This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-26159249
The article has changed 11 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| South Wales NHS: Plan to centralise services on five sites | |
| (about 5 hours later) | |
| Health boards across south Wales have are discussing whether to centralise key services into five hospitals. | |
| It means services would be focused on the University Hospital of Wales in Cardiff, Morriston Hospital in Swansea, a new hospital near Cwmbran, Prince Charles Hospital in Merthyr and the Princess of Wales Hospital, Bridgend. | |
| Some services would be downgraded at the Royal Glamorgan in Llantrisant. | |
| The recommendation needs to be accepted by the five south Wales health boards. | |
| The proposal involves centralising high level emergency care - A&E - and specialist care for mothers, newborn babies and children, at fewer hospitals. | |
| Four suggested options all included retaining the services in hospitals in Cardiff and Swansea. | |
| Any final decision will be scrutinised by five Community Health Councils (CHC). | |
| The plans to centralise services follow concerns they are spread too thinly across the region. | The plans to centralise services follow concerns they are spread too thinly across the region. |
| However, some opponents warn patients could face greater risks if they have to travel further for treatment. | However, some opponents warn patients could face greater risks if they have to travel further for treatment. |
| Since the start of 2012, senior managers and medical professionals from five health boards - Abertawe Bro Morgannwg, Cwm Taf, Cardiff and Vale, Aneurin Bevan, Powys and the Welsh Ambulance Service - have been working together in the South Wales Programme (SWP) to develop proposals involving hospitals from Swansea to Newport. | |
| Services considered include obstetrics, neonatal, paediatrics and A&E - although managers insist no individual A&E department would close. | Services considered include obstetrics, neonatal, paediatrics and A&E - although managers insist no individual A&E department would close. |
| The services are provided by eight hospitals, but health bosses claim the current system is unsustainable and patients could suffer. | The services are provided by eight hospitals, but health bosses claim the current system is unsustainable and patients could suffer. |
| Last May, the SWP launched an eight-week public consultation on four proposed models - two of which involved centralising those services at five sites in south Wales and two which involved concentrating those services at four hospital sites. | Last May, the SWP launched an eight-week public consultation on four proposed models - two of which involved centralising those services at five sites in south Wales and two which involved concentrating those services at four hospital sites. |
| In all of the suggested models, the services would be retained at University Hospital of Wales in Cardiff and Morriston Hospital in Swansea. | In all of the suggested models, the services would be retained at University Hospital of Wales in Cardiff and Morriston Hospital in Swansea. |
| The options: | |
| All four options include a plan to build a new hospital at Llanfrechfa Grange, near Cwmbran, which would incorporate the A&E, obstetric and paediatric services currently delivered at Nevill Hall hospital in Abergavenny and the Royal Gwent Hospital in Newport. | All four options include a plan to build a new hospital at Llanfrechfa Grange, near Cwmbran, which would incorporate the A&E, obstetric and paediatric services currently delivered at Nevill Hall hospital in Abergavenny and the Royal Gwent Hospital in Newport. |
| During the consultation, 50 public meetings were held and the SWP received 61,422 responses. Seven petitions were submitted, containing 6,367 signatures. | During the consultation, 50 public meetings were held and the SWP received 61,422 responses. Seven petitions were submitted, containing 6,367 signatures. |
| Supporters of hospital reconfiguration claim the changes are essential to make sure that patients get the best care, and say some units do not meet UK-wide professional standards. | Supporters of hospital reconfiguration claim the changes are essential to make sure that patients get the best care, and say some units do not meet UK-wide professional standards. |
| If services are spread too thinly they claim doctors do not get to see enough patients to keep their skills up to scratch and problems can arise in attracting and providing adequate training to junior doctors. | If services are spread too thinly they claim doctors do not get to see enough patients to keep their skills up to scratch and problems can arise in attracting and providing adequate training to junior doctors. |
| Further, those who support change argue that as medicine gets more advanced, hospitals have no option but to specialise. | Further, those who support change argue that as medicine gets more advanced, hospitals have no option but to specialise. |
| They say the model of care - developed in the 1950s centred around district general hospitals, providing similar services in each locality - is outdated. | They say the model of care - developed in the 1950s centred around district general hospitals, providing similar services in each locality - is outdated. |
| They argue the changes would also help tackle other challenges such as an ageing population as well as the financial pressures. | They argue the changes would also help tackle other challenges such as an ageing population as well as the financial pressures. |
| Some respondents - most notably Plaid Cymru assembly members, MPs and councillors - opposed the South Wales Programme, arguing that it would be unnecessary if the Welsh government recruited extra doctors. | Some respondents - most notably Plaid Cymru assembly members, MPs and councillors - opposed the South Wales Programme, arguing that it would be unnecessary if the Welsh government recruited extra doctors. |
