This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/26/nyregion/fatal-stabbings-on-upper-west-side-nanny-is-arrested.html
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| 2 Siblings Killed in New York City; Nanny Arrested | |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| A mother returned home from work to her luxury Upper West Side apartment on Thursday night to find two of her children, a 2-year-old boy and 6-year-old girl, fatally stabbed in a bathtub by the family’s nanny, the authorities said. The nanny herself lay nearby, near a bloody knife, with an apparently self-inflicted slash to her own throat. | A mother returned home from work to her luxury Upper West Side apartment on Thursday night to find two of her children, a 2-year-old boy and 6-year-old girl, fatally stabbed in a bathtub by the family’s nanny, the authorities said. The nanny herself lay nearby, near a bloody knife, with an apparently self-inflicted slash to her own throat. |
| Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly said that the mother had left her apartment a block from Central Park at 57 West 75th Street with one of her children, a 3-year-old girl. The two other children were left with the nanny. | Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly said that the mother had left her apartment a block from Central Park at 57 West 75th Street with one of her children, a 3-year-old girl. The two other children were left with the nanny. |
| When the mother returned around 5:30 p.m., he said, she found a dark apartment. She went back down to the lobby to ask the doorman if he had seen the nanny and her children. When told that they had not left the building, she returned to the apartment. When she turned the lights on in the bathroom, she discovered her two children in the bathtub and the nanny unconscious on the floor. | When the mother returned around 5:30 p.m., he said, she found a dark apartment. She went back down to the lobby to ask the doorman if he had seen the nanny and her children. When told that they had not left the building, she returned to the apartment. When she turned the lights on in the bathroom, she discovered her two children in the bathtub and the nanny unconscious on the floor. |
| “There were bloodcurdling screams from a woman and man’s screaming,” said Rima Starr, who lives down the hall from the victims’ second-floor apartment. Ms. Starr recognized the man’s voice as the building superintendent’s. She heard him yelling: “You slit her throat! You slit her throat!” | “There were bloodcurdling screams from a woman and man’s screaming,” said Rima Starr, who lives down the hall from the victims’ second-floor apartment. Ms. Starr recognized the man’s voice as the building superintendent’s. She heard him yelling: “You slit her throat! You slit her throat!” |
| The nanny, whose name was not released, was arrested as soon as the police arrived, according to law enforcement officials. She was taken to NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center, where she was in critical but stable condition. | The nanny, whose name was not released, was arrested as soon as the police arrived, according to law enforcement officials. She was taken to NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center, where she was in critical but stable condition. |
| The police did not release the name of the family because they were trying to locate the children’s father. They also declined to release the name of the nanny but said she was 50. | The police did not release the name of the family because they were trying to locate the children’s father. They also declined to release the name of the nanny but said she was 50. |
| Paul J. Browne, the chief spokesman for the Police Department, said the mother got home with her younger daughter and saw the nanny “laying face up on the bathroom floor with stab wounds to the throat area.” There was a kitchen knife next to her. | Paul J. Browne, the chief spokesman for the Police Department, said the mother got home with her younger daughter and saw the nanny “laying face up on the bathroom floor with stab wounds to the throat area.” There was a kitchen knife next to her. |
| “It is believed that she is the assailant,” Mr. Browne said. The nanny had yet to be formally charged, he said. | “It is believed that she is the assailant,” Mr. Browne said. The nanny had yet to be formally charged, he said. |
| A neighbor, concerned about the screams coming from the second floor apartment, called 911, he said. | A neighbor, concerned about the screams coming from the second floor apartment, called 911, he said. |
| Ms. Starr said that when she saw the children’s mother in the building’s lobby, she was in a state of shock. “She was screaming in a psychotic state,” she said. “She was not lucid.” | Ms. Starr said that when she saw the children’s mother in the building’s lobby, she was in a state of shock. “She was screaming in a psychotic state,” she said. “She was not lucid.” |
