This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2013/jun/18/seattle-woman-naveena-shine-live-on-light

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Seattle woman Naveena Shine drops attempt to live on light Seattle woman Naveena Shine drops attempt to live on light
(4 months later)
A Seattle woman is to abandon her controversial attempt to
live on light on Wednesday after 47 days of surviving on water and tea.		A Seattle woman is to abandon her controversial attempt to
live on light on Wednesday after 47 days of surviving on water and tea.
Naveena Shine, 65, had been attempting to go without food for 100 days. She said the "overt" reason for ending what she described as an "experiment" was financial – she claimed she will lose the trailer she has been staying in on Wednesday – but said she believed her monetary woes were "a simple a message from the universe that it is time to stop".Naveena Shine, 65, had been attempting to go without food for 100 days. She said the "overt" reason for ending what she described as an "experiment" was financial – she claimed she will lose the trailer she has been staying in on Wednesday – but said she believed her monetary woes were "a simple a message from the universe that it is time to stop".
"After 47 days [the post was written after 44 days] I still feel really good, weight loss is slowing and all seems well. However, I still have no evidence that I am actually living on light and it could well be slow starvation," Shine wrote on her Facebook page."After 47 days [the post was written after 44 days] I still feel really good, weight loss is slowing and all seems well. However, I still have no evidence that I am actually living on light and it could well be slow starvation," Shine wrote on her Facebook page.
"Now that I am ending the experiment I will never know.""Now that I am ending the experiment I will never know."
Doctors have warned that it is impossible for humans to survive on light and urged Shine to start eating. Four people are reported to have died attempting to subsist on light alone.Doctors have warned that it is impossible for humans to survive on light and urged Shine to start eating. Four people are reported to have died attempting to subsist on light alone.
"Plants have what are called choroplasts that contain chlorophyll and they have the ability to capture energy from sunlight," said Dr Ronald Hoffman medical director of the Hoffman Center and host of a weekly health podcast."Plants have what are called choroplasts that contain chlorophyll and they have the ability to capture energy from sunlight," said Dr Ronald Hoffman medical director of the Hoffman Center and host of a weekly health podcast.
"Humans don't have cholorphyll or chloroplasts. No humans do. It is impossible for a human to have that."Humans don't have cholorphyll or chloroplasts. No humans do. It is impossible for a human to have that.
Shine, who is originally from Birmingham in the UK, said "a doctor can't see living on light because he looks through different lenses". She has not been undergoing medical tests during her period without food but has dropped to 126lb from her starting weight of 159lb.Shine, who is originally from Birmingham in the UK, said "a doctor can't see living on light because he looks through different lenses". She has not been undergoing medical tests during her period without food but has dropped to 126lb from her starting weight of 159lb.
Shine had said she would stop the fast if her weight dropped below 120lb. In daily posts to Facebook and YouTube she had complained of light-headedness and nausea, and said her extremities felt cold. Commenters have been a mixture of those who appear to believe living on light is possible and others urging her to stop.Shine had said she would stop the fast if her weight dropped below 120lb. In daily posts to Facebook and YouTube she had complained of light-headedness and nausea, and said her extremities felt cold. Commenters have been a mixture of those who appear to believe living on light is possible and others urging her to stop.
"From the feedback I am getting, it is becoming patently clear that most of the world is by no means ready to receive the information I am attempting to produce," Shine said. "Even if it were true that a person can 'live on light' and I were successful in demonstrating that, I see that it would be synonymous with putting a non-driver behind the wheel of a huge truck. It would be an accident in the making.""From the feedback I am getting, it is becoming patently clear that most of the world is by no means ready to receive the information I am attempting to produce," Shine said. "Even if it were true that a person can 'live on light' and I were successful in demonstrating that, I see that it would be synonymous with putting a non-driver behind the wheel of a huge truck. It would be an accident in the making."
In a YouTube video posted on Sunday, Shine said there are "many, many complex reasons" for ending her experiment. "Because I'm closing it doesn't mean to say there's any failure here," she said.In a YouTube video posted on Sunday, Shine said there are "many, many complex reasons" for ending her experiment. "Because I'm closing it doesn't mean to say there's any failure here," she said.
"I'm looking healthy, I feel healthy, bouncing with energy, none of those dire predictions that people were saying were going to happen happened.""I'm looking healthy, I feel healthy, bouncing with energy, none of those dire predictions that people were saying were going to happen happened."
But Shine appeared to acknowledge the risk to her health, at one point saying "I have no idea if I could" complete the 100 days.But Shine appeared to acknowledge the risk to her health, at one point saying "I have no idea if I could" complete the 100 days.
"Personally, do I think it's possible? For me it's still a question. I see much more evidence to show that yes it's possible, but I also see that it has to come out from the inside. I'm not willing to risk either my life or other people's lives," Shine said."Personally, do I think it's possible? For me it's still a question. I see much more evidence to show that yes it's possible, but I also see that it has to come out from the inside. I'm not willing to risk either my life or other people's lives," Shine said.
Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning.