This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-21483103

The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 2 Version 3
Jeremy Hunt warns NHS health trusts over gagging orders Jeremy Hunt warns NHS health trusts over gagging orders
(about 1 hour later)
Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt has written to all English NHS trusts to urge them not to use gagging clauses to stop staff raising concerns over care.Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt has written to all English NHS trusts to urge them not to use gagging clauses to stop staff raising concerns over care.
He says a culture of openness is vital if the NHS is to avoid mistakes seen at Stafford Hospital, where abuse and neglect led to hundreds of deaths.He says a culture of openness is vital if the NHS is to avoid mistakes seen at Stafford Hospital, where abuse and neglect led to hundreds of deaths.
It comes after Gary Walker, a former NHS boss in Lincolnshire, broke such an order by talking to the BBC.It comes after Gary Walker, a former NHS boss in Lincolnshire, broke such an order by talking to the BBC.
Mr Walker said he had been gagged from raising fears over patient safety.Mr Walker said he had been gagged from raising fears over patient safety.
'Positive move'
The former chief executive of United Lincolnshire Hospitals Trust (ULHT) said he had no choice but to sign an agreement linked to a confidentiality clause in April 2011.The former chief executive of United Lincolnshire Hospitals Trust (ULHT) said he had no choice but to sign an agreement linked to a confidentiality clause in April 2011.
He was sacked in 2010 for gross professional misconduct for allegedly swearing in a meeting.He was sacked in 2010 for gross professional misconduct for allegedly swearing in a meeting.
Mr Walker said he was gagged by the NHS from speaking out about his dismissal and his concerns over the quality of care at the trust.Mr Walker said he was gagged by the NHS from speaking out about his dismissal and his concerns over the quality of care at the trust.
After breaking the order, lawyers for the trust then warned him he would have to repay £500,000.After breaking the order, lawyers for the trust then warned him he would have to repay £500,000.
Speaking to the BBC on Saturday, Mr Walker applauded Mr Hunt for "clearly taking a personal interest" in his case and the issue of gagging orders. Speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme on Saturday, Mr Walker applauded Mr Hunt for "clearly taking a personal interest" in his case and the issue of gagging orders.
"I think that's a very positive move.""I think that's a very positive move."
"I don't think it's simply about the Lincolnshire Trust," he added, calling for Mr Hunt to investigate the "chain of command" that led to the gagging, which he said included the Department of Health, the East Midlands Strategic Health Authority (SHA) and the Lincolnshire Trust.
"I don't think Mr Hunt can investigate his own department so I think he should be looking for someone exceptionally independent from all of this."
Test caseTest case
In his letter, Mr Hunt said that staff who had the courage and professional integrity to raise concerns over care should be "encouraged and celebrated".In his letter, Mr Hunt said that staff who had the courage and professional integrity to raise concerns over care should be "encouraged and celebrated".
The health secretary had said on Friday he did not want to make a judgement about Mr Walker's claims but there were "a lot of very serious allegations that we need to get to the bottom of".The health secretary had said on Friday he did not want to make a judgement about Mr Walker's claims but there were "a lot of very serious allegations that we need to get to the bottom of".
He said this could become a test case for other "gagged" NHS employees, but said he did not know how many of these orders were in place.He said this could become a test case for other "gagged" NHS employees, but said he did not know how many of these orders were in place.
Mr Hunt said the trust should have been concentrating on the concerns raised, rather than instructing their lawyers .Mr Hunt said the trust should have been concentrating on the concerns raised, rather than instructing their lawyers .
ULHT has said the allegations that they had tried to stifle debate about patient safety issues were "incorrect".ULHT has said the allegations that they had tried to stifle debate about patient safety issues were "incorrect".
BBC Radio 4 Today programme reporter Andy Hosken said Mr Hunt's letter could spell the end of the National Health Service gag if the NHS trusts' chairmen to whom he wrote actually followed the advice and guidance contained within the letter.BBC Radio 4 Today programme reporter Andy Hosken said Mr Hunt's letter could spell the end of the National Health Service gag if the NHS trusts' chairmen to whom he wrote actually followed the advice and guidance contained within the letter.
Our correspondent said the letter was certainly a warning shot across the boughs of the trusts, some of which he criticised for institutional self-defence that prevented honest acknowledgment of failure.Our correspondent said the letter was certainly a warning shot across the boughs of the trusts, some of which he criticised for institutional self-defence that prevented honest acknowledgment of failure.
It appeared the use of these gagging clauses was widespread in the NHS, he added.It appeared the use of these gagging clauses was widespread in the NHS, he added.
'Stop ongoing litigation'
Employment solicitor Andrew Tobey told Today it was "emotive" to use the term gagging order, adding that agreements which included mutual confidentiality obligations were not always "the blunt instrument they are made out to be".
"It is perfectly possible to refine these clauses to still allow the ex-employee to talk to regulatory bodies about patient safety," he said.
Mr Tobey added such contracts could benefit the NHS and the taxpaying public because "the aim of of these agreements does stop ongoing litigation" following the dismissal of an employee, and "allows both sides to move forward" without costly court battles.
ULHT is one of 14 trusts in England currently being investigated for high death rates, in the wake of the Stafford hospital scandal, where hundreds are believed to have died after receiving poor care.ULHT is one of 14 trusts in England currently being investigated for high death rates, in the wake of the Stafford hospital scandal, where hundreds are believed to have died after receiving poor care.
It was revealed on Friday that police and prosecutors are now studying a damning report into failures at Stafford to see whether any criminal charges should be brought against staff.It was revealed on Friday that police and prosecutors are now studying a damning report into failures at Stafford to see whether any criminal charges should be brought against staff.
A spokesman for the SHA said it had always acted "appropriately and properly" in the "interest of patients".