| First, she wailed that she would never see her child again, Ms. Starr said. Then she was “just screaming and swaying,” she recalled. “She had a lucid moment and said, ‘I need a doctor.’ ” | First, she wailed that she would never see her child again, Ms. Starr said. Then she was “just screaming and swaying,” she recalled. “She had a lucid moment and said, ‘I need a doctor.’ ” |
| Neighbors saw the mother, a towel over her head, clinging to her one surviving child, being escorted by the police to a waiting ambulance. | Neighbors saw the mother, a towel over her head, clinging to her one surviving child, being escorted by the police to a waiting ambulance. |
| In a neighborhood where nannies are common, where in the afternoon they can be seen by the dozens pushing strollers or walking their charges to school, the violence struck a nerve of stark disbelief. There were no immediate explanations for what drove the nanny’s actions. Mr. Browne said he did not know if she left a note behind, and he could not immediately say how long she had worked for the family. | In a neighborhood where nannies are common, where in the afternoon they can be seen by the dozens pushing strollers or walking their charges to school, the violence struck a nerve of stark disbelief. There were no immediate explanations for what drove the nanny’s actions. Mr. Browne said he did not know if she left a note behind, and he could not immediately say how long she had worked for the family. |
| Ms. Starr said she did not know her neighbor well, but described a young, loving couple. The husband is a businessman, she said. They have a big, friendly greyhound named Babar, she said. | Ms. Starr said she did not know her neighbor well, but described a young, loving couple. The husband is a businessman, she said. They have a big, friendly greyhound named Babar, she said. |
| She had seen the nanny in the building, she said, but never got the sense of anything being out of the ordinary. | She had seen the nanny in the building, she said, but never got the sense of anything being out of the ordinary. |
| “I rode in the elevator with the nanny just the day before yesterday,” Ms. Starr said. “I was making small talk. She was sort of unfriendly, didn’t want to interact. But I didn’t notice anything strange or weird.” | “I rode in the elevator with the nanny just the day before yesterday,” Ms. Starr said. “I was making small talk. She was sort of unfriendly, didn’t want to interact. But I didn’t notice anything strange or weird.” |
| Sandy Marcus, a speech therapist, has lived in the building, La Rochelle, for more than 30 years. She was watching television when she saw a report about the stabbing, and when she heard the address, and realized it was her building, she went downstairs. | Sandy Marcus, a speech therapist, has lived in the building, La Rochelle, for more than 30 years. She was watching television when she saw a report about the stabbing, and when she heard the address, and realized it was her building, she went downstairs. |
| “I wanted to make sure it was nobody I knew,” she said. | “I wanted to make sure it was nobody I knew,” she said. |
| She reached the balcony level overlooking the lobby and saw two women — one being lifted into an ambulance outside the building, the other in a chair in the lobby, holding a young child. The woman in the chair was a woman she recognized as the mother of a family of young children who lived on the second floor. She said the mother was screaming “for dear life.” | She reached the balcony level overlooking the lobby and saw two women — one being lifted into an ambulance outside the building, the other in a chair in the lobby, holding a young child. The woman in the chair was a woman she recognized as the mother of a family of young children who lived on the second floor. She said the mother was screaming “for dear life.” |
| “Seeing these two kids playing in the hall, and now two of them are dead, it’s a nightmare,” she said. “The most horrible thing.” | “Seeing these two kids playing in the hall, and now two of them are dead, it’s a nightmare,” she said. “The most horrible thing.” |
Reporting was contributed by James Barron, Joseph Goldstein, Kia Gregory and William K. Rashbaum. | Reporting was contributed by James Barron, Joseph Goldstein, Kia Gregory and William K. Rashbaum. |
| This article has been revised to reflect the following correction: | This article has been revised to reflect the following correction: |
| Correction: October 25, 2012 | Correction: October 25, 2012 |
An earlier version of this article misstated the ages and sex of the children who were killed. They were 2 and 6 years old, not 3 and 5. And one was a girl; they were not both boys. | An earlier version of this article misstated the ages and sex of the children who were killed. They were 2 and 6 years old, not 3 and 5. And one was a girl; they were not both boys. |