This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/12/cruel-vicious-treatment-cattle-gaza
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| 'Cruel and vicious' treatment of cattle in Gaza sparks Labor call to ban exports | 'Cruel and vicious' treatment of cattle in Gaza sparks Labor call to ban exports |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| Labor has called for the suspension of selected animal export licences in the wake of harrowing new footage of “cruel and vicious” treatment of Australian cattle in Gaza. | Labor has called for the suspension of selected animal export licences in the wake of harrowing new footage of “cruel and vicious” treatment of Australian cattle in Gaza. |
| The footage, filmed by local civilians and uploaded to YouTube, shows cattle tied to poles, trees and vehicles before being stabbed in the neck and eyes. One animal was kneecapped by bullets fired from an assault rifle. | The footage, filmed by local civilians and uploaded to YouTube, shows cattle tied to poles, trees and vehicles before being stabbed in the neck and eyes. One animal was kneecapped by bullets fired from an assault rifle. |
| Animals Australia said the footage, filmed during a ritual called the “festival of sacrifice”, was some of the worst seen in a series of animal welfare outrages involving Australian cattle. | Animals Australia said the footage, filmed during a ritual called the “festival of sacrifice”, was some of the worst seen in a series of animal welfare outrages involving Australian cattle. |
| The animal welfare group has sent the footage to MPs and senators and has lodged a legal complaint about alleged breaches of the live export code. It is the third such complaint in three months, following similar scenes of cruelty in Jordan and Mauritius. | The animal welfare group has sent the footage to MPs and senators and has lodged a legal complaint about alleged breaches of the live export code. It is the third such complaint in three months, following similar scenes of cruelty in Jordan and Mauritius. |
| According to the Department of Agriculture, the Australian firm Livestock Shipping Services is the only supplier with an approved supply chain into the Palestinian territories. | According to the Department of Agriculture, the Australian firm Livestock Shipping Services is the only supplier with an approved supply chain into the Palestinian territories. |
| Animals Australia is calling for the live export trade to be scrapped entirely. Neither the Coalition nor Labor supports this stance, although the opposition agriculture spokesman, Joel Fitzgibbon, said export permits for some firms should be suspended while investigations were carried out. | Animals Australia is calling for the live export trade to be scrapped entirely. Neither the Coalition nor Labor supports this stance, although the opposition agriculture spokesman, Joel Fitzgibbon, said export permits for some firms should be suspended while investigations were carried out. |
| Plans for an interim ban on the trade were voted down in federal parliament on Thursday, Australian Associated Press reported. | Plans for an interim ban on the trade were voted down in federal parliament on Thursday, Australian Associated Press reported. |
| Labor senators voted with the Coalition to overturn a Greens motion calling for the cessation of exports until an investigation into previous welfare issues was complete. | Labor senators voted with the Coalition to overturn a Greens motion calling for the cessation of exports until an investigation into previous welfare issues was complete. |
| The Department of Agriculture was looking into 14 complaints regarding breaches of standards as set out in the Export Control Act, the Greens said. | The Department of Agriculture was looking into 14 complaints regarding breaches of standards as set out in the Export Control Act, the Greens said. |
| Three of the matters involved allegations of "cruel slaughter" by large export companies, the Senate was told. | Three of the matters involved allegations of "cruel slaughter" by large export companies, the Senate was told. |
| The motion was voted down by 44 votes to nine. | The motion was voted down by 44 votes to nine. |
| Calling the footage “confronting” and “distressing”, Fitzgibbon said the latest revelations of cruelty could “undermine public confidence in what is a very, very important industry for this country”. | Calling the footage “confronting” and “distressing”, Fitzgibbon said the latest revelations of cruelty could “undermine public confidence in what is a very, very important industry for this country”. |
| Lyn White, campaign director at Animals Australia, said: “There are no words to adequately describe the carnage in these videos and the scale of abuse endured by Australian cattle. It is shocking and completely harrowing to watch. | Lyn White, campaign director at Animals Australia, said: “There are no words to adequately describe the carnage in these videos and the scale of abuse endured by Australian cattle. It is shocking and completely harrowing to watch. |
