This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2013/mar/05/benefits-welfare
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Children's rights cited in legal challenge launched against 'bedroom tax' | Children's rights cited in legal challenge launched against 'bedroom tax' |
(7 months later) | |
A legal challenge has been launched on behalf of 10 disabled and vulnerable children against the government's so-called "spare bedroom tax", which is expected to lead to a reduction in benefits for hundreds of thousands of people because they have at least one unused room. | A legal challenge has been launched on behalf of 10 disabled and vulnerable children against the government's so-called "spare bedroom tax", which is expected to lead to a reduction in benefits for hundreds of thousands of people because they have at least one unused room. |
Amid concerns that disabled people will be disproportionately affected by the change in benefit rules, a high court judge will on Tuesday rule on an application to have a full judicial review of the policy before it comes into effect on 1 April. | Amid concerns that disabled people will be disproportionately affected by the change in benefit rules, a high court judge will on Tuesday rule on an application to have a full judicial review of the policy before it comes into effect on 1 April. |
The challenge to Iain Duncan Smith, the secretary of state for work and pensions, has been launched by 22 claimants in total – 10 children, seven parents and five other adults – whose cases are supported by charities. | The challenge to Iain Duncan Smith, the secretary of state for work and pensions, has been launched by 22 claimants in total – 10 children, seven parents and five other adults – whose cases are supported by charities. |
Under the new rules, housing benefit will only be payable on the basis that children under 16 of the same gender will share a room, and children under 10 will share a room regardless of their gender. | Under the new rules, housing benefit will only be payable on the basis that children under 16 of the same gender will share a room, and children under 10 will share a room regardless of their gender. |
All 10 of the children in the claims fall into one of the categories and are expected to share a bedroom with siblings. | All 10 of the children in the claims fall into one of the categories and are expected to share a bedroom with siblings. |
However, all of them have also been assessed as needing their own bedrooms – either due to disabilities, because they are at risk of violence from a sibling or because of trauma experienced as a result of abuse and domestic violence. | However, all of them have also been assessed as needing their own bedrooms – either due to disabilities, because they are at risk of violence from a sibling or because of trauma experienced as a result of abuse and domestic violence. |
The children include one who has Down's syndrome and three with autism. One boy has a rare and very severe genetic condition affecting the brain, Joubert's syndrome. | The children include one who has Down's syndrome and three with autism. One boy has a rare and very severe genetic condition affecting the brain, Joubert's syndrome. |
Four of the children have been settled in their current accommodation having fled serious domestic violence and abuse. The National Autistic Society and Contact a Family have submitted witness evidence in support of the claims. | Four of the children have been settled in their current accommodation having fled serious domestic violence and abuse. The National Autistic Society and Contact a Family have submitted witness evidence in support of the claims. |
The cases lodged by disabled adults include one relating to Charlotte Carmichael and her husband Jayson. She sleeps on a hospital mattress to ease bed sores caused by her spina bifida, while he uses a single bed in their smaller second room. But from April the new regulations would mean that they are under-occupying their specially adapted flat in Southport, Merseyside. | The cases lodged by disabled adults include one relating to Charlotte Carmichael and her husband Jayson. She sleeps on a hospital mattress to ease bed sores caused by her spina bifida, while he uses a single bed in their smaller second room. But from April the new regulations would mean that they are under-occupying their specially adapted flat in Southport, Merseyside. |
Rebekah Carrier, a solicitor at Hopkin Murray Beskine, which is acting for the children and their parents, said the changes would have a "catastrophic impact" on her clients and thousands of other vulnerable children and adults. | Rebekah Carrier, a solicitor at Hopkin Murray Beskine, which is acting for the children and their parents, said the changes would have a "catastrophic impact" on her clients and thousands of other vulnerable children and adults. |
She added: "Experts have assessed my clients as being unable to share a room with their siblings. | She added: "Experts have assessed my clients as being unable to share a room with their siblings. |
"A year ago the children's commissioner warned the government that these changes would have a disproportionate and devastating impact on families with disabled children and those fleeing domestic violence. The appalling situation my clients now find themselves in was entirely predictable and avoidable. | "A year ago the children's commissioner warned the government that these changes would have a disproportionate and devastating impact on families with disabled children and those fleeing domestic violence. The appalling situation my clients now find themselves in was entirely predictable and avoidable. |
"The government is advising these families to consider taking in a lodger to make up the financial shortfall, but none of these families have a spare room available because the rooms are already being used. | "The government is advising these families to consider taking in a lodger to make up the financial shortfall, but none of these families have a spare room available because the rooms are already being used. |
"It is also very surprising that the government is advising families with disabled children, and children suffering trauma following serious abuse, to invite a stranger into their home." | "It is also very surprising that the government is advising families with disabled children, and children suffering trauma following serious abuse, to invite a stranger into their home." |
Housing benefit and universal credit claimants deemed to have one unused bedroom in their council or housing association home will lose 14% of their housing benefit and those with two or more will lose 25%. | Housing benefit and universal credit claimants deemed to have one unused bedroom in their council or housing association home will lose 14% of their housing benefit and those with two or more will lose 25%. |
Estimates by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) indicate that 660,000 people living in social housing will lose an average of £728 a year as a result of the change. | Estimates by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) indicate that 660,000 people living in social housing will lose an average of £728 a year as a result of the change. |
A spokesperson for the DWP said the department acknowledged that the legal action was being taken and would respond in due course. | A spokesperson for the DWP said the department acknowledged that the legal action was being taken and would respond in due course. |
On the broader issue, he said: "We have provided councils with a £155m discretionary fund in order to help those affected by the changes such as disabled people. | On the broader issue, he said: "We have provided councils with a £155m discretionary fund in order to help those affected by the changes such as disabled people. |
"However, with two million people on the housing waiting list and around one million empty bedrooms, it is only fair that we make proper use of social housing in this country. | "However, with two million people on the housing waiting list and around one million empty bedrooms, it is only fair that we make proper use of social housing in this country. |
"The same rules already apply to those in the private rental sector." | "The same rules already apply to those in the private rental sector." |
Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |
Previous version
1
Next version