This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/31/nyregion/mansour-arbabsiar-sentenced-for-plot-to-kill-saudi-ambassador.html
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Man Sentenced in Plot to Kill Saudi Ambassador | Man Sentenced in Plot to Kill Saudi Ambassador |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| An Iranian-American used-car salesman from Texas who was accused of plotting to hire assassins from a Mexican drug cartel to murder Saudi Arabia’s ambassador to the United States was sentenced to 25 years in prison on Thursday in federal court in Manhattan. | An Iranian-American used-car salesman from Texas who was accused of plotting to hire assassins from a Mexican drug cartel to murder Saudi Arabia’s ambassador to the United States was sentenced to 25 years in prison on Thursday in federal court in Manhattan. |
| The man, Mansour J. Arbabsiar, a naturalized American citizen living in Corpus Christi, Tex., was arrested on Sept. 29, 2011, at Kennedy International Airport and ultimately pleaded guilty to his role in the bizarre scheme. | The man, Mansour J. Arbabsiar, a naturalized American citizen living in Corpus Christi, Tex., was arrested on Sept. 29, 2011, at Kennedy International Airport and ultimately pleaded guilty to his role in the bizarre scheme. |
| Before he was sentenced, Mr. Arbabsiar told the judge: “Whatever I did wrong, I take responsibility for it. I can’t change what I did. I have a good heart. I never hurt anyone.” He added, “My mind sometimes is not in a good place.” | |
| When the case, with a plotline that seemed scripted from a Hollywood movie, was made public, it riveted Washington and raised already heightened tensions between the Sunni royal family that rules Saudi Arabia and the Shiite-controlled government in Iran. | When the case, with a plotline that seemed scripted from a Hollywood movie, was made public, it riveted Washington and raised already heightened tensions between the Sunni royal family that rules Saudi Arabia and the Shiite-controlled government in Iran. |
| At the time of Mr. Arbabsiar’s arrest, Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. said that the plot had been “directed and approved by elements of the Iranian government and, specifically, senior members of the Quds force,” which is part of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps. | At the time of Mr. Arbabsiar’s arrest, Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. said that the plot had been “directed and approved by elements of the Iranian government and, specifically, senior members of the Quds force,” which is part of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps. |
| The Iranian government has said it had nothing to do with the plot. | The Iranian government has said it had nothing to do with the plot. |
| The plan, according to government officials, involved Mr. Arbabsiar paying a member of the Los Zetas drug cartel $1.5 million to plant a bomb at a Washington restaurant while the Saudi ambassador, Adel al-Jubeir, dined. However, Mr. Arbabsiar’s contact with the Mexican cartel turned out to be an informer for the Drug Enforcement Administration, who quickly alerted United States authorities. | The plan, according to government officials, involved Mr. Arbabsiar paying a member of the Los Zetas drug cartel $1.5 million to plant a bomb at a Washington restaurant while the Saudi ambassador, Adel al-Jubeir, dined. However, Mr. Arbabsiar’s contact with the Mexican cartel turned out to be an informer for the Drug Enforcement Administration, who quickly alerted United States authorities. |
| In court, a federal prosecutor, Glen Kopp, told the judge that Mr. Arbabsiar’s act had been “an extraordinary crime that requires an equally serious sentence.” | |
| The judge, John F. Keenan of United States District Court, said before imposing the sentence: “Nothing in the record before me warrants a sentence of less than 25 years. In a case like this, deterrence is of supreme importance.” | |
| “Others who may have financial or political purposes in engaging in acts of violence against the United States or its interests,” he added, “must learn the lesson that such conduct will not be tolerated.” | |
| Sabrina Shroff, the federal public defender who represents Mr. Arbabsiar, said after the proceeding that she did not believe the sentence would be an effective deterrent. “Who is the message going to?” she said. “Does Iran really care?” | |
