This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/may/21/maria-stubbings-public-inquiry-domestic-violence
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Maria Stubbings was killed by one man. The question is: who let it happen? | Maria Stubbings was killed by one man. The question is: who let it happen? |
| (about 7 hours later) | |
| Maria Stubbings is dead, strangled by a former boyfriend and let down by the police who could have done more to keep her safe, but didn't. Maria Stubbings is dead and, it would seem, not much has changed since I began campaigning on this issue over three decades ago. The statistics are consistent, year after year: on average, two women die each week in England and Wales as a result of domestic violence, a number etched into the minds of those of us who keep asking why nothing has changed. | Maria Stubbings is dead, strangled by a former boyfriend and let down by the police who could have done more to keep her safe, but didn't. Maria Stubbings is dead and, it would seem, not much has changed since I began campaigning on this issue over three decades ago. The statistics are consistent, year after year: on average, two women die each week in England and Wales as a result of domestic violence, a number etched into the minds of those of us who keep asking why nothing has changed. |
| In calling on the home secretary, Theresa May, to set up a Stephen Lawrence-style public inquiry into why victims of domestic violence are not getting sufficient protection, the Stubbings family join a large number of feminists who have been arguing the same point for years. | In calling on the home secretary, Theresa May, to set up a Stephen Lawrence-style public inquiry into why victims of domestic violence are not getting sufficient protection, the Stubbings family join a large number of feminists who have been arguing the same point for years. |
| We need a formal inquiry because investigations into domestic homicides often result in nothing but cliches: there were mistakes; opportunities were missed; communication lines were faulty; the police are sorry; lessons have been learned. But the fact is, domestic violence accounted for 10% of emergency calls in 2011/12, according to the Office for National Statistics, and there were 2 million cases of domestic abuse. Lessons were not learned. No amount of apologising is enough. | We need a formal inquiry because investigations into domestic homicides often result in nothing but cliches: there were mistakes; opportunities were missed; communication lines were faulty; the police are sorry; lessons have been learned. But the fact is, domestic violence accounted for 10% of emergency calls in 2011/12, according to the Office for National Statistics, and there were 2 million cases of domestic abuse. Lessons were not learned. No amount of apologising is enough. |
| The Macpherson inquiry happened because campaigners insisted Stephen died not only of a stab wound inflicted by violent racists, but because there was a culture of racism in the police. | The Macpherson inquiry happened because campaigners insisted Stephen died not only of a stab wound inflicted by violent racists, but because there was a culture of racism in the police. |
| Maria Stubbings died not only of strangulation at the hands of a violent man, but because there is a culture of misogyny within the police and wider society – as the IPCC report five years after the murder so chillingly demonstrates. But as Davina James-Hanman, director of the charity Against Violence and Abuse, puts it: "We have had IPCC reports, assurances, and apologies for two decades, and yet we still have dead body after dead body and the same mistakes made over and over." | Maria Stubbings died not only of strangulation at the hands of a violent man, but because there is a culture of misogyny within the police and wider society – as the IPCC report five years after the murder so chillingly demonstrates. But as Davina James-Hanman, director of the charity Against Violence and Abuse, puts it: "We have had IPCC reports, assurances, and apologies for two decades, and yet we still have dead body after dead body and the same mistakes made over and over." |
| I recall the first domestic murder case I was involved in as a campaigner, in 1983. Keith Ward killed his partner, Julie Stead. She had complained many times to the police about him, but was ignored. Ward pleaded provocation and was sentenced to three years in prison. My campaign group, alongside Julie's family, petitioned the court, calling for a longer sentence. We were ignored. In 1990 Ward killed another woman, Valerie Middleton while on weekend release from a two-year sentence for a previous attack on her. This time he was convicted of murder. Two sets of children had lost their mother; two women had lost their livesJulie Stead died 30 years ago, and so much remains the same. | I recall the first domestic murder case I was involved in as a campaigner, in 1983. Keith Ward killed his partner, Julie Stead. She had complained many times to the police about him, but was ignored. Ward pleaded provocation and was sentenced to three years in prison. My campaign group, alongside Julie's family, petitioned the court, calling for a longer sentence. We were ignored. In 1990 Ward killed another woman, Valerie Middleton while on weekend release from a two-year sentence for a previous attack on her. This time he was convicted of murder. Two sets of children had lost their mother; two women had lost their livesJulie Stead died 30 years ago, and so much remains the same. |
