This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/may/02/george-bush-kimberly-rivera
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Who served their country better: George Bush or Kimberly Rivera? | Who served their country better: George Bush or Kimberly Rivera? |
| (5 months later) | |
| Ultimately, the success of the nation depends on the character of its citizens. | Ultimately, the success of the nation depends on the character of its citizens. |
| So said George W Bush in his speech at the dedication of his presidential library in Texas last week. The library officially opened to the public on 1 May, the tenth anniversary of his famous "Mission Accomplished" speech aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, anchored just off the coast of San Diego. Bush, in his remarks at the library, along with President Barack Obama, former secretary of state Condoleezza Rice and others all failed to mention the word "Iraq". | So said George W Bush in his speech at the dedication of his presidential library in Texas last week. The library officially opened to the public on 1 May, the tenth anniversary of his famous "Mission Accomplished" speech aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, anchored just off the coast of San Diego. Bush, in his remarks at the library, along with President Barack Obama, former secretary of state Condoleezza Rice and others all failed to mention the word "Iraq". |
| Violence in Iraq surged this April. In waves of attacks and counterattacks that resembled the high point of sectarian violence there from 2006-08, 460 people were killed, and 1,219 people were injured, mostly civilians. At least 13 were killed on 1 May, portending an equally violent month. | Violence in Iraq surged this April. In waves of attacks and counterattacks that resembled the high point of sectarian violence there from 2006-08, 460 people were killed, and 1,219 people were injured, mostly civilians. At least 13 were killed on 1 May, portending an equally violent month. |
| Amid this ongoing violence, a young, pregnant soldier has been sent to prison this week for desertion. She refused to return to the war in Iraq back in 2007. Pfc Kimberly Rivera first deployed to Iraq in 2006. She guarded the gate at forward operating base Loyalty in eastern Baghdad at a time when the base was under constant attack. She said of the experience: | Amid this ongoing violence, a young, pregnant soldier has been sent to prison this week for desertion. She refused to return to the war in Iraq back in 2007. Pfc Kimberly Rivera first deployed to Iraq in 2006. She guarded the gate at forward operating base Loyalty in eastern Baghdad at a time when the base was under constant attack. She said of the experience: |
| "I had a huge awakening seeing the war as it truly is: people losing their lives for greed of a nation, and the effects on the soldiers who come back with new problems such as nightmares, anxieties, depression, anger, alcohol abuse, missing limbs and scars from burns. Some don't come back at all." | "I had a huge awakening seeing the war as it truly is: people losing their lives for greed of a nation, and the effects on the soldiers who come back with new problems such as nightmares, anxieties, depression, anger, alcohol abuse, missing limbs and scars from burns. Some don't come back at all." |
| Her attorney, James Branum, who defends soldiers who resist deployment, told me: | Her attorney, James Branum, who defends soldiers who resist deployment, told me: |
| "She felt that she morally could not do what she was asked to do; at the same time, she realized that she would put other soldiers in danger if she didn't pull the trigger when the time came. She talked to a chaplain about it. The chaplain largely pushed her aside, did not give her the counsel that she really needed." | "She felt that she morally could not do what she was asked to do; at the same time, she realized that she would put other soldiers in danger if she didn't pull the trigger when the time came. She talked to a chaplain about it. The chaplain largely pushed her aside, did not give her the counsel that she really needed." |
| The chaplain should have advised her that she could apply to be a conscientious objector. | The chaplain should have advised her that she could apply to be a conscientious objector. |
| Not knowing what her options were, while on leave in Texas in January 2007, Kimberly decided she could not return to war. With her husband, Mario, and their two young children, she drove to Canada, and settled in Toronto as she sought refugee status. She and Mario had two more children there. | Not knowing what her options were, while on leave in Texas in January 2007, Kimberly decided she could not return to war. With her husband, Mario, and their two young children, she drove to Canada, and settled in Toronto as she sought refugee status. She and Mario had two more children there. |
| Canada has a long tradition as a refuge for war resisters. During the Vietnam war, tens of thousands (the exact number is unknown) of young men fled the US to avoid the draft, refusing to fight. After the war, most were granted amnesty and returned home. In 2004, Jeremy Hinzman became the first US soldier known to flee there in opposition to the Iraq war. The War Resisters Support Campaign was formed in Toronto shortly thereafter. | Canada has a long tradition as a refuge for war resisters. During the Vietnam war, tens of thousands (the exact number is unknown) of young men fled the US to avoid the draft, refusing to fight. After the war, most were granted amnesty and returned home. In 2004, Jeremy Hinzman became the first US soldier known to flee there in opposition to the Iraq war. The War Resisters Support Campaign was formed in Toronto shortly thereafter. |
| Since 2008, the Federal Court of Canada has found errors in the handling of 11 of the cases of US war resisters. Kimberly Rivera has this group's support, along with that of members of the Canadian parliament, Amnesty International and South African Archbishop Desmond Tutu, a Nobel Peace Prize winner. Despite the precedent and the outpouring of support, the Canadian government denied her refugee application. She turned herself in to US authorities at the border on 20 September 2012. | Since 2008, the Federal Court of Canada has found errors in the handling of 11 of the cases of US war resisters. Kimberly Rivera has this group's support, along with that of members of the Canadian parliament, Amnesty International and South African Archbishop Desmond Tutu, a Nobel Peace Prize winner. Despite the precedent and the outpouring of support, the Canadian government denied her refugee application. She turned herself in to US authorities at the border on 20 September 2012. |
| At her court martial this week at Fort Carson in Colorado, the judge sentenced her to 14-months imprisonment, which was lowered to 10 months based on a plea agreement. James Branum said of the sentence: | At her court martial this week at Fort Carson in Colorado, the judge sentenced her to 14-months imprisonment, which was lowered to 10 months based on a plea agreement. James Branum said of the sentence: |
| "The prosecutor at trial said that he asked the judge to give a harsh sentence to send a message to the war resisters in Canada. Many other resisters receive little jail time or no jail time. And people that desert, generally, over 90% do no jail time at all. And so, we feel that Kim was singled out." | "The prosecutor at trial said that he asked the judge to give a harsh sentence to send a message to the war resisters in Canada. Many other resisters receive little jail time or no jail time. And people that desert, generally, over 90% do no jail time at all. And so, we feel that Kim was singled out." |
| Kimberly Rivera refused to shoot at children in Iraq. She had the courage to dissent, to resist. Now, she sits in prison, pregnant, away from her husband, Mario, and four young children: Christian, 11; Rebecca, eight; Katie, five; and Gabriel, two. | Kimberly Rivera refused to shoot at children in Iraq. She had the courage to dissent, to resist. Now, she sits in prison, pregnant, away from her husband, Mario, and four young children: Christian, 11; Rebecca, eight; Katie, five; and Gabriel, two. |
| George W Bush was right when he said that the success of the nation depends on the character of its citizens – citizens, that is, like Kimberly Rivera. | George W Bush was right when he said that the success of the nation depends on the character of its citizens – citizens, that is, like Kimberly Rivera. |
| • Denis Moynihan contributed research to this column. | • Denis Moynihan contributed research to this column. |
| • This article was amended on 6 May 2013. The original said incorrectly that at least 11 US war resisters had been granted permanent residency in Canada, recognizing their refugee status. | • This article was amended on 6 May 2013. The original said incorrectly that at least 11 US war resisters had been granted permanent residency in Canada, recognizing their refugee status. |
| © 2013 Amy Goodman; distributed by King Features Syndicate | © 2013 Amy Goodman; distributed by King Features Syndicate |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |