This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-cornwall-21594109
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 7 | Version 8 |
---|---|
Councillor considers resignation over disabled comment | Councillor considers resignation over disabled comment |
(about 1 hour later) | |
A councillor who said disabled children "should be put down" because they cost too much is considering his future. | A councillor who said disabled children "should be put down" because they cost too much is considering his future. |
Collin Brewer, an independent member of Cornwall Council, made the comments to a Disability Cornwall member at a stall at County Hall in Truro in 2011. | Collin Brewer, an independent member of Cornwall Council, made the comments to a Disability Cornwall member at a stall at County Hall in Truro in 2011. |
The charity complained and the authority's Standards Committee has reported its findings. | The charity complained and the authority's Standards Committee has reported its findings. |
Mr Brewer, who has faced calls to step down, has apologised and said he would consider his position at home later. | Mr Brewer, who has faced calls to step down, has apologised and said he would consider his position at home later. |
Mr Brewer said he had hoped his comment that "disabled children cost the council too much money and should be put down", would provoke a response and a debate into the issue of service costs provision, but said he "did not get the reaction he wanted". | Mr Brewer said he had hoped his comment that "disabled children cost the council too much money and should be put down", would provoke a response and a debate into the issue of service costs provision, but said he "did not get the reaction he wanted". |
"Sometimes people can catch you on the wrong day. It's not a good enough excuse and I will forever be apologising for what I said." | "Sometimes people can catch you on the wrong day. It's not a good enough excuse and I will forever be apologising for what I said." |
Comment 'depraved' | Comment 'depraved' |
Councillor John Wood, leader of the Independent Group, said: "My personal thoughts are that yes he should stand down." | Councillor John Wood, leader of the Independent Group, said: "My personal thoughts are that yes he should stand down." |
"As soon as I heard of the Standards Committee's findings I wrote to Mr Brewer and said as far as I was concerned he was no longer a member of our group. | "As soon as I heard of the Standards Committee's findings I wrote to Mr Brewer and said as far as I was concerned he was no longer a member of our group. |
"If I was in his position I would resign." | "If I was in his position I would resign." |
Theresa Court, who was on the Disability Cornwall stall, said she was "absolutely horrified" when she heard the "depraved comment". | Theresa Court, who was on the Disability Cornwall stall, said she was "absolutely horrified" when she heard the "depraved comment". |
Steve Paget, chair of Disability Cornwall, said Mr Brewer's apology did not feel "heartfelt" and believes it has been sparked by media attention. | Steve Paget, chair of Disability Cornwall, said Mr Brewer's apology did not feel "heartfelt" and believes it has been sparked by media attention. |
"It is unforgivable for anybody who is an elected member, who is a member of Cornwall council to say such an abhorrent thing," said Mr Paget. | "It is unforgivable for anybody who is an elected member, who is a member of Cornwall council to say such an abhorrent thing," said Mr Paget. |
"It is of great concern to us that anyone with such beliefs, let alone to vocalise them, could be a representative and elected member of our local authority." | "It is of great concern to us that anyone with such beliefs, let alone to vocalise them, could be a representative and elected member of our local authority." |
Sue Bennie, from Camborne, has a 15-year-old son with a disability. "I am trying very hard not to swear," she said. | Sue Bennie, from Camborne, has a 15-year-old son with a disability. "I am trying very hard not to swear," she said. |
"Words can never be taken back, others have resigned for less. I think he should go." | "Words can never be taken back, others have resigned for less. I think he should go." |
North Cornwall MP Dan Rogerson said he was "shocked" at the comments. | North Cornwall MP Dan Rogerson said he was "shocked" at the comments. |
"I'm stunned that he would have made a remark like that and there is no way it can be defended." | "I'm stunned that he would have made a remark like that and there is no way it can be defended." |
Model Katie Price, who has a disabled son, tweeted: "Many disabled contribute more to society than mr brewer - ask our paralympians." | Model Katie Price, who has a disabled son, tweeted: "Many disabled contribute more to society than mr brewer - ask our paralympians." |
'No offence meant' | 'No offence meant' |
Earlier, Mr Brewer told BBC News that he had received no calls to resign from his Wadebridge seat. He said he had been in a meeting in the morning about council cuts and had been "hot under the collar". | Earlier, Mr Brewer told BBC News that he had received no calls to resign from his Wadebridge seat. He said he had been in a meeting in the morning about council cuts and had been "hot under the collar". |
"I listened to one of the ladies on the Disability Cornwall stall and came out with the comment," he said. | "I listened to one of the ladies on the Disability Cornwall stall and came out with the comment," he said. |
"If only I had not said that. I didn't mean it. I did it to provoke a response and debate the issue of service costs provision. | "If only I had not said that. I didn't mean it. I did it to provoke a response and debate the issue of service costs provision. |
"It backfired. I was treating her with a lack of respect and I shouldn't have done it." | "It backfired. I was treating her with a lack of respect and I shouldn't have done it." |
He added: "I meant no offence. I would defend disabled children to the last." | He added: "I meant no offence. I would defend disabled children to the last." |
The Standards Committee ordered Mr Brewer to make a formal written apology to the charity, which he has completed. | The Standards Committee ordered Mr Brewer to make a formal written apology to the charity, which he has completed. |
Trevor Doughty, Cornwall Council's director of children's services, said in a statement: "I am shocked and disappointed by the remarks made by Councillor Brewer. | |
"The comments were cruel and ignorant and are contrary to the council's policy of supporting all people with disabilities. | |
"We are very proud of the disability services provided in Cornwall and wish to totally dissociate ourselves with these completely unacceptable views." |