This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-22853071
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Man of Steel film receives largely positive response | Man of Steel film receives largely positive response |
(1 day later) | |
Reviews of Man of Steel, the eagerly anticipated "reboot" of the Superman franchise, have been largely favourable, with some reservations. | Reviews of Man of Steel, the eagerly anticipated "reboot" of the Superman franchise, have been largely favourable, with some reservations. |
The film, directed by 300's Zack Snyder and starring British actor Henry Cavill as the superhero, opens in UK cinemas this week. | The film, directed by 300's Zack Snyder and starring British actor Henry Cavill as the superhero, opens in UK cinemas this week. |
Total Film praised "an intelligent, earnest attempt to modernise and mature the original superhero". | Total Film praised "an intelligent, earnest attempt to modernise and mature the original superhero". |
But The Guardian noted Cavill's "frowning humourlessness". | But The Guardian noted Cavill's "frowning humourlessness". |
In his review, writer Andrew Pulver said the influence of producer Christopher Nolan - British director of Inception and the Dark Knight trilogy - was evident in early scenes where Superman struggles to accept his identity. | In his review, writer Andrew Pulver said the influence of producer Christopher Nolan - British director of Inception and the Dark Knight trilogy - was evident in early scenes where Superman struggles to accept his identity. |
"Reminiscent, perhaps, of Batman Begins, this is superheroism as a burden, and a burden transformed into neurosis," he wrote. | "Reminiscent, perhaps, of Batman Begins, this is superheroism as a burden, and a burden transformed into neurosis," he wrote. |
"It's this early part of the film that is most successful," Pulver continues. | "It's this early part of the film that is most successful," Pulver continues. |
"Nolan and Snyder, along with scriptwriter David S Goyer, have created a plausible context for the introspection and self-doubt that dogs the adult version of their costumed warrior." | "Nolan and Snyder, along with scriptwriter David S Goyer, have created a plausible context for the introspection and self-doubt that dogs the adult version of their costumed warrior." |
'Titanic clashes' | 'Titanic clashes' |
Man of Steel sees Superman attempt to save the world while battling General Zod, a rebellious military leader from his home planet of Krypton - played by Boardwalk Empire's Michael Shannon. | |
In its four-star review, Total Film said the film's action set-pieces made up for the lack of action in a previous attempt at a "reboot", 2006's Superman Returns, | In its four-star review, Total Film said the film's action set-pieces made up for the lack of action in a previous attempt at a "reboot", 2006's Superman Returns, |
"There are some truly titanic clashes here between super-beings, going at it like flesh-and-blood Transformers," wrote Matthew Leyland. | "There are some truly titanic clashes here between super-beings, going at it like flesh-and-blood Transformers," wrote Matthew Leyland. |
Cavill, he said, "doesn't make heavy work of one of the biggest, toughest roles in comic-book cinema" but is overall "more solid than spectacular." | Cavill, he said, "doesn't make heavy work of one of the biggest, toughest roles in comic-book cinema" but is overall "more solid than spectacular." |
Jersey native Cavill, 30, is the first non-American to play the role of Superman on screen - a "tough gig" according to Empire magazine. | Jersey native Cavill, 30, is the first non-American to play the role of Superman on screen - a "tough gig" according to Empire magazine. |
"While there are some interesting touches," writes Dan Jolin, "his Kal-El is a bit stiff and slow to thaw" - a reference to Superman's Krypton birth name. | "While there are some interesting touches," writes Dan Jolin, "his Kal-El is a bit stiff and slow to thaw" - a reference to Superman's Krypton birth name. |
However, he concludes: "It feels the right Superman origin story for our era, and teases what would be a welcome new superfranchise." | However, he concludes: "It feels the right Superman origin story for our era, and teases what would be a welcome new superfranchise." |
In the US, reviewers have also picked up on the film's darker tone and lack of humour. | In the US, reviewers have also picked up on the film's darker tone and lack of humour. |
Variety said Man of Steel "is undeniably impressive, in the sense that little if any expense has been spared in bringing Snyder's vision to the screen". | Variety said Man of Steel "is undeniably impressive, in the sense that little if any expense has been spared in bringing Snyder's vision to the screen". |
According to Scott Foundas, though, "this is a case where less would almost surely have been more". | According to Scott Foundas, though, "this is a case where less would almost surely have been more". |
"Zack Snyder's huge, back story-heavy extravaganza is a rehab job that perhaps didn't cry out to be done," said The Hollywood Reporter's Todd McCarthy. | "Zack Snyder's huge, back story-heavy extravaganza is a rehab job that perhaps didn't cry out to be done," said The Hollywood Reporter's Todd McCarthy. |
But the film, he continues, "proves so overwhelmingly insistent in its size and strength that it's hard not to give in". | But the film, he continues, "proves so overwhelmingly insistent in its size and strength that it's hard not to give in". |
Man of Steel is out in the UK and US on Friday. | Man of Steel is out in the UK and US on Friday. |
Previous version
1
Next version