This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/18/world/middleeast/afghan-forces-struggle-as-us-weans-them-off-support.html
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Afghan Forces Struggle as U.S. Weans Them Off Support | Afghan Forces Struggle as U.S. Weans Them Off Support |
| (about 11 hours later) | |
| KABUL, Afghanistan — When the American-led NATO coalition officially transferred security responsibility for all of Afghanistan to government forces in a ceremony on Tuesday, it was in part a formality. Already this year, Afghan forces have been in the lead in fighting the Taliban in more than three-quarters of the country — and they have been killed and wounded at a record pace, accordingly. | KABUL, Afghanistan — When the American-led NATO coalition officially transferred security responsibility for all of Afghanistan to government forces in a ceremony on Tuesday, it was in part a formality. Already this year, Afghan forces have been in the lead in fighting the Taliban in more than three-quarters of the country — and they have been killed and wounded at a record pace, accordingly. |
| But after Tuesday, these are supposed to be the rules everywhere: while American units may sometimes be close by, Afghan forces must operate without American air support, medical evacuation helicopters or partnered combat units. If they get in trouble, NATO will not be riding to the rescue, except in the most dire cases. | But after Tuesday, these are supposed to be the rules everywhere: while American units may sometimes be close by, Afghan forces must operate without American air support, medical evacuation helicopters or partnered combat units. If they get in trouble, NATO will not be riding to the rescue, except in the most dire cases. |
| This summer is shaping up as a lesson in tough love from American military mentors to demonstrate whether the Afghan forces really can become self-sufficient by the withdrawal deadline for Western forces in 2014. | This summer is shaping up as a lesson in tough love from American military mentors to demonstrate whether the Afghan forces really can become self-sufficient by the withdrawal deadline for Western forces in 2014. |
| Just how tough that has been is perhaps nowhere more evident than in Room 648 of the Afghan National Army’s Military Hospital in Kabul. The room is shared by two soldiers wounded in the same battle against the Taliban in southern Afghanistan on May 22 and 23. One of them lost three limbs, the other lost two. | Just how tough that has been is perhaps nowhere more evident than in Room 648 of the Afghan National Army’s Military Hospital in Kabul. The room is shared by two soldiers wounded in the same battle against the Taliban in southern Afghanistan on May 22 and 23. One of them lost three limbs, the other lost two. |
| Their company, with the 205th Afghan Army Corps, was based in the Panjwai district of Kandahar Province. In May, they were sent to a village near Zangabad, the site of a popular anti-Taliban uprising in March that American and Afghan officials had hailed as turning a corner in an area long dominated by the militants. Just two months later, though, the insurgents were back. | Their company, with the 205th Afghan Army Corps, was based in the Panjwai district of Kandahar Province. In May, they were sent to a village near Zangabad, the site of a popular anti-Taliban uprising in March that American and Afghan officials had hailed as turning a corner in an area long dominated by the militants. Just two months later, though, the insurgents were back. |
| According to the wounded soldiers’ accounts, later confirmed by their company commander, they found the area heavily mined and booby-trapped. When the soldiers began tripping mines, Taliban gunmen attacked, using tunnels through walls between adjoining homes in the village to hit and run. | According to the wounded soldiers’ accounts, later confirmed by their company commander, they found the area heavily mined and booby-trapped. When the soldiers began tripping mines, Taliban gunmen attacked, using tunnels through walls between adjoining homes in the village to hit and run. |
| “No one came to our aid and did anything,” said Lt. Masiullah Hamdard, who lost both legs and his left arm in the fight and was still twisting in pain from his injuries. He said that two American helicopters and a jet were circling above the battle. “We kept begging them to shoot up the place but they didn’t do anything whatever.” | “No one came to our aid and did anything,” said Lt. Masiullah Hamdard, who lost both legs and his left arm in the fight and was still twisting in pain from his injuries. He said that two American helicopters and a jet were circling above the battle. “We kept begging them to shoot up the place but they didn’t do anything whatever.” |
| Indeed, from Tuesday on, that is American policy everywhere in Afghanistan. The American military has decreed that no air support be available to Afghans unless an exception is approved by an officer holding a general’s rank — and already, the anecdotal evidence indicates that such exceptions have been rare. | Indeed, from Tuesday on, that is American policy everywhere in Afghanistan. The American military has decreed that no air support be available to Afghans unless an exception is approved by an officer holding a general’s rank — and already, the anecdotal evidence indicates that such exceptions have been rare. |