| “Any politician or industry supporter who has propagated the industry's clever PR line that we can improve animal welfare by being in the market should be locked in a room and forced to watch an hour of footage from Gaza.” | “Any politician or industry supporter who has propagated the industry's clever PR line that we can improve animal welfare by being in the market should be locked in a room and forced to watch an hour of footage from Gaza.” |
| White said there was now “extensive evidence” that Australian animals were being subjected to cruelty and that regulations, in the form of the exporter supply chain assurance system, were ineffective. | White said there was now “extensive evidence” that Australian animals were being subjected to cruelty and that regulations, in the form of the exporter supply chain assurance system, were ineffective. |
| Under the regulations, Australian suppliers have to ensure the welfare of animals throughout the supply chain by transferring them to approved facilities where they are humanely culled. | Under the regulations, Australian suppliers have to ensure the welfare of animals throughout the supply chain by transferring them to approved facilities where they are humanely culled. |
| “This is what Australian exporters have been exporting animals to for decades,” White said. “It is time for every politician to search their consciences as to how they can allow this trade to continue.” | “This is what Australian exporters have been exporting animals to for decades,” White said. “It is time for every politician to search their consciences as to how they can allow this trade to continue.” |
| The UK-based group Compassion in World Farming said Australia’s live export trade was responsible for “massive animal suffering”. | The UK-based group Compassion in World Farming said Australia’s live export trade was responsible for “massive animal suffering”. |
| Its chief policy adviser, Peter Stevenson, said: “I have worked in this field for over 20 years and have never witnessed slaughter practices as cruel and vicious as those inflicted on Australian cattle in Gaza. Compassion in World Farming calls on Australia to now end its ruthless live export trade.” | Its chief policy adviser, Peter Stevenson, said: “I have worked in this field for over 20 years and have never witnessed slaughter practices as cruel and vicious as those inflicted on Australian cattle in Gaza. Compassion in World Farming calls on Australia to now end its ruthless live export trade.” |
| Tony Abbott has previously ruled out shutting down the live export trade, although he has called on suppliers to follow the regulations. This week, Indonesia called on its cattle importers to cease trade with Australia until diplomatic relations, strained by the spying controversy, improve. | Tony Abbott has previously ruled out shutting down the live export trade, although he has called on suppliers to follow the regulations. This week, Indonesia called on its cattle importers to cease trade with Australia until diplomatic relations, strained by the spying controversy, improve. |
| The independent MP Andrew Wilkie, a vocal critic of the live export trade, said the “barbaric” treatment of Australian animals needed to stop. | The independent MP Andrew Wilkie, a vocal critic of the live export trade, said the “barbaric” treatment of Australian animals needed to stop. |
| “The government must put an end to this breathtakingly cruel and economically counterproductive trade,” he said. “The scenes in the latest footage can only be characterised as being akin to a charnel house. | “The government must put an end to this breathtakingly cruel and economically counterproductive trade,” he said. “The scenes in the latest footage can only be characterised as being akin to a charnel house. |
| “If the government doesn’t have the backbone to stop the trade altogether, then it should at least commit to ban or refuse permits to all companies that have demonstrated a continuing disregard for animal welfare. | “If the government doesn’t have the backbone to stop the trade altogether, then it should at least commit to ban or refuse permits to all companies that have demonstrated a continuing disregard for animal welfare. |
| “I call on all members and senators to watch this footage, as difficult as it may be to sit through, before making a decision on this issue.” | “I call on all members and senators to watch this footage, as difficult as it may be to sit through, before making a decision on this issue.” |
| A spokesman for the Department of Agriculture said an investigation into the alleged animal abuse has been launched. "The department believes, based on their appearance, that some cattle in the footage are Australian cattle," he said. | |
| "However, we are working to determine the circumstances surrounding this incident including verifying the source, date, time and location of the footage. | |
| "The department, as the regulator of the livestock export trade, takes all reports of animal welfare breaches seriously, and investigates all complaints against the relevant regulatory framework." | |
| Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. | Our editors' picks for the day's top news and commentary delivered to your inbox each morning. |