This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/28/turkey-bbc-reporter-recep-tayyip-erdogan-treason

The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Turkish PM's treason claims against BBC reporter chills other journalists Turkish PM's treason claims against BBC reporter chills other journalists
(about 1 hour later)
Based in London, where she is a presenter for the BBC's Turkish service, until last week Selin Girit was little known in her home country. That all changed when the prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, accused her of treason after her coverage of the recent anti-government protests. The attack struck fear into other journalists, who believe Erdoğan – having consistently blamed the media for fanning the protests – is intent on stifling all dissent. Selin Gerit, a London-based presenter for BBC's Turkish service, was until last week relatively unknown in her home country. However, that changed when Recep Tayyip Erdoğan told parliament she was guilty of treason over her coverage of the anti-government protests sweeping the nation.
The campaign against Girit was launched last weekend when the mayor of Ankara, Melih Gökçek, started tweeting aggressively against her. The BBC protested strongly against what it called government intimidation. Erdoğan was clearly unimpressed. Speaking in parliament a day later, he said Girit was "part of a conspiracy against her own country". The prime minister's condemnation has triggered concerns among fellow journalists, who believe Erdoğan – who accuses the media of fanning the demonstrations – is attempting to stifle dissent.
Turkish journalists see the focus on Girit as a warning to them all – an example to cow the rest of them into submission. Serdar Korucu, editor of a major Turkish news outlet, said: "The prime minister is telling us, 'Be careful what you say and do, or you can easily be next'." The campaign against Girit was launched last weekend when the mayor of Ankara, Melih Gökçek, posted a series of angry tweets. The BBC criticised what it called government intimidation. The corporation's comments triggered Erdoğan to claim in parliament the following day that Girit was "part of a conspiracy against her own country".
The Turkish mainstream media have ignored much of the unrest, with CNNTürk airing a documentary on penguins while the central square in Istanbul became the scene of street protests unprecedented in Erdoğan's 10-year rule. Turkish journalists see the focus on Girit as a warning to them all – an example to cow the rest of them into submission. Serdar Korucu, editor of a major domestic news outlet, said: "The prime minister is telling us, 'Be careful what you say and do, or you can easily be next'."
The public was outraged, and protests were staged in front of Turkish news outlets. Many journalists, however, were not surprised. Fatma Demirelli, managing editor of the English-language daily Today's Zaman, explained that self-censorship had long become the norm in Turkish newsrooms. "Journalists now have a sort of split brain: on the one hand you see what the news is, but on the other you immediately try to gauge how to report it without stepping on anyone's foot. Self-censorship has become an automatic reflex." The mainstream media have ignored much of the unrest, with CNNTürk airing a documentary on penguins while the central square in Istanbul became the scene of street protests unprecedented in Erdoğan's 10-year rule. The public was outraged, and protests were staged outside local news outlets.
Self-censorship is not new in a country that tops the world list of jailers of journalists, with 67 currently incarcerated, according to Reporters Without Borders. But it has drawn more attention during the protests around Gezi Park. Many journalists, however, were not surprised. Fatma Demirelli, managing editor of Today's Zaman, the English-language daily, said self-censorship had long become the norm in newsrooms. "Journalists now have a sort of split brain: on the one hand you see what the news is, but on the other you immediately try to gauge how to report it without stepping on anyone's foot," she said. "Self-censorship has become an automatic reflex."
"The significant difference with the current events is that the censorship has affected a different constituency of people – middle-class Turks – rather than other groups whose causes have been more frequently subjected to censorship, such as activists advocating Kurdish rights and politics," said Andrew Gardner, Turkey researcher for Amnesty International. "Another difference is that the events were widely covered in international media, exposing the self-censorship in mainstream Turkish media further." Turkey has more journalists in its prisons than anywhere else in the world, with 67 incarcerated, according to Reporters Without Borders. But the government's stance against the media has drawn more attention during the protests around Gezi Park.
Censorship and control aside, violence and arbitrary threats against reporters trying to cover the events have also increased. "The significant difference with the current events is that the censorship has affected a different constituency of people – middle-class Turks – rather than other groups whose causes have been more frequently subjected to censorship, such as activists advocating Kurdish rights and politics," said Andrew Gardner, Turkey researcher for Amnesty International.
The Committee to Protect Journalists has documented a large number of cases of attacks on the press during the protests, including physical assault, detentions, threats and the unlawful confiscation of equipment and protective gear. Several journalists, Turkish and foreign, have sustained injuries from beatings and plastic bullets used by the police. "Another difference is that the events were widely covered in international media, exposing the self-censorship in mainstream Turkish media further."
The organisation singled out police brutality as the biggest threat against journalists working in Turkey, saying that reporters were more at risk than they had been in two decades. Censorship and control aside, violence and arbitrary threats against journalists trying to report the events have also increased. The Committee to Protect Journalists has documented a large number attacks on the press during the protests, including physical assault, detentions, threats and the unlawful confiscation of equipment and protective gear. Several reporters – Turkish and foreign – have sustained injuries from beatings and plastic bullets used by the police.
After covering a peaceful protest that was violently dispersed with tear gas and water cannon, journalist Alpbugra Bahadir Gültekin was repeatedly beaten by the police. "I told them that I was with the press, but they first insulted and then started beating me. After I fell to the ground, several officers continued to beat and to kick me," he said. The organisation singled out police brutality as the biggest threat against journalists in Turkey, claiming that reporters were facing the greatest risk to their safety in more than two decades.
Having recovered security camera footage of the incident, he brought charges against the police. He does not expect to be heard. "They operate in an atmosphere of impunity. But we have to start somewhere, and bring these incidents to light." After covering a peaceful protest that was violently dispersed with teargas and water cannon, journalist Alpbugra Bahadir Gültekin was repeatedly beaten by the police. "I told them that I was with the press, but they first insulted and then started beating me. After I fell to the ground, several officers continued to beat and to kick me," he said.
Demirelli and Korucu agreed that Erdoğan had become a figure beyond criticism. "News stations have started to correct the prime minister's slips of the tongue unasked, in order to be on the safe side," Korucu said. "Nobody wants to ask uncomfortable questions, in order to keep him happy. But how can we begin to understand issues of interest if asking is not free any more?" He managed to recover CCTV footage of the incident and filed charges against the police. However, he does not expect to be heard. "They operate in an atmosphere of impunity. But we have to start somewhere, and bring these incidents to light, " Gültekin said.
Demirelli and Korucu agreed that Erdoğan was becoming a figure beyond criticism. "News stations have started to correct the prime minister's slips of the tongue unasked, in order to be on the safe side," Korucu said. "Nobody wants to ask uncomfortable questions, in order to keep him happy. But how can we begin to understand issues of interest if asking is not free any more?"
Demirelli said: "Journalists now always wonder if they really want to investigate, for fear that they might actually find something."Demirelli said: "Journalists now always wonder if they really want to investigate, for fear that they might actually find something."
Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning.Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning.
Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. Enter your email address to subscribe.Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. Enter your email address to subscribe.
Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox every weekday.Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox every weekday.