| Instead of close air support, the American military has been providing equipment and training to help the Afghans use mortars and other artillery when they get in trouble, according to Maj. Gen. James C. McConville, the American commander in eastern Afghanistan. “If you do it for them, they will never build the capability and the capacity to do it,” he said. “We don’t want them to get used to a capability they’re not going to have in the future.” | Instead of close air support, the American military has been providing equipment and training to help the Afghans use mortars and other artillery when they get in trouble, according to Maj. Gen. James C. McConville, the American commander in eastern Afghanistan. “If you do it for them, they will never build the capability and the capacity to do it,” he said. “We don’t want them to get used to a capability they’re not going to have in the future.” |
| Coalition officials still have combat ability here — roughly 65,000 American troops are still in Afghanistan — and say they would use it in cases where Afghan forces got into real trouble. The fighting in Panjwai, apparently, did not reach that point. | Coalition officials still have combat ability here — roughly 65,000 American troops are still in Afghanistan — and say they would use it in cases where Afghan forces got into real trouble. The fighting in Panjwai, apparently, did not reach that point. |
| “I am 100 percent sure if we had air support available to us like the Americans would have, we would not have the sort of casualties that were inflicted on us there,” said the Afghan company commander in the Panjwai fight, Capt. Safid Gul. He was more philosophical than rueful, however. “This is our house and we have to protect it. No one else can save it for us.” | “I am 100 percent sure if we had air support available to us like the Americans would have, we would not have the sort of casualties that were inflicted on us there,” said the Afghan company commander in the Panjwai fight, Capt. Safid Gul. He was more philosophical than rueful, however. “This is our house and we have to protect it. No one else can save it for us.” |
| Captain Gul said that government forces, which numbered 40 soldiers and 40 police officers in all, took a total of 20 casualties in Panjwai — 13 wounded and 7 killed, or a fourth of their number in all. Those numbers were roughly confirmed by the Panjwai district governor, Haji Faizal Mohammad. | Captain Gul said that government forces, which numbered 40 soldiers and 40 police officers in all, took a total of 20 casualties in Panjwai — 13 wounded and 7 killed, or a fourth of their number in all. Those numbers were roughly confirmed by the Panjwai district governor, Haji Faizal Mohammad. |
| Afghan forces have paid dearly in other skirmishes with the Taliban, including a May offensive by the insurgents in Sangin district, a much-contested area in Helmand Province. The Taliban were beaten back, but at a cost of 19 soldiers and police officers killed. | Afghan forces have paid dearly in other skirmishes with the Taliban, including a May offensive by the insurgents in Sangin district, a much-contested area in Helmand Province. The Taliban were beaten back, but at a cost of 19 soldiers and police officers killed. |
| Afghan Army casualties reflect their increased role in the fight. According to Gen. Dawlat Waziri, the deputy spokesman of the Defense Ministry, from March 21 to June 11 of this year, usually a slower time than later in the summer, a total of 276 Afghan soldiers were killed. That was already on pace to top the previous Afghan year’s total of 1,170, itself a record. In the same March 21 to June 11 period, fewer than 50 Americans were killed. (Afghans observe a lunar year, which began March 21 this year.) | |
| On Sunday alone, 10 Afghan soldiers were killed in four different provinces, the Defense Ministry said Monday. | On Sunday alone, 10 Afghan soldiers were killed in four different provinces, the Defense Ministry said Monday. |
| The increased casualty rate for the Afghan National Army has raised concerns about what effect it might have on the military’s already high attrition rate. Last year, Afghan officials confirmed that because of desertions, casualties and low re-enlistments, the army had to replace about a third of its soldiers annually. | The increased casualty rate for the Afghan National Army has raised concerns about what effect it might have on the military’s already high attrition rate. Last year, Afghan officials confirmed that because of desertions, casualties and low re-enlistments, the army had to replace about a third of its soldiers annually. |
| More recently, Defense Ministry officials have refused to divulge attrition statistics, saying that they are considered secret because of the possible impact on morale. | More recently, Defense Ministry officials have refused to divulge attrition statistics, saying that they are considered secret because of the possible impact on morale. |