| The Conservatives' assembly leader, Andrew RT Davies, said in his submission he was "convinced that these proposals would not be necessary given adequate expenditure by the Welsh government". | The Conservatives' assembly leader, Andrew RT Davies, said in his submission he was "convinced that these proposals would not be necessary given adequate expenditure by the Welsh government". |
| In total, 3.3% of respondents argued to maintain the status quo. | In total, 3.3% of respondents argued to maintain the status quo. |
| Several professional medical bodies claim the proposed changes do not go far enough to tackle the challenges the NHS faces. | Several professional medical bodies claim the proposed changes do not go far enough to tackle the challenges the NHS faces. |
| A spokesperson said: "The case for service change is well established and clinically supported. | A spokesperson said: "The case for service change is well established and clinically supported. |
| "As we near the end of the process, the time has come to stop playing politics on this vital issue and allow health boards to reconfigure services to put them on a safe, sustainable footing for the future." | "As we near the end of the process, the time has come to stop playing politics on this vital issue and allow health boards to reconfigure services to put them on a safe, sustainable footing for the future." |
| In its submission, the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges Wales Committee argued all the proposed models could prove unsustainable in the long term. | In its submission, the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges Wales Committee argued all the proposed models could prove unsustainable in the long term. |
| It said a proper emergency and complex acute care service could not be sustained in more than three centres in south Wales. | It said a proper emergency and complex acute care service could not be sustained in more than three centres in south Wales. |
| Other respondents expressed concern about the capacity of the Welsh Ambulance Service to cope with lengthened journey times, while some were worried that centralising services on to fewer sites would lead to increased pressures on A&E departments and longer ambulance handover times. | Other respondents expressed concern about the capacity of the Welsh Ambulance Service to cope with lengthened journey times, while some were worried that centralising services on to fewer sites would lead to increased pressures on A&E departments and longer ambulance handover times. |
| Many respondents suggested public transport routes and timetables needed to be better aligned to hospital services and visiting times. | Many respondents suggested public transport routes and timetables needed to be better aligned to hospital services and visiting times. |
| The majority of the public responses supported a five-site model. | The majority of the public responses supported a five-site model. |
| The SWP's final recommendation was revealed on Thursday. | |
| The health boards will now meet to decide whether to back the plan. It is unclear what would happen if a health board rejected the plan put forward by the SWP, but if that happens, BBC Wales understands the whole process of NHS reorganisation in south Wales could be jeopardised. | |
| Even if all health boards agree, the plans would be scrutinised further by the five south Wales CHCs. | Even if all health boards agree, the plans would be scrutinised further by the five south Wales CHCs. |
| If any CHC objects, the proposals would be sent to the Welsh government for a final decision. | If any CHC objects, the proposals would be sent to the Welsh government for a final decision. |
| BBC Wales understands an appeal is likely. | BBC Wales understands an appeal is likely. |
| It is also understood that, if health boards back the reorganisation plans, they will also approve a mechanism to allow the SWP group to be reconvened to make future decisions about the provision of other services. | It is also understood that, if health boards back the reorganisation plans, they will also approve a mechanism to allow the SWP group to be reconvened to make future decisions about the provision of other services. |
| This would allow the health boards once again to work together to plan services across their boundaries. | This would allow the health boards once again to work together to plan services across their boundaries. |
| Health managers have stressed the final decision will not be based solely on the consultation responses. | Health managers have stressed the final decision will not be based solely on the consultation responses. |
| In November Paul Hollard, programme director for the SWP, said: "It is important the public understands the consultation responses on their own will not determine the outcome of the South Wales Programme. | In November Paul Hollard, programme director for the SWP, said: "It is important the public understands the consultation responses on their own will not determine the outcome of the South Wales Programme. |
| "The responses, together with the evidence gathered to support the consultation, the equality impact assessment and further work carried out in response to issues raised during the consultation, will be used by the health boards and the community health councils to reach a decision." | "The responses, together with the evidence gathered to support the consultation, the equality impact assessment and further work carried out in response to issues raised during the consultation, will be used by the health boards and the community health councils to reach a decision." |