This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2013/mar/31/ice-balloon-alec-wilkinson-review
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| The Ice Balloon by Alec Wilkinson – review | The Ice Balloon by Alec Wilkinson – review |
| (6 months later) | |
| In August 1930, the Norwegian ship Bratvaag, carrying a party of scientists and seal-hunters, moored off the tiny Arctic island of Kvitøya. Few humans had ever set foot there – it is extremely remote and usually surrounded by thick pack ice. A couple of sailors began to explore and stumbled on a boat, protruding from a snow drift. Inside they found books, shotguns and instruments. Outside were human remains. | In August 1930, the Norwegian ship Bratvaag, carrying a party of scientists and seal-hunters, moored off the tiny Arctic island of Kvitøya. Few humans had ever set foot there – it is extremely remote and usually surrounded by thick pack ice. A couple of sailors began to explore and stumbled on a boat, protruding from a snow drift. Inside they found books, shotguns and instruments. Outside were human remains. |
| One corpse was wearing a jacket with a monogram that revealed its owner's identity: SA Andrée, the Swedish explorer who, with two companions, had set off 33 years earlier, on 11 July 1897, in a hydrogen balloon to discover the north pole. The men's diaries showed they had fallen well short of their goal and had perished in October that year, trying to make their way back to civilisation. | One corpse was wearing a jacket with a monogram that revealed its owner's identity: SA Andrée, the Swedish explorer who, with two companions, had set off 33 years earlier, on 11 July 1897, in a hydrogen balloon to discover the north pole. The men's diaries showed they had fallen well short of their goal and had perished in October that year, trying to make their way back to civilisation. |
| The bodies of Andrée and his companions, Knut Fraenkel and Nils Strindberg, were eventually brought back to Sweden where they were accorded a lavish state funeral. Their remains were cremated without proper medical examination, however, and the omission has since fuelled wild speculation about the causes of their deaths. They were well-armed and supplied when they perished. So what killed them? | The bodies of Andrée and his companions, Knut Fraenkel and Nils Strindberg, were eventually brought back to Sweden where they were accorded a lavish state funeral. Their remains were cremated without proper medical examination, however, and the omission has since fuelled wild speculation about the causes of their deaths. They were well-armed and supplied when they perished. So what killed them? |
| Suggestions have included suicide (they had a good supply of opium), polar bear attacks, scurvy, botulism and lead poisoning from contaminated tinned food. To his credit, Wilkinson downplays such speculation. As he notes, the three men had dragged extremely heavy sleds over treacherous ice floes for three months when they reached Kvitøya. "The sailors from the Bratvaag … decided that they had died of cold and exhaustion," he says. | Suggestions have included suicide (they had a good supply of opium), polar bear attacks, scurvy, botulism and lead poisoning from contaminated tinned food. To his credit, Wilkinson downplays such speculation. As he notes, the three men had dragged extremely heavy sleds over treacherous ice floes for three months when they reached Kvitøya. "The sailors from the Bratvaag … decided that they had died of cold and exhaustion," he says. |
| The fact that Wilkinson backs the idea that the three men met relatively prosaic deaths might seem undramatic. The Ice Balloon is a lively read, nevertheless, and is at pains to paint Andrée in a reasonable light, previous biographers having suggested his expedition was foolhardy and badly planned. In truth, it was no different to so many other fatal polar expeditions of the day. | The fact that Wilkinson backs the idea that the three men met relatively prosaic deaths might seem undramatic. The Ice Balloon is a lively read, nevertheless, and is at pains to paint Andrée in a reasonable light, previous biographers having suggested his expedition was foolhardy and badly planned. In truth, it was no different to so many other fatal polar expeditions of the day. |
| Write your review of this or any other book, find out what other readers thought or add it to your lists | Write your review of this or any other book, find out what other readers thought or add it to your lists |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |