This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2013/mar/03/halifax-high-pressure-sales
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Exposed: bank's high-pressure sales culture continues | Exposed: bank's high-pressure sales culture continues |
| (about 17 hours later) | |
| An employee of Britain's biggest banking group has described a "disheartening and demotivating" sales culture that pressurises staff into selling financial products to customers in order to meet strict points-based daily targets. | An employee of Britain's biggest banking group has described a "disheartening and demotivating" sales culture that pressurises staff into selling financial products to customers in order to meet strict points-based daily targets. |
| The man, who did not wish to be named, but we will call David Elliott, works as a financial consultant for Halifax. He says his job chiefly entails trying to sell insurance to customers. "I've been a counter clerk, banking adviser, financial adviser and now I'm a financial consultant – so I've been at every level there is in a retail bank. It gradually gets worse the higher you climb the ladder and now I'm at the highest seller point in banking and the pressure is abnormal," he says. | The man, who did not wish to be named, but we will call David Elliott, works as a financial consultant for Halifax. He says his job chiefly entails trying to sell insurance to customers. "I've been a counter clerk, banking adviser, financial adviser and now I'm a financial consultant – so I've been at every level there is in a retail bank. It gradually gets worse the higher you climb the ladder and now I'm at the highest seller point in banking and the pressure is abnormal," he says. |
| Sales targets are everywhere, and products translate into points which are added to a branch total, he adds. Loans and home insurance attract the most points, and there are also points for generating new leads from customers. | Sales targets are everywhere, and products translate into points which are added to a branch total, he adds. Loans and home insurance attract the most points, and there are also points for generating new leads from customers. |
| On Friday, Lloyds Group, which owns Halifax, said in its annual report that it was "Reviewing and developing incentives continually to ensure they promote colleagues behaviours that meet customer needs and regulatory expectations". | On Friday, Lloyds Group, which owns Halifax, said in its annual report that it was "Reviewing and developing incentives continually to ensure they promote colleagues behaviours that meet customer needs and regulatory expectations". |
| The bonus pool for employees has been cut, and Lloyds said the average pay out was £3,900 last year, but Elliott suggests there is still a big focus on sales. He told us how, throughout the day, staff discuss how much they have sold and how they can sell more. He outlined to The Observer a typical series of meetings – up to four a day. | The bonus pool for employees has been cut, and Lloyds said the average pay out was £3,900 last year, but Elliott suggests there is still a big focus on sales. He told us how, throughout the day, staff discuss how much they have sold and how they can sell more. He outlined to The Observer a typical series of meetings – up to four a day. |
| ■ Meeting one, 9am to 9.35am | ■ Meeting one, 9am to 9.35am |
| "All sellers and managers sit at a table with the customer information that is in each seller's diary for that day. Each seller is grilled about which products customers can be cross-sold. Either that or they are referred to another seller to sell them something. That leaves people so disheartened and demotivated it's untrue. How can you know a customer's needs without ever speaking to them?" | "All sellers and managers sit at a table with the customer information that is in each seller's diary for that day. Each seller is grilled about which products customers can be cross-sold. Either that or they are referred to another seller to sell them something. That leaves people so disheartened and demotivated it's untrue. How can you know a customer's needs without ever speaking to them?" |
| ■ Meeting two, 11.30am (15-20mins) | ■ Meeting two, 11.30am (15-20mins) |
| "A check-in, in the same room with a member of counter, banking hall, sales and management staff. We all write on the board what sales have been done that day. These are transferred into "points" and the branch roughly has to do 5,000 points per day. If we are behind, everyone at that check-in is grilled on how to get more points ." | "A check-in, in the same room with a member of counter, banking hall, sales and management staff. We all write on the board what sales have been done that day. These are transferred into "points" and the branch roughly has to do 5,000 points per day. If we are behind, everyone at that check-in is grilled on how to get more points ." |
| ■ Meeting three, 12.30pm (15-20mins) | ■ Meeting three, 12.30pm (15-20mins) |
| "The same as meeting two. If sales aren't being met, all advisers who don't have appointments are forced to cold-call existing customers about potential products they could want." | "The same as meeting two. If sales aren't being met, all advisers who don't have appointments are forced to cold-call existing customers about potential products they could want." |
| ■ Meeting four, 3pm (15-20mins) | ■ Meeting four, 3pm (15-20mins) |
| "Pressure is put on staff again to find more points from customers before 5pm." | "Pressure is put on staff again to find more points from customers before 5pm." |