| “The person has to matter,” she added. “Unfortunately for Mr. Arbabsiar, neither the United States nor the Iranian government cares. He’s expendable.” | |
| The authorities said Mr. Arbabsiar had confessed to his role in the plot and provided valuable intelligence about Iran’s role in supporting the plan. He claimed that his cousin, a member of the Quds Force, recruited him to carry out the plot, according to the authorities. | The authorities said Mr. Arbabsiar had confessed to his role in the plot and provided valuable intelligence about Iran’s role in supporting the plan. He claimed that his cousin, a member of the Quds Force, recruited him to carry out the plot, according to the authorities. |
| After Mr. Arbabsiar’s arrest, the authorities said that he “knowingly and voluntarily” waived his rights to remain silent, to have a lawyer present during his interrogation and to be taken speedily before a judge, and that he provided his cooperation. | After Mr. Arbabsiar’s arrest, the authorities said that he “knowingly and voluntarily” waived his rights to remain silent, to have a lawyer present during his interrogation and to be taken speedily before a judge, and that he provided his cooperation. |
| Though Mr. Arbabsiar, 58, was originally charged with offenses that carried a maximum sentence of life in prison, he ultimately pleaded guilty in October 2012 to three counts for which he faced a maximum of 25 years. The charges included conspiracy to commit an act of terrorism transcending national boundaries and two counts related to murder-for-hire. | Though Mr. Arbabsiar, 58, was originally charged with offenses that carried a maximum sentence of life in prison, he ultimately pleaded guilty in October 2012 to three counts for which he faced a maximum of 25 years. The charges included conspiracy to commit an act of terrorism transcending national boundaries and two counts related to murder-for-hire. |
| After Mr. Arbabsiar pleaded guilty, the case has focused on whether he should receive 25 years, as the United States attorney’s office had sought, or less. | After Mr. Arbabsiar pleaded guilty, the case has focused on whether he should receive 25 years, as the United States attorney’s office had sought, or less. |
| The defense had sought a 10-year term, arguing, among other points, that Mr. Arbabsiar’s crime had been the result of a longstanding, untreated bipolar disorder, and that when he was recruited into the plot by his cousin in Iran, he was in a deep depression after business failures and the deaths of his best friend and his father. | The defense had sought a 10-year term, arguing, among other points, that Mr. Arbabsiar’s crime had been the result of a longstanding, untreated bipolar disorder, and that when he was recruited into the plot by his cousin in Iran, he was in a deep depression after business failures and the deaths of his best friend and his father. |
| “He felt like a complete failure,” Dr. Michael B. First, a Columbia University professor of clinical psychiatry retained by the defense, testified in a presentence hearing on May 8. “He was extremely down on himself. His life was a wreck. He hated himself. He was having suicidal thoughts.” | “He felt like a complete failure,” Dr. Michael B. First, a Columbia University professor of clinical psychiatry retained by the defense, testified in a presentence hearing on May 8. “He was extremely down on himself. His life was a wreck. He hated himself. He was having suicidal thoughts.” |
| In a report filed with the judge, Dr. First quoted from interviews he had conducted with Mr. Arbabsiar, who recalled his cousin’s asking for his assistance and his feeling immediately uplifted. “Here was my cousin, a very powerful man in Iran, with connections to the government and Army, asking me to help him,” Mr. Arbabsiar said. He said that he felt he had “a purpose” and that it was “like a drug to me,” as though he had been given cocaine, he said. | In a report filed with the judge, Dr. First quoted from interviews he had conducted with Mr. Arbabsiar, who recalled his cousin’s asking for his assistance and his feeling immediately uplifted. “Here was my cousin, a very powerful man in Iran, with connections to the government and Army, asking me to help him,” Mr. Arbabsiar said. He said that he felt he had “a purpose” and that it was “like a drug to me,” as though he had been given cocaine, he said. |
