This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-25348924
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Are we being fair to the NHS? | Are we being fair to the NHS? |
(about 11 hours later) | |
Negative headlines about the NHS abound at the moment. | Negative headlines about the NHS abound at the moment. |
This week alone there has been stories about ambulances queuing, failing GP surgeries and over-stretched maternity units. | This week alone there has been stories about ambulances queuing, failing GP surgeries and over-stretched maternity units. |
Then on Friday it emerged the A&E waiting time target had been missed for the first time this winter. | |
But is the health service getting a raw deal? | But is the health service getting a raw deal? |
The truth is the NHS in England is probably the most transparent health system in the world. | The truth is the NHS in England is probably the most transparent health system in the world. |
Data is available on hundreds of different metrics covering everything from the mortality rates for individual surgeons to how much each hospital spends on food - and they are all just a few clicks of the mouse away. | Data is available on hundreds of different metrics covering everything from the mortality rates for individual surgeons to how much each hospital spends on food - and they are all just a few clicks of the mouse away. |
What is more, this is just the start. | What is more, this is just the start. |
Ministers and the senior leadership in the NHS want even more openness. | Ministers and the senior leadership in the NHS want even more openness. |
From next April, patients will be able to log on to a website to look up what the staffing levels are for each and every hospital ward in England. | From next April, patients will be able to log on to a website to look up what the staffing levels are for each and every hospital ward in England. |
This transparency is a godsend for journalists, allowing them to mine data for stories. | This transparency is a godsend for journalists, allowing them to mine data for stories. |
One needs to look no further than on the BBC News website to see that. | One needs to look no further than on the BBC News website to see that. |
This week saw the launch of our A&E tracker, which is based on the blizzard of weekly statistics pumped out by NHS England. | This week saw the launch of our A&E tracker, which is based on the blizzard of weekly statistics pumped out by NHS England. |
National concern | National concern |
But the greater transparency is not the only factor. | But the greater transparency is not the only factor. |
There has also been a change in mindset to poor care following the Stafford Hospital scandal. | There has also been a change in mindset to poor care following the Stafford Hospital scandal. |
No longer is it acceptable to argue that exceptions to the rule do not matter. | No longer is it acceptable to argue that exceptions to the rule do not matter. |
As one senior NHS manager put it to me: "There used to be the attitude if 95% or so of care was good, it was not necessarily a matter of national concern what happened in the remaining 5%. That is not the case now." | As one senior NHS manager put it to me: "There used to be the attitude if 95% or so of care was good, it was not necessarily a matter of national concern what happened in the remaining 5%. That is not the case now." |
The result has been that there is now a laser-like focus on any sign of poor care. | The result has been that there is now a laser-like focus on any sign of poor care. |
Take, Thursday's story about GPs. | Take, Thursday's story about GPs. |
The CQC was on the look out for problems. Of the 910 practices inspected, 80% were targeted because concerns had already been flagged up. | The CQC was on the look out for problems. Of the 910 practices inspected, 80% were targeted because concerns had already been flagged up. |
Problems were found in about 300, but this is not the same as saying a third of GPs are failing - as was reported by some. | Problems were found in about 300, but this is not the same as saying a third of GPs are failing - as was reported by some. |
Another factor is the need for two of the key organisations keeping an eye on the health service to make some waves. | Another factor is the need for two of the key organisations keeping an eye on the health service to make some waves. |
The Care Quality Commission - with its three new chief inspectors - is striving to show it can be a watchdog with bite after being criticised in the past for being too timid. | The Care Quality Commission - with its three new chief inspectors - is striving to show it can be a watchdog with bite after being criticised in the past for being too timid. |
Meanwhile, NHS England, created in the shake-up in April, is doing much to push the transparency agenda. | Meanwhile, NHS England, created in the shake-up in April, is doing much to push the transparency agenda. |
But the changing landscape is not necessarily a bad thing, as Dr Johnny Marshall, of the NHS Confederation, which represents NHS trusts, explains. | But the changing landscape is not necessarily a bad thing, as Dr Johnny Marshall, of the NHS Confederation, which represents NHS trusts, explains. |
"By increasing transparency, we are increasing the chances of improving care," he says. | "By increasing transparency, we are increasing the chances of improving care," he says. |
"These problems we are seeing reported have probably been there for years, its just that we are now shining a light on them. | "These problems we are seeing reported have probably been there for years, its just that we are now shining a light on them. |
"It makes it pretty painful at the moment, but we are giving ourselves the best chance of success. If that happens everyone benefits." | "It makes it pretty painful at the moment, but we are giving ourselves the best chance of success. If that happens everyone benefits." |
Previous version
1
Next version