This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2013/feb/18/nat-rothschild-bumi-key-investor
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Nat Rothschild suffers blow in bid to seize back Bumi control | Nat Rothschild suffers blow in bid to seize back Bumi control |
| (7 months later) | |
| Nat Rothschild's bid to seize back control of the embattled mining group Bumi has been dealt a blow after a key investor sold his shareholding shortly before a crucial vote on the company's future. | Nat Rothschild's bid to seize back control of the embattled mining group Bumi has been dealt a blow after a key investor sold his shareholding shortly before a crucial vote on the company's future. |
| The scion of the Rothschild banking dynasty had expressed confidence that he would prevail at an extraordinary general meeting on Thursday, when he will seek to install a new board at the Indonesian coal-mining concern. | The scion of the Rothschild banking dynasty had expressed confidence that he would prevail at an extraordinary general meeting on Thursday, when he will seek to install a new board at the Indonesian coal-mining concern. |
| The Bumi story was supposed to be a lucrative combination of two worlds, merging the coal assets of Indonesia's Bakrie family with Rothschild's money and roster of blue-chip City investors. | The Bumi story was supposed to be a lucrative combination of two worlds, merging the coal assets of Indonesia's Bakrie family with Rothschild's money and roster of blue-chip City investors. |
| Instead, the former partners in the business are locked in a battle for control that should be settled this week. Rothschild claimed at the weekend that his camp would "win by a convincing margin", allowing the financier to pursue litigation against the Bakries over allegations that $1bn (£645m) has gone missing from the group's assets. The Bakries have denied involvement in financial irregularities. | Instead, the former partners in the business are locked in a battle for control that should be settled this week. Rothschild claimed at the weekend that his camp would "win by a convincing margin", allowing the financier to pursue litigation against the Bakries over allegations that $1bn (£645m) has gone missing from the group's assets. The Bakries have denied involvement in financial irregularities. |
| However, the result of the shareholder poll was thrown into doubt when an ally of the Bakries, Rosan Roeslani, agreed to sell his 10% stake to two funds and a company controlled by a high-profile Indonesian family. | However, the result of the shareholder poll was thrown into doubt when an ally of the Bakries, Rosan Roeslani, agreed to sell his 10% stake to two funds and a company controlled by a high-profile Indonesian family. |
| Before that move, the UK's Takeover Panel had deemed Roeslani to be acting in concert with the Bakries and another Indonesian investor, Samin Tan, in a ruling that restricted the group's voting power to 29.9% of a shareholder ballot even though they controlled about 57% of the equity. That enhanced the power of Rothschild's 18% stake, which was further boosted by the support of UK shareholders including Schroders and Brompton Asset Management. | Before that move, the UK's Takeover Panel had deemed Roeslani to be acting in concert with the Bakries and another Indonesian investor, Samin Tan, in a ruling that restricted the group's voting power to 29.9% of a shareholder ballot even though they controlled about 57% of the equity. That enhanced the power of Rothschild's 18% stake, which was further boosted by the support of UK shareholders including Schroders and Brompton Asset Management. |
| Monday's events, the Roeslani stake may be voted as the new owners wish. The Takeover Panel surprised the financier by declaring that the three buyers – Flaming Luck Investments, which is owned by the Tanoesoedibjo family, Avenue Asia Capital Management and Argyle Street Management – are not considered to be acting with the Bakries. | Monday's events, the Roeslani stake may be voted as the new owners wish. The Takeover Panel surprised the financier by declaring that the three buyers – Flaming Luck Investments, which is owned by the Tanoesoedibjo family, Avenue Asia Capital Management and Argyle Street Management – are not considered to be acting with the Bakries. |
| Reports stated that the Indonesian media company MNC Group, owned by Hary Tanoesoedibjo, is a leading contender in the bid for a majority interest in the Bakries' media company PT Visi Media Asia. In turn, that sale is intended to fund the Bakrie family's plan to buy back Bumi coal assets and exit the venture. | Reports stated that the Indonesian media company MNC Group, owned by Hary Tanoesoedibjo, is a leading contender in the bid for a majority interest in the Bakries' media company PT Visi Media Asia. In turn, that sale is intended to fund the Bakrie family's plan to buy back Bumi coal assets and exit the venture. |
| One source familiar with the takeover battle for the London-listed business told Reuters: "It appears to be wide open." | One source familiar with the takeover battle for the London-listed business told Reuters: "It appears to be wide open." |
| One fund manager said the row carried unhappy parallels with the Guinness share-trading scandal in the 1980s, which damaged the City's reputation as a listing destination. | One fund manager said the row carried unhappy parallels with the Guinness share-trading scandal in the 1980s, which damaged the City's reputation as a listing destination. |
| "This is a test case for London," said the fund manager at one of Bumi's 10 largest institutional investors. "If being listed here is going to mean anything, the regulator has to … enforce the rules to make sure the accounts are trustworthy, the roles of directors are upheld and the rights of minority shareholders are better protected." | "This is a test case for London," said the fund manager at one of Bumi's 10 largest institutional investors. "If being listed here is going to mean anything, the regulator has to … enforce the rules to make sure the accounts are trustworthy, the roles of directors are upheld and the rights of minority shareholders are better protected." |
| In an ironic twist for Bumi's co-founder, the company's board is being advised by the Rothschild Group, the investment bank that is under the influence of the French branch of the 41-year-old's family. | In an ironic twist for Bumi's co-founder, the company's board is being advised by the Rothschild Group, the investment bank that is under the influence of the French branch of the 41-year-old's family. |
| The board, which features City grandees Lord Renwick and Sir Julian Horn-Smith, is backing a divorce with the Bakries that would see the family buy back their mines, leaving the listed company with an interest in Berau, another Indonesian mining venture. | The board, which features City grandees Lord Renwick and Sir Julian Horn-Smith, is backing a divorce with the Bakries that would see the family buy back their mines, leaving the listed company with an interest in Berau, another Indonesian mining venture. |
| The board argues that Rothschild risks miring the business in lawsuits if he pursues litigation against the Bakries. | The board argues that Rothschild risks miring the business in lawsuits if he pursues litigation against the Bakries. |
| A spokesman for Rothschild declined to give an immediate response to the latest developments surrounding the control of Bumi. | A spokesman for Rothschild declined to give an immediate response to the latest developments surrounding the control of Bumi. |
| Chris Fong, a senior vice-president with the Bakrie Group, described Rothschild's plans as "ill-thought-out proposals" that could provoke legal and regulatory chaos by provoking countersuits from Bumi's Indonesian shareholding bloc, which controls the majority of the group's equity. | Chris Fong, a senior vice-president with the Bakrie Group, described Rothschild's plans as "ill-thought-out proposals" that could provoke legal and regulatory chaos by provoking countersuits from Bumi's Indonesian shareholding bloc, which controls the majority of the group's equity. |
| Following drops in coal prices and the disputes between shareholders, the group's shares have been trading at about one-third of the 2011 listing price. | Following drops in coal prices and the disputes between shareholders, the group's shares have been trading at about one-third of the 2011 listing price. |
| However, it rose 4.4% on news of the deal on Monday. | However, it rose 4.4% on news of the deal on Monday. |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |