This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-22347581

The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Kermit Gosnell case: Jury hears closing arguments Kermit Gosnell case: Jury hears closing arguments
(35 minutes later)
A Pennsylvania jury has heard closing arguments in the trial of an abortion clinic doctor accused of killing four babies and an adult patient.A Pennsylvania jury has heard closing arguments in the trial of an abortion clinic doctor accused of killing four babies and an adult patient.
Prosecutors allege Dr Kermit Gosnell killed babies born alive after late-term abortions by snipping their spines at the neck with scissors.Prosecutors allege Dr Kermit Gosnell killed babies born alive after late-term abortions by snipping their spines at the neck with scissors.
His defence lawyer said it was "ridiculous" to say the foetuses were alive after in utero injections of a heart-stopping drug.His defence lawyer said it was "ridiculous" to say the foetuses were alive after in utero injections of a heart-stopping drug.
Jury deliberations begin on Tuesday.Jury deliberations begin on Tuesday.
Dr Gosnell faces the death penalty or life in prison if convicted.Dr Gosnell faces the death penalty or life in prison if convicted.
Several former clinic employees have plead guilty to murder and testified against Dr Gosnell and an unlicensed doctor, Eileen O'Neill.Several former clinic employees have plead guilty to murder and testified against Dr Gosnell and an unlicensed doctor, Eileen O'Neill.
The defence has separately argued that Dr Gosnell is not responsible for the overdose death of Karnamaya Mongar, a refugee from Nepal, saying her death was caused by medical complications.The defence has separately argued that Dr Gosnell is not responsible for the overdose death of Karnamaya Mongar, a refugee from Nepal, saying her death was caused by medical complications.
'La-la land''La-la land'
During closing arguments in Philadelphia on Monday, prosecutor Ed Cameron asked jurors to serve justice for Dr Gosnell's alleged victims.During closing arguments in Philadelphia on Monday, prosecutor Ed Cameron asked jurors to serve justice for Dr Gosnell's alleged victims.
Mr Cameron argued that Dr Gosnell was grossly incompetent as an abortion provider. He detailed the prosecution's evidence of a dirty clinic with unqualified staff, with foetal remains dumped down a drain, Bucks County Courier Times columnist JD Mullane reported. "Are you human?" Mr Cameron asked Dr Gosnell, who sat calmly during the proceedings. "To med these women up and stick knives in the backs of babies?"
Calling the clinic an "assembly line with no regard" for patients, the prosecutor argued Dr Gosnell was grossly incompetent as an abortion provider and sought to get rich by employing unqualified staff and keeping an dirty, out-of-date clinic.
He alleged that two mentally unstable medical assistants and a teenager on were duty delivering anaesthesia the night Mongar came in.
"If that doesn't tell you right away what kind of practice Dr Gosnell ran, nothing will,'' Mr Cameron said.
Defence lawyer Jack McMahon told jurors on Monday prosecutors had manipulated former employees of the clinic into testifying and created "the most extraordinary hype and exaggeration in the history of the justice system".Defence lawyer Jack McMahon told jurors on Monday prosecutors had manipulated former employees of the clinic into testifying and created "the most extraordinary hype and exaggeration in the history of the justice system".
Mr McMahon acknowledged jurors had seen horrifying images during the trial, but argued that prosecutors did not have definitive proof the foetuses were viable and alive.Mr McMahon acknowledged jurors had seen horrifying images during the trial, but argued that prosecutors did not have definitive proof the foetuses were viable and alive.
"Abortion, as is any surgical procedure, isn't pretty," he said. "It's bloody. It's real. But you have to transcend that.""Abortion, as is any surgical procedure, isn't pretty," he said. "It's bloody. It's real. But you have to transcend that."
He also called prosecutors "elitist" and "racist" for pursuing Dr Gosnell, who is black and served mostly poor minority women.He also called prosecutors "elitist" and "racist" for pursuing Dr Gosnell, who is black and served mostly poor minority women.
"We know why he was targeted,'' Mr McMahon said. "If you don't see that reality... you're living in some sort of la-la land.""We know why he was targeted,'' Mr McMahon said. "If you don't see that reality... you're living in some sort of la-la land."
During the trial, Judge Jeffrey Minehart threw out three other murder charges involving aborted foetuses, citing insufficient evidence that they were born alive and then killed.During the trial, Judge Jeffrey Minehart threw out three other murder charges involving aborted foetuses, citing insufficient evidence that they were born alive and then killed.
'Chest was moving''Chest was moving'
Prosecutors have argued Dr Gosnell would have not cut the foetus' spines after abortions unless he feared they were not dead.Prosecutors have argued Dr Gosnell would have not cut the foetus' spines after abortions unless he feared they were not dead.
Former staff have testified they saw aborted foetuses move after the procedure on at least two occasions, only to have Dr Gosnell explain the movements as an involuntary response.Former staff have testified they saw aborted foetuses move after the procedure on at least two occasions, only to have Dr Gosnell explain the movements as an involuntary response.
In one case, Ashley Baldwin, a former employee said, "the chest was moving".In one case, Ashley Baldwin, a former employee said, "the chest was moving".
Abortions in Pennsylvania are illegal if not performed by a licensed doctor and if done past the 24th week of pregnancy and the mother's life is not in danger.Abortions in Pennsylvania are illegal if not performed by a licensed doctor and if done past the 24th week of pregnancy and the mother's life is not in danger.
According to a grand jury report, records of the length of the pregnancies at the time of the abortion were falsified by non-medical staff using ultrasounds. Other records were lost entirely.According to a grand jury report, records of the length of the pregnancies at the time of the abortion were falsified by non-medical staff using ultrasounds. Other records were lost entirely.