| But a psychiatrist retained by the government, Dr. Gregory B. Saathoff of the University of Virginia, disagreed with the defense expert’s findings, testifying in another hearing on Wednesday that he did not believe Mr. Arbabsiar had a bipolar disorder. | But a psychiatrist retained by the government, Dr. Gregory B. Saathoff of the University of Virginia, disagreed with the defense expert’s findings, testifying in another hearing on Wednesday that he did not believe Mr. Arbabsiar had a bipolar disorder. |
| Dr. Saathoff met with Mr. Arbabsiar last year over six sessions for a total of about 32 hours, according to a report he filed last October, when Mr. Arbabsiar’s lawyer, Sabrina Shroff, a federal public defender, was seeking to have his statements to the Federal Bureau of Investigation suppressed on grounds that he had a serious mental illness when he agreed to cooperate with the authorities after his arrest after waiving his right to a lawyer or a speedy court appearance. | Dr. Saathoff met with Mr. Arbabsiar last year over six sessions for a total of about 32 hours, according to a report he filed last October, when Mr. Arbabsiar’s lawyer, Sabrina Shroff, a federal public defender, was seeking to have his statements to the Federal Bureau of Investigation suppressed on grounds that he had a serious mental illness when he agreed to cooperate with the authorities after his arrest after waiving his right to a lawyer or a speedy court appearance. |
| Dr. Saathoff said in his report that he had concluded that “Mr. Arbabsiar does not suffer from bipolar disorder or any other mental illness that would have precluded him from knowingly consenting to F.B.I. questioning following his arrest without the presence of an attorney.” | Dr. Saathoff said in his report that he had concluded that “Mr. Arbabsiar does not suffer from bipolar disorder or any other mental illness that would have precluded him from knowingly consenting to F.B.I. questioning following his arrest without the presence of an attorney.” |
| His interviews with Mr. Arbabsiar, as summarized in the report, offered an unusually candid look at the man prosecutors described as the alleged assassin. | His interviews with Mr. Arbabsiar, as summarized in the report, offered an unusually candid look at the man prosecutors described as the alleged assassin. |
| In one unusual episode, Mr. Arbabsiar told the doctor he had been on a flight from Europe to Iran around 2004, and bought duty-free cologne for the pilot and a flight attendant. Calling the gift a “nice gesture,” the pilot invited Mr. Arbabsiar into the cockpit and allowed him to sit in the co-pilot’s seat and even gave him “a special tour at the controls,” Dr. Saathoff wrote. | In one unusual episode, Mr. Arbabsiar told the doctor he had been on a flight from Europe to Iran around 2004, and bought duty-free cologne for the pilot and a flight attendant. Calling the gift a “nice gesture,” the pilot invited Mr. Arbabsiar into the cockpit and allowed him to sit in the co-pilot’s seat and even gave him “a special tour at the controls,” Dr. Saathoff wrote. |
| Mr. Arbabsiar told Dr. Saathoff that he felt his crime, because it involved the planned assassination of a Saudi official, “would have the attention of top U.S. leadership, including President Obama.” | Mr. Arbabsiar told Dr. Saathoff that he felt his crime, because it involved the planned assassination of a Saudi official, “would have the attention of top U.S. leadership, including President Obama.” |
| The psychiatrist said that Mr. Arbabsiar had also talked about how he had made a mistake and was hoping for leniency from the judge. | The psychiatrist said that Mr. Arbabsiar had also talked about how he had made a mistake and was hoping for leniency from the judge. |
| “'We all make mistakes. Some are big and some are little,'” Dr. Saathoff quoted Mr. Arbabsiar as saying. “'I know that this is a big mistake, so I felt: ‘Yes, O.K., put me in jail. Just not for too long.'” | “'We all make mistakes. Some are big and some are little,'” Dr. Saathoff quoted Mr. Arbabsiar as saying. “'I know that this is a big mistake, so I felt: ‘Yes, O.K., put me in jail. Just not for too long.'” |
Vivian Yee contributed reporting. |