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/oct/05/abu-hamza-loses-extradition-appeal
The article has changed 8 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Abu Hamza extradition to US goes ahead after court defeat | Abu Hamza extradition to US goes ahead after court defeat |
| (about 1 month later) | |
| The radical cleric Abu Hamza and four other terrorist suspects were last night extradited to the US after the high court cleared the way for their immediate removal. | The radical cleric Abu Hamza and four other terrorist suspects were last night extradited to the US after the high court cleared the way for their immediate removal. |
| The men were on two planes that left a military airbase in Suffolk late last night, the home secretary, Theresa May, said. Speaking after the US-bound flights had taken off, May said: "I can confirm that tonight two planes have left RAF Mildenhall to transport Abu Hamza, Babar Ahmad, Adel Abdul Bary, Syed Ahsan and Khalid al-Fawwaz to the US to face trial. | The men were on two planes that left a military airbase in Suffolk late last night, the home secretary, Theresa May, said. Speaking after the US-bound flights had taken off, May said: "I can confirm that tonight two planes have left RAF Mildenhall to transport Abu Hamza, Babar Ahmad, Adel Abdul Bary, Syed Ahsan and Khalid al-Fawwaz to the US to face trial. |
| "I am pleased the decision of the court today meant that these men, who used every available opportunity to frustrate and delay the extradition process over many years, could finally be removed. | "I am pleased the decision of the court today meant that these men, who used every available opportunity to frustrate and delay the extradition process over many years, could finally be removed. |
| "This government has co-operated fully with the courts and pressed at every stage to ensure this happened. We have worked tirelessly, alongside the US authorities, the police and the prison service, to put plans in place so that tonight these men could be handed over within hours of the court's decision. It is right that these men, who are all accused of very serious offences, will finally face justice." | "This government has co-operated fully with the courts and pressed at every stage to ensure this happened. We have worked tirelessly, alongside the US authorities, the police and the prison service, to put plans in place so that tonight these men could be handed over within hours of the court's decision. It is right that these men, who are all accused of very serious offences, will finally face justice." |
| After three days of legal argument, Sir John Thomas, president of the Queen's Bench division, and Mr Justice Ouseley lifted injunctions that had been preventing the men's removal. | After three days of legal argument, Sir John Thomas, president of the Queen's Bench division, and Mr Justice Ouseley lifted injunctions that had been preventing the men's removal. |
| The decision is the culmination of an eight-year legal battle that has strained the government's constitutional relationship with the European court of human rights in Strasbourg and frustrated politicians, as well as the lord chief justice. | The decision is the culmination of an eight-year legal battle that has strained the government's constitutional relationship with the European court of human rights in Strasbourg and frustrated politicians, as well as the lord chief justice. |
| The cases have involved appeals through the hierarchy of British and European courts, then back to the royal courts of justice in London. | The cases have involved appeals through the hierarchy of British and European courts, then back to the royal courts of justice in London. |
| Delivering judgment, Sir John Thomas said: "All of these claimants have long ago exhausted the [legal] procedures in the UK. There's an overwhelming public interest in the proper functioning of the extradition arrangements in the US. It's important to recognise the finality of these proceedings." | Delivering judgment, Sir John Thomas said: "All of these claimants have long ago exhausted the [legal] procedures in the UK. There's an overwhelming public interest in the proper functioning of the extradition arrangements in the US. It's important to recognise the finality of these proceedings." |
| Sir John said that extradition proceedings should take months not years and the process had been "disfigured" by protracted delays. "There's no appeal from our decision and the home secretary will be free" to extradite them, he added. | Sir John said that extradition proceedings should take months not years and the process had been "disfigured" by protracted delays. "There's no appeal from our decision and the home secretary will be free" to extradite them, he added. |
| Sir John was scathing about the attempt to try to bring a private prosecution against Babar Ahmad and Talha Ahsan in Britain. "It's now far, far, far too late to raise it now," he said. The use of such a procedure amounted to an "abuse of process". | Sir John was scathing about the attempt to try to bring a private prosecution against Babar Ahmad and Talha Ahsan in Britain. "It's now far, far, far too late to raise it now," he said. The use of such a procedure amounted to an "abuse of process". |
| Sir John Thomas also suggested that reform of extradition procedures in future to stop them dragging on for so long. He said: "There may well be a need to reconsider the inter-relationship of the statutory appeal scheme, the ability to reopen appeals and the role of judicial review." | Sir John Thomas also suggested that reform of extradition procedures in future to stop them dragging on for so long. He said: "There may well be a need to reconsider the inter-relationship of the statutory appeal scheme, the ability to reopen appeals and the role of judicial review." |
| The US wants all five men to face al-Qaida-related terrorist charges in American courts. | The US wants all five men to face al-Qaida-related terrorist charges in American courts. |
| The Home Office reacted immediately to the decision by tweeting: "We welcome the high court decision on Abu Hamza & others. We are now working to extradite these men as quickly as possible." | The Home Office reacted immediately to the decision by tweeting: "We welcome the high court decision on Abu Hamza & others. We are now working to extradite these men as quickly as possible." |
| Police vehicles, including armoured vans, arrived at HMP Long Lartin, near Evesham, in Worcestershire at around 6.30pm on Friday. After about an hour, the vehicles, understood to have Hamza and the other men inside, left the prison grounds. Under heavy security, they drove off at speed to RAF Mildenhall. | Police vehicles, including armoured vans, arrived at HMP Long Lartin, near Evesham, in Worcestershire at around 6.30pm on Friday. After about an hour, the vehicles, understood to have Hamza and the other men inside, left the prison grounds. Under heavy security, they drove off at speed to RAF Mildenhall. |
