This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/11/world/africa/pistorius-murder-trial.html
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Judge Bans Broadcast of Autopsy Testimony at Pistorius Murder Trial | Judge Bans Broadcast of Autopsy Testimony at Pistorius Murder Trial |
| (about 3 hours later) | |
| Oscar Pistorius, the double amputee track star accused of murdering his girlfriend, vomited repeatedly in the courtroom on Monday as a pathologist gave graphic evidence about her injuries. News coverage of the testimony was restricted by a sweeping ban on live broadcasting or reporting on Twitter. | |
| The athlete’s reaction came after the judge, Thokozile Masipa, concurred with requests from both the defense and prosecution — and from the pathologist, Gert Saayman — for live audio, Twitter feeds and video broadcasting of testimony to be prohibited because of what was termed the “explicitly graphic nature” of the evidence. | The athlete’s reaction came after the judge, Thokozile Masipa, concurred with requests from both the defense and prosecution — and from the pathologist, Gert Saayman — for live audio, Twitter feeds and video broadcasting of testimony to be prohibited because of what was termed the “explicitly graphic nature” of the evidence. |
| The broadcast ban contradicted an earlier ruling by a different judge that all testimony would be relayed live on radio and that much of it would be shown on television. Journalists were, however, permitted to report the outlines of the pathologist’s testimony without quoting witnesses directly. | The broadcast ban contradicted an earlier ruling by a different judge that all testimony would be relayed live on radio and that much of it would be shown on television. Journalists were, however, permitted to report the outlines of the pathologist’s testimony without quoting witnesses directly. |
| Before the prohibition came into force, Mr. Saayman said his testimony had “the potential to compromise the dignity of the deceased.” | Before the prohibition came into force, Mr. Saayman said his testimony had “the potential to compromise the dignity of the deceased.” |
| “I think that it goes against the good morals of society for us to make information of this nature available in a manner that vulnerable or unsuspecting people in society may be exposed,” he said. | “I think that it goes against the good morals of society for us to make information of this nature available in a manner that vulnerable or unsuspecting people in society may be exposed,” he said. |
| As Mr. Saayman testified, according to reporters in the courtroom, Mr. Pistorius hunched over in the dock, retching repeatedly. A bucket was placed at his feet. The trial, now in its second week, was halted briefly as the judge asked the chief defense lawyer, Barry Roux, to attend to his client, The Associated Press reported. | As Mr. Saayman testified, according to reporters in the courtroom, Mr. Pistorius hunched over in the dock, retching repeatedly. A bucket was placed at his feet. The trial, now in its second week, was halted briefly as the judge asked the chief defense lawyer, Barry Roux, to attend to his client, The Associated Press reported. |
| Mr. Pistorius, 27, is accused of the premeditated murder of his 29-year-old girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp, early on Feb. 14, 2013. If convicted, he would face a minimum jail term of 25 years. Mr. Pistorius has said that Ms. Steenkamp was killed by mistake when he fired four shots through a locked bathroom door, believing that there was an intruder in his upscale villa in a gated complex in Pretoria. | |
| According to news reports on Monday, the trial heard that Ms. Steenkamp had been hit once on the right of her head, once on her right arm and once in the area of her right hip. She had also been hit in the right hand. The pathologist referred to exit wounds and to injuries consistent with the impact of being shot through a door. | According to news reports on Monday, the trial heard that Ms. Steenkamp had been hit once on the right of her head, once on her right arm and once in the area of her right hip. She had also been hit in the right hand. The pathologist referred to exit wounds and to injuries consistent with the impact of being shot through a door. |
| The broadcasting ban rekindled a debate about the court’s handling of the huge public interest in the trial of Mr. Pistorius, an athlete whose triumphs as the “Blade Runner” — referring to the sickle-shaped prosthetics that enable him to compete — seemed an emblem of triumph over adversity. | The broadcasting ban rekindled a debate about the court’s handling of the huge public interest in the trial of Mr. Pistorius, an athlete whose triumphs as the “Blade Runner” — referring to the sickle-shaped prosthetics that enable him to compete — seemed an emblem of triumph over adversity. |
| The prosecutor, Gerrie Nel, said the ban ordered on Monday by Judge Masipa, was “not a question of press freedom.” | The prosecutor, Gerrie Nel, said the ban ordered on Monday by Judge Masipa, was “not a question of press freedom.” |
| Before the trial, Mr. Pistorius’s defense team had sought an absolute ban on all live broadcasting from the courtroom in Pretoria, the administrative capital of South Africa. | Before the trial, Mr. Pistorius’s defense team had sought an absolute ban on all live broadcasting from the courtroom in Pretoria, the administrative capital of South Africa. |
| Karyn Maughan, a legal reporter for eNCA, a news channel in South Africa, said in a Twitter post that the sound of Mr. Pistorius’s vomiting was “audible to everyone sitting in court, a constant grim soundtrack to Saayman’s testimony.” | Karyn Maughan, a legal reporter for eNCA, a news channel in South Africa, said in a Twitter post that the sound of Mr. Pistorius’s vomiting was “audible to everyone sitting in court, a constant grim soundtrack to Saayman’s testimony.” |
| In a separate post, she said that one court official “has her hand over her mouth. She, like many other people in this court, looks nauseous.” | In a separate post, she said that one court official “has her hand over her mouth. She, like many other people in this court, looks nauseous.” |
| The broadcasting ban on Monday was the second ruling that Judge Masipa has made on coverage of the trial. Last week, she ordered that still images of witnesses who had requested not to be pictured on television — even if the images had been collected from websites or other sources outside the courtroom — could not be reproduced in reporting of the hearings. | The broadcasting ban on Monday was the second ruling that Judge Masipa has made on coverage of the trial. Last week, she ordered that still images of witnesses who had requested not to be pictured on television — even if the images had been collected from websites or other sources outside the courtroom — could not be reproduced in reporting of the hearings. |
| The judge made the ruling after images of a witness for the prosecution, taken from a website, were shown by media organizations. “I am warning the media, if you do not behave, you will not be treated with soft gloves,” Judge Masipa said. | The judge made the ruling after images of a witness for the prosecution, taken from a website, were shown by media organizations. “I am warning the media, if you do not behave, you will not be treated with soft gloves,” Judge Masipa said. |