| The root of the problem is that women are routinely disbelieved and disrespected when reporting domestic abuse, not just by police but across the statutory agencies. Any public inquiry must include in its remit not only the police, but other organisations that routinely fail women, such as health and social services. | The root of the problem is that women are routinely disbelieved and disrespected when reporting domestic abuse, not just by police but across the statutory agencies. Any public inquiry must include in its remit not only the police, but other organisations that routinely fail women, such as health and social services. |
| And if there is anyone who doesn't think the victims' suffering is reason enough for a public inquiry, consider the costs. Research by Crime Concern in 1998 found that the cost per annum of domestic violence to statutory agencies was at least £5m, but it was probably closer to £7.5m because that research excluded the costs of murder inquiries and rehousing council tenants (Counting the Costs: Estimating the Impact of Domestic Violence in the London Borough of Hackney, Elizabeth A Stanko et al). | And if there is anyone who doesn't think the victims' suffering is reason enough for a public inquiry, consider the costs. Research by Crime Concern in 1998 found that the cost per annum of domestic violence to statutory agencies was at least £5m, but it was probably closer to £7.5m because that research excluded the costs of murder inquiries and rehousing council tenants (Counting the Costs: Estimating the Impact of Domestic Violence in the London Borough of Hackney, Elizabeth A Stanko et al). |
| There is the wider human cost too. Living in a violent household is horrific for children. A National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) study of 139 child abuse cases in England in 2009-11 found that almost two-thirds had have domestic abuse as a risk factor: men who commit acts of serious sexual violence against women often abuse children too. Mick Philpott, convicted of killing six of his children in an arson attack, has since been accused of rape and domestic violence. | There is the wider human cost too. Living in a violent household is horrific for children. A National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) study of 139 child abuse cases in England in 2009-11 found that almost two-thirds had have domestic abuse as a risk factor: men who commit acts of serious sexual violence against women often abuse children too. Mick Philpott, convicted of killing six of his children in an arson attack, has since been accused of rape and domestic violence. |
| Women's Aid Federation England has identified a number of ways in which children who witness domestic violence are affected. These include developing anxiety and depression, having difficulty concentrating at school, and suffering from flashbacks; bed-wetting, aggression and self-harm are not uncommon. Later, some will self-medicate with drugs and alcohol, and many will find relationships difficult. If they become parents, the violence they witnessed can impact on the way they relate to their own children, resulting in a lack of connection, or even further violence. | Women's Aid Federation England has identified a number of ways in which children who witness domestic violence are affected. These include developing anxiety and depression, having difficulty concentrating at school, and suffering from flashbacks; bed-wetting, aggression and self-harm are not uncommon. Later, some will self-medicate with drugs and alcohol, and many will find relationships difficult. If they become parents, the violence they witnessed can impact on the way they relate to their own children, resulting in a lack of connection, or even further violence. |
| Protecting women is the best way to protect children, yet some women cite inappropriate child protection intervention as one of the reasons they cannot escape. One woman I spoke to called police to her home following a serious assault, and subsequently received a letter from social services warning her that if she did not take steps to address the "unsafe environment", her two children – who were in the home at the time of the attack – would be in danger of being removed. This woman is now too scared to ask police for help in case it leads to her losing her children. | Protecting women is the best way to protect children, yet some women cite inappropriate child protection intervention as one of the reasons they cannot escape. One woman I spoke to called police to her home following a serious assault, and subsequently received a letter from social services warning her that if she did not take steps to address the "unsafe environment", her two children – who were in the home at the time of the attack – would be in danger of being removed. This woman is now too scared to ask police for help in case it leads to her losing her children. |
| Some men are victims of domestic violence at the hands of female partners, and deserve services and recognition. But domestic violence is primarily a crime against women and children by men. A public inquiry into domestic violence must examine domestic homicides in the context of patriarchy and discrimination against women or, once again, nothing will change. | Some men are victims of domestic violence at the hands of female partners, and deserve services and recognition. But domestic violence is primarily a crime against women and children by men. A public inquiry into domestic violence must examine domestic homicides in the context of patriarchy and discrimination against women or, once again, nothing will change. |
| • Refuge and Maria's family have launched a petition calling for a public inquiry into domestic violence |