| The revelations come almost six months after the Financial Services Authority told banks and building societies to clean up their act following a review of the sales culture at Britain's biggest financial firms. | The revelations come almost six months after the Financial Services Authority told banks and building societies to clean up their act following a review of the sales culture at Britain's biggest financial firms. |
| The regulator concluded that many, if not all, of the recent mis-selling scandals had dysfunctional incentive schemes at their root. | The regulator concluded that many, if not all, of the recent mis-selling scandals had dysfunctional incentive schemes at their root. |
| At some banks there are signs the culture could be changing. Co-operative Bank, Barclays and HSBC have all removed sales targets from staff pay. Elsewhere, however, it seems to be more of the same. Although Lloyds Group has made some changes and introduced an element of bonus linked to customer services, Elliott says he feels like "part of a used-car salesman sketch" and is unhappy with the way the bank seems entirely focused on making sales. "They tell colleagues " sell to a need", but they can't because they have to sell, sell, sell," he says. "Any product from mortgages to bank accounts could be the next PPI, because of the pressure to sell." He says he has complained to line managers and has been told to "like it or leave" and he says he has done the job required of him. But, he says, after several years at the bank: "I'm just infuriated." | At some banks there are signs the culture could be changing. Co-operative Bank, Barclays and HSBC have all removed sales targets from staff pay. Elsewhere, however, it seems to be more of the same. Although Lloyds Group has made some changes and introduced an element of bonus linked to customer services, Elliott says he feels like "part of a used-car salesman sketch" and is unhappy with the way the bank seems entirely focused on making sales. "They tell colleagues " sell to a need", but they can't because they have to sell, sell, sell," he says. "Any product from mortgages to bank accounts could be the next PPI, because of the pressure to sell." He says he has complained to line managers and has been told to "like it or leave" and he says he has done the job required of him. But, he says, after several years at the bank: "I'm just infuriated." |
| Job adverts for similar roles on the Lloyds Group site talk of "delivering the highest standards of customer service and suggesting the right products in each situation", but the mention of sales targets is not far away. | Job adverts for similar roles on the Lloyds Group site talk of "delivering the highest standards of customer service and suggesting the right products in each situation", but the mention of sales targets is not far away. |
| An advert for a personal banking adviser in Peterborough, paying £16,020-£19,700, describes the ideal candidate as someone able to "meet and exceed personal sales, cross sales and quality referral targets, contributing towards the branch team's service and sales targets". Excellent customer service and experience are also named as key, but come after sales in the job description. | An advert for a personal banking adviser in Peterborough, paying £16,020-£19,700, describes the ideal candidate as someone able to "meet and exceed personal sales, cross sales and quality referral targets, contributing towards the branch team's service and sales targets". Excellent customer service and experience are also named as key, but come after sales in the job description. |
| A Halifax spokeswoman said branches had short meetings throughout the day but these "are designed to review all aspects of the customer experience". She added: "This includes looking at whether there are opportunities to make customers better off." | A Halifax spokeswoman said branches had short meetings throughout the day but these "are designed to review all aspects of the customer experience". She added: "This includes looking at whether there are opportunities to make customers better off." |
| The spokeswoman said: "We have a clear reward framework for colleagues that ensures we recognise behaviours that are focused on achieving correct customer outcomes and excellent service. Branch targets for both service and meeting customer needs are set on the basis of the local market and resource levels in that particular location." | The spokeswoman said: "We have a clear reward framework for colleagues that ensures we recognise behaviours that are focused on achieving correct customer outcomes and excellent service. Branch targets for both service and meeting customer needs are set on the basis of the local market and resource levels in that particular location." |
| She added: "We have taken steps in the past year to ensure as much as possible that there is no product bias in our framework. We also have a number of quality controls in place. This includes monitoring sales to ensure that colleagues have met customer needs appropriately and communicated important information clearly … We also have clawback mechanisms in place for any colleagues who make inappropriate sales." | She added: "We have taken steps in the past year to ensure as much as possible that there is no product bias in our framework. We also have a number of quality controls in place. This includes monitoring sales to ensure that colleagues have met customer needs appropriately and communicated important information clearly … We also have clawback mechanisms in place for any colleagues who make inappropriate sales." |