| One of the biggest issues to many Afghan soldiers is a lack of medical evacuation capacity after the Americans began withdrawing it over the past year. With as few as two Afghan helicopters per corps — there are six army corps in the country — available for medevacs, that means most victims are moved by ambulance. | One of the biggest issues to many Afghan soldiers is a lack of medical evacuation capacity after the Americans began withdrawing it over the past year. With as few as two Afghan helicopters per corps — there are six army corps in the country — available for medevacs, that means most victims are moved by ambulance. |
| The other soldier in Room 648 at the Military Hospital, Pvt. Abdul Wali, 18, from Baghlan Province, had taken refuge in a house with soldiers and police officers while the Taliban attacked from outside during the two days of the fight. Soldiers had checked the house for bombs, but without the sophisticated detectors used by American forces, missed one hidden behind a wall. During the fight, the Taliban detonated it by remote control, wounding all those inside. | The other soldier in Room 648 at the Military Hospital, Pvt. Abdul Wali, 18, from Baghlan Province, had taken refuge in a house with soldiers and police officers while the Taliban attacked from outside during the two days of the fight. Soldiers had checked the house for bombs, but without the sophisticated detectors used by American forces, missed one hidden behind a wall. During the fight, the Taliban detonated it by remote control, wounding all those inside. |
| “No one came to our aid,” Private Wali said. He lay in the rubble of the building for half an hour before anyone dug him and the other victims out, and it was another half-hour before medical help came. | “No one came to our aid,” Private Wali said. He lay in the rubble of the building for half an hour before anyone dug him and the other victims out, and it was another half-hour before medical help came. |
| A year ago, that would have been an American helicopter. This time, it was a government ambulance. | A year ago, that would have been an American helicopter. This time, it was a government ambulance. |
| “For us it’s difficult to implement that ‘golden hour,’ ” said Maj. Gen. Mussa Wardak, director of the army’s five military hospitals, referring to the critical early minutes to stabilize and treat trauma victims. “Air transportation is our biggest problem. Of course, when we get more responsibility it increases the casualties.” | “For us it’s difficult to implement that ‘golden hour,’ ” said Maj. Gen. Mussa Wardak, director of the army’s five military hospitals, referring to the critical early minutes to stabilize and treat trauma victims. “Air transportation is our biggest problem. Of course, when we get more responsibility it increases the casualties.” |
| The two soldiers in Room 648 were among the lucky. After the ambulance took them to their local base, they got first aid, and then an Afghan helicopter brought them to the hospital here in Kabul — all in the same day, if not the same hour. | The two soldiers in Room 648 were among the lucky. After the ambulance took them to their local base, they got first aid, and then an Afghan helicopter brought them to the hospital here in Kabul — all in the same day, if not the same hour. |
| After officials left the hospital room, the two men spoke frankly about their feelings. Private Wali, who lost the sight of one eye along with both limbs, said his father cried when he joined the Afghan National Army and begged him not to go. He sat up in bed on his stumps, defiantly, and said, “They cannot fight us face to face, but their bombs are very cruel.” | After officials left the hospital room, the two men spoke frankly about their feelings. Private Wali, who lost the sight of one eye along with both limbs, said his father cried when he joined the Afghan National Army and begged him not to go. He sat up in bed on his stumps, defiantly, and said, “They cannot fight us face to face, but their bombs are very cruel.” |
| Lieutenant Hamdard had this lament: “I wanted to serve my country, and now I have failed.” | |
| His father, Abdul Raziq, who was helping to feed both patients their lunch, cut in angrily. “You gave your legs and arm. What do you have left to give?” | His father, Abdul Raziq, who was helping to feed both patients their lunch, cut in angrily. “You gave your legs and arm. What do you have left to give?” |
| Mr. Raziq has three more sons, which is what he has left to give, he said — despite his earlier opposition to Lieutenant Hamdard’s joining up. “I will let them join the army when they grow up because I am proud of my kids and my country, and no one else can save our country for us.” | Mr. Raziq has three more sons, which is what he has left to give, he said — despite his earlier opposition to Lieutenant Hamdard’s joining up. “I will let them join the army when they grow up because I am proud of my kids and my country, and no one else can save our country for us.” |
Sharifullah Sahak contributed reporting from Kabul, and Taimoor Shah from Kandahar, Afghanistan. | Sharifullah Sahak contributed reporting from Kabul, and Taimoor Shah from Kandahar, Afghanistan. |