| Four of the five men had claimed that harsh prison conditions in the high security unit at the US jail, ADX Florence in Colorado, where they may eventually be imprisoned would breach their human rights. Abu Hamza, it was said, would not have to spend too long at the facility because of hid many medical conditions. | Four of the five men had claimed that harsh prison conditions in the high security unit at the US jail, ADX Florence in Colorado, where they may eventually be imprisoned would breach their human rights. Abu Hamza, it was said, would not have to spend too long at the facility because of hid many medical conditions. |
| Abu Hamza, 54, who was jailed for seven years for soliciting murder and inciting racial hatred, has been fighting extradition since 2004. His lawyers opposed deportation on the grounds that he was suffering memory loss and depression and was unfit to plead. They sought permission for the former imam at Finsbury Park mosque in north London to be given an MRI scan to assess his medical condition. | Abu Hamza, 54, who was jailed for seven years for soliciting murder and inciting racial hatred, has been fighting extradition since 2004. His lawyers opposed deportation on the grounds that he was suffering memory loss and depression and was unfit to plead. They sought permission for the former imam at Finsbury Park mosque in north London to be given an MRI scan to assess his medical condition. |
| Ahmad, 37, a computer expert, and Ahsan, 33, are accused of raising funds for terrorism through a website. Lawyers for the two men challenged the director of public prosecution's decision not to charge them with offences allegedly committed in the UK. Fawwaz, who is alleged to have been an aide to Osama bin Laden in the 1990s, was seeking disclosure of an 800-page MI6 document relating to the debriefing of another suspect which, his lawyers maintain, would undermine the charges against him. | Ahmad, 37, a computer expert, and Ahsan, 33, are accused of raising funds for terrorism through a website. Lawyers for the two men challenged the director of public prosecution's decision not to charge them with offences allegedly committed in the UK. Fawwaz, who is alleged to have been an aide to Osama bin Laden in the 1990s, was seeking disclosure of an 800-page MI6 document relating to the debriefing of another suspect which, his lawyers maintain, would undermine the charges against him. |
| Bary, 52, is also said to have worked closely with Bin Laden. His barrister argued that conditions in US high-security jails would breach his rights under the European convention on human rights – a claim already dismissed by the Strasbourg court. | Bary, 52, is also said to have worked closely with Bin Laden. His barrister argued that conditions in US high-security jails would breach his rights under the European convention on human rights – a claim already dismissed by the Strasbourg court. |
| Bary and Fawwaz are wanted in relation to the bombings of US embassies in east Africa in 1998. | Bary and Fawwaz are wanted in relation to the bombings of US embassies in east Africa in 1998. |
| Protesters opposing deportation and supporting Ahmad and Ahsan gathered outside the royal courts of justice. | Protesters opposing deportation and supporting Ahmad and Ahsan gathered outside the royal courts of justice. |
| Lines of police officers watched as protesters chanted: "British justice for British citizens" and waved "Stop extradition" placards. A few wore union flag T-shirts emblazoned with the motto: "Extradite me, I'm British". | Lines of police officers watched as protesters chanted: "British justice for British citizens" and waved "Stop extradition" placards. A few wore union flag T-shirts emblazoned with the motto: "Extradite me, I'm British". |
| The US embassy in London welcomed the court's decision and noted that they had submitted the first extradition request 14 years ago: "These extraditions mark the end of a lengthy process of litigation through the UK courts and the European court of human rights." Its statement particularly highlighted the Strasbourg court's finding that conditions in American maximum security facilities did not violate European standards. | The US embassy in London welcomed the court's decision and noted that they had submitted the first extradition request 14 years ago: "These extraditions mark the end of a lengthy process of litigation through the UK courts and the European court of human rights." Its statement particularly highlighted the Strasbourg court's finding that conditions in American maximum security facilities did not violate European standards. |
| Babar Ahmad stated: "Today I have lost my eight-year-and-two-month battle against extradition to the US. I would like to thank all those over the years who supported me and my family: lawyers, politicians, journalists and members of the public from all walks of life. | Babar Ahmad stated: "Today I have lost my eight-year-and-two-month battle against extradition to the US. I would like to thank all those over the years who supported me and my family: lawyers, politicians, journalists and members of the public from all walks of life. |
| "By exposing the fallacy of the UK's extradition arrangements with the US, I leave with my head held high, having won the moral victory." | "By exposing the fallacy of the UK's extradition arrangements with the US, I leave with my head held high, having won the moral victory." |
| Ashfaq Ahmad, father of Babar Ahmad, stated: "After over 40 years of paying taxes in this country, I am appalled that the system has let me down in a manner more befitting of a third world country than one of the world's oldest democracies. | Ashfaq Ahmad, father of Babar Ahmad, stated: "After over 40 years of paying taxes in this country, I am appalled that the system has let me down in a manner more befitting of a third world country than one of the world's oldest democracies. |
| "It seems that the Metropolitan police, the CPS and even the court have all colluded to implement a predetermined decision which was made in Washington. | "It seems that the Metropolitan police, the CPS and even the court have all colluded to implement a predetermined decision which was made in Washington. |
| "We will never abandon our struggle for justice and the truth will eventually emerge of what will be for ever remembered as a shameful chapter in the history of Britain." | "We will never abandon our struggle for justice and the truth will eventually emerge of what will be for ever remembered as a shameful chapter in the history of Britain." |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. | |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. Enter your email address to subscribe. |